Overview and Direct Answer
Section 167 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) is a jurisdictional boundary and immunity provision, not a penal offence S1, s. 167. It declares that no person subject to the Army Act, 1950, the Indian Navy (Discipline) Act, 1934 (now read with the Navy Act, 1957), or the Air Force Act, 1950 shall be subject to punishment under the BNS for any of the offences defined in Chapter VIII (Sections 159 to 168) S1, s. 167. Its function is to prevent double regulation and conflict between ordinary criminal courts and military tribunals for specifically military offences (mutiny, assault on superior officers, desertion, harbouring deserters, insubordination) committed by serving personnel, while leaving civilians who abet or harbour military offenders liable under Sections 159–166 and 168 BNS S1, s. 159–168; S6. Section 167 BNS immunises service personnel only from offences defined in Chapter VIII BNS. It does not exempt them from punishment under other chapters of the BNS (such as murder under Section 103, rape under Section 64, or theft under Section 303), which remain governed by the concurrent-jurisdiction framework of the Armed Forces Acts and Section 521 of the BNSS, 2023 S1, s. 167; S6.
Statutory Text and Scope of the Exclusion
Section 167 BNS provides:
"No person subject to the Army Act, 1950, the Indian Navy (Discipline) Act, 1934, or the Air Force Act, 1950 shall be subject to punishment under this Sanhita for any of the offences defined in this Chapter." S1, s. 167
Because Section 167 BNS is an exclusionary rule rather than an offence-creating section, its legal operation turns on three precise statutory boundaries:
- Who is Covered ("Persons Subject to Certain Acts"):
- The immunity applies to any person who, at the time of the alleged offence, is legally subject to:
- The Army Act, 1950 (Act 46 of 1950) (see Section 2 of the Army Act, 1950, which covers regular officers, junior commissioned officers, warrant officers, enrolled persons, and civilians accompanying a force on active service);
- The Air Force Act, 1950 (Act 45 of 1950) (see Section 2 of the Air Force Act, 1950); or
- The Indian Navy (Discipline) Act, 1934 (Act 34 of 1934), which was repealed and replaced by the Navy Act, 1957 (Act 62 of 1957) S1, s. 167. By virtue of Section 8 of the General Clauses Act, 1897 (and Section 186 of the Navy Act, 1957), statutory references to the repealed Indian Navy (Discipline) Act, 1934 are construed as references to the re-enacted Navy Act, 1957, although the retention of the 1934 title in Section 167 BNS (and in Section 159 BNS, which additionally contains a drafting cross-reference typo pointing to
"section 165"instead of"section 167"from the First Bill) reflects a carryover from IPC Section 139 S1, s. 159; S1, s. 167; S3, s. 139.
- Important Boundary on Paramilitary / Central Armed Police Forces (CAPFs): Personnel of the Border Security Force (BSF Act, 1968), Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF Act, 1949), Indo-Tibetan Border Police (ITBP Act, 1992), Sashastra Seema Bal (SSB Act, 2007), Assam Rifles (Assam Rifles Act, 2006, unless placed under the Army Act), and Coast Guard (Coast Guard Act, 1978) are not subject to the three Acts enumerated in Section 167 BNS S1, s. 167. Conversely, because Chapter VIII offences (Sections 159–168) apply only to the
"Army, Navy or Air Force of the Government of India", if a civilian or CAPF member abets desertion or insubordination of a soldier in the Indian Army, that civilian or CAPF member is not immunised by Section 167 BNS and can be prosecuted under Chapter VIII BNS S1, s. 159–167.
- The immunity applies to any person who, at the time of the alleged offence, is legally subject to:
- What Offences are Excluded ("Any of the Offences Defined in This Chapter"):
- The bar applies strictly to Chapter VIII BNS (Sections 159 to 168):
- Abetting mutiny or attempting to seduce a soldier/sailor/airman from duty (Sections 159–160);
- Abetment of assault on a superior officer (Sections 161–162);
- Abetment of desertion (Section 163);
- Harbouring a deserter (Section 164);
- Negligent concealment of a deserter on a merchant vessel (Section 165);
- Abetment of an act of insubordination (Section 166); and
- Wearing military garb or carrying a military token (Section 168: which by its own terms already applies only to a person
"not being a soldier, sailor or airman") S1, s. 159–168.
- Why are service personnel excluded from Chapter VIII BNS? Because the Army Act, 1950 (Sections 34–70), Navy Act, 1957, and Air Force Act, 1950 (Sections 34–72) already comprehensively penalise mutiny, desertion, harbouring deserters, striking superiors, and insubordination when committed or abetted by persons subject to military law S1, s. 1(6); S1, s. 167; S6. Section 1(6) BNS reinforces this by stating that
"Nothing in this Sanhita shall affect the provisions of any Act for punishing mutiny and desertion of officers, soldiers, sailors or airmen in the service of the Government of India"S1, s. 1(6).
