The provision in one view
Section 163 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 punishes abetting the desertion of any officer, soldier, sailor or airman in the Army, Navy or Air Force of the Government of India. The punishment is imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to two years, or with fine, or with both S1; S4.
Its predecessor is section 135 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 S2. The comparison returned 1.0000 -- a perfect match, operative text and marginal note alike.
Five findings:
- The penalty is disjunctive, unlike the two sections before it. A court may impose imprisonment, or a fine alone, or both. Sections 161 and 162 did not offer that choice S1; S8.
- This is the first bailable offence in the Chapter, and the first triable by "Any Magistrate" S3.
- That forum description creates a problem of its own kind. "Any Magistrate" includes a Magistrate of the second class, who may impose only one year -- half the section's maximum S3.
- Section 1(6) of the Sanhita expressly saves Acts punishing desertion, which makes it more directly relevant to this section than to any earlier one in the Chapter S6.
- There is no case law at all -- a distinctive-phrase search returned four results, every one of them a statute page S2.
The exact words
163. Abetment of desertion of soldier, sailor or airman. Whoever abets the desertion of any officer, soldier, sailor or airman, in the Army, Navy or Air Force of the Government of India, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to two years, or with fine, or with both S1.
At 257 characters this is the shortest section in the Chapter so far, and the marginal note is intelligible standing alone -- unlike the heading of section 162, which depends on a back-reference S1; S8.
The elements
Three things must be established S1:
- A desertion by an officer, soldier, sailor or airman.
- That person must be in the Army, Navy or Air Force of the Government of India.
- The accused must have abetted that desertion.
As throughout this Chapter, the section opens with "whoever", so the abettor need not be a serviceman. Only the deserter must be S1.
The section does not say the desertion must have occurred
This is worth stating carefully, because the preceding pair of sections turned on exactly that distinction.
Section 161 punishes abetting an assault on a superior officer; section 162 punishes the same abetment where the assault was actually committed, and carries a higher maximum S8. Section 163 has no such twin. It refers to abetting "the desertion", and the Sanhita contains no companion section imposing a different penalty according to whether the serviceman in fact deserted S1; S4.
Whether the words "abets the desertion" require a completed desertion, or are satisfied by abetment of a desertion that did not follow, is not settled by anything located for this article, and no authority on the point exists. The general abetment provisions supply a partial answer: section 49 applies where the act abetted is committed and no express provision is made, while sections 55 and 56 apply where it is not committed and no express provision is made S4. Since section 163 is an express provision, both are displaced, and the question falls to be answered on the words of section 163 itself. This article does not assert an answer.
"Desertion" is not defined
The Sanhita does not define desertion, and no authority on its meaning was located S1; S4. The concept belongs to service law rather than to the general criminal law, and the service Acts were not examined for this article.
That matters more here than at any earlier section in the Chapter, for the reason given next.
Section 1(6) expressly saves Acts punishing desertion
Section 1(6) of the Sanhita provides S6:
"Nothing in this Sanhita shall affect the provisions of any Act for punishing mutiny and desertion of officers, soldiers, sailors or airmen in the service of the Government of India or the provisions of any special or local law."
That saving names desertion, and this section punishes abetting desertion. The relationship is therefore more direct than at sections 159 to 162, where the saving mentioned mutiny and desertion while the sections concerned mutiny, assault and abetment of assault.
Three points should be made with care, because it is easy to overstate the effect.
The saving protects the service Acts; it does not define anything. Section 1(6) says that nothing in the Sanhita shall affect those Acts. It does not tell a court what desertion means, and it does not import any definition from service law into section 163 S6.
Its words are "in the service of", not "subject to". That distinction was recorded in this collection's article on section 159, where the Penal Code's dropped Explanation had extended the service terms to persons subject to the service Acts. Section 1(6) uses the narrower-sounding formula, and nothing located for this article establishes that the two phrases are coextensive S6.
