Statutory Text and Aggravated Place in Chapter XIV
Section 230 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) (replacing Section 194 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC)) deals with the gravest form of perjury and evidence fabrication: weaponising false evidence to send a person to the gallows S1; S3 (Section 230; Section 194). The provision is structured into two numbered subsections:
"(1) Whoever gives or fabricates false evidence, intending thereby to cause, or knowing it to be likely that he will thereby cause, any person to be convicted of an offence which is capital by the law for the time being in force in India shall be punished with imprisonment for life, or with rigorous imprisonment for a term which may extend to ten years, and shall also be liable to fine which may extend to fifty thousand rupees. (2) If an innocent person be convicted and executed in consequence of false evidence referred to in sub-section (1), the person who gives such false evidence shall be punished either with death or the punishment hereinbefore described." S1 (Section 230(1)–(2))
Dissecting the Ingredients of Subsections (1) and (2)
1. Section 230(1): Basic Capital-Frameup Offence (Inchoate as to Conviction)
To establish an offence under Section 230(1) BNS, the prosecution must prove S1 (Section 230(1)):
- Underlying Act of False Evidence: The accused must either give false evidence (satisfying all ingredients of Section 227 BNS) or fabricate false evidence (satisfying all ingredients of Section 228 BNS) S1 (Sections 227, 228, 230(1)).
- Specific Mens Rea (Intention or Knowledge of Likelihood): Beyond the intentionality required by Section 229, the accused must act "intending thereby to cause, or knowing it to be likely that he will thereby cause" any person to be convicted of a capital offence S1 (Section 230(1)). Mere negligence or a false statement on a peripheral point not calculated or known to be likely to procure a capital conviction remains under Section 229(1) BNS S1 (Sections 229(1), 230(1)).
- Nature of the Target Offence (Capital by the Law for the Time Being in Force in India): The offence for which conviction is sought must be punishable with death under any law currently in force in India, whether under the BNS itself (such as murder under Section 103, gang rape on a woman under eighteen years under Section 70(2), or waging war under Section 147) or under a special central statute (such as the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967, the POCSO Act, 2012, or the Army Act, 1950), by virtue of the broad phrase "by the law for the time being in force in India" S1 (Section 230(1)).
- Actual Conviction Not Required Under Subsection (1): Under Section 230(1), liability is complete the moment the false evidence is given or fabricated with the requisite intent or knowledge of likelihood, even if the target accused is ultimately acquitted or the fabrication is exposed before judgment S1 (Section 230(1)).
2. Section 230(2): Aggravated Result Offence (Judicial Execution of an Innocent Person)
For the capital punishment tier under Section 230(2) BNS to be triggered, three additional cumulative conditions must be proved S1 (Section 230(2)):
- Victim's Factual Innocence: The person against whom the false evidence was directed must be an "innocent person" S1 (Section 230(2)).
- Actual Conviction and Execution: That innocent person must have been both convicted and actually executed (put to death pursuant to the sentence) S1 (Section 230(2)). If the innocent person is sentenced to death on the basis of the false evidence, but the death sentence is commuted or overturned on appeal before execution, Section 230(2) does not apply; the offender is punished under Section 230(1) (though see Section 232(2) where witness intimidation leads to a sentence of death or >7 years imprisonment) S1 (Sections 230(1)–(2), 232(2)).
- Causal Link ("In Consequence of" False Evidence): The conviction and execution must have occurred "in consequence of" the false evidence referred to in subsection (1) S1 (Section 230(2)).
- Textual Precision Note ("the person who gives such false evidence"): Note that while Section 230(1) refers to "Whoever gives or fabricates false evidence", the closing words of Section 230(2) (retained from IPC Section 194) state "the person who gives such false evidence shall be punished either with death or the punishment hereinbefore described", though where a fabricator tenders or uses the fabricated evidence in court, Section 233 BNS treats the corrupt user in the same manner as if they gave or fabricated false evidence S1; S3 (Sections 230, 233; Section 194).
Comparison Between IPC Section 194 and BNS Section 230
| Dimension | IPC, 1860: Section 194 | BNS, 2023: Section 230 | Legal Significance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Structure | Single section with two unnumbered clauses S3 (Section 194) | Divided into Section 230(1) and Section 230(2) S1 (Section 230) | Clarifies charging and sentencing between non-executed and executed cases S1; S4. |
| Imprisonment under First Limb | Imprisonment for life, or rigorous imprisonment up to 10 years S3 (Section 194) | Imprisonment for life, or rigorous imprisonment up to 10 years S1 (Section 230(1)) | Unchanged; note that if term imprisonment is chosen instead of life imprisonment, it must be rigorous S1 (Section 230(1)). |
| Fine under First Limb | "and shall also be liable to fine" (unlimited) S3 (Section 194) | "and shall also be liable to fine which may extend to fifty thousand rupees" S1 (Section 230(1)) | Introduces a statutory fine ceiling of ₹50,000 while keeping fine mandatory alongside imprisonment S1 (Section 230(1)). |
| Punishment under Second Limb | Death or the punishment described in first limb S3 (Section 194) | Death or the punishment described in subsection (1) S1 (Section 230(2)) | Unchanged; capital sentence remains discretionary and subject to the Bachan Singh "rarest of rare" standard S1; S5. |
Procedural Classification and Cognizance Requirements
- BNSS First Schedule Classification: Both Section 230(1) and Section 230(2) are classified as Non-cognizable, Non-bailable, and Triable by the Court of Session S4 (First Schedule, Entries 230(1) & 230(2)).
- Mandatory Court-Complaint Bar (BNSS Section 215(1)(b)(i) & Section 379): Because Section 215(1)(b)(i) BNSS expressly covers "sections 229 to 233 (both inclusive)", no Court can take cognizance of an offence under Section 230(1) or 230(2) BNS committed in or in relation to a proceeding in any Court except upon a written complaint of that Court (or an officer authorised by it, or a superior Court) under Section 379 BNSS, followed by committal to the Court of Session S4; S6 (Sections 215(1)(b)(i), 379).
Practical Illustrations and Counterexamples
- Example 1: Section 230(1) Attracted Even Upon Acquittal of Target: In a murder trial under Section 103(1) BNS (a capital offence), W deliberately deposes falsely on oath that he saw the accused X stab the deceased, intending to procure X's conviction for murder. During cross-examination, CCTV footage proves X was in another city, and the Sessions Court acquits X. Even though X was acquitted, W has committed the complete offence under Section 230(1) BNS and faces life imprisonment or rigorous imprisonment up to 10 years plus fine up to ₹50,000 upon a complaint lodged by the Sessions Court under Section 379 BNSS S1; S4 (Section 230(1); Sections 215, 379).
- Example 2: Counterexample Where Target Offence Is Not Capital: If W gives false evidence intending to cause X to be convicted of dacoity under Section 310(2) BNS (which is punishable with imprisonment for life or rigorous imprisonment up to 10 years, not death), Section 230 BNS does not apply; instead, the offence falls under Section 231 BNS S1 (Sections 230, 231).