The short answer
Section 105 punishes culpable homicide not amounting to murder. Like Sections 103 and 104 it punishes without defining: culpable homicide is defined in Section 100, murder in Section 101, and Section 105 applies where the homicide falls short of murder S1.
It has two punishment limbs, divided by a semicolon, and they carry different sentences:
| Limb 1: the intention limb | Limb 2: the knowledge limb | |
|---|---|---|
| When it applies | the act causing death is done with the intention of causing death, or of causing such bodily injury as is likely to cause death | the act is done with the knowledge that it is likely to cause death, but without any intention to cause death or such bodily injury |
| Custodial | imprisonment for life, or 5 to 10 years | up to 10 years |
| Minimum | five years | none |
| Life option | yes | no |
| Fine | "and shall also be liable to fine" | "and with fine" |
Two real changes from IPC Section 304, and both make the section harsher S3:
- A five-year minimum was added to the intention limb. The Penal Code had no minimum.
- The fine-only option was removed from the knowledge limb. Under the Penal Code a court could impose imprisonment, or a fine alone, or both. Under Section 105 it must impose imprisonment and fine.
The "Part I / Part II" labels are gone. Practitioners have always called the two limbs of Section 304 "Part I" and "Part II". Those words appear nowhere in Section 105: we tested for them S1. The limbs survive; the shorthand has no statutory footing.
(A) What the documented record shows
Against IPC Section 304: four differences
The statutory headings are identical S3. The word-level comparison returns exactly four differences:
| IPC 304 | BNS 105 | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | murder | murder, |
| 2 | (nothing) | which shall not be less than five years but |
| 3 | years, or | years and |
| 4 | or with both, | (deleted) |
The first is a comma. The second is the five-year floor. The third and fourth together convert the knowledge limb's sentence from "ten years, or with fine, or with both" into "ten years and with fine".
The five-year minimum, and a test of ours that failed first
A long fragment spanning the five-year phrase came back False against the Gazette. That is not a discrepancy. It is the Gazette's two-column layout. The marginal note drops into the running text word by word S2:
…for a term which shall not be HOMICIDE NOT AMOUNTING TO less than five years but which may extend to ten years, and shall also be liable to fine, if the MURDER. act by which the death is caused…
Resolved in halves, each component is present: "which shall not be less than five years", "shall not be less than five years but", and "but which may extend to ten years" S2. The five-year minimum is confirmed.
The removal of the fine-only option, with a negative control
The knowledge limb's new wording is present in the Gazette: "term which may extend to ten years and with fine, if the act is done with the knowledge" S2.
And the negative control passed: the Penal Code's "term which may extend to ten years, or with fine, or with both, if the act is done with the knowledge" is absent from the Gazette S2. The fine-only option appears nowhere in the Sanhita's version of this provision.
Provenance, and a page break in the middle of the section
IPC Section 304 carries footnote marker 1: Act 26 of 1955, section 117 and the Schedule, substituting "imprisonment for life" for "transportation for life" with effect from 1 January 1956 S3. The same footnote serves Sections 302, 303 and 304 on that printed page.
Extracting Section 304 was the fiddliest job in this group, because the provision spans a page break: the intention limb ends one page, and a footnote block and the page number 74 sit between the two limbs before the knowledge limb resumes. Those four lines were excised, and the excision was proved lossless by a reinsertion test that rebuilt the original string exactly: 717 characters against 717, string-equal S3. Without that test an unnoticed page marker could have been silently absorbed into the statutory text.
The five-year floor is selective, not a Code-wide default
Scanning all 358 sections, "shall not be less than five years" appears in exactly six S5:
68 · 105 · 111 · 113 · 124 · 144
So the Sanhita uses the five-year floor deliberately and sparingly. It is neither unique to Section 105 nor the Code's general practice.
Commencement and cross-references
Section 105 commenced on 1 July 2024; the only excepted provision was Section 106(2). Read in both the English and the Hindi text of the notification, which agree S4. Section 105 is in neither list in Section 2(24) S1.
The BNSS refers to Section 105 three times: more than any other section in this group S6. Two are model forms of charge, reciting that the accused "committed culpable homicide not amounting to murder, causing the death of…, and thereby committed an offence punishable under section 105 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023", one adding "within the cognizance of this Court" and the other "within the cognizance of the Court of Session".
The third is more interesting. It is an illustration on separate charges: where a person exposes a child with knowledge that it is thereby likely to cause its death, and the child dies in consequence, "A may be separately charged with, and convicted of, offences under sections 93 and 105 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023" S6. Section 93 is the exposure-and-abandonment provision covered earlier in this collection. The illustration shows the two operating together rather than one absorbing the other.
