Statutory Text and Three-Tier Structure
Section 238 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) (replacing the heavily litigated Section 201 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC)) criminalises causing the disappearance of evidence of an offence or giving false information to screen an offender from legal punishment S1; S3 (Section 238; Section 201). Section 238 BNS organises the three sentencing tiers into lettered clauses (a), (b), and (c):
"Whoever, knowing or having reason to believe that an offence has been committed, causes any evidence of the commission of that offence to disappear, with the intention of screening the offender from legal punishment, or with that intention gives any information respecting the offence which he knows or believes to be false shall,— (a) if the offence which he knows or believes to have been committed is punishable with death, be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to seven years, and shall also be liable to fine; (b) if the offence is punishable with imprisonment for life, or with imprisonment which may extend to ten years, be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to three years, and shall also be liable to fine; (c) if the offence is punishable with imprisonment for any term not extending to ten years, be punished with imprisonment of the description provided for the offence, for a term which may extend to one-fourth part of the longest term of the imprisonment provided for the offence, or with fine, or with both. Illustration. A, knowing that B has murdered Z, assists B to hide the body with the intention of screening B from punishment. A is liable to imprisonment of either description for seven years, and also to fine." S1 (Section 238)
The Four Classic Ingredients (Palvinder Kaur & Sukhram)
In Palvinder Kaur v. State of Punjab, AIR 1952 SC 354, V.L. Tresa v. State of Kerala, (2001) 3 SCC 549, and Sukhram v. State of Maharashtra, (2007) 7 SCC 502, the Supreme Court settled the four indispensable ingredients that the prosecution must establish beyond reasonable doubt under IPC Section 201 (now BNS Section 238) S5; S6; S7:
- Actual Commission of a Predicate Offence: The prosecution must first prove that an "offence" (defined in Section 2(24) BNS) has actually been committed S1; S5 (Sections 2(24), 238).
- If Death Was Accidental or Suicidal, Section 238 Fails: As held in Palvinder Kaur, if the prosecution fails to prove that the deceased died as a result of a criminal offence (for instance, where the evidence is consistent with accidental poisoning or suicide), disposing of the dead body out of panic or fear of false implication cannot sustain a conviction under Section 238 BNS because no predicate offence was proved to have been committed S5.
- Can the Principal Offender Also Be Convicted Under Section 238 BNS?: Yes. Both the principal offender (who commits the murder and then burns or buries the corpse to cover their tracks) and a third-party accessory after the fact can be charged and convicted under Section 238 BNS S1; S7 (Section 238). Moreover, as held in V.L. Tresa v. State of Kerala, (2001) 3 SCC 549, even if an accused is acquitted of the principal murder charge due to insufficient proof of who struck the fatal blow, they can still be convicted under Section 238 BNS if it is proved that a homicidal murder occurred and the accused knowingly caused the evidence to disappear to screen the offender S7 (Paras 11–14).
- Knowledge or Reason to Believe: The accused must know or have reason to believe (defined in Section 2(29) BNS as having sufficient cause to believe that thing and not otherwise) that the predicate offence has been committed S1; S6 (Sections 2(29), 238).
- Two Alternative Modes of Conduct:
- Limb 1: Causing any evidence of the commission of that offence to disappear (e.g., disposing of a corpse, washing bloodstains from a weapon, formatting a CCTV DVR hard drive, or burning blood-soaked clothes) S1 (Section 238); OR
- Limb 2: Giving any information respecting the offence which the accused knows or believes to be false (e.g., lodging a false accidental-death report with police to mislead investigators away from a homicide) S1 (Section 238).
- Specific Ulterior Mens Rea ("With the Intention of Screening the Offender from Legal Punishment"): The disappearance of evidence or giving of false information must be animated by the specific intention to shield the offender from legal punishment S1; S6 (Section 238). If a person moves a weapon solely to prevent a child from getting hurt, or cleans a floor without knowing a crime occurred, Section 238 BNS is not attracted S1; S6 (Section 238).
Graded Punishment & BNSS First Schedule Classification Matrix
| Clause of Section 238 BNS | Gravity of Predicate Offence | Maximum Punishment under Section 238 BNS | Cognizability (BNSS First Schedule) | Bailability & Trial Court (BNSS First Schedule) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Section 238(a) | Offence punishable with death S1 (Section 238(a)) | Imprisonment of either description up to 7 years, and fine S1 (Section 238(a)) | According as the predicate offence is cognizable or non-cognizable S4 | Bailable; Triable by Court of Session S4 |
| Section 238(b) | Offence punishable with imprisonment for life, or imprisonment up to 10 years S1 (Section 238(b)) | Imprisonment of either description up to 3 years, and fine S1 (Section 238(b)) | Non-cognizable S4 | Bailable; Triable by Magistrate of the first class S4 |
| Section 238(c) | Offence punishable with imprisonment for any term not extending to 10 years S1 (Section 238(c)) | Imprisonment of the description provided for the offence up to 1/4th of the longest term, or fine, or both S1 (Section 238(c)) | Non-cognizable S4 | Bailable; Triable by Court by which the offence is triable S4 |
Procedural Nuances and Extraterritorial Cross-Reference Note
- Why Police Can Investigate Section 238(b)/(c) Alongside a Murder or Robbery FIR: Although the BNSS First Schedule classifies standalone offences under Section 238(b) and 238(c) as Non-cognizable, under Section 174(4) BNSS (formerly Section 155(4) CrPC), where a case relates to two or more offences of which at least one is cognizable (such as murder under Section 103 BNS or robbery under Section 309 BNS), the entire case is deemed to be a cognizable case S4. Moreover, all three clauses of Section 238 BNS are Bailable in the First Schedule, and Section 238 is not subject to the court-complaint bar in Section 215(1)(b)(i) BNSS S4.
- Note on the Explanation to Section 240 BNS: Under the IPC, the Explanation to Section 203 defined "offence" to include certain extraterritorial acts for "sections 201 and 202 and in this section" S3 (Section 203). In the enacted BNS, the Explanation to Section 240 prints "In sections 236 and 237 and in this section" instead of "sections 238 and 239": a legislative drafting cross-reference note that practitioners should bear in mind alongside general extraterritorial jurisdiction under Section 1(4)–(5) BNS S1; S3 (Sections 1(4)–(5), 238, 240; Section 203).