What the saving does and does not resolve is not addressed by any authority. Whether a person may be prosecuted under section 163 for abetting a desertion that is also punishable under the Army Act, 1950 or another service enactment, and whether section 1(6) bears on that question, was not researched for this article. The service Acts were not examined.
The penalty
The punishment is imprisonment of either description -- rigorous or simple under section 4(c), with the choice directed under section 7 -- for a term which may extend to two years, or with fine, or with both S1; S4.
The disjunctive form is a change of pattern within the Chapter
The three sections before this one all read "shall also be liable to fine", which makes fine an addition to imprisonment rather than an alternative to it. Section 163 reads "or with fine, or with both" S1; S8.
The practical difference is real. Under section 163 a court may dispose of the matter by fine alone, with no imprisonment at all. Under sections 161 and 162 it may not S1; S8.
No sum is expressed for the fine. Section 8(1) therefore applies: the amount "is unlimited, but shall not be excessive" S5.
Classification under the First Schedule
The entry, read in the full raw column layout, is S3:
| Column | Entry |
|---|---|
| 1. Section | 163 |
| 2. Offence | Abetment of the desertion of an officer, soldier, sailor or airman. |
| 3. Punishment | Imprisonment for 2 years, or fine, or both. |
| 4. Cognizable or not | Cognizable. |
| 5. Bailable or not | Bailable. |
| 6. By what Court triable | Any Magistrate. |
The punishment column is accurate, reproducing the disjunctive structure faithfully -- "or fine, or both" S1; S3.
The first bailable offence in the Chapter
Sections 159, 160, 161 and 162 are all non-bailable. Section 163 is bailable S3.
The line is therefore not drawn by length of sentence alone. It is drawn between the subject matter: mutiny and assaults on superior officers on the one hand, and desertion on the other. Abetting a desertion is treated as materially less grave than abetting an assault on a superior officer, even though both are abetment offences committed by persons who need not be servicemen S1; S3; S8.
The reverse divergence returns, in its original form
Column 2 reads "Abetment of the desertion of an officer, soldier, sailor or airman." The marginal note of section 163 reads "Abetment of desertion of soldier, sailor or airman", and omits "officer" S1; S3.
The operative text does not omit it: the section punishes abetting the desertion of "any officer, soldier, sailor or airman" S1. So on this occasion the First Schedule is the more faithful document, as it was at sections 159 and 161. That makes three instances in this Chapter of the same divergence, against one instance -- section 162 -- where the Schedule instead produced a third and ungrammatical variant of its own S3.
One refinement should be recorded, because it changes what the divergence shows. The marginal note of section 135 of the Penal Code is identical, and also omits "officer" S2. The omission is therefore inherited from 1860, not introduced by the Sanhita. The same was true at section 161. What the Schedule does is restore a word that the marginal notes of both statutes have always left out.
"Any Magistrate" is an under-specified forum
Section 163 is the first offence in the Chapter triable by "Any Magistrate" rather than by a named tier S3.
Section 23 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita sets the tiers S3:
- Section 23(1): a Chief Judicial Magistrate -- any sentence except death, life, or imprisonment exceeding seven years, with no cap on fine.
- Section 23(2): a Magistrate of the first class -- three years, or fifty thousand rupees, or both, or community service.
- Section 23(3): a Magistrate of the second class -- one year, or ten thousand rupees, or both, or community service.
The phrase "Any Magistrate" is used 174 times in the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, and the expression "Magistrate of the second class" appears nowhere in the First Schedule S3. The Schedule's vocabulary for the trying court is therefore limited to three forms: a Court of Session, a Magistrate of the first class, and "Any Magistrate". It follows that "Any Magistrate" is the formula by which the second class tier is reached at all.
And that produces a mismatch:
- A Chief Judicial Magistrate is fully competent: two years is well within his power and he faces no cap on fine S3.
- A Magistrate of the first class can impose the full two years, but not an unlimited fine -- his fine is capped at fifty thousand rupees S3; S5.
- A Magistrate of the second class can impose neither in full: one year against a maximum of two, and ten thousand rupees against an unlimited fine S3; S5.
