The short answer
Section 123 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 punishes administering poison, a stupefying, intoxicating or unwholesome drug, "or other thing" to a person, with intent to cause hurt, or with intent to commit or facilitate an offence, or knowing hurt is likely. It carries up to ten years and a mandatory fine. S1
Two things set this section apart from everything else in this chapter.
It is a word-for-word transplant. A token comparison against IPC section 328 returns zero differences - not a comma, not a punctuation mark, not a figure. Section 123 is the only provision in this family reproduced entirely unaltered. Sections 119 and 120 came close but each had at least a dropped comma; section 123 has nothing. S1; S2
And despite its marginal note, it does not require hurt to be caused. The heading says "Causing hurt by means of poison", but the operative words punish the act of administering coupled with the required intent or knowledge. The Bombay High Court set out the elements in Madhukar Damu Patil v. State of Maharashtra and there are only two of them - the administering, and the mental element. Resulting injury is not among them. S1; S4
The practical reach of the section is wider still, because of one holding worth quoting at the outset: "administering of poison is only one of the modes by which an act may fall within the mischief contemplated by this section." S4
The two elements
In Madhukar Damu Patil the appellant argued that no offence under IPC section 328 was made out because the prosecution had not proved that any poison was administered. The Court rejected that and set out the elements: S4
"(i) Some person or persons should administer or cause to be taken by any person any poison or stupefying, intoxicating or unwholesome drug, or other thing; and
(ii) The intention of the person or persons mentioned in (i) should be to cause hurt to the person concerned, or should be to commit or to facilitate commission of an offence or there should be knowledge on the part of the person or persons that the result of his act or their act was likely to cause hurt to the concerned persons.
Both these elements should exist conjunctively, then and then alone would the offence be complete". S4
Element one: administering, or causing to be taken
The conduct is "administers to or causes to be taken by any person". So both direct administration and procuring the victim to consume the substance himself are covered - slipping something into a drink and handing over a drink are equally within the section. S1
The substances are "any poison or any stupefying, intoxicating or unwholesome drug, or other thing". That last phrase is doing heavy lifting, and it is why the appellant's argument in Madhukar Damu Patil failed:
"the prosecution [need not] prove that any poison was administered to the victim. The language of the section clearly shows that the act of administering any stupefying, intoxicating or unwholesome drug or any other thing with the intention to cause hurt to a person or with the intention to commit or to facilitate commission of an offence or knowing it to be likely that hurt would be caused, would also fall within the mischief of the section. It needs to be emphasised that administering of poison is only one of the modes by which an act may fall within the mischief contemplated by this section." S4
That matters evidentially. Prosecutions of this kind often founder on chemical analysis - the substance was never recovered, or the report is inconclusive. On this reasoning, proof that some stupefying or unwholesome thing was administered can suffice; the prosecution is not obliged to identify a poison. S4
In Madhukar Damu Patil itself the evidence was that two men approached a woman of about fifty at a bus stand, gave her something, and stole her gold ornaments - which were later melted into a bar of 57 grams. The Court held that "some stupefying or intoxicating or unwholesome drug or some other thing was given to her with the intention to commit theft of her ornaments", and sustained the conviction under IPC section 328 read with section 34, together with the conviction for theft. The appeal was dismissed on all three grounds advanced, including a plea that the five-year sentence was excessive. S2; S4
Element two: the mental element, in three alternatives
The intent or knowledge may take any of three forms, and only one need be established: S1
- intent to cause hurt to the person to whom the substance is administered;
- intent to commit or to facilitate the commission of an offence; or
- knowledge that hurt is likely to be thereby caused.
