Statutory Text and Legislative Evolution
Section 232 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS): replacing Section 195A of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC), which was originally inserted by the Code of Criminal Procedure (Amendment) Act, 2005 (Act 2 of 2006): specifically criminalises witness intimidation aimed at procuring false evidence S1; S3; S5 (Section 232; Section 195A). BNS Section 232 organises the provision into two numbered subsections:
"(1) Whoever threatens another with any injury to his person, reputation or property or to the person or reputation of any one in whom that person is interested, with intent to cause that person to give false evidence shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to seven years, or with fine, or with both. (2) If an innocent person is convicted and sentenced in consequence of false evidence referred to in sub-section (1), with death or imprisonment for more than seven years, the person who threatens shall be punished with the same punishment and sentence in the same manner and to the same extent such innocent person is punished and sentenced." S1 (Section 232(1)–(2))
Essential Ingredients of Subsections (1) and (2)
1. Section 232(1): Threatening to Cause False Evidence
To establish an offence under Section 232(1) BNS, the prosecution must prove S1 (Section 232(1)):
- Act of Threatening with Injury: The accused must hold out a threat of "injury" (defined in Section 2(14) BNS as any harm whatever illegally caused to any person, in body, mind, reputation or property) S1 (Sections 2(14), 232(1)).
- Scope of Threatened Interest (Notice the Statutory Asymmetry):
- If the threat is directed against the target witness directly, it covers injury to their person, reputation, or property S1 (Section 232(1)).
- If the threat is directed against any one in whom that person is interested (e.g., a child, spouse, or parent of the witness), the statute specifies injury to the "person or reputation" of that third party (omitting "property" of the third party, mirroring the exact wording of criminal intimidation under Section 351(1) BNS / Section 503 IPC) S1 (Sections 232(1), 351(1)).
- Specific Ulterior Intent ("With Intent to Cause That Person to Give False Evidence"): This is the decisive element that separates Section 232(1) BNS (carrying up to 7 years imprisonment) from general criminal intimidation under Section 351(2) BNS (carrying up to 2 years imprisonment) S1 (Sections 232(1), 351(2)).
- Crucial Distinction: Threatening a Witness to Give False Evidence vs. Threatening a Witness Not to Appear at All: If an accused threatens a subpoenaed witness not to come to court at all, that conduct constitutes criminal intimidation (Section 351 BNS) and obstructing justice/witness tampering, whereas if the accused threatens a witness to step into the witness box and turn hostile by swearing falsely (e.g., "Depose on oath that you never saw me at the crime scene, or I will harm your family"), the threat is made with intent to cause that person to give false evidence (Section 227 BNS), squarely triggering Section 232(1) BNS S1 (Sections 227, 232(1), 351).
- Inchoate Completion under Subsection (1): Under Section 232(1), the offence is complete as soon as the threat is communicated with the requisite intent, even if the courageous witness refuses to yield and testifies truthfully S1 (Section 232(1)).
2. Section 232(2): Aggravated Consequence Where an Innocent Person Is Convicted and Sentenced
Subsection (2) escalates the punishment when four conditions converge S1 (Section 232(2)):
- The threatened witness actually gives false evidence pursuant to the threat;
- An innocent person is convicted AND sentenced in consequence of that false evidence;
- The sentence imposed on the innocent person is death or imprisonment for more than seven years; and
- In that event, the person who threatened the witness must be punished with the exact same punishment and sentence, in the same manner and to the same extent, as the innocent person was punished and sentenced S1 (Section 232(2)).
Comparison Between IPC Section 195A and BNS Section 232
| Feature | IPC, 1860: Section 195A | BNS, 2023: Section 232 | Legal Significance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Numbering | Two unnumbered paragraphs S3 (Section 195A) | Numbered subsections 232(1) and 232(2) S1 (Section 232) | Cleaner statutory citation and separate BNSS First Schedule rows S1; S4. |
| Subsection (1) Punishment | Imprisonment of either description up to 7 years, or fine, or both S3 (Section 195A) | Imprisonment of either description up to 7 years, or fine, or both S1 (Section 232(1)) | Unchanged; note the disjunctive "or" allowing imprisonment alone, fine alone, or both S1 (Section 232(1)). |
| Subsection (2) Trigger | Innocent person convicted and sentenced to death or imprisonment for more than 7 years S3 (Section 195A) | Innocent person convicted and sentenced to death or imprisonment for more than 7 years S1 (Section 232(2)) | Unchanged; unlike Section 230(2) (which requires execution for the death penalty), Section 232(2) triggers upon conviction and sentence S1 (Sections 230(2), 232(2)). |
Procedural Classification and the Special Rule in BNSS Section 215(5)
Section 232 BNS occupies a unique procedural position under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS) that every criminal practitioner must understand S4:
- Cognizable and Non-Bailable Status: Unlike almost every other offence in Chapter XIV (which are non-cognizable and bailable), both Section 232(1) and Section 232(2) are classified in the BNSS First Schedule as Cognizable and Non-bailable, triable by the Court by which the offence of giving false evidence is triable S4 (First Schedule, Entries 232(1) & 232(2)).
- Reconciling BNSS Section 215(1)(b)(i) with BNSS Section 215(5) and Cognizability:
- On the one hand, Section 215(1)(b)(i) BNSS includes "sections 229 to 233 (both inclusive)" in the list of offences requiring a written complaint of the Court when committed in or in relation to a court proceeding S4 (Section 215(1)(b)(i)).
- On the other hand, Section 215(5) BNSS (re-enacting Section 195A CrPC, which was inserted in 2009) explicitly states: "A witness or any other person may file a complaint in relation to an offence under section 232 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023" S4 (Section 215(5)). Furthermore, because the BNSS First Schedule classifies Section 232 as Cognizable, a threatened witness is not left helpless waiting for the conclusion of trial or a Section 379 preliminary inquiry: they can immediately approach the police (as well as the Witness Protection Cell under the Supreme Court's binding Witness Protection Scheme, 2018 in Mahender Chawla v. Union of India, (2019) 14 SCC 615) or file a direct complaint under Section 215(5) BNSS S4; S5 (Section 215(5)).