The short answer
Section 127 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 is the Sanhita's wrongful confinement provision, and it is the largest consolidation in this part of the Code. Eight sub-sections replace eight Penal Code sections - IPC sections 340 and 342 to 348. S1; S2
Sub-section (1) defines the offence and carries two Illustrations. Sub-sections (2) to (8) create a graduated series: S1
| Sub-s | Conduct | Punishment |
|---|---|---|
| (2) | wrongful confinement | up to 1 year, or fine up to 5,000, or both |
| (3) | for three days or more | up to 3 years, or fine up to 10,000, or both |
| (4) | for ten days or more | up to 5 years, and fine not less than 10,000 |
| (5) | knowing a writ for liberation has issued | up to 2 years, in addition to any other term under this Chapter, and fine |
| (6) | secret confinement | up to 3 years, in addition to any other punishment, and fine |
| (7) | to extort property, or constrain to an illegal act | up to 3 years, and fine |
| (8) | to extort a confession or information, or compel restoration of property | up to 3 years, and fine |
Three things matter most.
Confinement is defined as a species of restraint. Sub-section (1) begins "Whoever wrongfully restrains any person in such a manner as to prevent that person from proceeding beyond certain circumscribing limits". So every wrongful confinement is necessarily a wrongful restraint under section 126, but not the other way round. S1; S6
Sub-section (4) carries a minimum fine - "fine which shall not be less than ten thousand rupees". That is the first minimum fine encountered anywhere in this collection, and because no ceiling is stated, section 8(1) supplies an upper limit that is unlimited but not excessive. S1; S7
There is no minimum term anywhere in section 127. The only "not less than" in the whole section attaches to that fine. S1
Sub-section (1): the definition, and the boundary with Section 126
The definition
"Whoever wrongfully restrains any person in such a manner as to prevent that person from proceeding beyond certain circumscribing limits, is said 'wrongfully to confine' that person." S1
How confinement differs from restraint
This is the question section 126 expressly declined to answer, and the texts answer it between them.
Section 126(1) - wrongful restraint - is prevention from proceeding in a direction in which the person has a right to proceed. It blocks a route. S6
Section 127(1) - wrongful confinement - is a wrongful restraint done in such a manner as to prevent proceeding beyond circumscribing limits. It encloses. S1
So the relationship is one of containment, not alternatives:
- Every wrongful confinement is a wrongful restraint, because sub-section (1) is built on the words "wrongfully restrains".
- Not every wrongful restraint is a confinement, because blocking one direction leaves others open.
- The difference is whether the person is shut in on all sides rather than merely turned back from one.
That reading comes from the statutory words and is this article's analysis; no decision located addresses the boundary directly. S1; S6
The Illustrations: limits need not be walls
The two Illustrations to sub-section (1) are doing real work, and the second is the important one: S1
"(a) A causes Z to go within a walled space, and locks Z in. Z is thus prevented from proceeding in any direction beyond the circumscribing line of wall. A wrongfully confines Z.
(b) A places men with firearms at the outlets of a building, and tells Z that they will fire at Z if Z attempts to leave the building. A wrongfully confines Z."
Illustration (a) is the obvious case - a physical enclosure. Illustration (b) establishes that the circumscribing limits may be created by threat rather than by structure. Nobody touches Z, no door is locked, and Z is free to walk out in the purely physical sense; the confinement lies in the credible threat that makes leaving impossible in practice. S1
That is worth holding onto, because it is what allows the section to reach encirclement by a crowd, a guarded room, or a person kept in place by intimidation.
Against IPC sections 340 and 342 to 348
Each sub-section was compared separately against its predecessor. The results vary widely, and no single pattern emerges.
