The provision in one view
Section 148 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 punishes two kinds of conspiracy. The first is a conspiracy to commit any of the offences punishable by section 147, which is waging war against the Government of India. The second is a conspiracy to overawe, by means of criminal force or the show of criminal force, the Central Government or any State Government. The punishment is imprisonment for life, or imprisonment of either description which may extend to ten years, and the offender is also liable to fine S1; S3.
An Explanation makes the offence complete on the agreement alone: it is not necessary that any act or illegal omission take place in pursuance of the conspiracy S1.
Its predecessor is section 121A of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 S2. A token-level comparison returned a similarity of 0.9551, and after the footnote markers and the cross-reference renumbering are set aside, one genuine textual change remains: the Sanhita inserted the words "and beyond", so that section 148 reads "within or without and beyond India" where section 121A read "within or without India" S1; S2.
The most important structural point about section 148 is counter-intuitive, and it is set out below: the section operates as a ceiling on liability, not as an extension of it.
The exact words
"Whoever within or without and beyond India conspires to commit any of the offences punishable by section 147, or conspires to overawe, by means of criminal force or the show of criminal force, the Central Government or any State Government, shall be punished with imprisonment for life, or with imprisonment of either description which may extend to ten years, and shall also be liable to fine.
Explanation. To constitute a conspiracy under this section, it is not necessary that any act or illegal omission shall take place in pursuance thereof." S1; S3
The two limbs
The Supreme Court, describing the predecessor provision, identified its structure plainly. Conspiracy to commit offences punishable under section 121 of the Penal Code attracted punishment under section 121A, and the maximum sentence could be imprisonment for life; "the other limb of Section 121A is the conspiracy to overawe by means of criminal force or the show of criminal force, the Central Government or any State Government" S5. The same two-limb structure is carried into section 148.
Limb one: conspiracy to commit a section 147 offence. Section 147 punishes waging war against the Government of India, attempting to wage such war, and abetting it S8. A conspiracy directed at any of those falls within limb one.
Limb two: conspiracy to overawe a Government by criminal force. This limb does not require war at all. It is satisfied by an agreement to overawe the Central Government or any State Government by criminal force or the show of criminal force. "Overawe" is not defined in the Sanhita, and no judicial definition of it was located for this article.
Limb two is the broader of the two, because it is not tied to the demanding judicial test for "waging war". A reader should not assume that the restrictive construction the courts have given to waging war controls limb two; that question was not researched here and no authority on it was located.
The Explanation: no overt act required
The Explanation states that no act or illegal omission need take place in pursuance of the conspiracy S1. The Supreme Court made the same point about the predecessor: the explanation "clarifies that it is not necessary that any act or illegal omission should take place pursuant to the conspiracy, in order to constitute the said offence" S5.
The offence is therefore complete when the agreement is made. Nothing need be done to carry it out, and nothing need be done to prepare for it. For limb one, that means a person may be liable under section 148 at a point when no step whatever has been taken towards war.
Section 148 against the general conspiracy provision, and why it is a ceiling
This is the part of section 148 most likely to be misunderstood, so it is worth working through carefully.
The Sanhita contains a general criminal conspiracy provision at section 61 S7. Two features of section 61 matter here.
First, section 61(1) designates as a criminal conspiracy an agreement to do an illegal act, or to do a lawful act by illegal means, subject to a proviso: no agreement except an agreement to commit an offence amounts to a criminal conspiracy unless some act besides the agreement is done in pursuance of it S7. So where the object is an offence, section 61 too is complete on the agreement; the overt-act requirement bites only on agreements whose object is not itself an offence.
Second, and decisively, section 61(2)(a) provides that a party to a criminal conspiracy to commit an offence punishable with death, imprisonment for life, or rigorous imprisonment for two years or more shall, "where no express provision is made in this Sanhita for the punishment of such a conspiracy", be punished in the same manner as if he had abetted such offence S7.
Now put those together with section 147.
Section 147 punishes the abettor of waging war with the same penalty as the person who wages it, and that penalty includes death S8. So if section 148 did not exist, a conspiracy to wage war would fall to section 61(2)(a), which would punish the conspirator "as if he had abetted" the offence, and abetment under section 147 carries death.
Section 148, however, is an express provision for the punishment of that conspiracy. It therefore displaces section 61(2)(a), and it fixes the maximum at imprisonment for life S1; S7. The Supreme Court's description of the predecessor is to the same effect: under section 121A "the maximum sentence could be imprisonment for life" S5.
