IPC2BNSConverter

BNS Section 134 · Deep dive

BNS Section 134: Force in an Attempted Theft - the Only Provision Carried Over Unchanged

Section 134 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 punishes using assault or criminal force against a person while attempting to steal something that person is carrying, with imprisonment of either description up to TWO YEARS, or fine, or both. This is the pickpocket-and-snatcher provision and three features define it. IT IS AN ATTEMPT OFFENCE - the theft need not succeed, the force and the attempt together completing it; theft is defined at section 303 as moving the property, so section 134 bites BEFORE the property has moved. THE PROPERTY MUST BE ON THE PERSON AT THE TIME - the words are 'THEN wearing or carrying', and the echo of section 128 (which says 'is wearing or carrying') is deliberate but NOT verbatim, section 134 adding the temporal qualifier, so property set down or not yet picked up falls outside the section on its words. AND IT IS PROCEDURALLY UNLIKE EITHER NEIGHBOUR: section 134 is COGNIZABLE BUT BAILABLE, where section 132 is cognizable and non-bailable and section 133 is neither - yet all three carry the same two-year maximum. THAT IS THE ARTICLE'S SHARPEST FINDING: the procedural regime is A GRID, NOT A DIAL. Cognizability, bailability and compoundability are set independently for each offence and none can be predicted from the sentence; section 134 is the only one of the three that is cognizable and bailable at once, and it is NOT COMPOUNDABLE with or without leave. Against IPC section 356 the comparison returns ZERO DIFFERENCES - THE FIRST ABSOLUTELY IDENTICAL PROVISION IN THIS COLLECTION - and because a nil result can be a failed extraction, the Penal Code text was printed and read in full before the result was accepted. WHAT CHANGED IS THE LANDSCAPE, NOT THE SECTION: section 304 creates SNATCHING, a new offence carrying three years and a mandatory fine, covering the completed taking. NO DECISION CONSTRUING THE INGREDIENTS WAS LOCATED: 458 results were overwhelmingly trial-court records, one retrieved decision proved to be a number collision across 5.8 million characters, and in SHAMSHAD the section 356 point was COUNSEL'S SUBMISSION WHICH FAILED, the Court upholding dacoity convictions.

By the Nyaya Yantra Editorial TeamLaw checked as of 14 October 2026 26 min read

Prepared with AI-assisted research from the official sources listed at the end of this article.

At a glance

Provision
BNS Section 134 — Assault or criminal force in attempt to commit theft of property carried by a person
Earlier law (IPC)
Indian Penal Code, 1860, s. 356 · direct
Side-by-side converterIPC 356 → BNS 134

The short answer

Section 134 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 punishes using assault or criminal force against a person while attempting to steal something that person is carrying. The maximum is two years' imprisonment of either description, or fine, or both. S1

"Whoever assaults or uses criminal force to any person, in attempting to commit theft on any property which that person is then wearing or carrying, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to two years, or with fine, or with both."

This is the pickpocket-and-snatcher provision, and three features define it.

It is an attempt offence. The theft need not succeed. The force and the attempt together complete the offence. S1; S7

The property must be on the person at the time. The words are "then wearing or carrying" - a temporal requirement that does real work, as explained below. S1

And it is procedurally unlike either of its neighbours. Section 134 is cognizable but bailable, where section 132 is cognizable and non-bailable and section 133 is neither. All three carry the same two-year maximum. S4; S9; S10

Against IPC section 356 the comparison returns no differences at all. The provision was carried into the Sanhita word for word. S1; S2

The elements

Assault or criminal force

The conduct element is shared with the rest of this group: an assault within section 130 or the use of criminal force within section 129. Words alone will not do, and no contact is required for an assault. S12; S13

In attempting to commit theft

Theft is defined at section 303 of the Sanhita: taking movable property dishonestly out of a person's possession without consent, by moving that property to such taking. S7

So the offence sits at a precise point in time. Section 134 bites where the accused assaults or uses force while attempting the theft - before the property has been moved. Once the property is moved, the theft itself is complete, and other provisions are engaged. Section 134 is the provision for the attempt that fails or is interrupted. S1; S7

How "attempting to commit theft" is construed was not researched for this article, and no authority on it was read. The point is flagged because the line between preparation and attempt is a general problem in criminal law that this section does not address. S1

"Which that person is then wearing or carrying"

This phrase repays close attention, and the single most important word in it is "then".