Sub-section (1) against IPC section 340 - no substantive change. The definition and both Illustrations are reproduced word for word. S1; S2
Sub-section (2) against IPC section 342 - the fine rose fivefold, from one thousand rupees to five thousand. The one-year maximum is unchanged. S1; S2
Sub-section (3) against IPC section 343 - two changes, pulling in opposite directions. The term rose from two years to three. But the fine, which IPC section 343 left unquantified, now carries a ceiling of ten thousand rupees. S1; S2
That second change needs the section 8(1) step. An unexpressed fine was unlimited but not excessive under IPC section 63, and section 8(1) says the same. So introducing a ten-thousand-rupee ceiling reduced the maximum fine exposure while the custodial maximum rose. The same phenomenon appeared at section 118(1), and it is the reason a fine comparison can never be done by reading the new figure alone. S1; S2; S7
Sub-section (4) against IPC section 344 - three changes. The term rose from three years to five. And the fine, again unquantified under the Penal Code, became "fine which shall not be less than ten thousand rupees" - a floor, not a ceiling. S1; S2
This is a genuinely unusual construction and the first of its kind in this collection. Because the sub-section states a minimum but no maximum, section 8(1) continues to supply the upper limit: the fine must be at least ten thousand rupees and may be any larger sum that is not excessive. A reader who treats ten thousand as the figure has the provision backwards. S1; S7
Sub-section (5) against IPC section 345 - a fine was added. IPC section 345 provided for two years' imprisonment in addition to any other term, with no fine at all. Sub-section (5) adds "and shall also be liable to fine". The term and the additive structure are unchanged. S1; S2
Sub-section (6) against IPC section 346 - two changes. The term rose from two years to three, and a fine was added where IPC section 346 provided none. S1; S2
Sub-sections (7) and (8) against IPC sections 347 and 348 - no substantive change. Sub-section (7) returned zero differences on comparison; sub-section (8) likewise, once a page number and the following sub-heading were set aside. S1; S2
The pattern, or the absence of one
Across eight sub-sections: two unchanged, one with a fivefold fine rise, one with a term rise plus a fine reduction, one with a term rise plus a minimum fine, one with a fine newly added, one with a term rise plus a fine newly added, and one more unchanged. S1; S2
There is no multiplier and no uniform approach. That is consistent with what this collection has found repeatedly: the Sanhita's treatment of penalties has to be checked provision by provision, and within a single section sub-section by sub-section. S1; S2
The two additive sub-sections
Sub-sections (5) and (6) are unusual in that their punishment runs in addition to other punishment, rather than instead of it. But they are not drafted alike, and the difference is worth noting. S1
Sub-section (5) imposes two years "in addition to any term of imprisonment to which he may be liable under any other section of this Chapter". S1
Sub-section (6) imposes three years "in addition to any other punishment to which he may be liable for such wrongful confinement". S1
So sub-section (5) reaches across the Chapter, while sub-section (6) is tied to the punishment for the confinement itself. Both formulations are carried over from the Penal Code unchanged, so neither is a Sanhita innovation; whether anything turns on the difference is not addressed by any decision located, and this article does not assert that it does. S1; S2
Classification: seven rows, and three defects
The First Schedule to the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 gives section 127 seven rows, one for each offence sub-section. There is no row for sub-section (1), which is purely definitional - the same arrangement as at section 126. S1; S8
| Entry | Punishment (column 3) | Cognizable? | Bailable? | Court |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 127(2) | Imprisonment for 1 year, or fine of 5,000 rupees, or both | Cognizable | Bailable | Any Magistrate |
| 127(3) | Imprisonment for 3 years, or fine of 10,000 rupees, or both | Cognizable | Bailable | Any Magistrate |
| 127(4) | Imprisonment for 5 years and fine of 10,000 rupees | Cognizable | Non-bailable | Magistrate of the first class |
| 127(5) | Imprisonment for 2 years in addition to any term of imprisonment to under any other section and fine | Cognizable | Bailable | Magistrate of the first class |
| 127(6) | Imprisonment for 3 years in addition to other punishment which he is liable to and fine | Cognizable | Bailable | Magistrate of the first class |
| 127(7) | Imprisonment for 3 years and fine | Cognizable | Bailable | Any Magistrate |
| 127(8) | Imprisonment for 3 years and fine | Cognizable | Bailable | Any Magistrate |
Only sub-section (4) is non-bailable. Every other sub-section is bailable. S8
Defect one: a forum mismatch the Sanhita created
Sub-section (4) carries five years and is assigned to a Magistrate of the first class, who may not pass more than three years under section 23(2) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita. S8; S9
The Sanhita created this gap. IPC section 344's maximum was three years, which matched a first-class Magistrate's power exactly. Raising the term to five years opened a two-year shortfall that did not previously exist. The same thing happened at section 121(1), where a three-year maximum became five while the forum stayed put. S1; S2; S8; S9