So the Schedule names a class of courts, some members of which cannot impose the sentence the section authorises. This is a softer form of the problem recorded at section 162, where the Schedule named a single tier that could not impose the maximum. Here the entry is not wrong for every court it names -- it is under-specified, and whether the maximum is available depends on which Magistrate happens to try the case S1; S3.
Two things should be said plainly about that.
It is not peculiar to section 163. "Any Magistrate" appears 174 times, and the same analysis would apply to every offence so classified whose maximum exceeds one year. Section 164, carrying the same two years, is also given to "Any Magistrate" S3. This is a feature of how the Schedule is drafted, not a slip in this entry.
Section 364 is again the answer the Code gives. Section 364(1) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita provides that a Magistrate who, after hearing the evidence, is of opinion that the accused ought to receive a punishment "different in kind from, or more severe than, that which such Magistrate is empowered to inflict" may record that opinion and submit the proceedings, forwarding the accused, to the Chief Judicial Magistrate; and section 364(3) empowers that Chief Judicial Magistrate to pass such sentence as he thinks fit and is according to law S3. A second class Magistrate who concludes that more than a year is warranted sends the case up. As recorded in this collection's article on section 162, that cure operates only at the end of the trial and the power to recall witnesses is discretionary.
No authority was located on the effect of a Schedule entry naming a class of courts not all of which can impose the section's maximum, and this article does not assert that such an entry is void or that a second class Magistrate's trial would be invalid S3.
The comparison with section 135 of the Penal Code
Section 163 replaces section 135 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 S2. A token-level comparison, with both windows bounded before the comparison was run, returned 1.0000. There are no differences in the operative text, and the marginal notes are identical as well. This is the sixth perfect match recorded in this collection, after sections 156, 157, 160, 161 and 162 S1; S2.
The table-of-contents trap was caught again. Section 135 appears at two places in the Penal Code text: an entry running 64 characters, and the operative provision running 339. The shorter one is the contents listing S2.
Two amendments, across twenty-three years
Section 135 carries three footnote markers, read in place from the footnote block serving its page S2:
- Marker 8: substituted by Act 10 of 1927 for "or sailor" -- giving "sailor or airman".
- Marker 9: substituted by the same Act for "or Navy" -- giving "Navy or Air Force".
- Marker 10: substituted by the Adaptation of Laws Order, 1950 for "Queen" -- giving "Government of India".
Two instruments, in 1927 and 1950. Neither altered the offence's scope as between the parties; both are the familiar service-reorganisation and post-Independence adaptations.
A refinement of how these footnotes work
This collection has recorded that Penal Code footnote numbering is page-local, so that marker 8 at one place is not the same amendment as marker 8 at another. Section 135 adds a further point.
Sections 134, 135, 136, 137 and 138 all sit on the same page -- there is no page break between them -- and every one of them uses markers 8, 9 and 10 for the same three substitutions S2. The numbering is therefore not merely page-local: within a page, a single footnote number is reused at each recurrence of the identical substitution. That is why five consecutive sections can all carry a marker 8 without conflict.
The practical consequence for anyone checking this work is that markers must be matched to the footnote block of the page, and a repeated number on one page should be read as one footnote serving several provisions -- not as several different amendments.
The 1955 transportation substitution does not reach this section
Section 135's penalty was always a term of ordinary imprisonment, never transportation, so the substitution made by Act 26 of 1955 had nothing to reach S2. Section 135 is the twelfth provision confirmed on the negative side of that pattern, which continues to hold without exception: the 1955 substitution reached only penalties actually expressed as transportation.
Where this section sits among its neighbours
The Chapter proceeds by subject matter, and the sections immediately following deal with the consequences of desertion rather than with abetting it S4:
- Section 164, harbouring a deserter -- two years, or fine, or both. It carries an Exception: the provision does not extend to the case in which the harbour is given by a wife to her husband S4.
- Section 165, a deserter concealed on board a merchant vessel through the negligence of the master -- a penalty not exceeding three thousand rupees, imposed on the master even though ignorant of the concealment, if he might have known of it but for neglect of duty or want of discipline on board S4.