Section 128, which defines force, speaks of anything which a person "is wearing or carrying". Section 134 speaks of property which the person "is then wearing or carrying". The echo is deliberate but it is not verbatim: section 134 adds the temporal qualifier. S1; S6

The consequence is that the property must be on the person at the moment of the attempt. Property that the complainant had set down, or had not yet picked up, is not within the section on its words - even though taking it by force might be an offence under some other provision. S1

Note also that the First Schedule describes the offence as theft of property "worn or carried" by a person, dropping the "then". That is a paraphrase; the section governs. S1; S4

No provocation carve-out

Unlike sections 131, 133 and 136, section 134 contains no reference to grave and sudden provocation - and no Explanation or Illustration of any kind. S1

That absence is worth noting rather than passing over. The three-way asymmetry in how the provocation Explanations are distributed across sections 131, 133 and 136 simply does not arise here, because section 134 does not use the formula at all. Nothing was found explaining why provocation is relevant to a dignity offence and to the general offence but not to this one. S1

Against IPC section 356

The comparison returns zero differences. The operative text of section 134 is identical to IPC section 356, word for word and punctuation for punctuation. S1; S2

This is the first provision in this collection found to be absolutely identical to its Penal Code predecessor - even section 130, the closest previous case, carried one punctuation change. S1; S2

A word on method, because a nil result of this kind can be an artefact. A zero-difference comparison is indistinguishable from a failed extraction, so the Penal Code text was printed out in full and read before the comparison was trusted. It was complete. The nil result is real. S2

No State amendment

The Penal Code text was extracted through to the next section heading to catch any State amendment note, and none is recorded against section 356. This check is now run as a matter of course, because a note of exactly that kind - a Maharashtra amendment raising a maximum from two years to five - sits against section 353 and would be invisible to anyone who stopped reading at the operative words. S2

The fine position is unchanged

Section 134 says simply "or with fine", so no ceiling is expressed and section 8(1) of the Sanhita supplies the limit. IPC section 356 also left the fine unquantified, so the position is the same under either Code. S1; S2

The contrast with the very next section is instructive. Section 135 - the sibling attempt provision, covering assault or criminal force in attempting wrongfully to confine a person - carries one year and a fine expressly capped at five thousand rupees. So two consecutive attempt-based aggravations use different fine-drafting styles, and nothing was found explaining the choice. S1; S11

The procedural picture: a grid, not a dial

This is the most useful thing this article has to say, and it sharpens an observation made at section 133.

Three consecutive sections carry exactly the same two-year maximum. Their procedural treatment is different in every case: S4; S9; S10

s. 132 public servants. 133 dishonours. 134 theft of carried property
Maximum2 years2 years2 years
Cognizable?YesNoYes
Bailable?NoYesYes
Compoundable?NoYes, without leaveNo

S4; S9; S10

Section 133's article observed that the procedural regime tracks the victim rather than the penalty. Section 134 shows that the position is more granular than that. Section 134's victim is anybody at all - the same as section 133's - yet section 134 is cognizable and not compoundable, while section 133 is neither. What distinguishes them is not the victim but the subject matter: property theft attracts police-initiated investigation and resists private settlement, where a dignity injury does not. S4; S9; S10

So the three variables move independently. Cognizability, bailability and compoundability are set separately for each offence, and none of them can be predicted from the maximum sentence. A reader working out the practical consequences of a charge must look up all three. S4

Section 134 is the only one of the three that is cognizable and bailable at the same time. S4

The First Schedule entry

ColumnEntry
Offence"Assault or criminal force in attempt to commit theft of property worn or carried by a person"
Punishment"Imprisonment for 2 years, or fine, or both"
Cognizable?Cognizable
Bailable?Bailable
Triable byAny Magistrate

S4

Not compoundable

Section 134 appears in neither Table to section 359 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita. Both were checked separately, with no entry in either. So the offence cannot be compounded, even with the court's permission. S4

That places it with section 132 and apart from sections 131, 133 and 136, all three of which appear in the section 359(1) Table and may be compounded without leave by the person assaulted. S4; S9; S10

Forum

The Schedule says "Any Magistrate". A Magistrate of the first class may pass up to three years under section 23(2) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita and so can impose the full two years; a Magistrate of the second class is capped at one year by section 23(3) and so cannot, although the Schedule makes the offence triable before him. S1; S4; S5

As at sections 132 and 133, the distinction is between competence to try and power to sentence. And as there, no causal claim is made: IPC section 356 also carried two years, and the First Schedule to the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 has never been retrieved for this collection, so whether the Sanhita created this gap or inherited it is unverified. S1; S2; S4

Snatching: a new offence that overlaps this one

Something significant has changed around section 134, even though the section itself did not.