Sections 361 and 362 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita supply the apparent route to a court competent to pass a heavier sentence, but that is the statutory answer rather than an adjudicated one, and no decision on the point was located. S8
A softer version of the same issue affects sub-sections (3), (7) and (8), all of which carry three years but are assigned to "Any Magistrate". A Magistrate of the second class may pass only one year under section 23(3), so the ceiling depends on which Magistrate in fact tries the case. S8; S9
Defect two: the Schedule turns a minimum fine into a flat figure
Column 3 for sub-section (4) reads "Imprisonment for 5 years and fine of 10,000 rupees". The section says "fine which shall not be less than ten thousand rupees". S1; S8
The row therefore presents a floor as though it were the sum. A reader working from the Schedule would conclude that ten thousand rupees is the fine, when in truth it is the minimum and section 8(1) leaves the maximum open. S1; S7; S8
This is the third distinct kind of Schedule defect this collection has found around minimum sentences - after a row presenting a minimum and a maximum as alternatives at section 121(2), and a row dropping a minimum altogether at section 124(2). The lesson is consistent: column 3 is a summary and the section governs. S8
Defect three: the sub-section (5) row is garbled and wider than the section
Column 3 for sub-section (5) reads "Imprisonment for 2 years in addition to any term of imprisonment to under any other section and fine". S8
Two problems. The words "to which he may be liable" have collapsed into a bare "to", leaving the entry ungrammatical. And the row says "under any other section" where the sub-section says "under any other section of this Chapter" - so the Schedule reads wider than the provision it summarises. The section's words control. S1; S8
Compounding: four yes, three no, and no evident logic
Both Tables to section 359 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita were searched separately. Every compoundable entry is in the section 359(1) Table, so none requires the court's permission, and nothing appears in the section 359(2) Table. S8
| Sub-s | Compoundable? | Who may compound |
|---|---|---|
| (2) | Yes, no permission needed | the person restrained or confined (in a row shared with section 126(2)) |
| (3) | Yes, no permission needed | the person confined |
| (4) | Yes, no permission needed | the person confined |
| (6) | Yes, no permission needed | the person confined |
| (5) | No - absent from both Tables | - |
| (7) | No - absent from both Tables | - |
| (8) | No - absent from both Tables | - |
The distribution does not track seriousness. Sub-section (4) is the gravest offence in the section - five years, the only non-bailable one, and the only one with a mandatory minimum fine - and it may be compounded without the court's permission. Sub-sections (7) and (8), at three years and bailable, cannot be compounded at all. And of the two additive provisions, secret confinement under sub-section (6) is compoundable while confinement in defiance of a writ under sub-section (5) is not. S8
This article reports that distribution as a verified fact. No rationale for it was found, and none is offered. S8
Taken with section 125, where clauses (a) and (b) require the court's leave, the surrounding provisions now display all three compounding positions: not compoundable, compoundable with leave, and compoundable without leave. S8
How the courts apply it
A Supreme Court conviction, upheld
In Raju Pandurang Mahale v. State of Maharashtra (Supreme Court, Doraiswamy Raju and Arijit Pasayat JJ, judgment of Arijit Pasayat J, 11 February 2004, reported AIR 2004 SC 1677 and (2004) 4 SCC 371), the appellant's conviction under IPC section 342 read with section 34 - six months' rigorous imprisonment - stood alongside a conviction under section 354 read with section 34. The trial court convicted, the Bombay High Court maintained those convictions, and the Supreme Court dismissed the appeal, holding that the conclusions below did "not suffer from any infirmity" and that the sentences, far from being excessive, were lenient. S4
The Court's reasoning on the confinement count concerned section 34 rather than the ingredients of section 342. It restated that under section 34 "the essence of the liability is to be found in the existence of a common intention animating the accused leading to the doing of a criminal act in furtherance of such intention", and that section 34 "is applicable even if no injury has been caused by the particular accused himself" and does not require proof of "some overt act on the part of the accused". S4
For a reader of section 127 the practical consequence is direct: a person may be liable for wrongful confinement on the basis of common intention without having personally done the confining act. The case is cited here for that and for the fact and level of the conviction; the underlying offences were grave and are not recounted. S4
Encirclement: the gherao case
Jay Engineering Works Ltd. v. State of West Bengal (Calcutta High Court, Special Bench, judgment of Sinha C.J., 29 September 1967, reported AIR 1968 Cal 407) arose from a group of cases the Court described as "gherao" cases. S5
The Court declined to define a gherao exhaustively, but described it as practised in those cases as "encirclement by the workmen of the employers and their managerial staff followed by various hostile manifestations", which "invariably take crude and obnoxious forms and involve physical and mental torture", and as including "the blockade of a target from inside", the object being "to compel the employers to accept the demands of the employees by threats and coercive methods". S5
