What Section 98 says
Section 98 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 is titled "Selling child for purposes of prostitution, etc." It reads S1:
Whoever sells, lets to hire, or otherwise disposes of any child with intent that such child shall at any age be employed or used for the purpose of prostitution or illicit intercourse with any person or for any unlawful and immoral purpose, or knowing it to be likely that such child will at any age be employed or used for any such purpose, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to ten years, and shall also be liable to fine.
Explanation 1.—When a female under the age of eighteen years is sold, let for hire, or otherwise disposed of to a prostitute or to any person who keeps or manages a brothel, the person so disposing of such female shall, until the contrary is proved, be presumed to have disposed of her with the intent that she shall be used for the purpose of prostitution.
Explanation 2.—For the purposes of this section "illicit intercourse" means sexual intercourse between persons not united by marriage or by any union or tie which, though not amounting to a marriage, is recognised by the personal law or custom of the community to which they belong or, where they belong to different communities, of both such communities, as constituting between them a quasi-marital relation.
The structure has two limbs that must both be present:
- a transaction: the accused sells, lets to hire, or otherwise disposes of a child; and
- a purpose or knowledge: intent that the child shall at any age be employed or used for prostitution, illicit intercourse, or any unlawful and immoral purpose; or knowledge that this is likely.
The words "at any age" matter: the intended employment or use need not be immediate. A sale today with a view to exploitation years later is within the section S1.
Maximum ten years; the fine is discretionary; there is no minimum S1. "Child" is unqualified, so Section 2(3) applies and means a person below eighteen S1.
Section 98 came into force on 1 July 2024 S4. It appears in neither list in Section 2(24) S1.
(A) What the documented record shows about the change
Six differences, and only one that matters
Section 98 replaces IPC Section 372, "Selling minor for purposes of prostitution, etc." The word-level comparison returns six differences S3:
| IPC s. 372 | BNS s. 98 | What it is |
|---|---|---|
| "person under the age of eighteen years" | "child" | the substantive change |
| "such person shall at any age" | "such child shall at any age" | consequential |
| "such person will at any age" | "such child will at any age" | consequential |
| "Explanation I" | "Explanation 1" | renumbering |
| "II" | "2" | renumbering |
| "quasi**- **marital" | "quasi-marital" | an IPC hyphenation artefact, tidied |
Everything else is word for word: the three transaction verbs, the purpose limb, "at any age", the ten-year maximum, the discretionary fine, the presumption in Explanation 1, and the whole of the definition of "illicit intercourse" S3.
The IPC contradicted itself, and the Sanhita fixed it
This is a real defect in the old law, and it is easy to miss unless you read the heading against the body.
IPC Section 372's heading said "Selling minor for purposes of prostitution". Its body said "any person under the age of eighteen years" S3.
So the same section used two different descriptions of the protected class, and the IPC contained no general definition of "minor" at all. Its only comparable definition, in Section 363A(b), was local to that section and gendered: male under sixteen, female under eighteen S3.
The Sanhita resolves the mismatch by using "child" in both the heading and the body, with a single statutory definition behind it.
The body wording was 1924 material, and what it replaced is not recorded
The published IPC text carries an insertion bracket marked 2 around "person under the age of eighteen years with intent that such person … will at any age be", and a bracket marked 3 before the Explanation S3.
We established the attribution by marker-to-block correspondence on the body span: Section 372 at index 373861, Section 373 at 375228, Section 374 at 376549: rather than by proximity. The footnote block reads:
- Subs. by Act 18 of 1924, s. 2, for certain words.
- Ins. by Act 18 of 1924, s. 3
- Subs. by s. 2, ibid., for certain words.
- Ins. by s. 4, ibid.
Markers 2 and 3 fall in Section 372; markers 4 and 5 in Section 373. So both the age wording and the Explanation in Section 372 are Act 18 of 1924 material S3. The string "Act 18 of 1924" occurs exactly twice in the whole IPC text S3.
One limit we will not cross. The footnotes say only "for certain words". What the 1924 Act replaced is not recorded in the text we examined. It is tempting to infer that the body originally said "minor", which would explain the heading, but that is an inference, not a record, and we do not make it.
