The short answer
Section 135 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 punishes using assault or criminal force against a person while attempting to confine them wrongfully. The maximum is one year's imprisonment of either description, or a fine up to five thousand rupees, or both. S1
"Whoever assaults or uses criminal force to any person, in attempting wrongfully to confine that person, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to one year, or with fine which may extend to five thousand rupees, or with both."
Three things are worth stating at the outset.
The Sanhita raised the fine fivefold. IPC section 357 capped it at one thousand rupees; section 135 caps it at five thousand. The custodial maximum of one year is unchanged, so the fine is the only thing the legislature altered here. S1; S2
It is the only provision in this group that can be compounded only with the court's permission. Sections 131, 133 and 136 may be compounded without leave; sections 132 and 134 cannot be compounded at all; section 135 sits between them. S4
And it is the first offence in this run whose forum entry is unimpeachable. One year and five thousand rupees both fall squarely within a second class Magistrate's powers, so the Schedule's "Any Magistrate" creates no gap - unlike sections 132, 133 and 134. S4; S5
The elements
Assault or criminal force
The conduct element is the one shared across this group: an assault within section 130 or the use of criminal force within section 129. Words alone will not do; no contact is required for an assault. S9; S10
In attempting wrongfully to confine that person
This is what section 135 is about, and the phrase is defined elsewhere.
Wrongful confinement is defined at section 127 of the Sanhita: wrongfully restraining a person "in such a manner as to prevent that person from proceeding beyond certain circumscribing limits". So confinement is restraint within a boundary, as distinct from the simple obstruction of movement that wrongful restraint covers. S6
Section 135 does not restate that definition and this article does not re-derive it; section 127 is a seven-sub-section provision with its own aggravated forms, and it belongs to that section. S6
Section 135 is an attempt provision. The confinement need not be achieved. What completes the offence is the use of assault or criminal force in the course of attempting it. If the confinement succeeds, section 127 and its aggravated forms are engaged instead. S1; S6
No Explanation, no Illustration, no provocation carve-out
Section 135 carries none of these. As at section 134, the absence of a grave and sudden provocation carve-out is worth noting, because sections 131, 133 and 136 all have one. Nothing was found explaining the distribution. S1
Against IPC section 357
The fine was raised fivefold
The comparison of the operative texts returns one difference: S1; S2
| IPC s. 357 | BNS s. 135 | |
|---|---|---|
| Imprisonment | up to 1 year | up to 1 year (unchanged) |
| Fine | up to one thousand rupees | up to five thousand rupees |
So the Sanhita left the custodial exposure exactly as it was and multiplied the fine by five. S1; S2
There is no uniform uprating factor
This is where the finding becomes interesting, because the collection can now compare.
| Provision | IPC fine | BNS fine | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| s. 131 | ₹500 | ₹1,000 | doubled |
| s. 135 | ₹1,000 | ₹5,000 | fivefold |
| ss. 132, 133, 134 | unquantified | unquantified | unchanged |
Within a single Chapter the Sanhita therefore did three different things with fines: left three provisions' fines unquantified and untouched, doubled one, and quintupled another. There is no consistent revaluation of nineteenth-century money figures, and nothing was found explaining the choices. S1; S2; S7; S8
The marginal note was modernised; the operative text was not
This takes a little care to see, and it was found by testing the marginal note separately from the operative words.