It held that the gherao as practised in those cases "has involved violation of the laws of the land and commission of cognizable offences under the Indian Penal Code and also other statutes", and that it "must be held to be unlawful". The impugned police circulars were held unlawful, the police officers were found to have failed in their duties, and the rule was made absolute. S5
Why this matters for section 127. Encirclement is precisely the mischief that Illustration (b) to sub-section (1) describes - a person enclosed by a cordon and a threat rather than by a wall. The decision shows the provision's predecessors being applied to that situation. S1; S5
An important caveat on attribution. The passage most often quoted from this decision - that where persons "wrongfully restrain or wrongfully confine another person... it is elementary that the matter comes under Sections 339, 340 read with Sections 341, 342 of the IPC... and cannot be saved by Section 17 of the Trade Unions Act 1926" - is not the Court's own holding. The judgment records it at paragraph 28 as one of several concessions made by the Advocate General to shorten the proceedings. It is therefore counsel's position, accepted for the purposes of the hearing, and this article does not cite it as authority. What the Court itself decided is set out in the paragraph above. S5
The decision is also a single High Court's, now nearly six decades old, and its industrial-relations context has moved on. It is relied on here only for the description of encirclement and for the holding that such conduct was unlawful and involved cognizable offences. S5
Practical distinctions and common misconceptions
Confinement is a form of restraint, not an alternative to it. Sub-section (1) is built on "wrongfully restrains", so a confinement charge carries the restraint elements with it. S1; S6
The limits need not be physical. Illustration (b) settles that a credible threat at the exits is enough. S1
Sub-section (1) creates no offence. It defines. The Schedule accordingly begins at 127(2). S1; S8
Duration escalates the offence, not the fault. Sub-sections (2), (3) and (4) differ only in how long the confinement lasted - one day, three days, ten days. The mental element is the same throughout. S1
Three days means three days or more; ten days means ten days or more. Both thresholds are expressed inclusively. S1
Sub-section (4)'s fine is a floor, not a figure. At least ten thousand rupees, with no stated ceiling, so section 8(1) governs the maximum. The Schedule's row is misleading on this. S1; S7; S8
There is no minimum term in section 127 - only the minimum fine in sub-section (4). S1
Sub-sections (5) and (6) stack. Their punishment is additional to other punishment, not a substitute for it. S1
A fine alone is available only under (2) and (3). Sub-sections (4) to (8) all use "and shall also be liable to fine" or equivalent, so the fine is cumulative on imprisonment. S1
Liability can rest on common intention. On Raju Pandurang Mahale, no personal overt act need be proved where section 34's successor applies. S4
Provocation is irrelevant. Section 127 contains no carve-out referring to section 122, which is confined to the hurt provisions. S1
No minor-offence illustration applies. Neither section 126 nor section 127 is named in any Illustration to section 245 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, and this article asserts no minor-offence relationship. S8
Worked examples
Example 1. A locks Z in a room overnight. Sub-section (2) - up to one year, or a fine up to five thousand rupees, or both. Compoundable by Z without the court's leave. S1; S8
Example 2. The same, for four days. Sub-section (3) - up to three years, or a fine up to ten thousand rupees, or both. S1
Example 3. The same, for a fortnight. Sub-section (4) - up to five years, and a fine of at least ten thousand rupees with no stated ceiling. Non-bailable. Note the forum point: the Schedule sends it to a Magistrate of the first class, who cannot pass more than three years. S1; S7; S8; S9
Example 4. A posts armed men at the exits of a building and tells Z they will fire if Z leaves. Wrongful confinement, on Illustration (b), with no wall and no lock. S1
Example 5. A crowd encircles Z's managerial staff and prevents them leaving until demands are met. On Jay Engineering Works, encirclement of that kind was held unlawful and to involve cognizable offences; which sub-section applies depends on duration and purpose, and sub-section (7) is in play if the object was to constrain them to do something illegal. S1; S5
Example 6. A keeps Z confined after being told that a writ for Z's liberation has issued. Sub-section (5) - two years in addition to the punishment for the confinement itself. Not compoundable. S1; S8
Example 7. A confines Z and conceals both the fact and the place from Z's family and from the police. Sub-section (6) - three years in addition to the other punishment. S1
Example 8. A confines Z to make Z's brother hand over property. Sub-section (7). If instead the object is to extract a confession from Z, sub-section (8). Neither is compoundable. S1; S8
Example 9. A plans the confinement and B carries it out, A never touching Z. On Raju Pandurang Mahale, common intention can found liability without a personal overt act. S4
Commencement and which law applies
Section 127 commenced on 1 July 2024, under Ministry of Home Affairs notification S.O. 850(E) dated 23 February 2024. S10
The temporal position here is not uniform across the section, which makes it unlike anything earlier in this part of the Code.
