Statutory Text and Place in the False-Information Triad
Section 240 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) (replacing Section 203 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC)) criminalises giving false information respecting an offence that has been committed S1; S3 (Section 240; Section 203):
"Whoever, knowing or having reason to believe that an offence has been committed, gives any information respecting that offence which he knows or believes to be false, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to two years, or with fine, or with both. Explanation.—In sections 236 and 237 and in this section the word 'offence' includes any act committed at any place out of India, which, if committed in India, would be punishable under any of the following sections, namely, 97, 99, 172, 173, 174, 175, 301, 304, 305, 306, 320, 325 and 326." S1 (Section 240)
Essential Ingredients of Section 240 BNS
To establish an offence under Section 240 BNS, four elements must be proved S1 (Section 240):
- An Offence Has Actually Been Committed: Just as under Sections 238 and 239 BNS, a predicate offence must in fact have been committed (either in India, or outside India if covered by the Explanation or Section 1(4)–(5) BNS) S1; S5 (Sections 238–240). If no offence was actually committed, giving a false rumour of a non-existent crime does not fall under Section 240 BNS (though it may attract Section 217 BNS if given to a public servant to cause them to use lawful power to someone's injury or annoyance, or Section 248 BNS if it is a false criminal charge against a specific person) S1 (Sections 217, 240, 248).
- Knowledge or Reason to Believe: The accused must know or have reason to believe (Section 2(29) BNS) that the predicate offence has been committed S1 (Sections 2(29), 240).
- Giving Information Respecting That Offence (Voluntary or Otherwise): Unlike Section 212 BNS (which requires the informant to be "legally bound to furnish information"), Section 240 BNS applies to "Whoever... gives any information": meaning it applies even when the informant volunteered the statement without any legal obligation to speak S1 (Sections 212, 240).
- Knowledge or Belief of Falsity: The accused must know or believe the information they give to be false S1 (Section 240).
How Section 240 BNS Differs from Sections 212, 217, 238, and 248 BNS
Because five different BNS provisions address false information regarding offences, practitioners rely on the following comparative matrix to identify the exact charge S1 (Sections 212, 217, 238, 240, 248):
| BNS Section (IPC Counterpart) | Is a Legal Duty to Inform Required? | Must a Predicate Offence Actually Have Occurred? | Required Ulterior Intent | Maximum Punishment |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Section 212 BNS (IPC 177) | Yes: must be legally bound to furnish information to a public servant S1 (Section 212) | Not under 1st limb; 2nd limb relates to commission/prevention of an offence S1 (Section 212) | None beyond knowing/having reason to believe information is false S1 (Section 212) | Up to 6 months / ₹5,000 fine (1st limb); up to 2 years or fine or both (2nd limb) S1 (Section 212) |
| Section 217 BNS (IPC 182) | No: applies to volunteering false information to a public servant S1 (Section 217) | No: often involves a completely fabricated complaint S1 (Section 217) | Intent/knowledge of likelihood to cause public servant to do/omit an official act or injure/annoy any person S1 (Section 217) | Up to 1 year, or fine up to ₹10,000, or both S1 (Section 217) |
| Section 238 BNS (IPC 201) | No S1 (Section 238) | Yes: predicate offence must be proved S1; S5 (Section 238) | Specific intent to screen the offender from legal punishment S1; S5 (Section 238) | Up to 7 years (capital), 3 years (life/10 yrs), or 1/4th term (<10 yrs) S1 (Section 238) |
| Section 240 BNS (IPC 203) | No: applies to any person giving false information S1 (Section 240) | Yes: predicate offence must be proved S1 (Section 240) | No screening intent required (general false information respecting an offence committed) S1; S5 (Section 240) | Up to 2 years, or fine, or both S1 (Section 240) |
| Section 248 BNS (IPC 211) | No S1 (Section 248) | No: punishes falsely charging an innocent person S1 (Section 248) | With intent to cause injury to any person, knowing there is no just/lawful ground S1 (Section 248) | Up to 5 years / ₹2 lakh fine (248(a)), or up to 10 years + fine (248(b)) S1 (Section 248) |
Critical Analysis of the Statutory Explanation to Section 240 BNS
The Explanation to Section 240 BNS warrants close textual attention by advocates and courts because of two legislative drafting features when compared against the Explanation to IPC Section 203 S1; S3 (Section 240; Section 203):
- Opening Cross-Reference ("In sections 236 and 237 and in this section"):
- In the IPC, the Explanation to Section 203 read: "In sections 201 and 202 and in this section the word 'offence' includes..." S3 (Section 203).
- In the BNS, IPC Sections 201, 202, and 203 became BNS Sections 238, 239, and 240; however, the enacted Explanation to Section 240 BNS prints "In sections 236 and 237 and in this section the word 'offence' includes..." (mirrors of the same two-section numerical offset also appear in the Explanation to Section 237 BNS and identical extraterritorial list in the Explanation to Section 249 BNS) S1; S3 (Sections 236–240, 249; Sections 200–203, 212).
- Enumerated Extraterritorial Sections:
- In the IPC, the Explanation listed IPC Sections
302, 304, 382, 392, 393, 394, 395, 396, 397, 398, 399, 402, 435, 436, 449, 450, 457, 458, 459 and 460(covering murder, culpable homicide, theft with preparation for hurt, robbery, dacoity, arson, and aggravated house-trespass) S3 (Section 203). - In BNS Section 240 (and identically in BNS Section 249), the Explanation enumerates BNS Sections
97, 99, 172, 173, 174, 175, 301, 304, 305, 306, 320, 325 and 326S1 (Sections 240, 249). Practitioners should verify the exact statutory text of these enumerated numbers when an extraterritorial predicate act committed by a non-citizen outside India is in issue (noting that for Indian citizens or Indian ships/aircraft/computer targets, Section 1(4)–(5) BNS already deems any BNS offence committed outside India to be punishable under the BNS) S1 (Sections 1(4)–(5), 240).
- In the IPC, the Explanation listed IPC Sections