- The bar applies strictly to Chapter VIII BNS (Sections 159 to 168):
- What Offences are NOT Excluded ("Civil Offences" under Other Chapters of the BNS):
- Section 167 BNS does not grant blanket immunity from the BNS. When a serving soldier, sailor, or airman commits an ordinary criminal offence outside Chapter VIII BNS (termed a
"civil offence"under Section 2(d) and Section 69 of the Army Act, 1950: such as murder, culpable homicide, hurt, extortion, theft, or cheating), both the ordinary criminal court and the Court-Martial possess concurrent jurisdiction (except for murder, culpable homicide not amounting to murder, and rape committed against a civilian in India outside active service, which are reserved to ordinary criminal courts under Section 70 of the Army Act, 1950) S6. As the Supreme Court explained in Som Datt Datta vs. Union of India, AIR 1969 SC 414 S6, the conflict between Court-Martial jurisdiction and ordinary criminal court jurisdiction over such non-Chapter-VIII offences is resolved through Sections 125–126 of the Army Act, 1950 and the Criminal Courts and Court-Martial (Adjustment of Jurisdiction) Rules (now read with Section 521 of the BNSS, 2023, replacing Section 475 CrPC, 1973) S6.
- Section 167 BNS does not grant blanket immunity from the BNS. When a serving soldier, sailor, or airman commits an ordinary criminal offence outside Chapter VIII BNS (termed a
Comparison with IPC Section 139 and Drafting Notes
| Feature | IPC, 1860 (Section 139) | BNS, 2023 (Section 167) | Legal & Textual Assessment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Enumerated Statutes | "the Army Act, the Army Act, 1950 (46 of 1950), the Naval Discipline Act, the Indian Navy (Discipline) Act, 1934 (34 of 1934), the Air Force Act or the Air Force Act, 1950 (45 of 1950)" S3, s. 139 | "the Army Act, 1950, the Indian Navy (Discipline) Act, 1934, or the Air Force Act, 1950" S1, s. 167 | Removes obsolete British parliamentary statutes (the Army Act, the Naval Discipline Act, the Air Force Act) that applied before 1950 S1, s. 167; S3, s. 139. |
| Naval Statute Reference | Retained Indian Navy (Discipline) Act, 1934 S3, s. 139 | Retains Indian Navy (Discipline) Act, 1934 S1, s. 167 | Editorial analysis: The 1934 Act was repealed and re-enacted by the Navy Act, 1957 (62 of 1957); under Section 8 of the General Clauses Act, 1897, the reference operates as a reference to the Navy Act, 1957 S1, s. 167. |
| Internal Cross-Reference in BNS Section 159 | IPC Section 131 had its own Explanation listing the three Acts S3, s. 131 | BNS Section 159 drops the Explanation and refers to "the Acts referred to in section 165" S1, s. 159 | Editorial analysis: In the First Bill (Bill 121 of 2023), the immunity clause listing the three Acts was Clause 165 S1, s. 159; S1, s. 167. When two earlier clauses were added in the Second Bill (Act 45 of 2023), Clause 165 became Section 167, but the cross-reference inside Section 159 remained "section 165" S1, s. 159; S1, s. 167. Courts apply purposive construction to read "section 165" in Section 159 as referring to Section 167 BNS S1, s. 159; S1, s. 167. |
Practical Examples and Counterexamples
- Editorial Hypothetical 1 (Serving Soldier Abetting Another Soldier's Desertion: Barred by Section 167 BNS):
- Assumed Facts: Nayak A and Sepoy B are both serving regular soldiers subject to the Army Act, 1950. Nayak A instigates Sepoy B to desert from their regiment and hides Sepoy B in his married quarters. Local civil police register an FIR against Nayak A under Sections 163 and 164 BNS.
- Analysis: Because Nayak A is subject to the Army Act, 1950, Section 167 BNS bars his punishment under the BNS for any offence defined in Chapter VIII (including Sections 163 and 164) S1, s. 163–164; S1, s. 167. Nayak A must instead be proceeded against under Section 38(2)/(3) of the Army Act, 1950 before a Court-Martial S1, s. 1(6); S1, s. 167.
- Editorial Hypothetical 2 (Counterexample, Serving Soldier Committing Cheating or Assault Against a Civilian, Not Barred by Section 167 BNS):
- Assumed Facts: While on leave in Bathinda, Nayak A (subject to the Army Act, 1950) commits cheating under Section 318(4) BNS and voluntarily causes grievous hurt under Section 117(2) BNS to a local shopkeeper. Nayak A claims immunity under Section 167 BNS.
- Analysis: Nayak A's claim fails. Section 167 BNS excludes punishment under the Sanhita only
"for any of the offences defined in this Chapter"(Chapter VIII, Sections 159–168) S1, s. 167. Offences under Chapters VI and XVII of the BNS remain punishable under the Sanhita, subject to the procedural forum-adjustment rules between the Magistrate and the Commanding Officer under Section 521 BNSS and Sections 69, 70, 125, and 126 of the Army Act, 1950 S1, s. 167; S6.