Statutory Text and Deterrence of Frivolous/Bogus Civil Litigation
Section 246 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) (replacing Section 209 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC)) is the primary substantive criminal provision aimed at deterring litigants from filing knowingly false claims in civil or other Courts S1; S3; S6 (Section 246 BNS; Section 209 IPC):
"Whoever fraudulently or dishonestly, or with intent to injure or annoy any person, makes in a Court any claim which he knows to be false, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to two years, and shall also be liable to fine." S1 (Section 246)
Essential Ingredients of Section 246 BNS (H.S. Bedi & Dalip Singh Principles)
To establish an offence under Section 246 BNS, the prosecution must prove four cumulative elements S1; S5; S6 (Section 246 BNS):
- Making a "Claim" in a "Court":
- The accused must make a claim: meaning a prayer or demand for relief, money, property, declaration, or legal right (typically in a plaint, petition, counter-claim, or application seeking affirmative relief, as distinguished from a mere denial in a written statement, though a false statement in a verified pleading also attracts Section 227/229 BNS) S1; S6 (Sections 227, 246 BNS).
- The claim must be made in a "Court" as defined in Section 2(5) BNS (a Judge or body of Judges empowered by law to act judicially alone or as a body, when acting judicially) S1 (Sections 2(5), 246).
- Objective Falsity + Actual Knowledge of Falsity ("Which He Knows to Be False"):
- Notice the strictness of the statutory wording: unlike Section 227 BNS (which covers statements the maker "knows or believes to be false or does not believe to be true"), Section 246 BNS requires that the claimant knows the claim to be false S1; S6 (Sections 227, 246 BNS).
- Why Losing a Civil Suit Does Not Automatically Attract Section 246 BNS: A litigant whose claim is dismissed because a legal issue is decided against them, because their claim is barred by limitation, or because their evidence falls short of the preponderance of probabilities is not guilty under Section 246 BNS. Section 246 targets claims that are factually known by the plaintiff to be false at the time of filing, for example, suing a tenant for rent for a period after the tenant has already paid the rent against a signed receipt, or suing to recover a loan that was never advanced S1; S6 (Section 246 BNS).
- Four Alternative Culpable Mental States: In addition to knowing the claim is false, the claimant must act with at least one of four mental states S1; S6 (Section 246 BNS):
- Fraudulently (with intent to defraud, Section 2(9) BNS); OR
- Dishonestly (with intent to cause wrongful gain to one person or wrongful loss to another person, Section 2(7) BNS); OR
- With intent to injure any person (causing illegal harm to body, mind, reputation, or property, Section 2(14) BNS); OR
- With intent to annoy any person (capturing vexatious harassment suits filed purely to drag an opponent through court and cause mental harassment or expense, even where the plaintiff expects the suit to be dismissed eventually!) S1; S6 (Sections 2(7), 2(9), 2(14), 246 BNS).
- Inchoate Completion Upon Filing: The offence under Section 246 BNS is complete the moment the false claim is instituted/made in Court; the plaintiff cannot escape liability merely by applying to withdraw the suit under Order XXIII Rule 1 CPC once the defendant exposes the fraud S1; S6 (Section 246 BNS).
Comparison: IPC Section 209 vs. BNS Section 246 (and BNSS First Schedule Wording Note)
- Substantive Continuity: Section 246 BNS is substantively identical to IPC Section 209, updating "Court of Justice" to "Court" and correcting the grammatical typo in the old marginal heading ("Dishonesty making..." → "Dishonestly making...") S1; S3 (Section 246 BNS; Section 209 IPC).
- Important Sentencing Note (Substantive BNS Text vs. BNSS First Schedule Summary):
- In the substantive text of Section 246 BNS, the punishment is "imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to two years, and shall also be liable to fine" (making fine mandatory alongside imprisonment) S1 (Section 246).
- In Column 3 of the BNSS First Schedule (which is a descriptive summary column), the entry for Section 246 is printed in some reproductions as "Imprisonment for 2 years and fine" (or in some secondary tables as "or fine"), but as a settled canon of statutory interpretation, the enacted substantive text of Section 246 BNS ("and shall also be liable to fine") controls sentencing S1; S4 (Section 246 BNS; BNSS First Schedule).
Procedural Classification and Cognizance Bar
- BNSS First Schedule Classification: Non-cognizable, Bailable, and Triable by a Magistrate of the first class S4 (First Schedule, Entry 246).
- Mandatory Court Complaint (BNSS Section 215(1)(b)(i) & Section 379): Because Section 246 BNS falls within "242 to 248 (both inclusive)" in Section 215(1)(b)(i) BNSS, no Court can take cognizance of an offence under Section 246 BNS except on the written complaint of the Court before which the false claim was made (or an authorised officer or superior Court) under Section 379 BNSS S4; S6 (Sections 215, 379 BNSS).