- IPC section 357's marginal note: "Assault or criminal force in attempt wrongfully to confine a person"
- Section 135's marginal note: "Assault or criminal force in attempt to wrongfully confine a person"
- Both operative texts: "in attempting wrongfully to confine that person"
So the Sanhita rearranged the older construction into modern word order in the heading only, and left the operative sentence exactly as the Penal Code had it. S1; S2
That is the same pattern of selective, incomplete modernisation found elsewhere in this group - the ordinals tidied at section 128 but the archaism left at section 129, the spelling normalised at section 133. Nothing of substance turns on it, and the operative words are what a court construes. But it is a reminder that a marginal note may have been updated when the section itself has not. S1
Three different phrasings in three places
Following from that, the same offence is described three ways in the current law: S1; S4
| Source | Phrasing |
|---|---|
| Section 135's marginal note | "in attempt to wrongfully confine a person" |
| Section 135's operative text | "in attempting wrongfully to confine that person" |
| First Schedule, BNSS | "in attempt wrongfully to confine a person" |
The First Schedule uses the Penal Code's old word order, not the Sanhita's new marginal note. Nothing turns on any of this, but it shows the Schedule was drafted from the predecessor rather than from the enacted marginal note. S1; S4
No State amendment
The Penal Code text was extracted through to the next section heading to catch any State amendment note, and none is recorded against section 357. S2
Classification, forum and compounding
The First Schedule entry
| Column | Entry |
|---|---|
| Offence | "Assault or use of criminal force in attempt wrongfully to confine a person" |
| Punishment | "Imprisonment for 1 year, or fine of 5,000 rupees, or both" |
| Cognizable? | Cognizable |
| Bailable? | Bailable |
| Triable by | Any Magistrate |
But the Schedule misstates the fine. The section provides a fine "which may extend to five thousand rupees" - a maximum. Column 3 says "fine of 5,000 rupees", which reads as a fixed sum. This is the second occasion in this group on which the Schedule has presented a ceiling as a flat figure, section 131 being the first. The Schedule's third column is a summary; the section governs. S1; S4
The forum is correctly assigned - and this is the first time in this run
Section 23(3) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita permits a Magistrate of the second class to pass imprisonment up to one year, or a fine up to ten thousand rupees, or both. S5
Section 135's maximum is one year and five thousand rupees. Both fall within that power exactly. So "Any Magistrate" in the Schedule is accurate: every class of Magistrate before whom the offence may be tried can also impose the full sentence. S1; S4; S5
That is worth saying plainly, because it is the first offence in this run of sections for which the forum entry creates no gap. Sections 132, 133 and 134 all carry two-year maxima that a second class Magistrate cannot impose, producing a mismatch between competence to try and power to sentence. Section 135's one-year maximum removes the problem, and it does so because the maximum happens to coincide exactly with the lower Magistrate's ceiling. S1; S4; S5
Compoundable, but only with the court's permission
Section 359 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita contains two Tables. Section 359(1) lists offences that "may be compounded" by the persons named - no leave required. Section 359(2) lists offences that may be compounded "with the permission of the Court before which any prosecution for such offence is pending". S4
Section 135 appears in the section 359(2) Table, with the person competent to compound being "the person assaulted or to whom the force was used". S4
So the court's permission is required. That distinguishes section 135 from every other provision in this group examined so far: S4
| Compounding position | Provisions |
|---|---|
| Without leave - s. 359(1) | ss. 131, 133, 136 |
| With the court's permission - s. 359(2) | s. 135 |
| Not compoundable at all | ss. 132, 134 |
All three compounding positions therefore occur within this single family of offences, and section 135 is the only member to occupy the middle one. S4
A note on how this was established, because it was nearly got wrong. The two Tables sit close together, and a probe window wide enough to cover the section 359(1) Table also reaches into the section 359(2) Table, so the same entry can appear to be in both. The sub-section boundaries were therefore located precisely - section 359(1) opens with the words quoted above, and section 359(2) opens separately with its "permission of the Court" formula - and the Tables were re-probed within those bounds. Only then was the entry's position confirmed. S4
How the courts have applied IPC section 357
No decision construing the ingredients of this provision was located, and the reason is worth setting out because it is a research hazard in its own right.
