Statutory Architecture: The Definitional Foundation of Perjury
Section 227 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) opens Chapter XIV (Of False Evidence and Offences Against Public Justice) by defining the core substantive concept of "giving false evidence": commonly referred to in criminal jurisprudence as perjury S1 (Section 227). Section 227 is a definitional provision; the corresponding punishments are enacted in Section 229 BNS (general punishment for false evidence) and Sections 230–231 BNS (aggravated punishments where false evidence is given with intent to procure conviction of a capital or grave offence) S1 (Sections 227, 229–231).
The operative text of Section 227 BNS states:
"Whoever, being legally bound by an oath or by an express provision of law to state the truth, or being bound by law to make a declaration upon any subject, makes any statement which is false, and which he either knows or believes to be false or does not believe to be true, is said to give false evidence." S1 (Section 227)
Breakdown of Essential Ingredients
To establish that a person has "given false evidence" within Section 227 BNS, three foundational elements must be satisfied S1; S5 (Section 227):
- Pre-existing Legal Obligation to State the Truth or Make a Declaration: The maker must fall into at least one of three statutory categories at the time of making the statement S1 (Section 227):
- Legally bound by an oath (including a solemn affirmation substituted for an oath under the Oaths Act, 1969, read with Section 2(23) BNS defining "oath"), administered by a Court or person legally competent to administer it S1; S5 (Sections 2(23), 227); or
- Legally bound by an express provision of law to state the truth (for example, a party verifying pleadings under Order VI Rule 15 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, or a person examined under a statutory provision that expressly mandates stating the truth: by contrast, note that Section 180(2) BNSS requires a witness examined by police during investigation to answer truly other than questions tending to expose them to a criminal charge, where the word "truly" in CrPC 161(2)/BNSS 180(2) has historically been analysed carefully alongside whether an express statutory duty attaches) S1 (Section 227); or
- Bound by law to make a declaration upon any subject S1 (Section 227).
- Making of a False Statement (Explanation 1): The person must make a statement that is objectively false, or, under Explanation 2 and Illustration (d), false as to their own state of knowledge or belief S1 (Section 227). Under Explanation 1, "A statement is within the meaning of this section, whether it is made verbally or otherwise": thereby encompassing oral testimony in the witness box, written pleadings, signed affidavits, gestures by a non-verbal witness, or certified translations S1 (Section 227, Explanation 1).
- Required Mens Rea (Three Alternative Mental States): The maker must make the false statement while possessing one of three culpable states of mind S1 (Section 227):
- They know the statement to be false; or
- They believe the statement to be false; or
- They do not believe the statement to be true (which captures reckless or baseless swearing where a witness asserts a fact as within their knowledge despite having no knowledge or belief on the subject whatsoever) S1 (Section 227, Illustration (d)).