The second alternative is the one that carries most of the section's real work. It is the drugging-to-rob case, the drugging-to-abduct case, the spiked drink before a sexual offence. The offence to be committed or facilitated need not be completed - the words are "with intent to commit or to facilitate" - and on the structure of the section it need not even be begun. In Madhukar Damu Patil the theft was completed and separately charged; nothing in the section requires that. S1; S4
What the elements do not include
There is no element of resulting hurt. The two-element analysis has no third limb, and the operative words never say that hurt must be caused - only that the accused must intend to cause it, or intend to commit or facilitate an offence, or know hurt likely. S1; S4
This is a genuine divergence between the marginal note and the section. "Causing hurt by means of poison" describes the paradigm case, not the minimum. Readers who work from the heading, or from the First Schedule's column 2 label which repeats it, will overstate what the prosecution must prove. S1; S10
Against IPC section 328: nothing changed
The comparison is unusually short. A token-level comparison of the operative text of section 123 against IPC section 328 returns no differences at all. The conduct, the list of substances, the catch-all "or other thing", all three mental alternatives, the ten-year maximum, "imprisonment of either description" and the mandatory fine are identical. S1; S2
No minimum sentence was added. No fine figure was introduced, so section 8(1) governs the fine: where no sum is expressed it "is unlimited, but shall not be excessive", exactly as IPC section 63 provided. The fine exposure is therefore unchanged. Applying that step matters, because elsewhere in this chapter a newly stated figure turned out to reduce the maximum fine - at section 118(1), where a twenty-thousand-rupee ceiling replaced an unquantified fine. S1; S2; S7; S9
And section 123 contains no carve-out referring to section 122. It joins sections 119, 120 and 121 in that respect; sections 115(2), 117(2) and 118 are the three provisions that do carry one. So grave and sudden provocation cannot move a case out of section 123. S1; S7; S8
One textual oddity should be recorded rather than relied on. The India Code consolidated print renders IPC section 328's marginal note as "with intent to commit and offence", where the Sanhita reads "with intent to commit an offence". The Bombay High Court, quoting the section in 1995, rendered it "an offence". That suggests the India Code rendering is a transcription artefact rather than the authentic Penal Code print, but the original Gazette of the 1860 Act was not retrieved and this article does not assert that the Sanhita corrected a real error. S1; S2; S4
How Section 123 relates to Section 118(1)
This is the comparison a practitioner actually needs, because both sections cover poison and they are four provisions apart.
Section 118(1) punishes a person who "voluntarily causes hurt by means of ... any poison or any corrosive substance ... or by means of any substance which it is deleterious to the human body to inhale, to swallow, or to receive into the blood". It carries three years, or a fine up to twenty thousand rupees, or both. S7
Section 123 punishes administering poison or a stupefying, intoxicating or unwholesome drug or other thing, with the specified intent or knowledge. It carries ten years and a mandatory fine. S1
The differences that decide which applies:
| s. 118(1) | s. 123 | |
|---|---|---|
| Hurt must be caused | Yes - it is "voluntarily causes hurt" | No - the act plus the mental element suffice |
| Mental element | voluntariness as to the hurt | intent to hurt, or intent to commit or facilitate an offence, or knowledge hurt likely |
| Maximum | 3 years | 10 years |
| Fine | ceiling of 20,000 rupees; fine alone available | mandatory, unquantified under s. 8(1); no fine alone |
| Provocation carve-out | yes, to s. 122 | none |
| Trial court | Magistrate of the first class | Court of Session |
Three working propositions follow.
Where a substance is administered to facilitate another offence and no injury results, only section 123 can apply - section 118(1) needs hurt. S1; S7
Where hurt is caused by poison but none of the section 123 mental alternatives is established, section 118(1) is the charge. The clearest case is hurt caused by a deleterious substance without any intent to injure or to commit an offence and without knowledge that hurt was likely. S1; S7
Where both are satisfied, section 123 is far graver - ten years against three, a Court of Session against a Magistrate, and no provocation carve-out. No decision addressing the overlap between these two provisions was located, so this analysis is reasoned from the texts. S1; S7
Classification: correctly assigned, for once
The First Schedule to the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 classifies section 123 as follows: S10
| Section | Offence | Punishment | Cognizable? | Bailable? | Court |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 123 | Causing hurt by means of poison, etc., with intent to commit an offence | Imprisonment for 10 years and fine | Cognizable | Non-bailable | Court of Session |
Cognizable, non-bailable, and - unlike sections 119(1), 120(1), 121(1) and 122(2) - assigned to a court that can actually impose the maximum. A Court of Session is subject to no ceiling comparable to the three-year limit on a Magistrate of the first class in section 23(2) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita. There is no forum mismatch here. S10; S11
That is worth stating positively, because this chapter has thrown up four mismatches in a row. Their distribution is inconsistent rather than systematically one way: the Schedule sends a ten-year offence to a Magistrate at section 119(1) and a ten-year offence to a Court of Session at section 123. S10; S11