Where the change aggravates, it is prospective only. The fivefold fine rise in sub-section (2), the term increases in sub-sections (3), (4) and (6), the minimum fine in sub-section (4), and the fines newly added in sub-sections (5) and (6) all increase exposure. Conduct before 1 July 2024 remains subject to IPC sections 342 to 346 as they stood. S1; S2; S10
Where nothing changed, the date is immaterial - sub-sections (1), (7) and (8). S1; S2
And in one respect the change is favourable to an accused. Sub-section (3) caps a fine that was previously unlimited. Whether a provision that reduces a maximum penalty can benefit someone whose conduct predates it is a distinct question, which this article does not attempt to resolve; it is raised because the asymmetry within a single section is easy to miss. S1; S2; S7
The elements are unchanged throughout, so nothing about what must be proved turns on the date. S1; S2
For proceedings instituted on or after 1 July 2024 the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita governs, so the seven Schedule rows and the compounding positions apply whichever substantive Act supplies the offence. S8
Related provisions worth reading alongside section 127
- Section 126 - wrongful restraint, of which confinement is a species, and the source of the elements sub-section (1) builds on. S6
- Section 8 - the amount of fine where no sum is expressed; essential to sub-sections (3) and (4). S7
- Sections 23, 359, 361 and 362 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 - sentencing powers, compounding, and commitment to a competent court. S8; S9
Sources and honest limits
All eight sub-sections were compared separately against their Penal Code predecessors by token-level comparison of the India Code texts, with the section text checked against the Gazette publication of the Sanhita. All seven First Schedule rows and both Tables to section 359 were read from the Gazette text of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, with wrapped continuation lines read in full. India Code handles were read from the verified section inventory. S1; S2; S3; S8
Two defects in the source text used for this collection should be recorded. The India Code record of section 127 carries doubled full stops at several points where the Gazette has one, and renders "valuable security" in sub-section (8) as a single word, "valuablesecurity". The Gazette form is authoritative and has been used throughout. S1; S3
What this article does not establish:
- The boundary analysis is this article's own. That confinement is a species of restraint follows from sub-section (1)'s opening words, but no decision addressing the boundary between sections 126 and 127 was located.
- No decision construing section 127 under its new numbering was located, and the searches on the predecessor provisions returned 58 and 12 hits which were not read exhaustively.
- Raju Pandurang Mahale is cited narrowly. Its reasoning on the confinement count is about common intention, not about the ingredients of confinement. The Court did not construe what "circumscribing limits" means.
- Jay Engineering Works is a single High Court decision of 1967, not binding elsewhere, and its subsequent treatment was not checked. The proposition most often quoted from it is a concession by the Advocate General, not the Court's holding, and is not relied on here.
- The two additive formulations in sub-sections (5) and (6) are reported, not resolved. Whether anything turns on the difference in their scope is not addressed by any decision located.
- No travaux were retrieved. A Law Commission search covering wrongful restraint and wrongful confinement was run at section 126 and returned nothing bearing on either, so nothing explains the fine changes, the minimum fine in sub-section (4), or the compounding distribution.
- No rationale for the compounding distribution was found, and the article deliberately offers none.
- The First Schedule to the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 was not retrieved, so no claim is made about how IPC sections 342 to 348 were previously classified, including whether any compounding position changed.
- The favourable-change question at sub-section (3) is raised but not answered, and nothing here should be read as advice on it.
- Habeas corpus and the writ referred to in sub-section (5) are not researched. The sub-section presupposes a writ for liberation duly issued; the law governing such writs is outside this article's scope.
- Dates. Law checked as of the date in the article metadata. Later decisions, and any amendment to the Sanhita or the Schedules, are not reflected.
Section 127 is where the Penal Code's scattered confinement provisions were gathered into one place, and the gathering is the main achievement: one definition, two Illustrations, and seven graduated offences that previously sat in seven separate sections. The substantive changes are real but uneven - a fivefold fine here, two extra years there, a fine newly attached to two provisions that had none, a fine ceiling that quietly reduced exposure, and a minimum fine that is the first of its kind. For a practitioner the two points most likely to be missed are structural rather than penal: that confinement is restraint plus enclosure, so section 126's elements come with it, and that the circumscribing limits can be built out of a threat as readily as out of a wall. Verify the current text and classification, and take advice on your own facts, before acting.