IPC2BNSConverter

BNS Section 102 · Deep dive

BNS Section 102: Transferred Malice, Reproduced Word for Word - and a Bail Argument That Mis-Read It

BNS Section 102 is the Sanhita's transferred-malice provision. Where a person, intending or knowing himself likely to cause death, kills SOMEONE ELSE - a person whose death he neither intended nor knew himself likely to cause - the culpable homicide 'is of the description of which it would have been' had he killed his intended victim. Against IPC Section 301 the word-level comparison returns ZERO DIFFERENCES: identical titles, and the operative sentence reproduced word for word and punctuation for punctuation. The IPC text carried no amendment markers, so these words have stood since 1860. One point is easy to get wrong, and a reported bail argument got it wrong: Section 102 creates NO offence and carries NO punishment - we tested that five ways. It is an ATTRIBUTION rule. It tells you which description of homicide applies; the sentence then comes from Section 103 or Section 105.

By the Nyaya Yantra Editorial TeamLaw checked as of 10 October 2026 17 min read

Prepared with AI-assisted research from the official sources listed at the end of this article.

At a glance

Provision
BNS Section 102 — Culpable homicide by causing death of person other than person whose death was intended
Earlier law (IPC)
Section 301 — Culpable homicide by causing death of person other than person whose death was intended · substantively unchanged
Side-by-side converterIPC 301 → BNS 102

What Section 102 says

Section 102 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 is titled "Culpable homicide by causing death of person other than person whose death was intended." It is one unbroken sentence S1:

If a person, by doing anything which he intends or knows to be likely to cause death, commits culpable homicide by causing the death of any person, whose death he neither intends nor knows himself to be likely to cause, the culpable homicide committed by the offender is of the description of which it would have been if he had caused the death of the person whose death he intended or knew himself to be likely to cause.

No sub-sections, no proviso, no Exception, no Explanation, no Illustration. Four hundred and twenty-one characters, and that is the entire section S1.

What it actually does, and what it does not do

This is the provision commonly called transferred malice, though that phrase appears nowhere in the statute.

A aims at Z and kills Y. Y's death A neither intended nor knew himself likely to cause. Section 102 says the culpable homicide A committed is of the description it would have been had he killed Z. A's liability is determined by what he meant to do, not by whose body received the blow.

But Section 102 does not create an offence, and it carries no punishment. We tested that five separate ways: the words "shall be punished", "punished", "imprisonment", "fine" and "punishable" are all absent from the section S1.

It is an attribution rule. It answers one question, which description of homicide is this?, and then hands over. If the answer is murder, the sentence comes from Section 103. If it is culpable homicide not amounting to murder, the sentence comes from Section 105 S1.

That distinction is not pedantic. As the case law section below shows, a reported bail argument turned on getting it wrong.

Section 102 came into force on 1 July 2024 S4, and appears in neither list in Section 2(24) S1.

(A) What the documented record shows about the change

Zero differences

Section 102 corresponds to Section 301 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860.

The titles are identical. The word-level comparison of the operative texts returns zero differences S3. Word for word, punctuation for punctuation, the provision is reproduced exactly.

This is the cleanest result in this group of articles. At Section 100 we found one added full stop; at Section 101, twenty-one layout and punctuation differences. Here there is nothing at all.

The section was never amended

The India Code slice for IPC Section 301 carries no amendment footnote markers S3. On the text examined, these words stood as enacted in 1860 and were carried into the Sanhita untouched: 164 years without a comma moving.

The slice measured 515 characters against the Sanhita's 421, the difference being the section title and heading matter, and fell within the band we asserted before reading the result S3.

A false alarm in our own testing, and how it resolved

When we checked the Sanhita text against the Gazette, the longer fragments came back False. On a less careful reading that would look like a discrepancy between the official Gazette and the India Code text.

It was not. The Gazette prints this section with its marginal note interleaved word by word through the running text. Read as a flat string, the Gazette says S2:

  1. If a person, by doing anything which he intends or knows to be likely to cause homicide by death, commits culpable homicide by causing the death of any person, whose death he causing death of person other neither intends nor knows himself to be likely to cause, the culpable homicide committed by than person the offender is of the description of which it would have been if he had caused the death of whose death the person whose death he intended or knew himself to be likely to cause. was intended.

The bold words are the marginal note "Culpable homicide by causing death of person other than person whose death was intended", the section's own title, dropping into the sentence a few words at a time, because the Gazette sets it in a narrow column beside the text.

Resolved in halves, every fragment is confirmed present and there is no discrepancy S2. We report the episode because a reader checking our work would otherwise hit the same False and have to work out why.

Cross-references

The BNSS makes no reference to Section 102 of the Sanhita, tested with a whole-number search so the digits could not match inside a longer number S7.

(B) Judicial and practical context

What we have not surveyed

The case law on IPC Section 301 has not been surveyed by this project, and nothing here is a summary of it. Transferred malice has been litigated in India for well over a century, and that authority applies to Section 102 unchanged, because the words are unchanged.