Section 304 of the Sanhita creates the offence of snatching, which the Penal Code did not contain. It provides that theft is snatching if, to commit theft, the offender "suddenly or quickly or forcibly seizes or secures or grabs or takes away" movable property from a person or from his possession - and it carries up to three years, with a mandatory liability to fine ("shall also be liable to fine"). S8

Three points follow, and the third is a limitation.

Section 304 is a form of completed theft, since it opens "Theft is snatching if...". Section 134 remains the provision for the attempt accompanied by force. S1; S7; S8

Section 304 is the more serious offence - three years against two, and a fine that must be imposed rather than may be. So conduct that would have been charged under IPC section 356 may now, if the property was actually taken, fall under a provision with a higher maximum. S1; S8

But the interaction between the two is not researched here. Section 304 is identified and quoted because a reader of section 134 needs to know it exists; its elements, its own comparison with the Penal Code, and how prosecutors will choose between the two provisions are not examined. No authority on section 304 was read - it is a new provision and there may be little. S8

How the courts have applied IPC section 356

Here the honest answer is that no decision construing the ingredients of the provision was located, and the search record is worth setting out because it explains why. S1

A first search returned 458 results, but they are overwhelmingly trial-court records - a long run of matters titled "State v. [name]" - which carry no precedential weight. Section 356 is a street-crime provision charged routinely alongside robbery, so the bulk of the material is first-instance. A second search aimed at appellate authority returned 44. S1

A decision that had to be discarded

One promising-looking result was retrieved and set aside: a Gujarat High Court appeal running to over five and a half million characters, in which every apparent reference to "356" turned out to be an accused serial number or a page number rather than the section. It does not construe section 356 at all. S1

That is the number-collision problem in a pure form, and it is recorded here because a reader searching this provision will meet it: a three-digit section number matches a great deal of text that has nothing to do with the section. S1

A decision where section 356 was argued and rejected

Shamshad v. State (High Court of Delhi, Mukta Gupta J, 1 June 2017, Crl.A. 150/2015) is genuinely about section 356, but not as a holding. S14

Counsel for the appellant submitted that an offence punishable under section 356 had been "converted" into one under section 395 read with section 120B - dacoity with conspiracy - by roping in a rickshaw-puller as a fifth conspirator to make up the number of accused that dacoity requires. Counsel argued that "at best the appellants can be convicted for offence punishable under Section 356 IPC or 392 IPC" and should be released on the period already served. S14

The Court rejected that submission. It upheld the convictions under section 395 and section 120B, and upheld the seven-year sentences imposed on those counts. The only relief given was on a different point: the convictions under section 412 - dishonestly receiving property stolen in a dacoity - were set aside, on the reasoning that a person who himself commits the dacoity cannot also be the receiver of the property stolen in it. S14

So the decision tells us two useful things and establishes nothing about the section's elements.

It shows the practical role of this provision: section 356, and now section 134, is the lesser charge in the street-theft family, routinely advanced by the defence as the offence that the facts really disclose instead of robbery or dacoity. S1; S14

And it shows that the argument does not always work. Whether the lesser provision applies instead of robbery or dacoity turns on the facts - here, on how many people participated and what was actually done. S14

The passage relied on is counsel's submission, not the Court's reasoning, and the Court did not construe section 356. That is stated plainly because mistaking an argument for a holding is a trap this collection has met repeatedly. S14

Practical distinctions and common misconceptions

The theft need not succeed. Section 134 is an attempt provision; the force plus the attempt completes the offence. S1; S7

The property must be on the person at the time. "Then wearing or carrying" is a temporal requirement, and property set down or not yet picked up is outside the section on its words. S1

If the property is actually taken, look at section 304. Snatching is a new offence carrying three years and a mandatory fine. S8

No provocation carve-out applies, unlike at sections 131, 133 and 136. S1

The offence is cognizable but bailable - the only combination of its kind among the three two-year provisions in this group. S4; S9; S10

