The short answer
Section 109 punishes attempt to murder. It is the longest provision in this group, two sub-sections and four Illustrations, and it is almost entirely unchanged from IPC Section 307 S1; S3.
Section 109(1): the main offence:
Whoever does any act with such intention or knowledge, and under such circumstances that, if he by that act caused death, he would be guilty of murder, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to ten years, and shall also be liable to fine; and if hurt is caused to any person by such act, the offender shall be liable either to imprisonment for life, or to such punishment as is hereinbefore mentioned.
Note the internal enhancement: ten years is the ceiling, but if hurt is caused, imprisonment for life opens up S1.
Section 109(2): the life-convict sub-section:
When any person offending under sub-section (1) is under sentence of imprisonment for life, he may, if hurt is caused, be punished with death or with imprisonment for life, which shall mean the remainder of that person's natural life.
There is no fine in sub-section (2). The word does not appear in it S1.
What actually changed. Against IPC Section 307:
- Sub-section (1): zero differences. Word for word identical S3.
- Sub-section (2): the whole-life alternative was added. The Penal Code said simply "he may, if hurt is caused, be punished with death". Now the court may impose death or whole-life imprisonment S3.
- Illustrations: one difference, in (c) only: a cross-reference updated from "the first paragraph of this section" to "sub-section (1)". Illustrations (a), (b) and (d) are identical S3.
- The marginal heading "Attempts by life-convicts" is gone, verified absent from the Gazette S2.
And this section has something no other in the group has: a court applying it in its own terms, and convicting. A Sessions Court set out both sub-sections, asked itself the Section 109(1) question directly, and convicted S6.
(A) What the documented record shows
Three components, compared separately
IPC Section 307 was not one block of text. It had three distinct components, and each was compared on its own S3:
| Component | IPC 307 | BNS 109 | Differences |
|---|---|---|---|
| Main offence | first paragraph | sub-section (1) | 0 |
| Life-convict limb | separately headed "Attempts by life-convicts" | sub-section (2) | 2 |
| Illustrations | (a) to (d) | (a) to (d) | 1, in (c) only |
The statutory headings are identical: "Attempt to murder" S3.
The one substantive change
| IPC 307, life-convict paragraph | BNS 109(2) | |
|---|---|---|
| Who | "any person offending under this section" | "any person offending under sub-section (1)" |
| Punishment | "be punished with death." | "be punished with death or with imprisonment for life, which shall mean the remainder of that person's natural life." |
The first change is housekeeping, consequential on the restructuring into sub-sections. The second is real: a whole-life alternative was added.
Be precise about what that does, and does not, mean. The Penal Code's wording was permissive, not mandatory: it read "he may, if hurt is caused, be punished with death" S3. So death was an available enhanced punishment, not a compulsory one. The Sanhita has therefore added an express intermediate option, not removed a mandatory sentence. That distinguishes it from Section 104, where the predecessor (IPC Section 303) said "shall be punished with death" and the change was of a different character.
The whole-life wording is not special to this section either. An enumeration across all 358 sections found "which shall mean the remainder of that person's natural life" in ten provisions: Sections 64, 65, 66, 70, 71, 104, 109, 117, 139 and 143 S5. Section 109(2) uses the Code's standard formula.
Illustration (c), and an 1891 amendment with a 2023 sequel
Illustration (c) ends by making the offender liable to the punishment provided by "the latter part of…" the provision. The Penal Code said "the latter part of the first paragraph of this section". Section 109 says "the latter part of sub-section (1)" S3.
The interesting part is the lineage. The words "the first paragraph of" were themselves inserted into Illustration (c) by Act 12 of 1891, section 2 and the Second Schedule S3. So an 1891 amendment added a phrase to clarify which part of the section the Illustration pointed at, and the 2023 restructuring into sub-sections has now replaced that phrase with the sub-section number that does the same job. A hundred and thirty-two years apart, two drafters solving the same problem.
Provenance: the most-amended provision in this group
IPC Section 307 was amended three times, more than any other provision examined here. All three footnotes come from the block at the foot of page 76, which is the page the markers fall on S3:
| Footnote | Amendment | What it did |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Act 26 of 1955, s. 117 and the Sch. (w.e.f. 1-1-1956) | "transportation for life" replaced by "imprisonment for life" |
| 2 | Act 24 of 1870, s. 11 | inserted the whole "Attempts by life-convicts" paragraph |
| 3 | Act 12 of 1891, s. 2 and the Second Sch. | inserted "the first paragraph of" into Illustration (c) |
Footnote 2 matters: the life-convict limb was not part of the 1860 Code. It was added ten years later. So the provision that became Section 109(2) has itself been amended twice since it was created.
Every excision was proved lossless by a reinsertion test that rebuilt the original string exactly S3:
- first paragraph: 475 characters against 475
- life-convict paragraph: 173 against 173: this one required handling nested markers, of the form
2[… 1[imprisonment for life] …] - Illustrations: 996 against 996
All three string-equal.