The consequence is that section 148 reduces a conspirator's maximum exposure rather than increasing it. Without section 148 the default route would reach the death penalty; with section 148 the ceiling is life imprisonment. A reader who assumes that a dedicated conspiracy section must make matters worse for the accused has the relationship backwards.
Two cautions. First, this is an analysis of how the two provisions interact on their face; no authority deciding the interaction under the Sanhita was located, and the conclusion is presented as a reading of the text. Second, nothing here affects the position of a person who actually abets rather than merely conspires: abetment of waging war remains inside section 147 at the higher penalty S8.
The added words: "and beyond India"
The one genuine textual change the Sanhita made is the insertion of "and beyond" S1; S2.
Section 121A of the Penal Code applied to a person who conspired "within or without India". Section 148 applies to a person who conspires "within or without and beyond India".
On its face the addition is redundant. "Without India" already means outside India, and "beyond India" appears to say the same thing again. Read literally, the phrase is a tautology, and the insertion adds nothing to the section's reach.
That observation should be stated carefully, for two reasons.
It is not safe to conclude that the words have no legal effect. Courts ordinarily presume that a legislature does not use words without purpose, and a court invited to give some content to "and beyond" might attempt to do so. No authority construing the phrase was located, and this article does not predict how it would be read.
It is also not safe to conclude that the reach has widened. Nothing in the added words identifies any territory or situation that "without India" would not already cover. Anyone asserting that section 148 extends further than section 121A did would need to identify such a case, and this article does not.
The honest position is therefore narrow: the words were added; they appear redundant; their effect, if any, is undetermined.
One related point of contrast is worth recording. Section 147 itself contains no extra-territorial words at all S8. The conspiracy section says expressly that it applies to conspiracies formed outside India, while the substantive war offence says nothing on the subject. The extra-territorial operation of section 147 therefore depends on the Sanhita's general provisions rather than on its own words, and that question was not researched for this article.
The rest of the comparison with section 121A
Apart from "and beyond", the comparison produced only two further differences, and both were artefacts or consequences of renumbering S1; S2:
- The cross-reference changed from section 121 to section 147, which is simply the Sanhita's renumbering of the substantive offence.
- Two apparent differences at "section 121, 9" and "Government 12," were footnote markers in the published Penal Code text, not statutory words.
Everything else, including the two limbs, the penalty of life or ten years with fine, and the Explanation in its entirety, is carried across unchanged.
Section 121A was not an 1860 provision
The Penal Code's footnote apparatus records that section 121A was inserted by Act 27 of 1870, section 4 S2. It was therefore not part of the Code as originally enacted; it was added ten years later. Section 148's lineage runs to 1870, not 1860.
The same apparatus records several layers of later change to the provision S2:
| Change | Instrument |
|---|---|
| The words "British India" successively replaced | Adaptation of Laws Order, 1948; Adaptation of Laws Order, 1950; Act 3 of 1951, s. 3 and the Schedule |
| The words "or to deprive the Queen of the sovereignty of the Provinces or of any part thereof" omitted | Adaptation of Laws Order, 1950 |
| "the G. of I, or any L. G." replaced | Adaptation of Laws Order, 1937 |
| "Provincial" replaced by "State" | Adaptation of Laws Order, 1950 |
| The words "or the Government of Burma" omitted | Adaptation of Laws Order, 1948 |
Two of those entries are historically striking. Section 121A once contained a third limb, directed at conspiracies to deprive the Queen of the sovereignty of the Provinces, which was removed in 1950. And until 1948 the provision protected the Government of Burma alongside the Indian Governments. The two-limb provision the Sanhita inherited is what remained after those excisions.
As at section 147, this account rests on the footnote apparatus published with the Penal Code; neither the 1860 Gazette nor the 1870 amending Act has been retrieved, and that limitation is recorded below.
