What Section 4 does
Section 4 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 ("BNS") carries the official marginal-note title Punishments. and lists the punishments that may be imposed under the Sanhita. It is a menu, not an offence: it confers no power to punish anybody for anything. The power comes from the individual offence sections, and Section 4 simply fixes the permissible kinds of punishment those sections may draw on. S1S2
The list is:
| Punishment | |
|---|---|
| (a) | Death |
| (b) | Imprisonment for life |
| (c) | Imprisonment, of two descriptions: (1) rigorous, that is, with hard labour; (2) simple |
| (d) | Forfeiture of property |
| (e) | Fine |
| (f) | Community Service |
Clause (f) is the headline. Community service is the first new category of punishment added to India's general penal code since 1860, and it is the main reason this short section matters.
The mapping: IPC s. 53, cleaned up and extended by one
| BNS s. 4 | IPC s. 53 | Change |
|---|---|---|
| (a) Death | "First,—Death" | Unchanged |
| (b) Imprisonment for life | "Secondly.—Imprisonment for life" | Unchanged |
| — | "Thirdly": omitted in the IPC itself | Gap removed |
| (c) Imprisonment, rigorous or simple | "Fourthly.—Imprisonment … (1) Rigorous, that is, with hard labour; (2) Simple" | Unchanged, including "with hard labour" |
| (d) Forfeiture of property | "Fifthly.—Forfeiture of property" | Unchanged |
| (e) Fine | "Sixthly.—Fine" | Unchanged |
| (f) Community Service | no IPC equivalent | New |
So Section 4 is a renumbering of IPC s. 53 with one genuinely new clause. Two tidying points are worth noting because they are sometimes mistaken for substance. First, the archaic ordinals ("First", "Secondly", "Fourthly") become letters (a) to (f). Second, IPC s. 53 contained a visible gap where "Thirdly", transportation, had been omitted from the IPC long before the BNS; the BNS simply closes the gap. No existing punishment was removed. S1S4
The retention of "rigorous, that is, with hard labour" in clause (c) is worth flagging expressly, since it is occasionally written up as having been softened. The words are carried over unchanged from IPC s. 53. S1S4
Community service: what it is, and where the definition actually lives
This is the part readers most need, and the part most often got wrong.
The BNS does not define community service. The expression appears in clause (f) and in a few other places in the Sanhita, but nowhere in it is the term explained. S1
The definition is in the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 ("BNSS"), in the Explanation to s. 23:
"Community service" shall mean the work which the Court may order a convict to perform as a form of punishment that benefits the community, for which he shall not be entitled to any remuneration. S5
That definition reaches the BNS through BNS s. 2(39), the residuary clause, under which words used but not defined in the Sanhita but defined in the BNSS carry the meaning assigned there. S1 So the correct citation chain for a court is s. 4(f), read with s. 2(39) of the BNS and the Explanation to s. 23 of the BNSS, not s. 4(f) alone.
Three features of that definition deserve attention:
- It is a punishment, not a concession. The Explanation calls it "a form of punishment". It is not probation, not a bond, and not a discharge.
- It is unpaid. The convict "shall not be entitled to any remuneration".
- Its content is left to the Court. The Explanation says only that it is "the work which the Court may order", performed so as to benefit the community. Neither the BNS nor the Explanation prescribes the hours, the nature of the work, the supervising agency, or the consequences of partial performance.
Editorial analysis. That third point is the practical weakness of the new punishment as it stands on the statute. A sentencing court is given a power with no statutory scale and no statutory machinery. How it is administered will depend on State-level arrangements and judicial practice rather than on the text of either Sanhita. This article does not assert how any particular court or State in fact administers it, because that was not verified.
Which offences can actually attract community service
Clause (f) makes community service an available punishment, but it is available only where an offence section provides for it. On a search of the Sanhita as published, six sections do: S1
| BNS section | Offence | How community service is provided |
|---|---|---|
| s. 202 | Public servant unlawfully engaging in trade | Simple imprisonment up to 1 year, or fine, or both, or community service |
| s. 209 | Non-appearance in response to a proclamation under BNSS s. 84 | Imprisonment up to 3 years, or fine, or both, or community service (the aggravated limb, for a declared proclaimed offender, carries up to 7 years and fine, with no community service option) |
| s. 226 | Attempt to commit suicide to compel or restrain exercise of lawful power | Simple imprisonment up to 1 year, or fine, or both, or community service |
| s. 303(2) | Theft | Mandatory community service in a defined narrow case: see below |
| s. 355 | Misconduct in public by a drunken person | Simple imprisonment up to 24 hours, or fine up to ₹1,000, or both, or community service |
| s. 356(2) | Defamation | Simple imprisonment up to 2 years, or fine, or both, or community service |
Anyone told that the BNS has introduced community service "for petty offences" generally should note how narrow the list is: six provisions out of 358.
