Statutory Text and Role as the Mirror Counterpart to Section 243 BNS
Section 244 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) (replacing Section 207 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC)) is the direct counterpart to Section 243 BNS S1; S3 (Sections 243, 244 BNS; Section 207 IPC). When a judgment-debtor or convict attempts to shield property from attachment, forfeiture, or execution, they rarely act alone; they typically rely on a collusive accomplice who either accepts a bogus transfer of the asset or files a bogus third-party objection claim (for example, under Order XXI Rule 58 CPC) pretending to be the true owner or mortgagee. Section 244 BNS punishes that collusive recipient or bogus claimant:
"Whoever fraudulently accepts, receives or claims any property or any interest therein, knowing that he has no right or rightful claim to such property or interest, or practices any deception touching any right to any property or any interest therein, intending thereby to prevent that property or interest therein from being taken as a forfeiture or in satisfaction of a fine, under a sentence which has been pronounced, or which he knows to be likely to be pronounced by a Court or other competent authority, or from being taken in execution of a decree or order which has been made, or which he knows to be likely to be made by a Court in a civil suit, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to two years, or with fine, or with both." S1 (Section 244)
Essential Ingredients of Section 244 BNS
To convict an accused under Section 244 BNS, the prosecution must establish four cumulative elements S1 (Section 244):
- Two Alternative Conduct Limbs (Actus Reus):
- Limb 1 (Accepting, Receiving, or Claiming Without Right): The accused fraudulently accepts, receives, or claims any property (movable or immovable) or any interest therein, knowing that he has no right or rightful claim to such property or interest (for example, filing an intervention/claim petition under Order XXI Rule 58 CPC or Section 86 BNSS asserting title under a fabricated lease or sham agreement to sell) S1 (Section 244); OR
- Limb 2 (Practising Deception Touching Property Rights): The accused practices any deception touching any right to any property or any interest therein S1 (Section 244).
- Fraudulent Mens Rea + Knowledge of Absence of Right: The accused must act "fraudulently" (with intent to defraud under Section 2(9) BNS) and with actual knowledge that they have no right or rightful claim to the property or interest S1 (Sections 2(9), 244).
- Bona Fide Third-Party Objector Protected: A third party who files an execution objection under a genuine, bona fide belief of title or possession, even if the Executing Court ultimately dismisses their claim on legal grounds, does not commit an offence under Section 244 BNS because they neither act "fraudulently" nor "knowing that he has no right or rightful claim" S1 (Section 244).
- Specific Ulterior Intent (To Prevent Seizure in Forfeiture, Fine Recovery, or Civil Execution): Identical to Section 243 BNS, the accused's intention must be to prevent the property or interest from being taken:
- As a forfeiture or in satisfaction of a fine under a sentence (pronounced or known likely to be pronounced by a Court or other competent authority); or
- In execution of a decree or order (made or known likely to be made by a Court in a civil suit) S1 (Section 244).
- Completion of the Offence: The offence is complete the moment the fraudulent acceptance, receipt, claim, or deception takes place with the requisite intent, even if the Executing Court sees through the collusion and rejects the third-party claim S1 (Section 244).
Comparison: IPC Section 207 vs. BNS Section 244 (and Asymmetry with Section 243 BNS)
| Feature | BNS Section 243 (IPC 206): Transferor / Concealer | BNS Section 244 (IPC 207): Collusive Recipient / Claimant |
|---|---|---|
| Target Conduct | Removes, conceals, transfers, or delivers property S1 (Section 243) | Accepts, receives, or claims property without right, or practices deception touching property right S1 (Section 244) |
| Maximum Imprisonment | 3 years (enhanced in BNS from 2 years in IPC 206) S1 (Section 243) | 2 years (unchanged from IPC 207) S1; S3 (Section 244 BNS; Section 207 IPC) |
| Fine Provision | Capped at ₹5,000 S1 (Section 243) | Unlimited fine ("or with fine, or with both", subject to Section 8(1) BNS) S1 (Sections 8(1), 244) |
| Procedural Bar | Covered by Section 215(1)(b)(i) BNSS S4 | Covered by Section 215(1)(b)(i) BNSS S4 |
Procedural Classification and Cognizance Rules
- BNSS First Schedule Classification: Non-cognizable, Bailable, and Triable by Any Magistrate S4 (First Schedule, Entry 244).
- Mandatory Court-Complaint Bar (BNSS Section 215(1)(b)(i) & Section 379): Because Section 244 BNS lies within "242 to 248 (both inclusive)" in Section 215(1)(b)(i) BNSS, when the offence is committed in or in relation to any proceeding in any Court (such as filing a fraudulent third-party claim petition in execution proceedings), no Court can take cognizance except upon the written complaint of that Court (or an authorised officer or superior Court) under Section 379 BNSS S4 (Sections 215, 379).