How section 148 fits the Chapter
Section 148 sits in Chapter VII of the Sanhita, "Of Offences against the State", which runs from section 147 to section 158 S3. Section 147 is the anchor of the Chapter, and sections 148 to 150 form a graded cluster around it:
| Section | Conduct | Maximum |
|---|---|---|
| 147 | waging, attempting, or abetting war | death |
| 148 | conspiring to commit a s. 147 offence, or to overawe a Government by criminal force | imprisonment for life |
| 149 | collecting arms with intent to wage war | imprisonment for life |
| 150 | concealing with intent to facilitate a design to wage war | not examined here |
The grading is not uniform in the way one might expect. Abetment of waging war sits inside section 147 at the top of the scale; conspiracy sits in section 148 one step below; and the collection of arms, which is a preparatory act, carries the same maximum as conspiracy according to the First Schedule S4.
Classification under the First Schedule
The First Schedule to the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 classifies the offence as follows S4:
| Column | Entry |
|---|---|
| Offence | Conspiring to commit certain offences against the State |
| Punishment | Imprisonment for life, or imprisonment for 10 years and fine |
| Cognizable or non-cognizable | Cognizable |
| Bailable or non-bailable | Non-bailable |
| By what court triable | Court of Session |
The forum entry is correct. A ten-year maximum, and a fortiori imprisonment for life, is beyond what a Magistrate of the first class may impose, and the offence is assigned to the Court of Session. There is no shortfall of the kind found elsewhere in this collection.
One divergence in the Schedule is worth noting. Column 2 paraphrases. The Sanhita's marginal note reads "Conspiracy to commit offences punishable by section 147"; the Schedule's description reads "Conspiring to commit certain offences against the State", which drops the cross-reference to section 147 and substitutes the general word "certain" S1; S4. Nothing turns on it, because the Schedule classifies and does not define, but a reader searching the Schedule for "section 147" will not find this row.
Being cognizable, the offence permits police registration and investigation without a Magistrate's order. Being non-bailable, bail is not a matter of right; the law governing bail has not been examined here.
Compounding
Section 148 appears in neither table of compoundable offences in section 359 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 S4. The offence is therefore not compoundable and cannot be settled by agreement, with or without the court's permission.
Case law
The leading authority on the Chapter, State (N.C.T. of Delhi) v. Navjot Sandhu, decided on 4 August 2005, is also the principal source on section 121A S5. Three points emerge.
The provision was applied and the convictions were sustained. The accused in that case were charged under sections 121, 121A and 122 of the Penal Code, among other provisions, and three of them were convicted on those charges S5. The companion decision in Shoukat Hussain Guru v. State (NCT) Delhi records the same charge sheet and the same convictions S6.
The Court described the section's structure and its Explanation, in the passage relied on above: the two limbs, the maximum of imprisonment for life, and the absence of any requirement of an act or illegal omission in pursuance of the conspiracy S5.
The Court observed that war, terrorism and acts to overawe the Government are hard to separate. In terms: "War, terrorism and violent acts to overawe the established Government have many things in common. It is not too easy to distinguish them" S5. That observation bears directly on limb two of section 148, since overawing a Government by criminal force is the very conduct the Court grouped with war and terrorism while declining to treat the categories as clearly separable.
A targeted search for authority on section 121A returned 109 results. Those examined were decisions of High Courts and trial courts; no Supreme Court authority on the ingredients of section 121A, other than Navjot Sandhu itself, was located S5. The practical consequence is that the content of "conspires to overawe" is substantially undetermined by binding authority.
A clarification about section 147 that emerged from this search
Navjot Sandhu also holds that the concept of war in section 121 of the Penal Code "is not to be understood in international law sense of inter-country war involving military operations by and between two or more hostile countries", and that the section "is not meant to punish prisoners of war of a belligerent nation" S5. That bears on section 147 rather than section 148, and it is recorded here because it was located while researching the conspiracy provision.
Commencement and application
Section 148 came into force on 1 July 2024, by Ministry of Home Affairs notification S.O. 850(E) dated 23 February 2024, which appointed that date for the provisions of the Sanhita subject to the exception stated in the notification S9.
Conduct before that date falls under section 121A of the Penal Code; conduct on or after it falls under section 148 S1; S2. Because the only substantive textual change is the insertion of apparently redundant words, the practical difference between the two provisions is small, but a charge should cite the provision in force when the agreement was made.
Authority on the temporal question
A decision of the Rajasthan High Court supplies authority for that proposition, though it must be used carefully.
In Tejender Pal Singh alias Timma v. State of Rajasthan, decided on 16 December 2024, the Court quashed a first information report so far as it rested on material published before 1 July 2024, holding:
"In my opinion, the substantive penal provisions of the BNS, 2023 [in this case section 152 and sections 197(1) of the Bhartiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023] cannot be retrospectively invoked against the petitioner for the so-called criminal acts done or committed before 01.07.2024, the date of it's coming into force." S10
Three qualifications must be stated.