Two negative controls, both passed
Against the Gazette S2:
- "Attempts by life-convicts": absent from the Sanhita entirely. The marginal heading was dropped, not relocated.
- "the first paragraph of this section": absent. The old cross-reference was replaced, not retained alongside the new one.
Commencement and cross-references
Section 109 commenced on 1 July 2024; the only excepted provision was Section 106(2). Read in both the English and the Hindi text, which agree S4. Section 109 is in neither list in Section 2(24), and the BNSS does not refer to it at all S1.
(B) Judicial context
The field, and the sample
Both exact-phrase searches returned ten results, the display limit, so the field is truncated and recorded as not surveyed S9.
We opened four. All four genuinely contained the phrase. But two of them turned out to be the same order: 12,188 and 12,204 characters, similarity 0.9985, the same neutral citation and the same bail application number, differing only in the cause title. Served separately for two co-applicants. Counted once S8; S9.
The case law on IPC Section 307 was NOT surveyed S9. That is a very large body of authority, including the law distinguishing an attempt to murder from lesser offences, and no summary of it is offered here.
A conviction under Section 109(1): the first section in this batch applied in its own terms
Chandralayout PS v. Waseem Bagewadi alias Waseem Pasha, Court of the LXVII Additional City Civil and Sessions Judge, Bengaluru, S.C. No. 1558 of 2025, judgment of 4 June 2026 S6.
This is the only decision in the whole v2 batch that construes a Sanhita provision in its own right rather than citing it in parentheses beside the Penal Code section. The Court set out both sub-sections in full, and the text it reproduced matches our verified inventory word for word, including the new whole-life words in sub-section (2), which corroborates both. It then applied the provision directly:
In view of Section 109(1) of BNS, the court has to look into whether the accused had intention or knowledge to kill C.W.1/P.W.1.
Charges had been framed for an "Offence under Section 109(1) r/w. Section 3(5) of BNS". The operative order records S6:
Acting under Section 258(2) of BNSS, the accused No.1 is convicted for the offence punishable under Sections 109(1) r/w. Section 3(5) of BNS. To hear regarding sentence.
A knife was produced as material object M.O.1.
How much weight this carries. It is a Sessions Court judgment, not appellate authority. It binds nobody. We cite it for one thing only: as evidence that Section 109(1) is being applied in its own terms, by a court reading the Sanhita rather than translating from the Penal Code.
A quashing on compromise, and what it does not establish
Devarakonda Vinay Kumar v. Veeralla Ramakrishna, High Court of Andhra Pradesh at Amaravati, Criminal Petition Nos. 4738 and 4739 of 2025, order of 1 May 2025 S7.
The Court recorded that "Although the offence alleged against the petitioners falls under Section 109 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita… which pertains to attempt to murder, the material on record indicates that an altercation occurred, during which the petitioners allegedly assaulted the respondent with a stick." The parties had settled, and applications were filed "seeking the permission of this Court to allow the petitioners and the de facto complainant to compound the offence under Sections 109 (1), 118(1) read with 3(5) of the B.N.S." One of the two crimes also carried charges under the SC and ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989.
The order allowed the applications and quashed the proceedings in both crimes S7.
Now the limit, which matters more than the holding. We do not treat this as establishing that an offence under Section 109 is a compoundable offence. Quashing proceedings on the basis of a settlement and statutory compounding are different mechanisms; the relevant BNSS provisions were not retrieved; and the BNSS First Schedule, which is what actually classifies offences, has never been examined in this project S7. What the order shows is that in these particular cases, on these facts, the High Court was willing to quash. Nothing more.
A submission that reads like a finding
The de-duplicated Bombay High Court bail order describes the applicant as "the prime accused (A-1) in a case involving an attempt to murder under Section 109 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) (formerly Section 307 IPC)", armed with a sword and delivering a targeted blow to the head S8.
That is the Additional Public Prosecutor's submission, not the Court's finding: the paragraph opens "The learned APP has submitted that…". We report it as a submission. The order also illustrates the parallel-citation habit, describing Section 109 as "formerly Section 307 IPC".
No decision construing Section 109(2) was retrieved, and in particular none on the new whole-life alternative S9.
(C) Editorial analysis: clearly labelled as ours
Everything in this part is our own reading of the verified material above.
This is a renumbering with one targeted amendment, and the amendment is easy to misdescribe. Adding whole-life imprisonment to Section 109(2) looks at first like a toughening. It is better read as widening the court's choice: the Penal Code offered the sentencing court exactly one enhanced option for a life-convict who caused hurt in an attempt to murder, and that option was death. Now there are two. Whether that makes outcomes harsher or softer in practice is not something the text can tell you, and we do not guess.
The structural change is the one practitioners will feel. "The latter part of the first paragraph" has become "sub-section (1)", and the marginal heading "Attempts by life-convicts" has gone. Anyone citing Section 307 authority under Section 109 needs to translate paragraph references into sub-section references, and the Illustration (c) change is the Sanhita doing exactly that translation for you, in the one place where the Code itself cross-refers.