As always, we note what this does not establish. Model forms and illustrations are drafting aids. The provision that classifies offences as cognizable or bailable is the First Schedule to the BNSS, which this project has not examined S6. So we state the forum on the strength of the forms, and nothing about cognizability, bailability or compoundability.
(B) Judicial context
What the searches could and could not do
Three exact-phrase searches each returned ten results, the repository's display limit, so the field is truncated, and recorded as not surveyed S10.
But here the sampling result was different from Section 103. We opened and read five documents, and all five genuinely contained the phrase S10. So at Section 105 the result sets are real hits, and the ten-result ceiling is hiding more of them. What follows is therefore a sample, not a survey, and this article does not claim to present the authorities on Section 105.
Three of the five sampled documents turned out to be the same judgment. Served under separate identifiers for three co-appellants, their full bodies measured 61,214, 61,219 and 61,222 characters with pairwise similarity of 0.9999, differing only in the cause title. They are counted once S7; S10.
The one judgment that engages the provision substantively
Patna High Court, Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 168 of 2020, 21 March 2025 (Rajeev Ranjan Prasad and Sourendra Pandey JJ.) S7. The Court held:
we are, however, persuaded to take a view that learned trial court is not correct in holding that the case would be covered under Section 304 Part II of the IPC.
It then set out "The Section 304 Part II IPC (now Section 105 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023)" and quoted the Penal Code text, retaining the amendment marker as 1[imprisonment for life] S7.
So, as at Sections 101 and 102, Section 105 appears here as a parallel citation rather than a provision construed in its own right, and the Court naturally used "Part II", the label the Sanhita abandoned. On the order, the convicts who were on bail were directed to surrender within six weeks and undergo the remaining sentences; the appeals were disposed of accordingly S7.
Two bail orders, and why only one of them says what it appears to say
Raman Kumar v. State of Madhya Pradesh (10 July 2026, Ajay Kumar Nirankari J.) contains what looks like a crisp statement of Section 105's requirements S8:
The offence punishable under Section 105 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 requires the prosecution to prima facie establish the essential ingredients of culpable homicide not amounting to murder, namely the existence of intention or knowledge as contemplated under the provision.
It is counsel's submission, not the Court's holding. The paragraph opens "Counsel for the applicant submits that FIR does not contain even a whisper of any intention or knowledge…" and closes "He submits that prosecution's own case is that the applicant…". The quoted sentence sits inside that submission S8.
We report it as a submission. And the Court did not accept it: "this Court is not inclined to extend the benefit of bail to the applicant at this stage. No case for grant of bail is made out". The application was dismissed S8.
Roshan Prasad v. State of Madhya Pradesh (11 August 2026, the same judge) is different: there the Section 105 passage is the Court's own assessment S9:
So far as Section 105 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, relating to culpable homicide not amounting to murder, is concerned, there is no material to demonstrate that the applicant had any knowledge regarding the engagement of Dr. Narendra John Kem by the Hospital or that the said doctor was performing angiography and angioplasty procedures in the Cath Lab.
So a court has applied Section 105's knowledge element, but at the bail stage, on the sufficiency of material, and not by construing the section's ingredients. Bail was dismissed, the Court recording that it did so "without expressing any opinion on the merits of the case" S9.
What has not been surveyed
The case law on IPC Section 304 was not surveyed S10. That body of authority (above all on the division between the two limbs, which is one of the most litigated questions in Indian sentencing) is substantial, it carries over to Section 105 because the trigger wording is unchanged, and it is not summarised here.
(C) Editorial analysis: clearly labelled as ours
Everything in this part is our own reading of the verified material above.
This is a genuinely harsher section, and in a way that is easy to miss. Nothing about the maximum changed: ten years in both limbs, life available in the intention limb, exactly as under the Penal Code. The changes are at the floor. A five-year minimum removes the court's power to pass a shorter sentence in the intention limb however sympathetic the facts; and removing the fine-only option in the knowledge limb removes the power to dispose of a case without imprisonment at all. Both reduce sentencing discretion downwards while leaving the ceiling alone. In our assessment that is the real character of the change, and it is the opposite of the pattern at Section 104, where discretion was widened.
The removal of the fine-only option deserves more attention than it usually gets. The knowledge limb catches the defendant who did not intend death: the classic rash-driving or dangerous-act case at the serious end. Under the Penal Code, a court faced with a marginal case could impose a fine and no imprisonment. That option is gone. We do not know what motivated it and found no documented rationale, so we record the change and its effect and offer no explanation.
Losing the "Part I / Part II" shorthand is a practical nuisance rather than a legal change. The entire body of authority on Section 304 is organised around those labels, and the Patna judgment above uses them. They never had statutory footing, and they still describe the limbs accurately, but anyone reading Section 105 for the first time will not find them, and anyone citing "Part II authority" under Section 105 needs to say which limb they mean.
