Statutory Definition and Numbering Disambiguation
Section 228 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) defines the offence of "fabricating false evidence" S1 (Section 228). Like Section 227 BNS, Section 228 is a definitional section whose general penal consequences flow through Section 229 BNS (and aggravated sentencing provisions in Sections 230–231 BNS) S1 (Sections 228–231).
- Critical Numbering Trap for Practitioners: Advocates and police officers transitioning from the 1860 Code must not confuse BNS Section 228 (Fabricating false evidence, formerly IPC Section 192) with old IPC Section 228 (Intentional insult or interruption to public servant sitting in judicial proceeding, which is now BNS Section 267) S1; S3; S7 (Sections 228, 267; Section 192).
The enacted text of Section 228 BNS provides:
"Whoever causes any circumstance to exist or makes any false entry in any book or record, or electronic record or makes any document or electronic record containing a false statement, intending that such circumstance, false entry or false statement may appear in evidence in a judicial proceeding, or in a proceeding taken by law before a public servant as such, or before an arbitrator, and that such circumstance, false entry or false statement, so appearing in evidence, may cause any person who in such proceeding is to form an opinion upon the evidence, to entertain an erroneous opinion touching any point material to the result of such proceeding is said 'to fabricate false evidence'." S1 (Section 228)
Three Modes of Conduct and the Dual-Intention Requirement
Unlike Section 227 BNS (which requires a pre-existing legal duty under oath or law to state the truth), any person can fabricate false evidence under Section 228 BNS even when not under oath and even prior to the institution of formal proceedings, provided the statutory elements are met S1 (Sections 227, 228):
- Three Alternative Modes of Physical Conduct (Actus Reus) S1 (Section 228):
- Causing any circumstance to exist (e.g., planting stolen goods in an innocent person's bag, staging fake crime-scene footprints, or inflicting a self-engineered wound to simulate an assault) S1 (Section 228, Illustration (a)); or
- Making any false entry in any book or record, or electronic record (e.g., backdating a ledger entry, altering a server log, or inserting a fictitious attendance entry in an official register; see Sections 2(8) and 2(10) BNS for "document" and "electronic record") S1 (Sections 2(8), 2(10), 228, Illustration (b)); or
- Making any document or electronic record containing a false statement (e.g., drafting a bogus receipt, preparing a fabricated medical report, or creating a spoofed email or chat transcript containing a false narrative) S1 (Section 228, Illustration (c)).
- First Limb of Mens Rea (Intention that It Appear in Evidence in a Qualifying Proceeding): The fabricator must intend that the staged circumstance, false entry, or false statement may appear in evidence in one of three specified forums S1 (Section 228):
- A judicial proceeding (including stages preliminary or ancillary thereto under Section 229 Explanations 1–3);
- A proceeding taken by law before a public servant as such (e.g., departmental, revenue, or tax adjudication proceedings conducted under statutory authority); or
- A proceeding before an arbitrator S1 (Section 228).
- Second Limb of Mens Rea (Intention to Cause an Erroneous Opinion on a Material Point): The fabricator must further intend that the fabricated item, when appearing in evidence, may cause the person who is to form an opinion upon the evidence in that proceeding to entertain an erroneous opinion touching any point material to the result of such proceeding S1 (Section 228).
- Completion of Offence Before Actual Use: Because Section 228 defines fabrication in terms of intending that the false matter may appear in evidence for the purpose of being used in a proceeding (see Section 229(1)), the offence of fabricating false evidence is complete the moment the circumstance, entry, or document is created with the requisite dual intent, even if the fabricator is caught before actually tendering it in Court S1 (Sections 228, 229(1)).
Analysis of the Three Statutory Illustrations
| Illustration | Statutory Fact Pattern | Legal Takeaway |
|---|---|---|
| Illustration (a) | A puts jewels into a box belonging to Z, with the intention that they may be found in that box, and that this circumstance may cause Z to be convicted of theft S1 (Section 228). | Illustrates "causing any circumstance to exist". No document or writing is required to fabricate false evidence S1 (Section 228). |
| Illustration (b) | A makes a false entry in his shop-book for the purpose of using it as corroborative evidence in a Court S1 (Section 228). | Illustrates "making any false entry in any book or record". Even though a party's own shop-book entry is merely corroborative (see Section 28 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, formerly Section 34 IEA), it touches a point material to the result S1 (Section 228). |
| Illustration (c) | A, intending to cause Z to be convicted of criminal conspiracy, writes a letter in imitation of Z's handwriting purporting to be addressed to an accomplice, and puts it in a place he knows police officers are likely to search S1 (Section 228). | Illustrates "making a document containing a false statement" and planting it for discovery during police search so that it appears in evidence at trial S1 (Section 228). |
Distinction Between Fabricating False Evidence (BNS Section 228) and Making a False Document / Forgery (BNS Section 335)
Advocates frequently face overlapping charges of fabricating false evidence (Section 228/229 BNS) and forgery (Sections 335/336 BNS, formerly Sections 464/463 IPC). A rigorous comparison reveals why a document can violate Section 228 without being a forgery under Section 335:
- Under Section 335 BNS (Making a false document), the essence of forgery is falsity of execution/authorship. The document must purport to be made, signed, or executed by someone who did not make or authorise it (or be dishonestly altered after execution) S1. A person who writes a self-serving lie in their own shop-book in their own name (as in Illustration (b) to Section 228) does not make a "false document" under Section 335 BNS because the book does not lie about who wrote it S1 (Section 228, Illustration (b)).
- Under Section 228 BNS (Fabricating false evidence), by contrast, making a false entry in one's own genuine book or creating a self-authored document containing a false statement is squarely covered, provided it is done with the dual intention that it appear in evidence and mislead the decision-maker on a material point S1 (Section 228).
IPC-to-BNS Comparison and Judicial Precedents
- Comparison with IPC Section 192: Section 228 BNS is substantively identical to Section 192 IPC (as amended by the Information Technology Act, 2000, which inserted references to "electronic record"), with the colonial phrase "Court of Justice" in Illustration
(b)modernised to "Court" S1; S3 (Section 228; Section 192). - Key Supreme Court Authority (Afzal v. State of Haryana, (1996) 7 SCC 397): Where police officials prepared false records and caused a forged/false counter-affidavit to be filed in a habeas corpus proceeding before the Supreme Court to conceal illegal detention of minors, the Supreme Court held the officials guilty of fabricating and giving false evidence in a judicial proceeding under Section 192 read with Section 193 IPC (now Section 228 read with Section 229(1) BNS) S5 (Paras 26–32).
- Procedural Cognizance Gate (Iqbal Singh Marwah v. Meenakshi Marwah, (2005) 4 SCC 370): While Section 215(1)(b)(ii) BNSS (formerly CrPC 195(1)(b)(ii)) bars private complaints for forgery (Sections 336, 340, 341 BNS) only when the forgery is committed after the document is produced in Court (custodia legis), Section 215(1)(b)(i) BNSS applies to Section 229 BNS (which punishes Section 228 BNS) whenever the offence of fabricating false evidence is alleged to have been committed "in, or in relation to, any proceeding in any Court" S4; S6 (Section 215(1)(b); Paras 10–11, 25–26, 33).