The Sanhita did NOT touch the purpose limb, and that is the most consequential thing about this section
Section 98 still requires that the sale be "for the purpose of prostitution or illicit intercourse with any person or for any unlawful and immoral purpose" S1.
We checked whether the Sanhita added anything to cover a sale for money with no such purpose. It did not. The phrases that would be needed are absent from the whole Code; only four sections of the Sanhita use the word "consideration" at all, and none concerns selling a person. The nearest provision is Section 145, "Habitual dealing in slaves", which requires habitual dealing S1.
There is also no Section 373A in the Indian Penal Code S3, which matters, as the next part explains.
(B) Judicial and practical context
Because the operative words are substantively unchanged, the construction of IPC Section 372 applies to Section 98.
The section punishes the transaction, not the exploitation
This is the single most important practical point, and a High Court has recently had to correct a trial court on it.
Sobhana @ Sandhya v. State of Kerala, Kerala High Court, 19 December 2025, 2025:KER:98740 S7.
The appellant had been convicted under Sections 366A and 372 and sentenced under Section 372 to eight years' rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 2,00,000. The trial court had convicted "after finding that the appellant was responsible for exploitation of the victim who was used for prostitution."
The High Court held that was an error:
the trial court erred in failing to note the object of section 372 IPC. The said provision makes the act of selling, letting on hire or otherwise disposing of any person … the offence.
Evidence that "the dress and gold of the victim were given by those who made money using her" was "not sufficient to attract the offence." And:
In the absence of any evidence adduced by the prosecution to prove sale or otherwise disposal of or letting on hire of the minor, the finding of guilt of the accused under section 372 IPC is without any basis and cannot be sustained.
The Section 372 conviction was set aside. The Section 366A conviction was affirmed. On the same facts, procuring was proved and selling was not S7.
The same point, independently, from Patna
Ramu Rai v. The State of Bihar, Patna High Court, 21 July 2017, Cr. App (SJ) No. 473 of 2013 S6.
Four appellants had been convicted under Sections 363/34 and 372/34: seven years' rigorous imprisonment and a Rs. 10,000 fine each under Section 372/34. The Court held:
It appears from perusal of Section 372 IPC that such offence may be completed on proof of sale, lets to hire or disposes of any person and the ingredients of the said Section do not appear in the case under the given facts…
And on the evidence: "there is nothing available in her evidence about sale or with whom they were talking to sell her and what consideration and even no transfer was made."
The Section 372 conviction was set aside; the Section 363 conviction was affirmed, and one appellant's Section 376 conviction remained intact. The appeals were partly allowed S6.
Timing: the intention is judged at the moment of sale
Madhu Bala v. State of Punjab, Punjab and Haryana High Court, 29 April 2014, CRA-S-3361-SB-2011, R.P. Nagrath J. S5.
The facts are stark. The appellant kept the newly born baby of an unmarried girl for more than three weeks. A police officer posing as a buyer approached her; she first demanded Rs. 1 lakh and the deal was settled at Rs. 80,000. She was tried under Sections 317 and 372, acquitted under Section 317 and convicted under Section 372 with seven years' rigorous imprisonment.
The Court stated the timing rule:
the crucial point of time for determining culpability of a person under Section 372 IPC is the one when sale takes place. It is at that point of time that the intention of the accused who sells the minor has to be taken into account.
And then came to the purpose limb. Disposing of a newly born male child was "apparently not for the purposes of prostitution or illicit intercourse", and the Court agreed with the Kerala High Court in Prema v. State of Kerala, 2013 (4) KLJ 252 that "sale of a newly born child can be unethical or illegal but was not for unlawful and immoral purposes."
It reinforced that with the oldest authority in this article, Empress of India v. Sri Lal and others, (1880) ILR 2 All 694, where girls were falsely represented as being of higher castes so that men would pay money to take them as wives. There it was held that the accused's real object was to get money, and:
The mischief aimed at by Sections 372 and 373 IPC was traffic in female minors for purposes of "prostitution" that is, in its perfectly well-understood sense, "or for any unlawful and immoral purpose" of a like description.
The appeal was allowed, the conviction set aside, and the appellant acquitted and ordered to be set at liberty forthwith S5.