First, the Court confined that holding to the sections before it. The words in square brackets are the Court's own, and the sections named are 152 and 197(1) -- not section 148. The decision is relied on here for the general reason the Court gave, that the Sanhita's substantive provisions do not operate retrospectively, and not as authority on this section.
Second, the broader statement is a reference to another judgment. The Court went on to record that in Vijay Sharma v. State, a judgment of the same judge, it had been held "that qua the offences committed before 01.07.2024 under the Indian Penal Code (IPC), an FIR cannot be registered under (BNS) after enforcement of Bhartiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) from 01.07.2024" S10. That judgment was not retrieved for this article, and the proposition is reported only as the Rajasthan High Court recorded it.
Third, the procedural split rests on a quoted decision of a different court. The judgment quotes the Allahabad High Court in Deepu v. State of Uttar Pradesh, summarising the effect of the repeals, the first proposition being that "If an FIR is registered on or after 1.7.2024 for the offence committed prior to 1.7.2024, then FIR would be registered under the provisions of IPC but the investigation will continue as per BNSS" S10. That is a quoted decision of another High Court, not the Rajasthan Court's own formulation, and it was not retrieved either. On it, the offence charged would be the Penal Code provision while the procedure followed would be the new Sanhita's -- a split the bare statement above does not capture.
None of this decides the continuing-conduct case, which is addressed next.
A conspiracy is, however, a continuing arrangement, and where an agreement was formed before 1 July 2024 and continued afterwards, the question of which provision applies is not one this article addresses. That question was not researched and no authority on it was located.
Practical points for readers
- The offence is complete on agreement. No act, no preparation, and no step towards war is required S1; S5.
- There are two limbs, and the second is wider. Conspiracy to overawe a Government by criminal force does not require war, and is not obviously subject to the restrictive test applied to waging war S1; S5.
- Section 148 caps exposure at life imprisonment. Because it is an express provision, it displaces section 61(2)(a), which would otherwise punish the conspirator as an abettor and so reach the death penalty available under section 147 S1; S7; S8.
- Abetment is not conspiracy. A person who abets the waging of war is charged under section 147 and faces death; a person who only agrees is charged under section 148 and faces at most life S1; S8.
- "Overawe" is undefined. No statutory definition and no judicial definition was located S1.
- The Schedule row does not mention section 147. Searching the First Schedule by the marginal note's wording will not find this offence S4.
- Cognizable, non-bailable, Court of Session, not compoundable S4.
Limitations of this article
- The effect of the inserted words "and beyond" is undetermined. They appear redundant; no authority construing them was located; and this article neither asserts that they widen the section's reach nor that they are legally inert.
- "Overawe" is not defined in the Sanhita and no judicial definition was located. The scope of limb two is correspondingly uncertain.
- The interaction between sections 148 and 61 is a reading of the text. No authority deciding it under the Sanhita was located.
- Whether the restrictive construction of "waging war" controls limb two was not researched, and no authority on it was located.
- The extra-territorial operation of section 147 was not researched. The contrast with section 148's express words is noted, not resolved.
- No Supreme Court authority on the ingredients of section 121A other than Navjot Sandhu was located. A search returned 109 results; those examined were High Court and trial court decisions.
- Neither the 1860 Gazette nor Act 27 of 1870 has been retrieved. The account of the provision's insertion and later amendment is an inference from the footnote apparatus published with the Penal Code.
- No Law Commission or legislative-committee material was located or searched for this section, so no documented rationale for inserting "and beyond" is offered. This is the obvious place such a rationale would be found, and its absence is a real gap in the account.
- The treatment of conspiracies straddling 1 July 2024 was not researched.
- Bail law and committal procedure were not examined beyond recording the Schedule's classification.
- Sections 149 to 158 were not analysed, and section 150 in particular is described only by its marginal note.
- Capital sentencing remains outside scope. It is relevant only indirectly, through the section 61(2)(a) analysis, and the article makes no statement about when a death sentence may be imposed.
Frequently asked questions
1. What does section 148 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita punish? Conspiring to commit any offence punishable by section 147, which is waging war against the Government of India, and conspiring to overawe the Central Government or any State Government by criminal force or the show of criminal force S1.
