What Section 8 does
Section 8 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 ("BNS") carries the official marginal-note title Amount of fine, liability in default of payment of fine, etc. and is the Sanhita's complete code on fines and on what happens when a fine is not paid. In seven sub-sections it answers:
- how much a fine can be when the offence section names no figure: s. 8(1);
- whether the court may order imprisonment in default: s. 8(2);
- how long that default imprisonment may be: s. 8(3) and s. 8(5);
- what description it is: s. 8(4) and s. 8(5);
- when it ends if the fine is paid, wholly or partly: s. 8(6);
- for how long the fine itself can be recovered: s. 8(7). S1S2
It also carries the consequences of default in community service, the new punishment added by s. 4(f), which has no IPC ancestor at all.
The mapping: eight IPC sections collapsed into one
Section 8 is one of the clearest consolidations in the Sanhita. The IPC spread this material across ss. 63 to 70; the BNS brings it into a single section. S1S4
| BNS s. 8 | IPC source | Change |
|---|---|---|
| (1) fine unlimited but not excessive | s. 63 | Verbatim |
| (2)(a), (b) power to order default imprisonment | s. 64 | Verbatim in substance |
| (3) one-fourth cap where imprisonment as well as fine | s. 65 | Verbatim |
| (4) description of default imprisonment | s. 66 | Extended to default in community service |
| (5) simple imprisonment and scale | s. 67 | Substantially changed: scope, amounts and the residual cap |
| (6)(a) imprisonment ends on payment | s. 68 | Verbatim |
| (6)(b) proportional payment, with Illustration | s. 69 | Verbatim rule; Illustration amounts updated |
| (7) six-year recovery; death and property | s. 70 | Verbatim |
So five of the seven sub-sections are carried across unchanged. The substance of the section is the IPC's. What changed is concentrated in sub-sections (4) and (5), and it is worth setting out precisely.
Sub-section (5): the real changes, and one of them is stricter
IPC s. 67 and BNS s. 8(5) do the same job, they cap default imprisonment where the offence is at the lighter end, but they differ in three ways.
| IPC s. 67 | BNS s. 8(5) | |
|---|---|---|
| Applies where the offence is punishable with | fine only | fine or community service |
| Description of default imprisonment | simple | simple (unchanged) |
| Cap where fine is small | 2 months: fine not exceeding ₹50 | 2 months: fine not exceeding ₹5,000 |
| Cap at the next tier | 4 months: fine not exceeding ₹100 | 4 months: fine not exceeding ₹10,000 |
| Cap in any other case | 6 months | 1 year |
Three observations follow, and they point in different directions.
1. The monetary thresholds were multiplied by one hundred. ₹50 became ₹5,000 and ₹100 became ₹10,000. Those IPC figures dated from 1860 and had become meaningless; the update is plainly overdue and plainly favourable to defendants, because the two shorter caps now reach far larger fines. A ₹4,000 fine that would have fallen into the IPC's residual six-month bracket now falls into the two-month bracket.
2. The residual cap was doubled, from six months to one year. This is the change that cuts the other way, and it is easy to miss while reading the reassuring threshold increases. Where the fine exceeds ₹10,000 and the offence is punishable with fine or community service, the maximum default imprisonment is now one year, where under IPC s. 67 it was six months. On the face of the text this is a stricter provision for the higher-value cases.
3. The scope changed. IPC s. 67 was keyed to an offence "punishable with fine only". BNS s. 8(5) is keyed to an offence punishable with "fine or community service". That reflects the arrival of community service in s. 4(f), but it also means the two provisions are not coextensive, which matters for the gap discussed below.
Editorial analysis. Read as a whole, sub-section (5) is neither simply a liberalisation nor simply a tightening. It rescues the great majority of small fines from long default terms while raising the ceiling for the largest. Anyone describing the BNS's fine provisions as uniformly modernised and softened is describing only the first half of the change.
Sub-section (4) and community service default
IPC s. 66 provided that default imprisonment for a fine "may be of any description to which the offender might have been sentenced for the offence". BNS s. 8(4) reproduces that and adds default in community service to it. S1S4
Read with s. 8(5), the position on community service is:
- If the offence was punishable with fine or community service and the convict defaults on either, the default imprisonment must be simple and is capped on the s. 8(5) scale.
- Otherwise, s. 8(4) allows default imprisonment of any description to which the offender might have been sentenced for that offence.