The conviction in the Bengaluru judgment is worth noticing for a reason that has nothing to do with its weight. Across this entire batch of eight sections, every other court we read cited the Sanhita section in brackets after the Penal Code section it was actually applying. This one read the Sanhita. It is a single Sessions Court judgment and binds nobody, but it is the first sign in our material of the new Code being used as a primary text rather than a translation table.
On this website's own mapping table: the punishment is right, the key difference is wrong, and the real change is missing. The entry records "Same - Up to 10 years, or life if hurt caused", which is correct for sub-section (1). But it gives the key difference as "Added provisions for organized crime", and Section 109 contains no organised-crime provision of any kind. We tested for "organis", "organiz", "syndicate" and "gang": zero occurrences. Organised crime is a separate section, Section 111. The entry also omits the one substantive change that was actually made, the whole-life alternative in sub-section (2). This is the fourth materially wrong entry this project has identified in that dataset S10.
Update, 10 November 2026: the mapping table has since been corrected against the bare Acts. The IPC 307 entry now reads: punishment "Same - Up to 10 years, or life if hurt caused"; key difference "Main offence unchanged. 109(2) lets a life convict who causes hurt be given life imprisonment for the rest of natural life, as an alternative to death".
What we checked, and what we could not
Checked and verified. The full text of Section 109: both sub-sections and all four Illustrations: against the verified inventory and, fragment by fragment, against the Gazette S1; S2. That sub-section (2) carries no fine, by testing for the word S1. That Section 109 contains no organised-crime wording, by testing four different terms S1. The comparison with IPC Section 307 component by component, with each excision proved lossless by a reinsertion test: 475 against 475, 173 against 173 (nested markers), 996 against 996, all string-equal S3. Two negative controls on the Gazette, for the dropped marginal heading and the replaced cross-reference S2. All three amendments to IPC Section 307, from the footnote block at the foot of page 76: including that the life-convict paragraph was inserted in 1870 and that Illustration (c)'s phrase was inserted in 1891 S3. That the whole-life formula appears in exactly ten sections, by enumeration S5. Commencement, in both language texts S4. That Section 109 is in neither Section 2(24) list and that the BNSS never mentions it S1. The de-duplication of two documents into one order, by full-body comparison S8. The attribution of the sword passage to the prosecutor rather than the Court S8. The Bengaluru conviction and the Amaravati quashing, each read to its operative order S6; S7.
Not checked, and material. The case law on IPC Section 307 was NOT surveyed, including the authority distinguishing attempt to murder from lesser offences, and no summary is offered S9. The Section 109 field is truncated at the display limit, not exhausted; what is reported is a sample S9. No decision construing Section 109(2) was retrieved, and none at all on the new whole-life alternative S9. Cognizability, bailability and compoundability are NOT stated. The BNSS First Schedule has never been examined, and the Amaravati order is expressly not treated as establishing that Section 109 is compoundable S7. The BNSS provisions on compounding and on quashing were not retrieved S7. Section 3(5) of the Sanhita, under which both the conviction and the quashed charges were framed, was not retrieved or analysed S6; S7. The SC and ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 was not retrieved S7. The Constitution was not retrieved; no constitutional text is quoted. No State amendment or variation was searched for. The existing deepDive content in the live dataset entry for IPC 307 was deliberately not read, to keep this article independent, so no textual overlap comparison was performed against it, and none is claimed S10.
How this article was prepared
IPC Section 307 was broken into its three components (first paragraph, life-convict paragraph, Illustrations) and each was compared separately against the corresponding part of Section 109, because comparing the whole as one block would have hidden which component changed.
Four of this project's standing rules did the work:
- Prove every excision lossless. Three separate reinsertion tests, including one with nested markers, all string-equal. Without them the 1870 and 1891 amendments could have been silently absorbed into the statutory text.
- Match markers to the right footnote block. All three footnotes sit at the foot of page 76, the page the markers fall on: the same block that governs Section 305, and the one whose page number we had to correct in that article.
- Compare full bodies when lengths look close. 12,188 and 12,204 characters proved to be one order under two identifiers.
- Do not let an order prove more than it says. A High Court quashing proceedings on a settlement is not a ruling that the offence is compoundable, and we say so rather than borrowing the convenient inference.
Documented statutory material, judicial material and our own assessment are kept separate and labelled. Where something is unknown, this article says so rather than filling the gap.
This article was prepared with AI assistance. No lawyer has reviewed it and no human legal review is claimed. Its status is "ready for human review": ready to be checked by a person, not already checked.
This article is new and standalone. It does not reproduce, replace or alter any existing content on this website, and nothing here has been published, integrated or deployed.
Law checked as of the date recorded in this article's metadata. Statutes and case law change, and this article is not legal advice. Whether an act amounts to an attempt to murder, whether hurt was caused, and what sentence may follow within the limits the section allows, are matters only a court can determine on the evidence before it, and no outcome in any case is guaranteed. Verify the current position and take advice from a qualified advocate before acting.