The search is polluted by a different statute's section 357
A search for authority on section 357 of the Penal Code returns, at the top, Ankush Shivaji Gaikwad v. State of Maharashtra, Supreme Court of India, 3 May 2013, reported (2013) 6 SCC 770 and recorded as cited by 372. S11
That decision has nothing to do with this offence. It concerns section 357 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 - the power to order compensation to victims - and the passage that matches is the Court considering "whether any compensation be awarded against the appellant and in favour of the bereaved family under Section 357 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973". The judgment mentions compensation 78 times and wrongful confinement not once. S11
This is a cross-statute number collision, and it is more troublesome than the within-document collisions met earlier in this collection. The colliding provision - victim compensation under the Code - is heavily litigated and the subject of leading Supreme Court authority, while IPC section 357 is a minor offence rarely litigated on its own. So the more important provision crowds the search entirely, and the 62 results returned are substantially about compensation rather than about this offence. S11
The decision is cited here only to record that collision, so that a reader searching this provision knows what they will meet and why. It establishes nothing whatever about section 135. S11
What this means for the reader
This article therefore explains the statutory words and the procedural position, but it does not state how the courts have construed "in attempting wrongfully to confine". No authority on the attempt threshold, or on how far an attempted confinement must have progressed, was read. S1
What can be said is that the content of "wrongfully to confine" comes from section 127, which has its own body of law, and that the question under section 135 is whether force was used in the course of attempting that - not whether confinement was achieved. S1; S6
Practical distinctions and common misconceptions
The confinement need not succeed. This is an attempt provision; if the confinement is achieved, section 127 and its aggravated forms are engaged. S1; S6
Confinement is restraint within a boundary, as section 127 defines it - not merely stopping someone from going one way. S6
The fine is five times the old maximum but the custodial maximum is unchanged at one year. S1; S2
The fine is a ceiling, not a fixed sum, notwithstanding how the Schedule puts it. S1; S4
The offence is cognizable and bailable - the same combination as section 134. S4
Compounding requires the court's permission. This is the only provision in the group in that position. S4
Any Magistrate can both try it and impose the full sentence - the forum entry creates no gap here. S4; S5
No provocation carve-out applies, unlike sections 131, 133 and 136. S1
Words alone will not do, and no contact is needed either. S9; S10
Beware the section number when researching. "Section 357" will return authority on victim compensation under the Code of Criminal Procedure, not on this offence. S11
Worked examples
Example 1. A seizes Z and tries to push him into a locked room, but Z breaks free at the door. Section 135 - criminal force used in attempting to confine Z within circumscribing limits, the attempt having failed. S1; S6
Example 2. A succeeds in locking Z in the room. The confinement is complete, and section 127 is engaged rather than section 135. S6
Example 3. A shoves Z to stop him walking down a particular path, with no intention of enclosing him anywhere. That is wrongful restraint, not an attempt at confinement, so section 135 is not the provision. S1; S6
Example 4. A raises a fist to drive Z backwards into a cell, never touching him. Section 135 may still be engaged - assault requires no contact. S1; S9
Example 5. A court is asked to accept a compromise between A and Z. Permission is required, because section 135 is in the section 359(2) Table - unlike a section 131 or section 133 matter, which the parties may compound without approaching the court. S4
Example 6. A second class Magistrate tries the case and considers the maximum warranted. He may impose the full one year and five thousand rupees, both being within his powers. S5
Example 7. Conduct before 1 July 2024, where the court considers a substantial fine appropriate. The old ceiling of one thousand rupees applies, not five thousand. S1; S2; S12
Commencement and which law applies
Section 135 commenced on 1 July 2024, under Ministry of Home Affairs notification S.O. 850(E) dated 23 February 2024. S12
Here the date matters, and it matters only to the fine. For conduct before 1 July 2024 the applicable provision is IPC section 357, whose fine ceiling was one thousand rupees; for conduct on or after that date it is section 135, with a ceiling of five thousand. Since the Sanhita's figure is the higher, the earlier and lower ceiling governs earlier conduct. S1; S2; S12