The theft proviso is different from the other five, and stricter in form
In five of the six sections community service is one option among several, and the court chooses. Section 303(2) is not like that. Its proviso reads:
"Provided that in cases of theft where the value of the stolen property is less than five thousand rupees, and a person is convicted for the first time, shall upon return of the value of property or restoration of the stolen property, shall be punished with community service." S1
Read carefully, this is a mandatory direction, "shall be punished with community service", and it is gated by three cumulative conditions:
- the value of the stolen property is less than five thousand rupees;
- the person is convicted for the first time under the section; and
- there is return of the value of the property or restoration of the stolen property.
Where all three are satisfied the proviso directs community service; it does not merely permit it. Two cautions, both visible on the face of the text. The proviso contains a duplicated "shall" ("…and a person is convicted for the first time, shall upon return … shall be punished…"), which is a drafting slip rather than a second condition. And it does not say by whom or at what stage the return or restoration must be made. No judicial decision construing the proviso was located for this article, so its precise operation should be treated as unsettled.
What happens if community service is not performed
Section 8, on fines and default, was drafted to accommodate the new punishment and expressly addresses default in community service.
- By s. 8(4), the imprisonment the court imposes in default of payment of a fine or in default of community service may be of any description to which the offender might have been sentenced for the offence.
- By s. 8(5), where the offence is punishable with fine or community service, the imprisonment imposed in default of either "shall be simple", and is capped on a scale: not exceeding two months where the fine does not exceed ₹5,000; four months where it does not exceed ₹10,000; and one year in any other case. S1
Two points follow. First, the BNS did not add clause (f) to s. 4 and leave it unsupported: it threaded the consequences of non-performance through the fine-default machinery. Second, and more practically, default in community service can end in imprisonment, so it is not a punishment without teeth; but where the offence was punishable only with fine or community service, that default imprisonment must be simple and is subject to the s. 8(5) caps.
Clause (d): forfeiture of property is retained, but it is nearly vestigial
Clause (d) carries forward "Forfeiture of property" from IPC s. 53. Its practical reach is easily overstated, and the reason is historical rather than anything the BNS did.
The IPC's general forfeiture provisions, ss. 61 and 62, were repealed by the Indian Penal Code (Amendment) Act, 1921 (16 of 1921), s. 4, long before the BNS. S4 After that, forfeiture survived only where a particular offence section provided for it, and the same position obtains under the Sanhita. On a search of the BNS as published, forfeiture of property is provided as a punishment by two sections, with a third providing for forfeiture of seized articles:
| BNS section | IPC counterpart | What is forfeited |
|---|---|---|
| s. 154: committing depredation on the territories of a foreign State at peace with the Government of India | s. 126 | Fine and forfeiture of any property used or intended to be used in committing the depredation, or acquired by it |
| s. 155: receiving property taken by war or depredation mentioned in ss. 153 and 154 | s. 127 | Fine and forfeiture of the property so received |
| s. 186(2): prohibition of fictitious stamps | s. 263A | Any such stamp, die, plate, instrument or materials in a person's possession for making a fictitious stamp may be seized and, if seized, shall be forfeited |
In each case the BNS reproduces the IPC position; the scope of forfeiture is unchanged. S1S4
A caution on searching for this: several BNS sections contain the word "forfeiture" without providing it as a punishment: ss. 243 and 244 (fraudulently removing, concealing or claiming property to prevent its seizure as forfeited) and ss. 255 and 256 (public servants acting to save property from forfeiture) are offences about forfeiture, not sentences of forfeiture. S1
So clause (d) preserves a head of punishment used by two offence sections. It is not a general confiscation power, and forfeiture or attachment of property in ordinary criminal practice is governed by procedural and special legislation rather than by BNS s. 4(d).
What Section 4 does not do
- It does not say which punishment applies to which offence. That is for the offence section.
- It does not create a sentencing hierarchy or guidelines. The order (a) to (f) is a list, not a scale of preference, and nothing in Section 4 directs a court to prefer a lighter punishment.
- It does not abolish the death penalty or life imprisonment. Both are retained in clauses (a) and (b).
- It does not make community service generally available. Only the six sections above provide it.
- It says nothing about how imprisonment for life is to be computed. That is s. 6, under which imprisonment for life is reckoned as equivalent to twenty years only "in calculating fractions of terms of punishment", and only "unless otherwise provided": a provision frequently misread as meaning a life sentence lasts twenty years. S1
Worked examples
Hypothetical illustrations constructed for this article, not decided cases.
