Statutory Text and Companion Relationship with Section 236 BNS
Section 237 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) (replacing Section 200 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC)) completes the pair of provisions governing evidentiary declarations S1; S3 (Sections 236, 237; Sections 199, 200). While Section 236 BNS punishes the declarant who makes or subscribes a materially false declaration, Section 237 BNS punishes any person who corruptly uses or attempts to use such a declaration as true:
"Whoever corruptly uses or attempts to use as true any such declaration, knowing the same to be false in any material point, shall be punished in the same manner as if he gave false evidence. Explanation.—A declaration which is inadmissible merely upon the ground of some informality, is a declaration within the meaning of section 234 and this section." S1 (Section 237)
Essential Ingredients of Section 237 BNS
To sustain a charge under Section 237 BNS, four cumulative elements must be established S1; S5 (Sections 236, 237):
- Subject Matter, "Any Such Declaration": The words "any such declaration" refer to a declaration of the kind described in Section 236 BNS, namely, a declaration which any Court, public servant, or other person is bound or authorised by law to receive as evidence of any fact S1; S6 (Sections 236, 237).
- Falsity in a Material Point: The declaration must be false in a point that is material to the object for which the declaration was made or used S1; S5 (Section 237). As held in Jotish Chandra Chaudhary v. State of Bihar, AIR 1969 SC 7, if the alleged inaccuracy in the declaration is not material to the legal object of the declaration, a conviction under Section 200 IPC (now Section 237 BNS) cannot stand S5.
- Conduct: Uses or Attempts to Use as True: The accused (who may be a third-party litigant tendering someone else's affidavit, or the declarant themselves tendering their previously signed declaration) must use or attempt to use the declaration as true S1 (Section 237).
- Mens Rea: "Corruptly" + "Knowing the Same to Be False":
- Whereas the maker under Section 236 is liable if they "know or believe" the statement to be false or "do not believe it to be true", the user under Section 237 is liable only if they act corruptly and knowing the declaration to be false in a material point S1; S5 (Sections 236, 237).
The Statutory Explanation: Effect of Procedural Informality and the "Section 234" Drafting Cross-Reference
The Explanation to Section 237 BNS addresses a classic technical defence: what if a litigant files a false affidavit in Court, and when caught, argues that the notary's stamp had expired, or the verification clause omitted the place of signing, rendering the affidavit technically defective under procedural rules?
- Substantive Rule of the Explanation: The Explanation forecloses that escape route by declaring that "A declaration which is inadmissible merely upon the ground of some informality, is a declaration within the meaning of... this section" S1 (Section 237, Explanation). Note, however, the distinction between a mere informality (such as an irregular verification format or defective stamp) and a complete lack of legal authority (where the oath was administered by an officer having no jurisdiction whatsoever or where the law does not authorise receiving a declaration as evidence at all): the Explanation cures only formal defects ("some informality"), not a total absence of statutory authority S1 (Sections 236, 237).
- Critical Textual Observation on the Cross-Reference to "Section 234":
- In the IPC, the Explanation to Section 200 read: "is a declaration within the meaning of sections 199 and 200" (since Section 199 defined false declarations and Section 200 punished their use) S3 (Section 200).
- In the enacted BNS, the Explanation to Section 237 prints: "is a declaration within the meaning of section 234 and this section" S1 (Section 237, Explanation). Because Section 234 BNS deals with certificates (formerly IPC 197) while Section 236 BNS deals with declarations (formerly IPC 199), the reference to "section 234" in the Explanation to Section 237 BNS (like the reference to "sections 236 and 237" in the Explanation to Section 240 BNS) reflects an unadjusted numerical offset during bill drafting S1; S3 (Sections 234, 236, 237, 240; Sections 199, 200, 203). Practitioners must cite the exact enacted wording while pointing out its legislative history derived from IPC Section 200 S1; S3.
Punishment and Procedural Classification
- Derivative Punishment: Punished "in the same manner as if he gave false evidence": importing Section 229(1) BNS (up to 7 years imprisonment and fine up to ₹10,000 when used/attempted to be used in a stage of a judicial proceeding) or Section 229(2) BNS (up to 3 years imprisonment and fine up to ₹5,000 in any other case) S1 (Sections 229, 237).
- BNSS First Schedule Classification: Non-cognizable, Bailable, and Triable by the Court by which the offence of giving false evidence is triable S4 (First Schedule, Entry 237).
- Mandatory Court-Complaint Gate (BNSS Section 215(1)(b)(i)): Section 237 BNS is expressly enumerated in Section 215(1)(b)(i) BNSS S4 (Section 215(1)(b)(i)). When the offence is committed in or in relation to any proceeding in any Court, cognizance is barred except on the written complaint of that Court (or an authorised officer or superior Court) under Section 379 BNSS S4 (Sections 215, 379).