Overview and Direct Answer
Section 165 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) imposes a specialised negligence-based penal liability on the master or person in charge of a merchant vessel on board of which a deserter from the Army, Navy, or Air Force of the Government of India is concealed S1, s. 165. Unlike Section 164 BNS, which requires positive knowledge or "reason to believe" that the person harboured is a deserter, Section 165 BNS applies even when the master is ignorant of the concealment ("though ignorant of such concealment"), provided he might have known of it "but for some neglect of his duty as such master or person in charge, or but for some want of discipline on board of the vessel" S1, s. 164–165. Replaces Section 137 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC), while increasing the maximum monetary penalty six-fold from ₹500 to ₹3,000 S1, s. 165; S3, s. 137; S5, p. 10. No sentence of substantive imprisonment can be imposed for this offence S1, s. 165.
Statutory Text and Ingredient Breakdown
Section 165 BNS states:
"The master or person in charge of a merchant vessel, on board of which any deserter from the Army, Navy or Air Force of the Government of India is concealed, shall, though ignorant of such concealment, be liable to a penalty not exceeding three thousand rupees, if he might have known of such concealment but for some neglect of his duty as such master or person in charge, or but for some want of discipline on board of the vessel." S1, s. 165
Because Section 165 BNS departs from the ordinary mens rea requirement of actual knowledge in Chapter VIII, every constituent element must be strictly satisfied:
- Specific Accused Capacity: Master or Person in Charge of a Merchant Vessel:
- Liability attaches exclusively to
"the master or person in charge of a merchant vessel"S1, s. 165. Subordinate crew members, stevedores, shipping company shareholders, or port agents who are not in command or charge of the vessel cannot be prosecuted as principals under Section 165 BNS (though if they knowingly conceal a deserter, they face prosecution under Section 164 BNS) S1, s. 164–165. - Under Section 2(32) BNS,
"vessel"means"anything made for the conveyance by water of human beings or of property", and the qualifier"merchant vessel"restricts the provision to commercial/mercantile shipping rather than naval warships or state public vessels S1, s. 2(32); S1, s. 165.
- Liability attaches exclusively to
- Actual Concealment of an Armed Forces Deserter on Board:
- A person who has deserted from the
"Army, Navy or Air Force of the Government of India"must actually be"concealed"on board the merchant vessel S1, s. 165. If a deserter boards openly as a ticketed passenger under a forged civilian identity document that passes standard port and shipboard inspection, the question turns on whether there was concealment discoverable through proper shipboard duty or discipline S1, s. 165.
- A person who has deserted from the
- Fault Element: Ignorance Attributable to Neglect of Duty or Want of Discipline:
- Section 165 BNS does not create absolute or no-fault liability. Although it operates where the master is
"ignorant of such concealment", the prosecution must prove a causal link ("but for") between the master's ignorance and either:- (a) Some neglect of his duty as master or person in charge (such as failing to conduct mandatory muster checks, stowaway searches, or crew-list verifications required under the Merchant Shipping Act, 1958 and port clearance regulations), or
- (b) Some want of discipline on board of the vessel (such as allowing unrecorded persons into crew quarters or cargo holds without gangway watch supervision) S1, s. 165.
- Conversely, if the master already knew or had reason to believe that the person concealed on board was a military deserter and allowed him to remain to evade apprehension, the master is guilty of the graver cognizable offence of harbouring a deserter under Section 164 BNS (punishable with up to 2 years' imprisonment), not merely Section 165 BNS S1, s. 164–165.
