Statutory Text and the Collusive-Decree Mechanism
Section 245 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) (replacing Section 208 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC)) addresses a sophisticated form of judicial fraud: collusive suits where a defendant intentionally allows a bogus or inflated decree to be passed or executed against themselves to cheat genuine creditors or rightful claimants S1; S3 (Section 245 BNS; Section 208 IPC):
"Whoever fraudulently causes or suffers a decree or order to be passed against him at the suit of any person for a sum not due or for a larger sum than is due to such person or for any property or interest in property to which such person is not entitled, or fraudulently causes or suffers a decree or order to be executed against him after it has been satisfied, or for anything in respect of which it has been satisfied, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to two years, or with fine, or with both. Illustration. A institutes a suit against Z. Z, knowing that A is likely to obtain a decree against him, fraudulently suffers a judgment to pass against him for a larger amount at the suit of B, who has no just claim against him, in order that B, either on his own account or for the benefit of Z, may share in the proceeds of any sale of Z's property which may be made under A's decree. Z has committed an offence under this section." S1 (Section 245)
Why Would a Defendant "Suffer" a False Decree Against Themselves? (The Statutory Illustration Explained)
At first glance, a layperson might wonder why any defendant would want a court decree passed against them for money they do not owe. The Statutory Illustration to Section 245 BNS explains the classic commercial and civil-execution fraud that this section prevents S1 (Section 245, Illustration):
- Under Section 73 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (rateable distribution of assets in execution), where multiple decree-holders have applied for execution of decrees for the payment of money against the same judgment-debtor, the proceeds of the judgment-debtor's attached property are distributed rateably (proportionally) among all decree-holders S1 (Section 245).
- Suppose Z owes ₹50 lakh to a genuine creditor A, and Z's only attachable property is worth ₹50 lakh. To prevent A from recovering his full ₹50 lakh, Z colludes with his brother-in-law B (to whom Z owes nothing) to file a friendly suit against Z for ₹1.5 crore. Z appears in Court and immediately confesses judgment or intentionally suffers an ex parte / consent decree in B's favour. When Z's ₹50 lakh property is sold in execution, B claims three-fourths of the sale proceeds (₹37.5 lakh) via rateable distribution and secretly hands it back to Z, leaving the genuine creditor A with only ₹12.5 lakh!
- Under this scheme, Z (the collusive defendant) commits an offence under Section 245 BNS, while B (the collusive plaintiff) simultaneously commits an offence under Section 247 BNS (and Section 246 BNS for making a false claim in Court) S1 (Sections 245–247).
Breakdown of Essential Ingredients
Section 245 BNS encompasses two distinct limbs of conduct by a defendant/judgment-debtor S1 (Section 245):
- First Limb: Fraudulently Causing or Suffering an Unjust Decree or Order to Be Passed:
- Conduct: Either actively causing (e.g., filing a written statement admitting a fictitious claim or signing a collusive compromise memo) or passively suffering (e.g., deliberately abstaining from defending a pre-arranged sham suit) a decree or order to be passed against oneself at the suit of any person S1 (Section 245);
- Subject Matter of the Unjust Decree: The decree or order must be for:
- A sum not due; or
- A larger sum than is due to such person; or
- Any property or interest in property to which such person is not entitled (e.g., suffering a collusive partition or specific-performance decree over mortgaged or disputed land to defeat a third party's rights) S1 (Section 245).
- Second Limb: Fraudulently Causing or Suffering Execution of an Already-Satisfied Decree:
- Even if the original decree was completely genuine when passed, if the debt has subsequently been paid off or satisfied out of court, and the judgment-debtor fraudulently causes or suffers that decree or order to be executed against him after it has been satisfied (for example, allowing an already-paid creditor to attach and auction his property so as to shield it from other unpaid creditors), the judgment-debtor violates the second limb of Section 245 BNS S1 (Section 245).
- Mens Rea: "Fraudulently": Both limbs strictly require that the accused act "fraudulently" (with intent to defraud under Section 2(9) BNS) S1; S5 (Sections 2(9), 245 BNS). A poverty-stricken defendant who simply lacks the funds to hire a lawyer and consequently suffers an ex parte decree for an inflated claim does not act fraudulently and commits no offence under Section 245 BNS S1 (Section 245).
Punishment and Procedural Classification
- Punishment: Imprisonment of either description up to two years, or with fine, or with both S1 (Section 245).
- BNSS First Schedule Classification: Non-cognizable, Bailable, and Triable by a Magistrate of the first class (note that while Sections 243 and 244 are triable by Any Magistrate, Sections 245, 246, and 247 are triable by a Magistrate of the first class) S4 (First Schedule, Entries 243–247).
- Mandatory Court-Complaint Bar (BNSS Section 215(1)(b)(i)): Section 245 BNS falls within "242 to 248 (both inclusive)" in Section 215(1)(b)(i) BNSS S4 (Section 215(1)(b)(i)). Cognizance can be taken only upon a written complaint of the Court concerned (or an authorised officer or superior Court) under Section 379 BNSS S4 (Sections 215, 379).