Statutory Text and the "Mirror Punishment" Principle
Section 231 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) (corresponding directly to Section 195 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC)) forms the second tier of aggravated perjury and evidence fabrication S1; S3 (Section 231; Section 195). Where Section 230 BNS addresses false evidence aimed at procuring a conviction for a capital offence, Section 231 BNS addresses false evidence aimed at procuring a conviction for any non-capital offence punishable with imprisonment for life, or imprisonment for a term of seven years or upwards S1 (Sections 230, 231):
"Whoever gives or fabricates false evidence intending thereby to cause, or knowing it to be likely that he will thereby cause, any person to be convicted of an offence which by the law for the time being in force in India is not capital, but punishable with imprisonment for life, or imprisonment for a term of seven years or upwards, shall be punished as a person convicted of that offence would be liable to be punished. Illustration. A gives false evidence before a Court intending thereby to cause Z to be convicted of a dacoity. The punishment of dacoity is imprisonment for life, or rigorous imprisonment for a term which may extend to ten years, with or without fine. A, therefore, is liable to imprisonment for life or imprisonment, with or without fine." S1 (Section 231)
Essential Ingredients and Threshold Analysis
To bring a charge within Section 231 BNS, the prosecution must establish four cumulative requirements S1 (Section 231):
- Giving or Fabricating False Evidence: The accused must give false evidence (under Section 227 BNS) or fabricate false evidence (under Section 228 BNS) S1 (Sections 227, 228, 231).
- Intent or Knowledge of Likelihood of Procuring Conviction: The accused must act "intending thereby to cause, or knowing it to be likely that he will thereby cause" any person to be convicted of the target offence S1 (Section 231).
- False Evidence to Secure an Acquittal Is Not Covered by Section 231: Notice the statutory asymmetry: if a witness gives false alibi testimony to secure the acquittal of an accused charged with dacoity or rape, Section 231 BNS is not attracted because the witness did not intend to cause anyone to be convicted; instead, that witness is punishable under the general perjury provision, Section 229(1) BNS (or Section 238 BNS if done to screen the offender by causing disappearance of evidence/giving false information) S1 (Sections 229(1), 231, 238).
- Target Offence Threshold (Non-Capital, Punishable with Life or ≥7 Years):
- The target offence must not be punishable with death (if death is one of the prescribed punishments for the target offence, Section 230 BNS applies instead of Section 231) S1 (Sections 230, 231).
- The target offence must be punishable, under the BNS or any other law for the time being in force in India, with imprisonment for life, or with imprisonment for a term of seven years or upwards S1 (Section 231).
- Why the 7-Year Threshold Exists: Because general perjury in a judicial proceeding under Section 229(1) BNS already carries up to 7 years imprisonment, no separate aggravated section is needed when false evidence is given to procure a conviction for an offence punishable with less than 7 years (e.g., simple theft under Section 303(2) BNS, punishable with up to 3 years) S1 (Sections 229(1), 231). Section 231 ensures that where a perjurer tries to frame someone for an offence carrying 10 years, 14 years, 20 years, or life imprisonment, the perjurer's own sentencing exposure rises to match the target offence rather than being capped at 7 years under Section 229(1) S1 (Sections 229(1), 231).
- Actual Conviction of the Victim Is Not Required: Just like Section 230(1) BNS, the offence under Section 231 BNS is complete as soon as the false evidence is given or fabricated with the requisite intent or knowledge, even if the framed accused is acquitted S1 (Section 231).
How the "Lex Talionis" / Mirror Sentencing Clause Operates
Section 231 BNS prescribes a derivative sentencing formula: the offender "shall be punished as a person convicted of that offence would be liable to be punished" S1 (Section 231).
- As demonstrated in the Statutory Illustration, because dacoity (Section 310(2) BNS, formerly Section 395 IPC) is punishable with imprisonment for life or rigorous imprisonment up to 10 years and fine, a witness who gives false evidence to get Z convicted of dacoity exposes themselves to that exact sentencing range S1 (Sections 231, 310(2)).
- Where the target offence carries a mandatory minimum sentence (for example, rape under Section 64(1) BNS, which carries rigorous imprisonment of not less than 10 years extendable to life and fine), the mirror clause "as a person convicted of that offence would be liable to be punished" imports the statutory sentencing parameters of that target offence S1 (Sections 64(1), 231).
IPC Section 195 vs. BNS Section 231 Comparison
| Aspect | IPC, 1860: Section 195 | BNS, 2023: Section 231 | Legal Significance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Substantive Text | Identical operative rule S3 (Section 195) | Identical operative rule S1 (Section 231) | 100% doctrinal and interpretive continuity S1; S3. |
| Statutory Illustration | Referred to "a Court of Justice" S3 (Section 195) | Updated to "a Court" S1 (Section 231) | Aligns with Section 2(5) BNS terminology S1. |
| BNSS First Schedule Trial Forum | Triable by Court of Session S3; S4 | Non-cognizable, Non-bailable, Triable by Court of Session S4 (First Schedule, Entry 231) | Unlike Section 229(1) (triable by JMFC), Section 231 is triable exclusively by the Court of Session S4. |
Procedural Classification and Cognizance Bar
- BNSS First Schedule: Non-cognizable, Non-bailable, and Triable by the Court of Session S4 (First Schedule, Entry 231).
- Mandatory Court Complaint (BNSS Section 215(1)(b)(i) & Section 379): Because Section 231 BNS falls within "sections 229 to 233 (both inclusive)" in Section 215(1)(b)(i) BNSS, neither a private individual nor the police via an independent FIR can initiate a prosecution when the offence is committed in or in relation to a court proceeding; cognizance requires a written complaint of the Court under Section 379 BNSS S4; S5 (Sections 215(1)(b)(i), 379).