- Section 165 BNS does not create absolute or no-fault liability. Although it operates where the master is
Comparison with IPC Section 137
Section 165 BNS preserves the exact grammatical structure and legal threshold of Section 137 of the IPC, 1860, while updating the colonial-era monetary cap S1, s. 165; S3, s. 137; S5, p. 10:
| Feature | IPC, 1860 (Section 137) | BNS, 2023 (Section 165) | Legal Effect of Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Target Accused | Master or person in charge of a merchant vessel S3, s. 137 | Master or person in charge of a merchant vessel S1, s. 165 | Unchanged S1, s. 165. |
| Mental / Fault Standard | Ignorant of concealment, if he might have known but for neglect of duty or want of discipline on board S3, s. 137 | Ignorant of concealment, if he might have known but for neglect of duty or want of discipline on board S1, s. 165 | Unchanged constructive negligence standard S1, s. 165. |
| Maximum Penalty | Penalty not exceeding five hundred rupees (₹500) S3, s. 137 | Penalty not exceeding three thousand rupees (₹3,000) S1, s. 165 | Six-fold increase in maximum monetary penalty S1, s. 165; S5, p. 10. |
| Procedural Status | Non-cognizable, Bailable, Any Magistrate | Non-cognizable, Bailable, Any Magistrate S4, s. 165 | Unchanged S4, s. 165. |
Punishment Matrix and Default-of-Fine Rules
- Primary Punishment: A monetary penalty (
"penalty not exceeding three thousand rupees", listed in the BNSS First Schedule as"Fine of 3,000 rupees") S1, s. 165; S4, s. 165. No substantive imprisonment is authorised for the offence itself S1, s. 165. - Imprisonment in Default of Payment: Because the offence is punishable solely with a monetary penalty/fine not exceeding ₹3,000, Section 8(5)(a) BNS governs any default sentence: the imprisonment imposed in default of payment must be simple imprisonment, and its term shall not exceed two months (since the fine does not exceed ₹5,000) S1, s. 8(5)(a); S1, s. 165. Under Section 8(6) BNS, such default imprisonment terminates immediately upon payment or proportional levy of the penalty S1, s. 8(6).
Procedural Classification under the BNSS, 2023
Under the First Schedule to the BNSS, 2023, Section 165 BNS is the only non-cognizable offence in Chapter VIII S4, s. 165:
- Cognizability: Non-cognizable (under Section 174 BNSS, a police officer cannot investigate or arrest without an order/warrant of a Magistrate having power to try the case) S4, s. 165.
- Bailability: Bailable S4, s. 165.
- Trial Court: Triable by Any Magistrate (and eligible for summary trial under Section 283 BNSS) S4, s. 165.
Practical Examples and Counterexamples
- Editorial Hypothetical 1 (Neglect of Pre-Departure Stowaway Check: Liable under Section 165 BNS):
- Assumed Facts: Captain K is the master of a coastal merchant cargo vessel departing Kandla port. Standard shipboard standing orders require the master to ensure a gangway watch and a pre-departure hold inspection. Captain K dispenses with both checks to sail early. A sailor who deserted from the Indian Navy slips aboard unchallenged and hides in an unlocked storage locker. Captain K has no actual knowledge of the sailor's presence until Coast Guard authorities board the vessel.
- Analysis: Captain K had no knowledge or reason to believe the deserter was aboard (so Section 164 BNS does not apply), but he would have discovered the concealment
"but for some neglect of his duty"and"want of discipline on board"S1, s. 164–165. Captain K is liable under Section 165 BNS to a penalty up to ₹3,000 S1, s. 165.
- Editorial Hypothetical 2 (Counterexample (Due Diligence Exercised, Sophisticated Concealment) Not Liable):
- Assumed Facts: On the same vessel, Captain K strictly enforces 24-hour gangway checks, verifies all crew Seafarer Identity Documents, and conducts a full stowaway search before departure. Unknown to Captain K, a deserting soldier was sealed inside a pre-manifested ISO shipping container at an inland ICD depot before the container was loaded onto the ship by port cranes.
- Analysis: Captain K is not liable under Section 165 BNS. Although a deserter was concealed on board and Captain K was ignorant of it, his ignorance was not caused by any neglect of duty as master or want of discipline on board the vessel S1, s. 165.