It cannot be compounded, with or without the court's leave. S4

Do not infer the procedure from the sentence. Sections 132, 133 and 134 share a two-year maximum and have three different procedural profiles. S4; S9; S10

There is no ceiling on the fine in the section, so section 8(1) governs it - unlike the very next section, which caps the fine at five thousand rupees. S1; S11

Words alone will not do, and no contact is needed either, assault requiring none. S12; S13

A second class Magistrate can try it but cannot impose the full two years. S5

Worked examples

Example 1. A grabs at the handbag Z is carrying, pushing Z in the process, but Z holds on and nothing is taken. Section 134 - force used in attempting theft of property Z was then carrying, and the attempt failed. S1

Example 2. A succeeds in wrenching the bag away. The theft is complete, and on the Sanhita's new provision this is capable of being snatching under section 304, carrying three years and a mandatory fine. The interaction with section 134 is not examined in this article. S7; S8

Example 3. A picks Z's pocket with no force at all and is caught before the wallet moves. Not section 134 - there has been no assault or criminal force. S1; S13

Example 4. Z has put his suitcase down on the platform beside him. A shoves Z and tries to take it. On the section's words this falls outside section 134, because the suitcase was not then being worn or carried - though other provisions may apply. S1

Example 5. A shoves Z while reaching for a chain round Z's neck. Section 134 - a chain worn is property "then wearing". S1

Example 6. Five people together use force to take goods a traveller is carrying. The defence may urge that this is only the lesser offence, but on Shamshad such an argument failed and convictions for dacoity were upheld. S14

Example 7. Z wishes to withdraw the complaint after recovering his property. The offence is not compoundable, so he cannot. S4

Example 8. A commits the offence against a police officer on duty, intending to deter him. Section 132 may also be engaged, which is non-bailable. S9

Commencement and which law applies

Section 134 commenced on 1 July 2024, under Ministry of Home Affairs notification S.O. 850(E) dated 23 February 2024. S15

For this section the transition is as immaterial as it can be, the provision being word for word identical to IPC section 356 with the same penalty and the same unquantified fine, and no State amendment recorded against either. For conduct before 1 July 2024 the applicable provision is IPC section 356; on or after it, section 134. S1; S2; S15

What has changed is the surrounding landscape rather than this section. The arrival of section 304 means that conduct of this general kind, where the property is actually taken, now meets a provision with a higher maximum than existed under the Penal Code. That is a question for section 304, not for this one. S8

  • Section 129 - criminal force, one of the two ways this offence may be committed. S13
  • Section 130 - assault, the other. S12
  • Section 128 - the definition of force, and the source of the "wearing or carrying" phrase that section 134 adapts. S6
  • Section 303 - the definition of theft, which section 134 presupposes. S7
  • Section 304 - snatching, a new offence carrying three years and a mandatory fine. S8
  • Section 135 - the sibling attempt provision, carrying one year and a capped fine. S11
  • Sections 132 and 133 - the two other two-year provisions in this group, each procedurally different. S9; S10

Sources and honest limits

The statutory comparison was made by token-level comparison of the India Code text of section 134 against the India Code text of IPC section 356, with page-number artefacts removed first and the Penal Code text extracted through to the next section heading to catch any State amendment note. Because the comparison returned nil, the Penal Code text was printed and read in full before the result was accepted. The section text was checked against the Gazette publication of the Sanhita. The First Schedule row and both Tables to section 359 were read from the Gazette text of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, as was section 23. The texts of sections 128, 129, 130, 132, 133, 135, 303 and 304 were read from the verified section inventory. S1; S2; S3; S4; S5; S6; S7; S8; S9; S10; S11; S12; S13

What this article does not establish:

