Overview and Direct Answer
Section 164 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) criminalises the act of knowingly harbouring an officer, soldier, sailor, or airman who has deserted from the Army, Navy, or Air Force of the Government of India S1, s. 164. The provision is aimed at civilians and persons not subject to military law (since service personnel are governed by their respective service statutes by virtue of Section 167 BNS) who facilitate a deserter's evasion of apprehension by providing shelter, sustenance, funds, transport, or other assistance S1, s. 2(13); S1, s. 164; S1, s. 167. Conviction carries imprisonment of either description for a term up to two years, or a fine, or both S1, s. 164. Section 164 contains a statutory Exception that exempts the spouse of the deserter from criminal liability for harbouring them: modernising the gender-specific exemption under old Section 136 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC), which protected only a "wife" harbouring her "husband" S1, s. 164; S3, s. 136.
Statutory Text and Structural Breakdown
In Chapter VIII (Of Offences Relating to the Army, Navy and Air Force), Section 164 BNS reads:
"Whoever, except as hereinafter excepted, knowing or having reason to believe that an officer, soldier, sailor or airman, in the Army, Navy or Air Force of the Government of India, has deserted, harbours such officer, soldier, sailor or airman, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to two years, or with fine or with both. Exception.—This provision does not extend to the case in which the harbour is given by the spouse of the deserter." S1, s. 164
To establish an offence under Section 164 BNS, the prosecution must prove four distinct statutory ingredients beyond reasonable doubt:
- Status of the Principal as a Deserter from the Indian Armed Forces: The person harboured must be an
"officer, soldier, sailor or airman, in the Army, Navy or Air Force of the Government of India"who"has deserted"S1, s. 164. Mere unauthorised absence without leave (AWOL) does not automatically equate to desertion under military law unless accompanied by the animus to permanently quit service or evade an important military duty (as distinguished in Sections 38 and 39 of the Army Act, 1950, and parallel provisions of the Navy Act, 1957 and Air Force Act, 1950) S1, s. 164; S6. - Actus Reus of Harbouring: The accused must
"harbour"such deserter S1, s. 164. By virtue of Section 2(13) BNS, the word"harbour"is inclusively defined to cover"supplying a person with shelter, food, drink, money, clothes, arms, ammunition or means of conveyance, or the assisting a person by any means, whether of the same kind as those enumerated in this clause or not, to evade apprehension"S1, s. 2(13). - Mens Rea: Knowledge or Reason to Believe: At the time of providing harbour, the accused must act
"knowing or having reason to believe"that the person harboured is a member of the Indian Armed Forces and has deserted S1, s. 164. Under Section 2(29) BNS, a person has"reason to believe"a thing"if he has sufficient cause to believe that thing but not otherwise"S1, s. 2(29). This sets an objective-cum-subjective threshold: mere carelessness or failure to inquire into a guest's leave papers is insufficient unless surrounding circumstances would put a reasonable person on notice of desertion S1, s. 2(29); S1, s. 164. - Absence of the Spousal Exception (and Section 167 Immunity): The accused must not be the
"spouse of the deserter"under the statutory Exception to Section 164 BNS, nor a person subject to the Army Act, 1950, the Indian Navy (Discipline) Act, 1934 (now read with the Navy Act, 1957), or the Air Force Act, 1950 under Section 167 BNS S1, s. 164; S1, s. 167.
Comparison with IPC Section 136: From "Wife" to Gender-Neutral "Spouse"
While the main enacting clause and punishment of Section 164 BNS are identical to Section 136 of the repealed IPC, 1860, Parliament introduced a substantive modification in the statutory Exception S1, s. 164; S3, s. 136; S5, p. 10:
| Statutory Element | IPC, 1860 (Section 136) | BNS, 2023 (Section 164) | Legal & Practical Significance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Protected Class of Service Personnel | Officer, soldier, sailor, or airman in the Army, Navy, or Air Force of the Government of India S3, s. 136 | Officer, soldier, sailor, or airman in the Army, Navy, or Air Force of the Government of India S1, s. 164 | Substantively unchanged; applies solely to the Armed Forces of the Union of India S1, s. 164. |
| Mental Element (Mens Rea) | Knowing or having reason to believe that such person has deserted S3, s. 136 | Knowing or having reason to believe that such person has deserted S1, s. 164 | Substantively unchanged; read with Section 2(29) BNS S1, s. 2(29). |
| Statutory Exception | "in which the harbour is given by a wife to her husband" S3, s. 136 | "in which the harbour is given by the spouse of the deserter" S1, s. 164 | Substantive expansion of immunity: With women serving across commissioned and non-commissioned ranks in the Army, Navy, and Air Force, a husband who harbours his deserting wife is now equally protected S1, s. 164. |
| Punishment | Imprisonment of either description up to 2 years, or fine, or both S3, s. 136 | Imprisonment of either description up to 2 years, or fine, or both S1, s. 164 | Unchanged S1, s. 164; S3, s. 136. |
This gender-neutral shift aligns Section 164 BNS with the broader drafting pattern of the Sanhita (compare Section 3(3) BNS substituting "spouse" for "wife" in constructive possession, and Sections 250/253/254 BNS on general harbouring exceptions) S1, s. 3(3); S1, s. 164. However, note the strict textual boundary of the Exception: it protects only a legally recognised "spouse" S1, s. 164. Parents, siblings, adult children, unmarried partners, and friends who knowingly harbour a military deserter enjoy no statutory immunity under Section 164 BNS, though familial ties may be weighed by the Magistrate at sentencing S1, s. 164.