The Court did not pretend to be comfortable with that. It recorded that it was "quite painful" that the mother of the baby could not be located, and that the appellant might have been prosecuted for conniving in abandoning the child: "But that was not the charge against the appellant." S5
What the Law Commission of India said about exactly this
Madhu Bala did not stop at acquitting. It set out an official recommendation, and that recommendation goes to the heart of what Section 98 does and does not do S5.
The Court recorded that the Law Commission of India took up the subject suo motu, because of the absence of any penal provision, and in its 146th report, on "Sale of Women and Children", recommended amending the Penal Code. The Commission's finding, as the Court set it out:
… the present legal position is seriously deficient in one important respect. It does not take care of the cases where a sale simpliciter of a person takes place, where there is no object of using the person sold for a purpose not specified in Sections 372-373 of the Indian Penal Code.
The lacuna existing in the present law, therefore, needs to be removed.
The Commission proposed a new Section 373-A, "Selling woman or minor, etc.", covering whoever, "in a case not falling under section 372 or Section 373", sells or buys for consideration any person under eighteen or any woman of any age, with a seven-year maximum, and an Explanation excluding the hiring of services S5.
The Court also recorded that in Prema's case the Kerala High Court had sent a copy of its judgment to the Secretary, Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment, Union of India, for steps on those recommendations, "but nothing is shown if any positive steps were initiated in that regard", and that the recommendations "deserve immediate attention by all stakeholders" S5.
The limits on this material must be stated clearly. The Law Commission's 146th report has not been retrieved by this project. Everything above about it is as the Punjab and Haryana High Court set it out, not as read in the report. The same applies to Prema v. State of Kerala, 2013 (4) KLJ 252, and to Empress of India v. Sri Lal, (1880) ILR 2 All 694: neither was retrieved S5.
The sale-simpliciter gap, traced across 144 years
Putting the retrieved material in order, the same point recurs:
| Source | What it says |
|---|---|
| Empress of India v. Sri Lal (1880), as quoted in Madhu Bala | the mischief is traffic for prostitution "or for any unlawful and immoral purpose" of a like description |
| Law Commission, 146th report, as quoted in Madhu Bala | the law "does not take care of" a sale simpliciter; the lacuna "needs to be removed"; proposed s. 373-A |
| Prema v. State of Kerala (2013), as quoted in Madhu Bala | sale of a newborn can be "unethical or illegal" but not for unlawful and immoral purposes |
| Madhu Bala (2014) | acquittal on a settled Rs. 80,000 sale of a newborn |
| Mrs. Ashalatha Y.K. v. State of Kerala (2024), discussed in our Section 93 article | "a mere sale of an infant by a parent for value would not fall as an exploitation of the child under Section 370" |
| BNS Sections 98 and 99 (2023, in force 2024) | purpose limb unchanged; no sale-simpliciter offence anywhere in the Code S1S3 |
A fourth identifier for one judgment
The Section 372 searches surfaced a document of 108,778 characters dated 27 August 2020: within the same length cluster as three records found while researching Section 96. Compared body against body, the similarity ratios were 0.9998, 0.9999 and 0.9999, with material differences only in the cause titles. This is a fourth document identifier for the same Karnataka High Court judgment. It was counted as the same judgment, and none of its content is relied on here S8.
(C) Editorial analysis: clearly labelled as ours
Everything in this part is our own reading. No source is offered beyond the texts already cited.
The "minor" to "child" change looks cosmetic and is not. It removes an internal contradiction that sat inside Section 372 for a century: a heading saying "minor" above a body saying "person under the age of eighteen years", in a Code with no definition of "minor". Anyone who read the heading alone got the law wrong. The Sanhita's single defined term closes that off. This is the sort of repair that no table of punishments will register.
But the Sanhita left the substantive gap exactly where it found it, and it was told about the gap. The Law Commission said in terms that a sale simpliciter was not covered and that the lacuna "needs to be removed". It drafted the provision. A High Court forwarded a judgment to a Union Ministry about it. Another High Court said it deserved "immediate attention". And then a complete recodification of the criminal law went through: renumbering these very sections, changing "minor" to "child" in both of them, and raising the punishment in Section 99 from ten years to a seven-to-fourteen-year range, without enacting anything for sale simpliciter. We make no claim about why. We say only that the omission cannot be explained by nobody having raised it.