  • NO DECISION CONSTRUING THE INGREDIENTS OF THIS PROVISION WAS LOCATED. A first search returned 458 results, overwhelmingly trial-court records with no precedential weight; a second, aimed at appellate authority, returned 44. Neither produced a decision construing the section's elements. So this article explains the statutory words but does not state how the courts have construed "attempting to commit theft" or "then wearing or carrying".
  • THE PASSAGE RELIED ON IN SHAMSHAD IS COUNSEL'S SUBMISSION, NOT A HOLDING, and the submission failed - the Court upheld the dacoity convictions. The Court did not construe section 356. It is cited for the practical role of the provision as the lesser charge in the street-theft family, and for the fact that the argument was rejected.
  • ONE RETRIEVED DECISION WAS DISCARDED AS A NUMBER COLLISION. In a Gujarat High Court appeal of over five and a half million characters, every apparent reference to "356" was an accused serial number or a page number. It is mentioned only to warn a reader searching this provision.
  • "ATTEMPTING TO COMMIT THEFT" IS NOT ANALYSED. The line between preparation and attempt is a general question of criminal law which this section does not address and which was not researched.
  • THE TEMPORAL READING OF "THEN" IS THIS ARTICLE'S OWN. That the property must be worn or carried at the moment of the attempt, and that property set down falls outside the section, is drawn from the statutory words by comparison with section 128. No authority on the point was read.
  • SECTION 304 IS IDENTIFIED, NOT ANALYSED. Snatching is a new offence and a reader of section 134 needs to know it exists, but its elements, its relationship to section 134 and to theft generally, and how prosecutors will choose between the provisions are not examined. No authority on it was read.
  • SECTION 303 IS CITED FOR ITS DEFINITION ONLY. Theft, its three Explanations and its own comparison with the Penal Code belong to that section.
  • THE FORUM GAP IS REPORTED WITHOUT ATTRIBUTING CAUSE. IPC section 356 also carried two years and the First Schedule to the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 has never been retrieved.
  • NOTHING EXPLAINS THE PROCEDURAL PATTERN. That sections 132, 133 and 134 share a maximum and differ in all three procedural variables is a verified fact about the First Schedule and the section 359 Tables; why the legislature set them as it did is not established, and no travaux were retrieved.
  • NOTHING EXPLAINS THE ABSENCE OF A PROVOCATION CARVE-OUT here where sections 131, 133 and 136 have one, or the different fine-drafting style at section 135.
  • PRIVATE DEFENCE IS STILL NOT EXAMINED anywhere in this collection, and it is capable of arising where force is used in or against an attempted theft.
  • No Law Commission search was run for this section.
  • Dates. Law checked as of the date in the article metadata. Later decisions, and any amendment to the Sanhita, are not reflected.

Section 134 is the least altered provision this collection has examined: the Sanhita reproduced IPC section 356 without changing a single character. What is interesting about it therefore lies outside its own text. Read against its neighbours, it shows that the procedural consequences attached to an offence in this Chapter are set independently of the sentence and independently of each other - three consecutive provisions share a two-year maximum and no two of them are treated alike, with section 134 alone being cognizable and bailable at once. Read against section 304, it shows that the Sanhita's real intervention in this area was not to amend the attempt provision but to add a new and graver offence of snatching beside it. And read on its own words, the small word "then" confines it to property actually on the person at the moment force is used. Verify the current text, and take advice on your own facts, before acting.