Statutory Explanations and Illustrations Explained
Section 227 BNS retains two critical Explanations and five Illustrations (a) through (e) that resolve recurring evidentiary defences S1 (Section 227):
| Statutory Unit | Core Rule / Fact Pattern | Legal Principle Illustrated |
|---|---|---|
| Explanation 1 | Statement made "verbally or otherwise" S1 (Section 227) | Written affidavits, verified statements, digital filings, and non-verbal signs qualify equally with oral testimony S1; S5. |
| Explanation 2 | False statement as to the belief of the person attesting S1 (Section 227) | A witness commits perjury by swearing they believe something they do not actually believe, or that they know something they do not know S1 (Section 227). |
| Illustration (a) | A, in support of a just claim which B has against Z for ₹1,000, falsely swears on a trial that he heard Z admit the justice of B's claim S1 (Section 227). | Materiality of the underlying claim's justice is irrelevant: perjury is committed even when false testimony is given to help a rightful litigant win a genuine debt S1 (Section 227). |
| Illustration (b) | A, bound by oath, states he believes a signature is Z's handwriting when he does not believe it to be so S1 (Section 227). | Dishonest opinion/belief testimony violates Section 227 via Explanation 2 S1 (Section 227). |
| Illustration (c) | A, knowing the general character of Z's handwriting, states in good faith that he believes a signature is Z's handwriting S1 (Section 227). | Counterexample (No Offence): Because A's statement is merely as to his belief and is true as to his belief in good faith (Section 2(11) BNS), A has not given false evidence even if the signature turns out to be forged S1 (Sections 2(11), 227). |
| Illustration (d) | A, bound by oath, states he knows that Z was at a particular place on a particular day, when A actually knows nothing upon the subject S1 (Section 227). | Reckless assertion of knowledge is perjury even if accidentally true: A gives false evidence whether Z was at that place on the day named or not S1 (Section 227). |
| Illustration (e) | A, an interpreter or translator bound by oath to interpret/translate truly, certifies as true what is not and what he does not believe to be true S1 (Section 227). | Extends perjury liability directly to court interpreters and translators S1 (Section 227). |
Absence of an Express "Materiality" Requirement in Section 227 vs. Section 228 & 236
A vital doctrinal distinction for practitioners comparing BNS Chapter XIV provisions is that Section 227 does not contain the words "touching any point material to the result" S1 (Section 227). By contrast, Section 228 BNS (fabricating false evidence) and Section 236 BNS (false statement in a declaration receivable as evidence) expressly require that the falsity touch a point material to the result or object S1; S5 (Sections 227, 228, 236). Under Section 227 BNS, even a false statement going to a witness's credit or collateral verification made under oath technically satisfies the definition of "giving false evidence", though, as the Supreme Court held in Chajoo Ram v. Radhey Shyam, (1971) 1 SCC 774, a Court exercising judicial discretion under Section 379 BNSS (formerly Section 340 CrPC) will direct prosecution only where deliberate falsehood is established on a matter of substance and it is expedient in the interests of justice S4; S6 (Section 379; Paras 7–8).
IPC-to-BNS Continuity and Key Judicial Precedents
- Exact Continuity with IPC Section 191: Section 227 BNS is a verbatim re-enactment of Section 191 IPC, including both Explanations and all five Illustrations
(a)to(e)S1; S3 (Section 227; Section 191). Accordingly, all IPC-era Supreme Court jurisprudence interpreting Section 191 IPC applies with full force to Section 227 BNS. - False Affidavits (Baban Singh v. Jagdish Singh, AIR 1967 SC 68): A three-Judge Bench of the Supreme Court clarified that where a person swears a false affidavit before a Court under an oath lawfully administered, the offence falls squarely under Section 191 IPC (now Section 227 BNS) read with Explanations 1 and 2, as well as Section 199 IPC (now Section 236 BNS) where the affidavit is receivable as evidence S5 (Paras 6–9).
- Expediency Threshold for Perjury Prosecution (Chajoo Ram v. Radhey Shyam, (1971) 1 SCC 774): The Supreme Court cautioned that indiscriminate prosecutions for every inaccurate statement would deter witnesses; Courts must invoke Section 379 BNSS (CrPC 340) only when the falsehood is conscious, deliberate, on a matter of substance, and conviction is reasonably probable S6 (Paras 7–8).
Procedural Classification and the BNSS Section 215 / 379 Gate
Because Section 227 is a definition section, the BNSS First Schedule classifies the offence under its punishing provision, Section 229 BNS (Non-cognizable, Bailable, Triable by Magistrate of the first class for judicial proceedings under Section 229(1), or Any Magistrate for other cases under Section 229(2)) S1; S4 (Sections 227, 229). Furthermore, when the false evidence is given in or in relation to a proceeding in any Court, Section 215(1)(b)(i) BNSS bars any Court from taking cognizance except on a written complaint of that Court (or an officer authorised by it, or a superior Court) following the preliminary procedure in Section 379 BNSS S4 (Sections 215, 379).