1. Community service is not available just because an offence is minor. A is convicted of an offence punishable with up to six months' simple imprisonment or fine. If that offence section does not mention community service, the court cannot impose it: s. 4(f) lists the punishment but does not authorise it for any particular offence. S1
2. The theft proviso, satisfied. B steals an item worth ₹3,000, is convicted for the first time under s. 303, and the property is restored. All three conditions of the proviso are met, so it directs that B be punished with community service. S1
3. The theft proviso, not satisfied. C steals an item worth ₹7,000 and restores it, and is a first-time convict. The value exceeds ₹5,000, so the proviso does not apply and the ordinary punishment under s. 303(2) (up to three years, or fine, or both) governs. Restoration may of course be urged in mitigation, but the proviso's mandatory direction is unavailable. S1
4. The theft proviso and a repeat convict. D steals an item worth ₹500 and restores it, but has a previous conviction under s. 303. The proviso requires a first conviction, so it does not apply; instead the second-conviction limb of s. 303(2) applies, which carries rigorous imprisonment of not less than one year extending to five years, and fine. On these facts the value of the property being small does not reduce the exposure. S1
5. Rigorous or simple. E is convicted of an offence punishable with "imprisonment of either description". By s. 4(c) both kinds exist, and by s. 7 the court may direct that the term be wholly rigorous, wholly simple, or partly each. S1
Common mistakes
- Treating s. 4 as a source of punishing power. It lists punishments; the offence section imposes them. S1
- Saying the BNS introduced community service for petty offences generally. Six sections provide it: ss. 202, 209, 226, 303(2), 355 and 356(2). S1
- Looking for a definition of community service in the BNS. There is none; it is defined in the Explanation to BNSS s. 23 and reaches the BNS through s. 2(39). S1S5
- Assuming community service is always discretionary. In the s. 303(2) proviso it is expressed as mandatory once three conditions are met. S1
- Assuming the theft proviso applies whenever property is returned. Value below ₹5,000 and a first conviction are separate, cumulative requirements. S1
- Thinking "rigorous imprisonment" no longer means hard labour. Clause (c)(1) retains "that is, with hard labour" from IPC s. 53. S1S4
- Reading clause (d) as a general power to confiscate an offender's property. The IPC's general forfeiture sections were repealed in 1921, and under the BNS forfeiture is a punishment only in ss. 154 and 155, with forfeiture of seized articles in s. 186(2). Sections 243, 244, 255 and 256 mention forfeiture but are offences about it, not sentences of it. S1S4
- Confusing s. 4 with s. 6. Section 6's twenty-year equivalence applies only to calculating fractions of terms, and only unless otherwise provided. S1
On the "need for change"
- Documented section-specific legislative rationale: none was located for Section 4 while preparing this article, and none is claimed. The addition of community service is widely described as a reformative measure, but no official statement of reasons tied to this clause was verified, so no legislative intent is asserted here.
- What the texts establish: clauses (a) to (e) reproduce IPC s. 53; clause (f) is new; the archaic ordinals and the vacant "Thirdly" are cleaned up. The new punishment is defined not in the BNS but in the BNSS, and is made available by only six offence sections. S1S4S5
- Editorial assessment: clause (f) is a real and novel addition to Indian sentencing options, and in that narrow sense Section 4 is the most changed of the Sanhita's opening provisions. But its practical footprint as enacted is small and its administration is left unlegislated. A description of the BNS as having introduced a broad regime of community-service sentencing would overstate what Section 4 and the six offence sections actually do.
Related provisions in this collection
- BNS s. 2(39): the residuary clause through which the BNSS definition of community service reaches the Sanhita.
- BNS s. 6: fractions of terms of punishment; the twenty-year equivalence for imprisonment for life.
- BNS s. 7: direction that imprisonment be wholly or partly rigorous or simple.
- BNS s. 8: amount of fine and default, including default of community service.
- BNS s. 11 and s. 12: solitary confinement, available only where rigorous imprisonment may be awarded.
- BNS ss. 202, 209, 226, 303, 355 and 356: the six offences that provide for community service.
- BNS s. 154 and s. 155: the two sections providing forfeiture of property as a punishment; see also s. 186(2) on forfeiture of seized articles.
Sources and disclaimer
Statutory text is from the Gazette of India publication of Act 45 of 2023 S1, cross-checked
against the India Code entry for the section S2. IPC text and its amendment history are from the
India Code version of Act 45 of 1860 S4. The definition of community service is quoted from the
Gazette text of the BNSS S5. Pinpoints and access dates are in the sources array.
This article is for education and general information. It is AI-assisted and has not been reviewed, verified or approved by a lawyer. It is not legal advice and must not be relied on for any actual case. No sentence is predictable from the statute alone, and the operation of the community-service provisions has not yet been settled by any decision located here. Verify the current position and take advice from a qualified advocate before acting.