Section 123 is not compoundable. It appears in neither the Table following section 359(1) nor the Table following section 359(2) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, so it cannot be compounded either with or without the court's permission. That contrasts with section 122, where both sub-sections may be compounded by the person hurt without the court's permission. S10
Two standing cautions. Column 3 reads "Imprisonment for 10 years and fine", dropping the statutory "which may extend to", so the ten years is a maximum. And column 2 repeats the marginal note, so it carries the same misleading implication that hurt must be caused. S1; S10
How Section 123 is being used
Reported decisions under the new numbering are thin and none construes the section, which is expected for a provision that commenced on 1 July 2024. Two examples show the range of contexts in which it is being invoked. S15
In Anirban Chakraborty v. State of Karnataka (Karnataka High Court, 27 February 2026), an anticipatory bail matter, section 123 was among the offences registered alongside section 103(1) - murder - and others. S12
In Prabhakar v. State (Madras High Court, 3 September 2026), section 123 was registered alongside section 276 and copyright offences in a matter concerning pharmaceutical consignments. That pairing is a reminder that "unwholesome drug" is capable of reaching commercial conduct and not only the classic drugging-to-rob case. S13
Neither decision construes the section, and neither is cited here for anything beyond the fact of the charge. S12; S13
The IPC-era authority shows the paradigm. Besides Madhukar Damu Patil, in Satbeer Singh v. State (Delhi High Court, 13 October 2004) a conviction under IPC section 328 stood alongside convictions for kidnapping and abduction, with five years' rigorous imprisonment imposed. That is the drugging-to-abduct case, and it illustrates the "intent to commit or facilitate an offence" limb in a different setting from theft. S14
A transcription caution
Madhukar Damu Patil is relied on here for its elements analysis, which is sound. But its quotation of the section renders the mental element as "with intent or to facilitate the commission of an offence", dropping the words "to commit". The statute reads "with intent to commit or to facilitate the commission of an offence". S1; S2; S4
Nothing turns on it for the holding, and the Court's own element (ii) states the alternative correctly. But it is the fourth instance in this chapter of a judgment reproducing statutory words imprecisely, after a Magistrate's substitution of a section number, a decision quoting a Supreme Court judgment at second hand, and a High Court reproducing the Penal Code's punctuation under the Sanhita's heading. Verify statutory text against the Gazette or India Code, not against a quotation in a judgment. S1; S4
Practical distinctions and common misconceptions
Poison need not be proved. Any stupefying, intoxicating or unwholesome drug, "or other thing", will do. Madhukar Damu Patil is express: administering poison is only one of the modes. S4
Hurt need not be caused. The two elements are the administering and the mental element. The marginal note and the Schedule label both overstate the requirement. S1; S4; S10
The intended offence need not be completed. The words are "with intent to commit or to facilitate the commission of an offence". S1
Both elements must coexist. Madhukar Damu Patil: "Both these elements should exist conjunctively." Administering a sedative with no relevant intent or knowledge is not this offence. S4
The victim may administer the substance himself. "Causes to be taken by any person" covers procuring consumption, not only forcing it. S1
Section 123 is not the acid provision. Grievous hurt by acid is dealt with separately at section 124, which the First Schedule classifies at not less than ten years up to life for sub-section (1), and at five to seven years for throwing or attempting to throw acid under sub-section (2) - both triable by a Court of Session. S10
The fine is mandatory and unquantified. "Shall also be liable to fine" means a fine must accompany the imprisonment, and section 8(1) sets no figure but forbids excess. A fine alone is not available. S1; S9
Provocation is no answer. Section 123 carries no carve-out to section 122. S1; S8
Worked examples
Example 1. A puts a sedative in B's tea at a bus stand and takes B's jewellery while B is insensible. Section 123, on Madhukar Damu Patil - and the theft is a separate offence. Ten years, Court of Session, non-bailable. S1; S4; S10
Example 2. A spikes B's drink intending to abduct B, but is interrupted and B is unharmed. Section 123 is complete. No hurt is required and the intended offence need not be committed. S1; S4
Example 3. The substance A administered is never recovered and no chemical report is available, but witnesses describe B becoming insensible immediately after consuming what A gave her. On Madhukar Damu Patil, the absence of proof of a specific poison is not fatal; it is enough that some stupefying or unwholesome thing was administered. S4
Example 4. A gives B a corrosive substance to drink in anger, causing injury, with no intention of committing any further offence and in circumstances where intent to hurt is made out. Both provisions are in play, and section 123 is the graver charge; if the mental element under section 123 fails, section 118(1) applies on its three-year scale. S1; S7
Example 5. A negligently serves B a deleterious substance, causing hurt, without intending hurt or any offence and without knowing hurt likely. Not section 123 - element two fails. Consider section 118(1), and the general hurt provisions. S1; S7
