Statutory Text and Mirror Relationship with Section 245 & Section 246 BNS
Section 247 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) (replacing Section 210 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC)) completes the civil-litigation fraud trilogy (Sections 245, 246, and 247 BNS) S1; S3 (Sections 245–247 BNS; Section 210 IPC). While Section 246 punishes the filing of a false claim in Court, and Section 245 punishes the defendant who collusively suffers a false decree, Section 247 BNS punishes the plaintiff or decree-holder who fraudulently obtains an unjust decree or fraudulently executes a decree that has already been satisfied:
"Whoever fraudulently obtains a decree or order against any person for a sum not due, or for a larger sum than is due or for any property or interest in property to which he is not entitled, or fraudulently causes a decree or order to be executed against any person after it has been satisfied or for anything in respect of which it has been satisfied, or fraudulently suffers or permits any such act to be done in his name, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to two years, or with fine, or with both." S1 (Section 247)
Essential Ingredients: The Three Modes of Liability Under Section 247 BNS
To convict an accused under Section 247 BNS, the prosecution must establish that the accused acted "fraudulently" (with intent to defraud under Section 2(9) BNS) in one of three statutory ways S1 (Sections 2(9), 247):
- Mode 1: Fraudulently Obtaining an Unjust Decree or Order:
- The accused obtains a decree or order (whether ex parte by suppressing summons service, by colluding with the defendant as in the Illustration to Section 245, or by playing active fraud on the Court as in S.P. Chengalvaraya Naidu v. Jagannath, (1994) 1 SCC 1) S1; S5 (Sections 245, 247 BNS); and
- That decree or order is for a sum not due, a larger sum than is due, or any property or interest in property to which the plaintiff is not entitled S1 (Section 247).
- Mode 2: Fraudulently Executing a Satisfied Decree ("Double Recovery" Fraud):
- Even where the original money or property decree was 100% legitimate when passed, if the judgment-debtor subsequently pays the decretal amount or satisfies the decree out of court, and the decree-holder (taking advantage of the fact that payment was not certified to the Executing Court under Order XXI Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908) fraudulently causes that decree or order to be executed again against the judgment-debtor, the decree-holder commits an offence under the second limb of Section 247 BNS S1 (Section 247).
- Interaction with Order XXI Rule 2(3) CPC: While Order XXI Rule 2(3) CPC bars the Executing Court from recognising an uncertified out-of-court payment in execution proceedings, criminal courts have consistently held that Order XXI Rule 2(3) CPC does not bar a criminal prosecution under IPC Section 210 (now BNS Section 247) against a decree-holder who pockets an out-of-court payment and then fraudulently executes the satisfied decree a second time S1 (Section 247)!
- Mode 3: Fraudulently Suffering or Permitting Such Act in One's Name:
- Captures a nominal plaintiff or decree-holder (such as a benamidar, assignor, or principal) who knowingly and fraudulently allows an agent, assignee, or accomplice to use their name to obtain a false decree or execute a satisfied decree S1 (Section 247).
Comparison Table: Section 246 vs. Section 247 BNS
| Feature | BNS Section 246 (IPC 209): Making False Claim | BNS Section 247 (IPC 210): Obtaining False Decree / Executing Satisfied Decree |
|---|---|---|
| Stage of Completion | Complete as soon as the false claim is made/filed in Court S1 (Section 246) | Requires that the decree or order is actually obtained, or that a satisfied decree is caused to be executed S1 (Section 247) |
| Required Mens Rea | Fraudulently, dishonestly, or with intent to injure or annoy, knowing the claim to be false S1 (Section 246) | Fraudulently (with intent to defraud, Section 2(9) BNS) S1 (Section 247) |
| Punishment Wording | Imprisonment up to 2 years, and shall also be liable to fine S1 (Section 246) | Imprisonment up to 2 years, or with fine, or with both S1 (Section 247) |
Procedural Classification and Cognizance Rules
- BNSS First Schedule Classification: Non-cognizable, Bailable, and Triable by a Magistrate of the first class S4 (First Schedule, Entry 247).
- Mandatory Court-Complaint Gate (BNSS Section 215(1)(b)(i)): Section 247 BNS is expressly included in Section 215(1)(b)(i) BNSS (
"242 to 248 (both inclusive)"), meaning no Court can take cognizance except upon the written complaint of the Court in which the decree was obtained or execution was taken out (or an authorised officer or superior Court) under Section 379 BNSS S4 (Sections 215, 379).