2. What is the punishment? Imprisonment for life, or imprisonment of either description up to ten years, and the offender is also liable to fine S1.
3. Does anything have to be done to carry out the conspiracy? No. The Explanation states that no act or illegal omission need take place in pursuance of the conspiracy, so the offence is complete on the agreement S1; S5.
4. Which section of the Indian Penal Code did this replace? Section 121A S2.
5. Was section 121A part of the original Penal Code? No. It was inserted by Act 27 of 1870, section 4, ten years after the Code was enacted S2.
6. Did the wording change? Barely. A comparison returned a similarity of 0.9551, and once footnote markers and the renumbered cross-reference are set aside, the only genuine change is the insertion of the words "and beyond" S1; S2.
7. What difference do the words "and beyond" make? On their face, none. "Without India" already means outside India and "beyond India" appears to repeat it, so the phrase reads as a tautology. No authority construing it was located, and this article does not assert either that the reach has widened or that the words are legally inert S1; S2.
8. How many limbs does the section have? Two: conspiracy to commit a section 147 offence, and conspiracy to overawe a Government by criminal force. The Supreme Court identified the same two-limb structure in the predecessor S1; S5.
9. Does the second limb require war? No. It requires an agreement to overawe the Central Government or a State Government by criminal force or the show of criminal force. War is not an element S1.
10. What does "overawe" mean? It is not defined in the Sanhita, and no judicial definition was located for this article S1.
11. Is section 148 harsher than the general conspiracy provision? No, and this is the counter-intuitive point. Section 61(2)(a) punishes a conspirator to a death or life offence as if he had abetted it, but only where no express provision exists. Section 148 is an express provision, so it displaces that route and caps the maximum at life imprisonment, whereas abetment under section 147 reaches death S1; S7; S8.
12. So a conspirator faces a lower maximum than an abettor? Yes, on the text. Abetment of waging war is inside section 147 and carries death; conspiracy falls under section 148 and carries at most imprisonment for life S1; S8.
13. Did the Supreme Court say the maximum under the predecessor was life? Yes. It said that conspiracy to commit offences punishable under section 121 attracted punishment under section 121A and that the maximum sentence could be imprisonment for life S5.
14. Has the provision actually been used? Yes. In the case decided by the Supreme Court in 2005, three accused were convicted under sections 121, 121A and 122 of the Penal Code among other provisions S5; S6.
15. Is there much case law on the ingredients? Not at the highest level. A targeted search returned 109 results, and those examined were High Court and trial court decisions; no Supreme Court authority on the ingredients other than the 2005 decision was located S5.
16. Is the offence cognizable? Yes, according to the First Schedule to the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 S4.
17. Is it bailable? No. It is classified as non-bailable S4.
18. Which court tries it? The Court of Session, which is correct given a maximum of life imprisonment S4.
19. Can it be compounded? No. Section 148 appears in neither table of compoundable offences in section 359 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 S4.
20. Why does the First Schedule not mention section 147? Because column 2 paraphrases. It describes the offence as "Conspiring to commit certain offences against the State", dropping the cross-reference that appears in the Sanhita's marginal note S1; S4.
21. When did section 148 come into force? 1 July 2024, by Ministry of Home Affairs notification S.O. 850(E) dated 23 February 2024 S9.
22. What if a conspiracy began before that date and continued after it? This article does not answer that. The question was not researched and no authority on it was located S1; S2.
23. Did section 121A ever cover anything it no longer covers? Yes. It once contained a limb directed at conspiracies to deprive the Queen of the sovereignty of the Provinces, omitted in 1950, and until 1948 it also protected the Government of Burma S2.
24. Where does section 148 sit in the Chapter? In Chapter VII, "Of Offences against the State", which runs from sections 147 to 158. Section 147 is the anchor, and sections 148, 149 and 150 form a graded cluster of conspiracy, arms collection and concealment around it S3.
This article states the law as published in the sources cited and is for general information only. It is not legal advice. Section 148 creates an offence that is complete on agreement alone, its second limb turns on the undefined word "overawe", and the effect of the words "and beyond" inserted by the Sanhita has not been determined by any authority located here, so the boundaries of this section are genuinely uncertain in more than one direction. Anyone affected by, or advising on, a matter under this section should obtain qualified legal advice. Verify the current text, and take advice on your own facts, before acting.