Statutory Text and Relationship with Section 234 BNS
Section 235 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) (replacing Section 198 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC)) is the companion provision to Section 234 BNS S1; S3 (Sections 234, 235; Section 198). Whereas Section 234 punishes the issuer or signer of a false statutory or legally admissible certificate, Section 235 punishes the corrupt user who tenders or attempts to use that certificate as true:
"Whoever corruptly uses or attempts to use any such certificate as a true certificate, knowing the same to be false in any material point, shall be punished in the same manner as if he gave false evidence." S1 (Section 235)
Breakdown of Essential Ingredients
To convict an accused under Section 235 BNS, the prosecution must prove four cumulative elements S1 (Sections 234, 235):
- The Certificate Must Be "Any Such Certificate" (Incorporating Section 234's Threshold): The words "any such certificate" refer directly back to Section 234 BNS S1 (Sections 234, 235). Therefore, the certificate used or attempted to be used must be one that is either:
- Required by law to be given or signed; or
- Relating to any fact of which such certificate is by law admissible in evidence S1 (Section 234).
- If the document is not a qualifying statutory/admissible certificate under Section 234, using it does not attract Section 235 BNS (though it may attract Section 233 BNS if it is fabricated evidence, or Section 340(2) BNS if it is a forged document) S1 (Sections 233–235, 340(2)).
- Falsity in a Material Point: The certificate must be objectively false in a point material to the purpose for which the law requires it or makes it admissible S1 (Section 235). Note that the certificate need not be a forgery (i.e., it may bear the genuine signature of a corrupt or misled official under Section 234, yet contain a materially false certification of fact) S1; S5 (Sections 234, 235).
- Conduct, Uses or Attempts to Use as a True Certificate: The accused must put the certificate into use, or attempt to use it, as a genuine, truthful certificate (for instance, submitting a materially false statutory birth, income, or medical cause-of-death certificate before a court, tribunal, or public authority) S1 (Section 235). Even if the authority detects the falsity immediately upon submission and refuses to act on it, the attempt to use is complete under Section 235 BNS S1 (Section 235).
- Stricter Mens Rea than Section 234 ("Corruptly" + "Knowing" It to Be False):
- Compare the mental element of the issuer in Section 234 ("knowing or believing that such certificate is false") with the mental element of the user in Section 235 ("corruptly uses... knowing the same to be false") S1 (Sections 234, 235).
- Under Section 235 BNS, the prosecution must prove both actual knowledge (not mere belief or suspicion) that the certificate is false in a material point, and corrupt purpose (an intention to procure an improper advantage or pervert the course of justice or official administration) S1; S5 (Section 235).
Comparison Table: Section 234 vs. Section 235 vs. Section 340(2) BNS
| Provision | Target Actor & Object | Required Mens Rea | Is Forgery of Signature Required? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Section 234 BNS (IPC 197) | Issuer / Signer of a statutory or legally admissible certificate S1 (Section 234) | Knowing or believing it is false in a material point S1 (Section 234) | No: applies where the authorised person genuinely signs a certificate containing a material falsehood S1 (Section 234). |
| Section 235 BNS (IPC 198) | User / Attempted User of a certificate covered by Section 234 S1 (Section 235) | Corruptly using, knowing it is false in a material point S1 (Section 235) | No: applies to using a genuinely signed certificate that certifies a false material fact S1 (Section 235). |
| Section 340(2) BNS (IPC 471) | User of any forged document or electronic record S1; S5 | Fraudulently or dishonestly, knowing or having reason to believe it is a forged document S1; S5 | Yes: requires the document to be a "false document" (forgery of authorship/execution) under Section 335 BNS S5. |
Punishment Matrix and Procedural Classification
- Punishment ("In the Same Manner as if He Gave False Evidence"): Incorporates Section 229 BNS (and Sections 230–231 where applicable) S1 (Sections 229, 235):
- If used or attempted to be used in any stage of a judicial proceeding: imprisonment of either description up to 7 years and fine up to ₹10,000 under Section 229(1) BNS S1 (Sections 229(1), 235).
- If used or attempted to be used in any other case (e.g., before an administrative or licensing authority): imprisonment of either description up to 3 years and fine up to ₹5,000 under Section 229(2) BNS S1 (Sections 229(2), 235).
- BNSS First Schedule Classification: Non-cognizable, Bailable, and Triable by the Court by which the offence of giving false evidence is triable S4 (First Schedule, Entry 235).
- Exclusion from the BNSS Section 215(1)(b)(i) Complaint Bar: Just like Section 234 BNS, Section 235 BNS is omitted from Section 215(1)(b)(i) BNSS (which skips from Section 233 to Section 236) S4 (Section 215(1)(b)(i)). Accordingly, a prosecution under Section 235 BNS does not require a prerequisite complaint from a Court under Section 379 BNSS when the false certificate is used before an administrative department or even where a standalone Section 235 complaint is instituted S4 (Sections 215, 379).