On this website's own mapping table: this entry is wrong, in both fields. It records the punishment as "Same punishment structure" and the key difference as "Clarified definitions for better interpretation". The punishment structure is not the same. A five-year minimum was added and the fine-only option removed. And no definition was clarified, because Section 105 contains no definition at all; it is purely a sentencing provision. This is the second materially wrong punishment entry this project has found in that dataset, after the entry for IPC 373 S11.
Update, 10 November 2026: the mapping table has since been corrected against the bare Acts. The IPC 304 entry now reads: punishment "Changed - Life, or 5 to 10 years, and fine (intent); up to 10 years and fine (knowledge)"; key difference "A 5-year minimum is new where death is caused with intent. Where death is caused with knowledge only, the fine-only option is gone".
The Section 93 illustration is worth noticing. The BNSS's own illustration contemplates a person being separately charged with and convicted of both exposure of a child under Section 93 and culpable homicide under Section 105 on the same facts. It is a drafting aid, not authority, but it indicates that the two provisions were designed to be capable of operating together.
What we checked, and what we could not
Checked and verified. The full text and heading of Section 105 against the verified inventory and, fragment by fragment, against the Gazette S1; S2. Both punishment limbs separately, including that limb 2 has no minimum and no life option, and that the fine is mandatory in form in each S1. That the words "Part I" and "Part II" appear nowhere in the section, by testing for them S1. The word-level comparison with IPC Section 304, on a line-scoped extraction spanning a page break, with the footnote block and page number excised and the excision proved lossless at 717 characters against 717, string-equal S3. The five-year minimum, resolved in halves after a longer fragment returned a false negative S2. The removal of the fine-only option, with a negative control on the Penal Code's wording S2. The 1955 amendment to Section 304 S3. That the five-year floor appears in exactly six sections, by scanning all 358 S5. Commencement, in both language texts S4. The three BNSS references, including the Section 93 illustration S6. The de-duplication of three documents into one judgment, by full-body comparison S7. The attribution of the Raman Kumar passage to counsel rather than the Court, by reading the surrounding paragraph S8. The contrasting attribution in Roshan Prasad S9.
Not checked, and material. The case law on IPC Section 304 was NOT surveyed, including the authority on the division between the two limbs, and this article offers no summary of it S10. The Section 105 field is TRUNCATED, not exhausted: three searches each hit the ten-result display limit, so there are authorities we have not seen, and what is reported above is a sample S10. Cognizability, bailability and compoundability are not stated. The BNSS First Schedule has never been examined; only the forum is stated, on the strength of the model forms S6. Whether the five-year minimum applies to an offence committed before 1 July 2024 is not analysed beyond noting that the Sanhita is harsher on this point and that the bar on retrospective penal liability exists; the Constitution was not retrieved and no constitutional text is quoted. The interaction between Section 105 and Sections 106 and 110 is not mapped. No State amendment or variation was searched for.
How this article was prepared
The official text of Section 105 was compared word by word with the official text of IPC Section 304: a comparison complicated by a page break falling inside the Penal Code provision, and every reported difference was then tested against the Gazette before being asserted.
Four of this project's standing rules did visible work:
- A Gazette-side False is not evidence of a discrepancy. The five-year minimum appeared absent until the fragment was resolved in halves and the interleaved marginal note identified.
- Prove an excision lossless before trusting it. A footnote block and the page number 74 sit inside Section 304. The reinsertion test came back string-equal at 717 against 717; without it, page furniture could have been absorbed into the statutory text.
- Compare full bodies when lengths look suspiciously close. Three documents, 61,214 / 61,219 / 61,222 characters, proved to be one judgment. Counted once.
- A proposition recorded as counsel's submission is never reported as the law. The crispest-looking statement of Section 105's ingredients we found is an argument that the Court rejected.
We also record a difference from Section 103 in this same batch: there, sampling showed the ten-result sets were spurious; here, sampling showed they were genuine. The same raw number, ten, meant different things, and only opening the documents distinguished them.
Documented statutory material, judicial material and our own assessment are kept separate and labelled. Where something is unknown, this article says so rather than filling the gap.
This article was prepared with AI assistance. No lawyer has reviewed it and no human legal review is claimed. Its status is "ready for human review": ready to be checked by a person, not already checked.
This article is new and standalone. It does not reproduce, replace or alter any existing content on this website, and nothing here has been published, integrated or deployed.
Law checked as of the date recorded in this article's metadata. Statutes and case law change, and this article is not legal advice. Which limb of Section 105 applies, whether the homicide amounts to murder, and what sentence follows within the limits the section allows, are matters only a court can determine on the evidence before it, and no outcome in any case is guaranteed. Verify the current position and take advice from a qualified advocate before acting.