- Section 166, abetment of an act of insubordination -- six months, or fine, or both, and only where the act of insubordination was committed in consequence of the abetment S4.
Section 166 is worth noting against section 163. It does contain the result-based condition that section 163 lacks: it applies only "if such act of insubordination be committed in consequence of that abetment" S4. So within the same Chapter the drafter has used an express causal condition where one was intended. That is a contextual observation, not a conclusion about how section 163 should be read, and the point is left open above.
Compounding
Section 163 is not compoundable.
Both Tables in section 359 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita were read within bounded windows. The number 163 does not appear in either, and the word "desertion" appears nowhere in either Table -- zero occurrences S3. There is accordingly no entry to adjudicate and no ambiguity to resolve, in contrast to sections 161 and 162 where the word "assault" appeared in both Tables and each occurrence had to be matched to its own entry.
Section 359(3), which extends compounding to the abetment of an offence compoundable under that section, cannot assist either. It requires the principal offence to be compoundable. Desertion is not an offence under the Sanhita at all -- the Sanhita punishes abetting it, harbouring a deserter and concealing one, but not the desertion itself, which is a matter for service law S1; S3; S4.
The duty to report does not extend to this section
Section 33(1) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita imposes a duty on every person aware of the commission of, or an intention to commit, an offence under one of twelve listed groups of sections to give information to the nearest Magistrate or police officer, in the absence of reasonable excuse S3.
All twelve clauses were read: sections 103 to 105; 111 to 113; 140 to 144; 147 to 154 and 158; 178 to 182; 189 and 191; 274 to 280; 307; 309 to 312; section 316(5); 326 to 328; and 331 and 332 S3.
No section of Chapter VIII appears in any clause. Section 163 is outside the duty, as is the whole Chapter.
The case law
There is none.
A distinctive-phrase search built on the section's own words -- "abets the desertion" together with the four service terms -- returned four results, and every one of them is a statute page: section 135 of the Indian Penal Code, the Penal Code itself, and the corresponding provision and text of the Jammu and Kashmir State Ranbir Penal Code, 1989. Not one judgment S2.
A search framed on the section number returned thirty-nine results, dominated by section 135 of municipal and police enactments and by large unrelated judgments on capital sentencing. None engages this provision S2.
No decision applying section 163 of the Sanhita was located either. The Sanhita commenced on 1 July 2024 S1.
Two notes on searching
A search for "section 163" is useless here. Section 163 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 belongs to the group of provisions governing statements made during investigation, and a query on it returned 14,524 results S2. Any search for this offence must be framed by reference to section 135 of the Penal Code or to the section's own words.
The analogy relied on at section 162 does not extend to this section. This collection's article on section 162 used a passage from In Re: Sahadevan on cumulative punishment, which turned on the relationship between a result-based provision and its bare-abetment counterpart. Section 163 has no such counterpart, so the analogy has no application here and has not been stretched to fit S1.
Commencement and application
Section 163 commenced on 1 July 2024. Ministry of Home Affairs notification S.O. 850(E) dated 23 February 2024 appointed that date for the provisions of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, with the exception noted in that notification S7.
Conduct before 1 July 2024 falls under section 135 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860; conduct on or after that date falls under section 163 S1; S2. The two provisions being textually identical, the transition raises no question of altered scope. The savings provisions of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita governing proceedings begun before that date were not examined.
Practical points for readers
- The abettor need not be a serviceman. Only the deserter must be in the Army, Navy or Air Force of the Government of India S1.
- Desertion itself is not an offence under the Sanhita. It is a matter for service law. The Sanhita punishes abetting it, harbouring a deserter and concealing one S1; S4.
- The penalty is disjunctive, so a fine alone is a lawful disposal -- unlike sections 161 and 162 S1; S8.
- The fine is unlimited under section 8(1), since no sum is expressed S5.
- The offence is cognizable but bailable, the first bailable offence in the Chapter S3.