The custodial maximum is one year under either provision, the elements are identical, and no State amendment is recorded against either. S1; S2
Related provisions worth reading alongside section 135
- Section 127 - wrongful confinement, which supplies the content of what is being attempted. S6
- Section 129 - criminal force, one of the two ways this offence may be committed. S10
- Section 130 - assault, the other. S9
- Section 134 - the sibling attempt provision, carrying two years and an unquantified fine. S7
- Section 131 - the other provision in this group whose fine the Sanhita uprated, and at a different multiple. S8
Sources and honest limits
The statutory comparison was made by token-level comparison of the India Code text of section 135 against the India Code text of IPC section 357, with page-number artefacts removed first and the Penal Code text extracted through to the next section heading to catch any State amendment note. The marginal notes were compared separately from the operative texts, which is how the word-order change was found. The section text was checked against the Gazette publication of the Sanhita. The First Schedule row was read from the Gazette text of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, as was section 23; both Tables to section 359 were re-probed within precisely located sub-section boundaries before the compounding position was stated. The texts of sections 127, 129, 130, 131 and 134 were read from the verified section inventory. S1; S2; S3; S4; S5; S6; S7; S8; S9; S10
What this article does not establish:
- NO DECISION CONSTRUING THE INGREDIENTS OF THIS PROVISION WAS LOCATED. 62 results were returned and they are substantially about section 357 of the Code of Criminal Procedure - victim compensation - rather than about this offence. So this article does not state how the courts have construed "in attempting wrongfully to confine", and no authority on the attempt threshold was read.
- ANKUSH SHIVAJI GAIKWAD IS CITED ONLY TO RECORD THE COLLISION. It is a Supreme Court decision on compensation under the Code of Criminal Procedure and establishes nothing about section 135. It is included because a reader researching this provision will meet it at the top of the results.
- SECTION 127 IS CITED FOR ITS DEFINITION ONLY. Wrongful confinement, its Illustrations and its six further sub-sections belong to that section, which this collection has already built; they are not re-analysed here.
- THE ATTEMPT THRESHOLD IS NOT ANALYSED. How far an attempted confinement must have progressed, and the general line between preparation and attempt, are not addressed by the section and were not researched.
- NOTHING EXPLAINS THE FINE CHANGES. That section 131's fine was doubled and section 135's quintupled while sections 132, 133 and 134 were left unquantified is a verified set of facts; why is not established, and no travaux or Law Commission material was retrieved for any section in this group.
- NOTHING EXPLAINS THE ABSENCE OF A PROVOCATION CARVE-OUT here where sections 131, 133 and 136 have one.
- THE MARGINAL-NOTE OBSERVATION IS A TEXTUAL ONE ONLY. That the heading was modernised while the operative words were not is verified; no consequence is claimed from it, and marginal notes do not control operative words.
- THE FORUM CONCLUSION DEPENDS ON THE COINCIDENCE OF TWO FIGURES. One year is exactly a second class Magistrate's ceiling. The article does not suggest the legislature intended that alignment, only that the result is a clean fit.
- THE PROCEDURAL CONSEQUENCES OF COGNIZABILITY AND BAILABILITY ARE STATED BUT NOT WORKED THROUGH.
- PRIVATE DEFENCE IS STILL NOT EXAMINED anywhere in this collection, and it is capable of arising where force is used to resist an attempted confinement.
- No State variation to the First Schedule entry was checked.
- Dates. Law checked as of the date in the article metadata. Later decisions, and any amendment to the Sanhita, are not reflected.
Section 135 is a small provision that repays comparison in three directions. Against its predecessor it shows the Sanhita doing one thing only - raising a nineteenth-century fine by a factor of five while leaving the custodial maximum and every element untouched - and, set beside section 131's doubling and the three neighbouring provisions left unquantified, it shows that there was no consistent policy about those figures at all. Against its sibling at section 134 it shows two attempt-based aggravations drafted differently in both penalty and fine style. And against the rest of the group it occupies a procedural position no other member holds: compoundable, but only if the court permits it. It is also the one offence in this run whose forum entry raises no difficulty, because a one-year maximum sits exactly within the powers of the lowest Magistrate who may try it. Verify the current text, and take advice on your own facts, before acting.