Example 6. B grossly insults A; A immediately forces an intoxicant on B intending to injure him. Section 123 applies and provocation does not reduce it, because the section carries no carve-out to section 122. S1; S8
Commencement and which law applies
Section 123 commenced on 1 July 2024, under Ministry of Home Affairs notification S.O. 850(E) dated 23 February 2024. S15
Because the section reproduces IPC section 328 with no change whatever - same elements, same ten-year maximum, same mandatory unquantified fine, no new minimum - the transition is as near to immaterial as it gets in this chapter. For conduct before 1 July 2024 the charge is IPC section 328; for conduct on or after it, section 123; and the exposure is identical either way. S1; S2; S15
That is a different position from every other section in this group. Sections 119 and 120 were substantively unchanged but each carried at least a punctuation change and, at section 120, a deleted illustration. Section 121 raised a maximum and added a minimum. Section 122 raised two fine ceilings and a term. Section 123 changed nothing at all. The reasoning in those sections should not be carried across. S1; S7; S8
The procedural law is separate: for proceedings instituted on or after 1 July 2024 the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita governs, so the First Schedule classification and the non-compoundability discussed above apply whichever substantive Act supplies the offence. S10
Related provisions worth reading alongside section 123
- Section 114 - definition of hurt, which supplies the content of "hurt" in the mental element. S5
- Section 115 - voluntarily causing hurt, the general provision. S6
- Section 117 - voluntarily causing grievous hurt, where a poisoning causes an injury in the closed list. S16
- Section 118 - hurt or grievous hurt by dangerous weapons or means, which also covers poison and is the provision most easily confused with this one. S7
- Section 122 - hurt on provocation; relevant here by its absence. S8
- Section 124 - grievous hurt by acid, and throwing or attempting to throw acid. S10
- Section 8 - the amount of fine where no sum is expressed. S9
- Section 23 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 - sentencing powers of Magistrates, the reason the Court of Session assignment matters. S11
Sources and honest limits
The comparison was made by token-level comparison of the India Code text of section 123 against the India Code text of IPC section 328, with the section text checked against the Gazette publication of the Sanhita. The First Schedule row and the absence of section 123 from both compounding Tables were read from the Gazette text of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita. India Code handles were read from the verified section inventory. S1; S2; S3; S10
What this article does not establish:
- No travaux. No Bill-stage document, committee report or Ministry note was retrieved. None is needed to explain a provision that was not changed, but none was found either.
- No Supreme Court authority was located. The searches returned 503 and 31 hits on IPC section 328, which were not read exhaustively. Madhukar Damu Patil is a single-Judge decision of the Bombay High Court and Satbeer Singh a single-Judge decision of the Delhi High Court; neither binds outside its own jurisdiction, and their subsequent treatment was not checked.
- The elements analysis rests on one High Court decision. Madhukar Damu Patil's two-element formulation is clear and reasoned, but it has not been verified against appellate or Supreme Court authority, and the proposition that hurt need not be caused follows from the statutory words and that formulation rather than from any decision squarely deciding the point.
- The section 118(1) comparison is reasoned, not decided. No decision addressing the overlap between the two provisions, or the choice between them, was located.
- No decision construing section 123 under its new numbering was found. The two 2026 decisions cited mention it only in lists of charges.
- The marginal-note discrepancy is unresolved. The India Code print of IPC section 328 reads "commit and offence" and the 1995 judgment reads "an offence". The original Gazette of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 was not retrieved, so this article does not say whether the Sanhita corrected an error or the India Code simply mistranscribed one.
- "Or other thing" has no boundary stated here. Madhukar Damu Patil establishes that the phrase extends beyond poison, but no authority defining its outer limits was located, and this article does not suggest where they lie.
- The First Schedule to the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 was not retrieved, so this article does not say how IPC section 328 was previously classified for cognizability, bail, forum or compounding, and therefore makes no claim that any of them changed.
- Non-compoundability was established from the Tables only. No authority on compounding this offence was sought.
- Dates. Law checked as of the date in the article metadata. Later decisions, and any amendment to the Sanhita or the Schedules, are not reflected.
Section 123 is the Penal Code's poisoning-to-commit-an-offence provision carried into the Sanhita untouched - the only provision in this chapter reproduced without a single textual change. The questions that decide cases under it are therefore exactly the questions that decided them before: was something stupefying, intoxicating, unwholesome or poisonous administered or caused to be taken, and was it done with intent to hurt, or to commit or facilitate an offence, or knowing hurt likely. Two points repay particular attention, and both cut against the marginal note: the prosecution need not identify a poison, and it need not prove that any hurt resulted. Verify the current text and classification, and take advice on your own facts, before acting.