- Check which Magistrate is trying the case. "Any Magistrate" includes a Magistrate of the second class, who cannot impose more than one year or a fine above ten thousand rupees. Section 364 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita is the route upward if a severer sentence is in prospect S3.
- The offence is not compoundable, and section 359(3) does not open a route S3.
- There is no duty to report it under section 33 S3.
- There is no case law. Do not expect to find any, and do not search for "section 163" S2.
Limitations of this article
This article is based on the sources cited and the following should be kept in view.
No judicial authority on this section or its predecessor was located at all. Every statement about the provision's meaning is accordingly drawn from its words and from the surrounding statutory scheme, not from any decision.
Whether section 163 requires the desertion actually to have occurred is not resolved. The question is raised in this article and expressly left open. The observation that section 166 contains an express causal condition while section 163 does not is offered as context, not as a conclusion on how section 163 should be read.
"Desertion" is not defined in the Sanhita and no authority on its meaning was located. The concept belongs to service law, which was not examined.
The Army Act, 1950, the Indian Navy (Discipline) Act, 1934, the Air Force Act, 1950 and the Navy Act, 1957 were not examined. Nothing is said about whether a desertion punishable under those Acts may also found a prosecution under section 163, or about how section 1(6) bears on that question.
Section 1(6) of the Sanhita is quoted and its terms described, but its legal effect is not asserted. In particular, nothing here resolves whether "in the service of the Government of India" and "subject to" the service Acts are coextensive -- a distinction recorded in this collection's article on section 159.
The forum analysis rests on reading the First Schedule entry against section 23 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita. No authority was located on the effect of a Schedule entry naming a class of courts not all of which can impose the section's maximum sentence, and this article does not assert that the entry is void or that a trial before a second class Magistrate would be invalid.
The statement that "Any Magistrate" reaches the second class tier is an inference from the Schedule's vocabulary -- the expression "Magistrate of the second class" appears nowhere in the First Schedule, while "Any Magistrate" appears 174 times. It is not drawn from any provision expressly saying so, and no authority on the point was located.
Section 364 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita was read, but no authority on its use was located and nothing is asserted about how readily Magistrates in fact submit proceedings under it.
The amendment history is taken from the footnote markers printed with section 135 of the Penal Code. The instruments themselves -- Act 10 of 1927 and the Adaptation of Laws Order, 1950 -- were not retrieved, and the footnote text is relied on for what they did.
The observation that footnote numbers are reused within a page for repeated substitutions is drawn from reading sections 134 to 138 and the single footnote block serving their page. It is an observation about the printed text relied on, not a statement about editorial practice generally.
Sections 164, 165 and 166 are described only to place section 163 in context. They were not examined in full and will be treated in their own articles.
No State amendment to section 163 was located, but no search of State amendment schedules was conducted, so the absence of such an amendment is not asserted as a verified fact.
No Law Commission or other legislative material explaining the retention of this section was located or searched for.
Sentencing practice under this section or its predecessor was not researched.
Frequently asked questions
1. What does section 163 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita punish? It punishes abetting the desertion of any officer, soldier, sailor or airman in the Army, Navy or Air Force of the Government of India S1.
2. What is the punishment? Imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to two years, or fine, or both S1.
3. Can a court impose a fine alone? Yes. The penalty is disjunctive, so fine alone is a lawful disposal. That differs from sections 161 and 162, where fine is an addition to imprisonment rather than an alternative S1; S8.
4. Is the fine limited? No sum is expressed, so under section 8(1) the fine is unlimited but must not be excessive S5.
5. Must the abettor be a member of the armed forces? No. The section begins with "whoever". Only the deserter must be in the forces S1.
6. Is desertion itself an offence under the Sanhita? No. The Sanhita punishes abetting a desertion, harbouring a deserter under section 164 and concealing one under section 165, but desertion itself is a matter for service law S1; S4.
7. What does "desertion" mean? The Sanhita does not define it and no authority on its meaning was located. The concept belongs to service law, which was not examined for this article S1.