This is the answer to a question the s. 4 article flags: community service is not a punishment without teeth. Non-performance can lead to imprisonment, and the Sanhita says so in terms. What neither Sanhita says is how non-performance is to be established or measured. There is no statutory rule on partial performance of community service, in contrast to the detailed rule for partial payment of a fine in s. 8(6)(b). That asymmetry is a genuine gap on the face of the text, and no judicial decision on it was located. S1
Sub-section (6): paying your way out, in whole or in part
Sub-section (6) is a mechanical but genuinely useful rule, and it is carried over unchanged from IPC ss. 68 and 69:
- (a) Default imprisonment terminates whenever the fine is paid or levied by process of law.
- (b) If part of the fine is paid or levied such that the imprisonment already suffered is "not less than proportional to the part of the fine still unpaid", the imprisonment terminates. S1
The Illustration works it through, and the BNS has updated its amounts: where IPC s. 69's illustration used a fine of ₹100 with ₹75 and ₹50 part-payments, BNS s. 8(6) uses ₹1,000 with ₹750 and ₹500. S1S4 The arithmetic is identical, a ten-fold scaling, and the worked example below follows the statute's own numbers.
A small inconsistency worth noting. The s. 8(5) thresholds were updated one hundred-fold (₹50 → ₹5,000), while the s. 8(6) illustration was updated ten-fold (₹100 → ₹1,000). Nothing turns on it legally, an illustration does not control the operative provision, but a reader comparing the two should not assume a single conversion factor was applied across the section.
Sub-section (7): the fine can be recovered for six years
Sub-section (7) reproduces IPC s. 70 verbatim. S1S4 Three limbs are worth separating:
- Unpaid fine may be levied at any time within six years after the sentence was passed.
- If under the sentence the offender is liable to imprisonment for longer than six years, the fine may be levied at any time before that period expires.
- The death of the offender does not discharge from liability any property which would, after death, be legally liable for his debts.
The third limb is the one most often overlooked: a fine is not extinguished by death so far as the estate is concerned.
A structural gap carried over from the IPC
This is a point of real practical interest, and it is a feature of both codes.
- s. 8(3) caps default imprisonment at one-fourth of the maximum term, but only "if the offence be punishable with imprisonment as well as fine".
- s. 8(5) imposes the simple-imprisonment requirement and the two-month, four-month and one-year caps, but only where the offence is punishable with "fine or community service".
Neither limb is keyed to the common formula "punishable with imprisonment or fine". On the literal words, an offence of that kind falls within s. 8(2)(b), so default imprisonment may be ordered, without falling within either express cap in s. 8(3) or s. 8(5). The IPC had exactly the same structure, s. 65 being conditioned on "imprisonment as well as fine" and s. 67 on "fine only". S1S4
What fills the gap in practice is procedural. BNSS s. 24 provides that a Magistrate may award such term of default imprisonment "as is authorised by law", subject to a proviso that the term (a) is not in excess of the Magistrate's powers under BNSS s. 23, and (b) shall not, where imprisonment has been awarded as part of the substantive sentence, exceed one-fourth of the term the Magistrate is competent to inflict for the offence otherwise than as default imprisonment. BNSS s. 24(2) adds that default imprisonment may be in addition to a substantive sentence for the maximum term the Magistrate may award. S5
So for a Magistrate the practical limits come from BNSS s. 24 read with s. 23. This is procedure under the BNSS, not substantive law under the BNS, and no decision on the point was located. The gap is identified here as a textual observation, not resolved.
Worked examples
Hypothetical illustrations constructed for this article, not decided cases.