The practical consequence is concrete, and it follows from the retrieved cases rather than from speculation. On Madhu Bala, a person who sells a newborn for Rs. 80,000 commits no offence under this section unless a proscribed purpose is proved, because the money motive is not itself an "unlawful and immoral purpose" of the kind the section aims at. On Sobhana, a person who profits from a child's exploitation commits no offence under this section either, unless a sale, hiring or disposal is proved. Those two holdings between them describe a fairly wide space in which neither limb is made out.
Explanation 1 is the part of this section that still does serious work, and its limits are worth seeing. The presumption applies only where a female under eighteen is disposed of to a prostitute or to a person who keeps or manages a brothel. Outside that specific pairing there is no presumption, and the prosecution must prove intent or knowledge in the ordinary way. Note also that this Explanation remains gendered ("a female", "her", "she") in a section whose operative words were deliberately made gender-neutral. The Sanhita changed "person under eighteen" to "child" in the body and left "a female under the age of eighteen years" standing in the Explanation. We offer no view on whether that was deliberate.
"At any age" is a quietly powerful phrase that survived unchanged. It means the prosecution need not show that exploitation was intended to begin soon, or at all within childhood. A sale of an infant with a view to use in adulthood is within the words. Against the narrowing effect of the purpose limb, this is the section's one genuinely wide feature, and it has been there since 1860.
What we checked, and what we could not
Checked and verified. The text and title of Section 98, including both Explanations, against this project's verified inventory and, fragment by fragment, against the Gazette S1S2. The word-level comparison with IPC Section 372 S3. The heading-versus-body mismatch inside IPC Section 372 S3. Amendment provenance by marker-to-block correspondence on body-resolved indices S3. That the IPC has no Section 373A S3. That the Sanhita contains no sale-simpliciter offence, by searching the whole Code for the needed phrases and counting every section using "consideration" S1. The punishment asymmetry with Section 99 S1. Commencement S4. Three judgments read in full S5S6S7. A four-way de-duplication check S8. The absence of any BNSS cross-reference, by whole-number test S9.
Not checked, and material. The Law Commission of India's 146th report: NOT retrieved. Everything attributed to it here is as the Punjab and Haryana High Court set it out, and that is said each time. Prema v. State of Kerala, 2013 (4) KLJ 252: not retrieved. Empress of India v. Sri Lal and others, (1880) ILR 2 All 694: not retrieved. The Madhya Pradesh High Court proposition about purchasers of newborns which Madhu Bala discusses (the source decision is not named in the text we read, and we therefore do not cite it. Act 18 of 1924) not retrieved; its short title remains unverified, and what it replaced in 1924 is not recorded. Whether the offence is cognizable or bailable. The BNSS First Schedule has not been examined S9. The Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act, 1956 and the POCSO Act, both named in the retrieved judgments, not retrieved. Any judicial construction of Section 98 itself; searches returned at the repository's ten-item display limit, so the field was not exhausted.
How this article was prepared
This article was prepared by comparing the official text of BNS Section 98 with the official text of IPC Section 372 word by word, verifying the Sanhita text against the Gazette fragment by fragment, establishing amendment provenance by marker-to-block correspondence on body-resolved indices rather than by proximity, searching the whole Sanhita to test whether a sale-simpliciter offence exists, and reading in full every judgment relied on.
Official recommendations quoted by a court are reported as what that court set out, because the report itself was not retrieved, and the article repeats that qualification wherever the recommendation is used, rather than stating it once and relying on the reader to remember.
Where a footnote records only that "certain words" were replaced, the article says what is not known instead of inferring what the earlier words were.
Where search results clustered in length, the bodies were compared before anything was counted.
Documented material, judicial material and our own analysis are kept separate and labelled. Where we do not know something, the article says so instead of filling the gap.
This article was prepared with AI assistance. No lawyer has reviewed this article and no human legal review is claimed. Its status is "ready for human review": ready to be checked by a person, not already checked.
This article does not reproduce or alter any existing content on this website.
Law checked as of the date recorded in this article's metadata. Statutes and case law change, and this article is not legal advice. Whether the ingredients of this section are made out in any given case, whether any statutory exception or defence applies, and what sentence may follow, are matters only a court can determine on the evidence before it, and no outcome in any case is guaranteed. Verify the current position and take advice from a qualified advocate before acting.