8. Must the desertion actually have happened? The section does not say so, and the question is not resolved by anything located for this article. Section 166, dealing with abetment of insubordination, does contain an express requirement that the act be committed in consequence of the abetment, while section 163 does not S1; S4.
9. Does section 1(6) of the Sanhita matter here? It is more directly relevant than at earlier sections in this Chapter, because it expressly saves Acts punishing mutiny and desertion. But it protects those Acts rather than defining anything, and its effect on a prosecution under section 163 was not researched S6.
10. Is the offence cognizable? Yes S3.
11. Is it bailable? Yes. It is the first bailable offence in Chapter VIII; sections 159 to 162 are all non-bailable S3.
12. Which court tries it? The First Schedule says "Any Magistrate" S3.
13. Can any Magistrate impose the full two years? No. "Any Magistrate" includes a Magistrate of the second class, who under section 23(3) may impose only one year and a fine of no more than ten thousand rupees S3.
14. Is that a defect? It is a mismatch, but a softer one than at section 162, where a single named tier could not impose the maximum. Here the entry is under-specified rather than wrong: a Chief Judicial Magistrate is fully competent, a first class Magistrate can impose the full term but not an unlimited fine, and a second class Magistrate can impose neither in full S3; S5.
15. Is it unique to this section? No. "Any Magistrate" appears 174 times in the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, and the same analysis applies to any such offence whose maximum exceeds one year. Section 164 is an example S3.
16. What happens if a severer sentence is warranted? Section 364 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita applies. The Magistrate records that opinion after hearing the evidence and submits the proceedings to the Chief Judicial Magistrate, who may pass any lawful sentence S3.
17. Which section of the Indian Penal Code did this replace? Section 135 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860, which carried the same two-year maximum and the same disjunctive penalty S2.
18. Did the wording change? No. The comparison returned a perfect match, and the marginal notes are identical as well S1; S2.
19. Does the First Schedule describe the offence correctly? The punishment column is accurate. Column 2 describes the offence as abetment of the desertion of "an officer, soldier, sailor or airman", which is closer to the operative text than the marginal note of either statute, since both marginal notes omit "officer" S1; S2; S3.
20. Was section 135 ever amended? Twice. Act 10 of 1927 substituted "sailor or airman" and "Navy or Air Force", and the Adaptation of Laws Order, 1950 substituted "Government of India" for "Queen" S2.
21. Was it affected by the 1955 transportation amendment? No. Act 26 of 1955 reached only penalties expressed as transportation, and section 135's penalty was always a term of ordinary imprisonment S2.
22. Can the offence be compounded? No. Section 163 does not appear in either Table in section 359 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, and the word "desertion" appears nowhere in either Table S3.
23. Could section 359(3) help, since it covers abetment? No. It requires the principal offence to be compoundable under that section. Desertion is not an offence under the Sanhita at all S1; S3.
24. Must I report this offence if I know about it? Not under section 33 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita. No section of Chapter VIII appears in any of its twelve clauses S3.
25. Is there any case law? None was located. A distinctive-phrase search returned four results, all of them statute pages, and no judgment at all S2.
26. Why is it hard to search for? Because section 163 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 concerns statements made during investigation and is heavily litigated; a query on it returned over fourteen thousand results. Search for section 135 of the Penal Code instead S2.
27. What is the difference between this section and section 164? Section 163 punishes abetting a desertion. Section 164 punishes harbouring a person who has already deserted, and carries an exception for harbour given by a wife to her husband S1; S4.
28. When did section 163 come into force? On 1 July 2024, by Ministry of Home Affairs notification S.O. 850(E) dated 23 February 2024 S7.
This article states the law as published in the sources cited and is for general information only. It is not legal advice. Section 163 reproduces its predecessor word for word, no court has interpreted either provision, and the First Schedule names a class of Magistrates not all of whom can impose the sentence the section authorises. Anyone facing a charge under this section, or advising on the forum in which it should be tried, should obtain professional advice on the current position before acting.