1. Unlimited but not excessive. A is convicted under a section that provides for a fine without naming a figure. By s. 8(1) the amount is unlimited, but it "shall not be excessive", so the absence of a ceiling is not an absence of control. S1
2. The one-fourth cap. B is convicted of an offence punishable with imprisonment up to four years as well as fine, and is fined. By s. 8(3) default imprisonment cannot exceed one-fourth of four years, that is one year. S1
3. The one-fourth cap where the maximum is life. C is convicted of an offence punishable with imprisonment for life as well as fine. Section 6 reckons imprisonment for life at twenty years for calculating fractions, so the s. 8(3) cap is five years. S1
4. The new scale. D is convicted of an offence punishable with fine or community service and is fined ₹4,000. By s. 8(5)(a) the default imprisonment must be simple and cannot exceed two months. Under IPC s. 67 the same fine would have exceeded both the ₹50 and ₹100 thresholds and fallen into the residual bracket of up to six months. S1S4
5. The residual cap, where the BNS is stricter. E is convicted of an offence punishable with fine or community service and is fined ₹60,000. The fine exceeds ₹10,000, so s. 8(5)(c) applies and the default imprisonment may extend to one year. The IPC equivalent was six months. S1S4
6. Paying part of the fine. F is fined ₹1,000 with four months' default imprisonment. Following the Illustration to s. 8(6), if ₹750 is paid before one month of imprisonment has expired, F is discharged as soon as the first month ends; if ₹500 is paid before two months have expired, F is discharged once the two months are completed. S1
7. Recovery after death. G is fined and dies two years later without paying. By s. 8(7) the fine may still be levied within six years of the sentence against property that would, after G's death, be legally liable for G's debts. S1
Common mistakes
- Thinking a fine with no stated maximum is truly unlimited. Section 8(1) adds "but shall not be excessive". S1
- Applying the one-fourth cap to every offence. Section 8(3) applies only where the offence is punishable with imprisonment as well as fine. S1
- Quoting the IPC's ₹50 and ₹100 figures. They are now ₹5,000 and ₹10,000. S1S4
- Assuming the new scale is uniformly more lenient. The residual cap doubled from six months to one year. S1S4
- Thinking default imprisonment runs concurrently with the substantive sentence. Section 8(2) says it "shall be in excess of any other imprisonment" to which the offender has been sentenced, and BNSS s. 24(2) says the same for a Magistrate's order. S1S5
- Assuming community service default is uncapped. Section 8(4) and, where applicable, s. 8(5) govern it, and in the s. 8(5) case the imprisonment must be simple. S1
- Assuming partial performance of community service earns proportional credit. Section 8(6)(b) gives that rule for part-payment of a fine; there is no equivalent for community service. S1
- Thinking a fine dies with the offender. Section 8(7) preserves liability against property that would be liable for his debts. S1
- Forgetting the six-year limit on levying a fine, or the extension where the offender is liable to imprisonment for longer than six years. S1
On the "need for change"
- Documented section-specific legislative rationale: none was located for Section 8, and none is claimed.
- What the texts establish: eight IPC sections (ss. 63 to 70) were consolidated into one, with five of the seven sub-sections carried over verbatim. The identifiable changes are the extension of s. 8(4) and s. 8(5) to community service, the hundred-fold increase in the s. 8(5) monetary thresholds, the doubling of the residual default cap from six months to one year, and the ten-fold update of the s. 8(6) Illustration. S1S4
- Editorial assessment: the consolidation is a clear drafting gain: a reader now finds the whole law of fines and default in one place instead of eight. The monetary updating was necessary and overdue. The doubling of the residual cap is a substantive increase in exposure that the structure of the section does not advertise, and is the one change in Section 8 that a defendant should care about. The structural gap for offences punishable with "imprisonment or fine" was not closed.
Verified judicial interpretation
No judgment on BNS s. 8 was located while preparing this article; it has been in force only since 1 July 2024. S3
Because sub-sections (1), (2), (3), (6) and (7) reproduce IPC ss. 63, 64, 65, 68, 69 and 70 in substance, IPC-era authority on those provisions should continue to apply, the operative wording being unchanged. Caution is needed on sub-section (5): authority construing IPC s. 67 was addressed to an offence "punishable with fine only" and to a six-month residual cap, and neither description fits the new provision. No case list is offered here for the unchanged sub-sections, because on these mechanical provisions the authorities add little to the statutory words.
Related provisions in this collection
- BNS s. 4(e) and (f): fine and community service as punishments.
- BNS s. 6: the twenty-year equivalence used when the s. 8(3) one-fourth cap is taken of a life maximum.
- BNS s. 7: the court's choice between rigorous and simple imprisonment, which s. 8(5) displaces by requiring simple imprisonment.
- BNS s. 9: limit of punishment where an offence is made up of several offences.
- BNSS s. 23 and s. 24: a Magistrate's sentencing powers and the procedural limits on default imprisonment.
Sources and disclaimer
BNS text is from the Gazette of India publication of Act 45 of 2023 S1, cross-checked against the
India Code entry for the section S2. IPC text is from the India Code version of Act 45 of 1860
S4. BNSS text is from the Gazette publication of Act 46 of 2023 S5. Pinpoints and access dates
are in the sources array.
This article is for education and general information. It is AI-assisted and has not been reviewed, verified or approved by a lawyer. It is not legal advice and must not be relied on for any actual case. The amount of any fine and the length of any default sentence are matters of judicial discretion within the statutory limits. Verify the current position and take advice from a qualified advocate before acting.