Frequently asked questions

+What does BNS Section 134 punish?
Using assault or criminal force against a person while attempting to commit theft of property that person is then wearing or carrying. The maximum is two years' imprisonment of either description, or fine, or both.
+Does the theft have to succeed?
No. This is an attempt offence: the force together with the attempt completes it. Theft is defined at section 303 as moving the property to take it dishonestly, so section 134 bites before the property has moved. Once it is moved the theft itself is complete and other provisions are engaged.
+What does 'then wearing or carrying' mean?
It is a temporal requirement, and the key word is 'then'. Section 128, which defines force, speaks of anything a person 'is wearing or carrying'; section 134 says 'is THEN wearing or carrying'. So the echo is deliberate but not verbatim - section 134 adds the qualifier, and the property must be on the person at the moment of the attempt. Property the complainant had set down, or had not yet picked up, falls outside the section on its words. Note that this reading is drawn from the statutory words and no authority on it was read.
+Does the First Schedule use the same wording?
Not quite. The Schedule describes the offence as theft of property 'worn or carried' by a person, dropping the 'then'. That is a paraphrase; the section governs.
+Is there a grave and sudden provocation carve-out?
No, and the absence is worth noting. Sections 131, 133 and 136 all use that formula; section 134 does not, and carries no Explanation or Illustration of any kind. So the three-way asymmetry in how the provocation Explanations are distributed simply does not arise here. Nothing was found explaining why provocation is relevant to the general offence and to the dignity offence but not to this one.
+Which IPC section did BNS Section 134 replace, and what changed?
IPC section 356, and nothing changed at all. The comparison returns ZERO differences - the operative text is identical word for word and punctuation for punctuation. This is the first provision in this collection found to be absolutely identical to its Penal Code predecessor; even section 130, the closest previous case, carried one punctuation change.
+How do you know the nil result is not a failed extraction?
Because that was expressly checked. A zero-difference comparison is indistinguishable from a failed extract, so the Penal Code text was printed out in full and read before the comparison was trusted. It was complete, so the nil result is real.
+Is there a State amendment to this provision?
None is recorded against IPC section 356. The Penal Code text was extracted through to the next section heading to catch any State amendment note - the check that located a Maharashtra amendment against IPC section 353 raising that provision's maximum from two years to five - and nothing of the kind is present here.
+Is there a ceiling on the fine?
Not in the section, which says simply 'or with fine', so section 8(1) of the Sanhita supplies the limit. IPC section 356 also left the fine unquantified, so the position is unchanged. The contrast with the very next section is instructive: section 135, the sibling attempt provision covering attempted wrongful confinement, carries one year and a fine expressly capped at five thousand rupees. Two consecutive attempt-based aggravations, two different fine-drafting styles, and nothing was found explaining the choice.
+Is the offence cognizable and bailable?
The First Schedule records it as COGNIZABLE and BAILABLE, triable by any Magistrate. So the police may register and investigate without a Magistrate's order, but bail is available as of right.
+Sections 132, 133 and 134 all carry two years. Are they treated the same?
No - and this is the most useful thing to understand about this part of the Chapter. All three carry the same two-year maximum and no two of them are treated alike. Section 132 is cognizable, non-bailable and not compoundable. Section 133 is non-cognizable, bailable and compoundable without leave. Section 134 is cognizable, bailable and not compoundable. So the three variables move independently and none of them can be predicted from the sentence: the procedural regime is a grid, not a dial. Section 134 is the only one of the three that is cognizable and bailable at the same time.
+Section 133's analysis said the regime tracks the victim. Does that still hold?
It needs refining. Section 134's victim is anybody at all, the same as section 133's, yet section 134 is cognizable and not compoundable while section 133 is neither. So what distinguishes them is not the victim but the subject matter: property theft attracts police-initiated investigation and resists private settlement, where a dignity injury does not. The position is more granular than a single variable.
+Can the offence be compounded?
No. Section 134 appears in neither Table to section 359 - both were checked separately and there is no entry in either - so it cannot be compounded even with the court's permission. That places it with section 132 and apart from sections 131, 133 and 136, all three of which may be compounded without leave by the person assaulted.
+Which Magistrate can try it, and can he impose the full two years?
The Schedule says 'Any Magistrate'. A Magistrate of the first class may pass up to three years under section 23(2) and so can impose the full two; a Magistrate of the second class is capped at one year by section 23(3) and so cannot, although the Schedule makes the offence triable before him. As at sections 132 and 133 the distinction is between competence to try and power to sentence, and no causal claim is made - IPC section 356 also carried two years and the First Schedule to the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 has never been retrieved for this collection.
+What is Section 304 and why does it matter here?
Section 304 creates the offence of SNATCHING, which the Penal Code did not contain. It provides that theft is snatching if, to commit theft, the offender 'suddenly or quickly or forcibly seizes or secures or grabs or takes away' movable property from a person or from his possession, and it carries up to THREE YEARS with a MANDATORY liability to fine. It matters because it is a form of COMPLETED theft, where section 134 remains the provision for the attempt accompanied by force - and because it is the more serious offence, so conduct that would have been charged under IPC section 356 may now, if the property was actually taken, fall under a provision with a higher maximum.
+So should a snatching be charged under Section 134 or Section 304?
This article does not answer that. Section 304 is identified and quoted because a reader of section 134 needs to know it exists, but its elements, its relationship to section 134 and to theft generally, and how prosecutors will choose between the provisions are not examined. No authority on section 304 was read - it is a new provision and there may be little.
+What have the courts said about the elements of this offence?
Nothing that was located. A first search returned 458 results, but they are overwhelmingly trial-court records titled 'State v. [name]', which carry no precedential weight - section 356 is a street-crime provision charged routinely alongside robbery, so most of the material is first-instance. A second search aimed at appellate authority returned 44. Neither produced a decision construing the section's elements.
+Was any decision discarded during the research?
Yes, and it is worth knowing about. A promising-looking Gujarat High Court appeal running to over five and a half million characters was retrieved and set aside, because every apparent reference to '356' turned out to be an accused serial number or a page number rather than the section. That is the number-collision problem in a pure form, and a reader searching a three-digit section number will meet it.
+What happened in Shamshad v. State?
Counsel for the appellant SUBMITTED that an offence punishable under section 356 had been 'converted' into one under section 395 read with section 120B - dacoity with conspiracy - by roping in a rickshaw-puller as a fifth conspirator to make up the number dacoity requires, and that 'at best the appellants can be convicted for offence punishable under Section 356 IPC or 392 IPC'. THE COURT REJECTED THAT SUBMISSION and upheld the convictions under sections 395 and 120B together with the seven-year sentences. The only relief given was on a different point: the section 412 convictions were set aside, because a person who himself commits the dacoity cannot also be the receiver of the property stolen in it.
+So what does Shamshad establish about Section 134?
Nothing about its elements, and the article says so plainly. The passage relied on is COUNSEL'S SUBMISSION, not the Court's reasoning, and the Court did not construe section 356. It is cited for two narrow things: that this provision is the lesser charge in the street-theft family, routinely advanced by the defence as the offence the facts really disclose instead of robbery or dacoity; and that the argument does not always work.
+Can words alone constitute this offence?
No - an assault or criminal force is required. But no contact is needed either, because assault requires none.
+What if the pocket is picked with no force at all?
Section 134 is not engaged, because there has been no assault or criminal force. The theft provisions would be the relevant ones.
+Which law applies to conduct before 1 July 2024?
IPC section 356. Since the two provisions are identical in every character, nothing whatever turns on the date so far as this section is concerned. What has changed is the surrounding landscape, because section 304 now adds a graver offence for the completed taking.