Punishment Matrix and Default-of-Fine Rules
Section 164 BNS prescribes alternative and cumulative sentencing options S1, s. 164:
- Imprisonment: Wholly rigorous, wholly simple, or partly rigorous and partly simple (
"imprisonment of either description", governed by Section 7 BNS) for a term extending up to two years, with no mandatory minimum sentence S1, s. 7; S1, s. 164. - Fine: Discretionary (
"or with fine or with both"), with no statutory monetary ceiling specified in Section 164 S1, s. 164. Under Section 8(1) BNS, where no sum is expressed to which a fine may extend, the amount of fine is unlimited,"but shall not be excessive"S1, s. 8(1). - Imprisonment in Default of Payment of Fine:
- Where the Court sentences the offender to both imprisonment and fine (or imprisonment is awardable and fine is imposed), Section 8(3) BNS caps default imprisonment at one-fourth of the maximum term fixed for the offence (i.e., six months (one-fourth of two years)) which may be of either description under Section 8(4) BNS S1, s. 8(3)–(4).
- Note that because Section 164 BNS is punishable with
"imprisonment... or with fine or with both", it falls under Section 8(2)(b) and 8(3) BNS rather than the fine-only scale in Section 8(5) BNS S1, s. 8(2)–(5).
Procedural Classification (BNSS, 2023) and Evidentiary Burdens (BSA, 2023)
Under the First Schedule to the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS), an offence under Section 164 BNS is classified as S4, s. 164:
- Cognizability: Cognizable (a police officer may register an FIR under Section 173 BNSS and arrest without warrant subject to the mandatory checklist and notice safeguards for offences punishable up to 7 years under Section 35(3)–(6) BNSS) S4, s. 164.
- Bailability: Bailable (the accused is entitled to bail as a matter of right under Section 478 BNSS) S4, s. 164.
- Trial Court: Triable by Any Magistrate S4, s. 164.
- Compoundability: Non-compoundable (not listed in the compounding tables of Section 359 BNSS).
Burden of Proof on the Spousal Exception: Under the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA) (corresponding to Section 105 of the repealed Indian Evidence Act, 1872), the burden of proving that the accused falls within the "spouse of the deserter" Exception rests on the accused on a preponderance of probabilities, unless the prosecution's own record already establishes the marital relationship. Conversely, the prosecution bears the primary burden of proving both (a) that the harboured person had in fact deserted (ordinarily proved through official service records/desertion rolls from the unit), and (b) that the accused provided assistance to evade apprehension with knowledge or reason to believe of that desertion S1, s. 2(13); S1, s. 164.
Practical Distinctions and Editorial Hypotheticals
- Section 164 (Post-Desertion Harbouring) vs. Section 163 (Abetment of Desertion):
- Section 163 BNS punishes abetting the desertion of an officer, soldier, sailor, or airman before or during the act of desertion S1, s. 163; S4, s. 163.
- Section 164 BNS applies after the desertion has taken place, when a person harbours the deserter to help them evade apprehension S1, s. 164. If a civilian both instigates a soldier to desert and pre-arranges a safe house for him, the conduct constitutes abetment of desertion under Section 163 BNS (and continuing harbouring under Section 164 BNS) S1, s. 163–164.
- Editorial Hypothetical 1 (Hospitality Without Reason to Believe: No Offence):
- Assumed Facts: R, a soldier posted at a border unit, deserts his regiment without leave and travels to his cousin M's house in Bathinda wearing civilian clothes. R tells M that he has been granted 15 days' casual leave and shows M an old leave pass on his phone whose dates M does not inspect closely. M provides R food and lodging for four days.
- Analysis: M is not guilty under Section 164 BNS. Although M supplied shelter and food, M neither knew nor had
"sufficient cause to believe"(Section 2(29) BNS) that R had deserted, nor did M assist R to evade apprehension under Section 2(13) BNS S1, s. 2(13); S1, s. 2(29); S1, s. 164.
- Editorial Hypothetical 2 (Changing One Fact: Active Evasion After Military Police Inquiry):
- Assumed Facts: Continuing from Hypothetical 1, on the fifth day, local police and Military Police visit M's neighbourhood with a desertion warrant for R. M learns of the warrant, hides R in an outhouse, gives R ₹10,000 in cash and a motorcycle, and directs him to flee to another district.
- Analysis: Once M acquired knowledge of the desertion warrant and supplied shelter, money, and a means of conveyance to help R evade apprehension, all ingredients of Section 164 BNS read with Section 2(13) BNS are satisfied S1, s. 2(13); S1, s. 164. Because M is a cousin and not the spouse of R, the statutory Exception does not apply S1, s. 164.
- Editorial Hypothetical 3 (Spousal Exception for a Female Officer's Husband):
- Assumed Facts: Flight Lieutenant S, a married female officer in the Indian Air Force, deserts her base. Her husband H, knowing she has deserted and is sought by Air Force authorities, conceals her in their farmhouse and provides funds to evade arrest.
- Analysis: Under old Section 136 IPC, H would not have been covered by the literal text of the Exception (
"by a wife to her husband") S3, s. 136. Under Section 164 BNS, because H is the"spouse of the deserter", H is expressly exempt from criminal liability under this section S1, s. 164.
Temporal Applicability and Savings (Section 358 BNS)
Section 164 BNS came into force on 1 July 2024 S2. By virtue of Section 358(2)–(3) BNS and Article 20(1) of the Constitution of India, any alleged harbouring of a military deserter committed prior to 1 July 2024 remains governed substantively by Section 136 of the IPC, 1860, while acts of harbouring committed on or after 1 July 2024 (or continuing acts of harbouring that persist on or after 1 July 2024) are governed by Section 164 BNS S1, s. 164; S1, s. 358.