Sources

  1. S1The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (Act No. 45 of 2023), section 134 - official text of the offence and the marginal note — Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India (India Code) (accessed 14 October 2026)
  2. S2The Indian Penal Code, 1860 (Act No. 45 of 1860), section 356 - the repealed text used for the correspondence analysis, extracted through to the next section heading to check for State amendment notes — Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India (India Code) (accessed 14 October 2026)
  3. S3The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 - Gazette of India, Extraordinary, Part II, Section 1, as published by the Ministry of Home Affairs - used to verify the text of section 134 as enacted — Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India (accessed 14 October 2026)
  4. S4The Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (Act No. 46 of 2023) - Gazette text, used for the First Schedule entry for section 134 and for both Tables to section 359 — Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India (accessed 14 October 2026)
  5. S5The Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (Act No. 46 of 2023), section 23 - sentences which Magistrates may pass — Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India (India Code) (accessed 14 October 2026)
  6. S6The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (Act No. 45 of 2023), section 128 - force, and the source of the 'wearing or carrying' phrase — Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India (India Code) (accessed 14 October 2026)
  7. S7The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (Act No. 45 of 2023), section 303 - theft — Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India (India Code) (accessed 14 October 2026)
  8. S8The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (Act No. 45 of 2023), section 304 - snatching, a new offence with no Penal Code equivalent — Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India (India Code) (accessed 14 October 2026)
  9. S9The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (Act No. 45 of 2023), section 132 - assault or criminal force to deter public servant from discharge of his duty, a procedural comparator — Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India (India Code) (accessed 14 October 2026)
  10. S10The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (Act No. 45 of 2023), section 133 - assault or criminal force with intent to dishonour, a procedural comparator — Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India (India Code) (accessed 14 October 2026)
  11. S11The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (Act No. 45 of 2023), section 135 - assault or criminal force in attempt to wrongfully confine a person, the sibling attempt provision — Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India (India Code) (accessed 14 October 2026)
  12. S12The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (Act No. 45 of 2023), section 130 - assault, and its Explanation — Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India (India Code) (accessed 14 October 2026)
  13. S13The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (Act No. 45 of 2023), section 129 - criminal force — Ministry of Law and Justice, Government of India (India Code) (accessed 14 October 2026)
  14. S14Shamshad v. State, High Court of Delhi, Mukta Gupta J, judgment dated 1 June 2017, Crl.A. 150/2015 - cited for the practical role of the provision and for the rejection of a submission, not for any construction of the section — Indian Kanoon (reproducing the judgment of the High Court of Delhi) (accessed 14 October 2026)
  15. S15Ministry of Home Affairs notification S.O. 850(E) dated 23 February 2024, appointing 1 July 2024 as the date of commencement of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 — Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India (accessed 14 October 2026)

Related deep dives

← All BNS section deep dives