What we searched, and how carefully

Four queries were run S6:

  • the exact phrase "Section 102 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita": exhausted, returning a single document;
  • that phrase together with "culpable homicide": genuine nil;
  • the abbreviated form with "transferred malice": genuine nil;
  • "Section 301 IPC" with "Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita" and "transferred malice": genuine nil.

In each nil the repository returned its own no-results marker with zero result entries, so each query was exhausted rather than truncated at the display limit. We ran the abbreviated forms deliberately: a nil on a long phrase is not evidence that no decision exists, only that nobody used that exact wording.

A looser query hit the repository's ten-result display limit. That one is recorded as not surveyed, not as a nil S6.

The one document, and it is not what it first appears

The single retrieved document is M. Selva Kumar v. The State of Karnataka, High Court of Karnataka at Dharwad, CRL.P No. 101377 of 2026, order of 20 July 2026, Anant Ramanath Hegde J. S5

It is a bail order, and the reference to Section 102 is in counsel's submission, not in the Court's reasoning. The order records S5:

It is also urged that… at the most, the petitioner could have been accused of offence punishable under Section 102 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, which would carry maximum punishment of 10 years of imprisonment and thus, would urge that the petitioner be released on bail.

Three things follow, and all three matter.

First, this is an argument, not a holding. We report it as a submission and not as the law.

Second, the submission as recorded mis-describes the provision. Section 102 is not an offence "punishable" with anything. It has no penalty clause: the five-way test above found none. The ten-year figure matches Section 105, which provides for culpable homicide not amounting to murder a term of not less than five years extending to ten years, with fine, on the intention limb S1. The argument being advanced was presumably that the case fell short of murder; but Section 102 is not the section that carries that sentence.

Third, the Court did not accept it. The order records that "the accused allegedly assaulted his wife on her neck with an axe three to four times. Prima facie, the manner of assault indicates an intention to cause her death." Noting two eye-witnesses, both stated to be relatives of the accused, and the recovery of the alleged weapon, the Court held that "no grounds are made out for grant of bail" and dismissed the petition. It added that the observations "are not expression on the merits of the case before the Trail Court" S5. The accused had been in custody since 31 January 2025, and the charge sheet had been filed S5.

So: no decision construing Section 102 was retrieved. The only retrieved reference to it is a submission that misread it, in an order that rejected the application.

(C) Editorial analysis: clearly labelled as ours

Everything in this part is our own reading.

Zero differences is a finding, not an absence of one. It is worth saying what it establishes. The whole of the transferred-malice doctrine in Indian law: every decision on Section 301: transfers to Section 102 without any adjustment whatever. There is no new word to argue about, no relabelled clause to map across, no restructured proviso. A practitioner can cite Section 301 authority under Section 102 and the only thing that has changed is the number on the front.

Compare Section 101 in this same group: twenty-one differences, none substantive, but including a clause relabelling that practitioners will be translating in their heads for years. Section 102 does not even cost that.

The bail argument is instructive, and we think it illustrates the real risk of this recodification. Nothing about Section 102 is harder than Section 301 was. The words are identical. What changed is the numbering, and with it the mental map. In the IPC, Section 301 sat between Section 300 (murder) and Section 302 (punishment for murder), so its character as a non-punitive attribution rule was visible from its neighbours. In the Sanhita the same provision sits between Section 101 (murder) and Section 103 (punishment for murder), structurally identical, yet an argument was advanced treating it as an offence carrying ten years.

Our assessment is that this is the predictable cost of renumbering a Code that practitioners have navigated by number for generations. It is not a defect in the drafting of Section 102, which is faultless. It is a transitional hazard, and it is the kind of error that will become less common as familiarity grows. In the meantime the useful habit is the one that caught it here: before attributing a punishment to a section, check whether the section contains one.

On the website's own mapping table. We have been critical of that dataset elsewhere in this collection: at Section 99 we found a flatly wrong punishment entry. Here it is correct: "Transferred Malice", "Same", "No major change". Given zero differences, "No major change" is accurate and if anything understates it. And the label "Transferred Malice" is genuinely useful, because that phrase appears nowhere in the statute and is how practitioners actually refer to the provision. Accuracy deserves reporting as readily as error.

What we checked, and what we could not

Checked and verified. The text and title of Section 102 against this project's inventory and, fragment by fragment, against the Gazette S1S2. The word-level comparison with IPC Section 301 on a line-scoped extraction with a length-band assertion (515 characters, in band), returning zero differences S3. That Section 102 carries no punishment, tested five ways S1. That Section 105 is the source of the ten-year figure, by reading Section 105's own text rather than assuming S1. The absence of amendment markers S3. The Gazette's marginal-note interleaving, resolved in halves so that the initial False results were explained rather than reported as a discrepancy S2. Four separate search queries, with abbreviated forms run deliberately S6. The bail order, read in full including its operative paragraphs S5. Commencement S4. The absence of a BNSS cross-reference, by whole-number test S7.

Not checked, and material. The case law on IPC Section 301 has NOT been surveyed, and this article offers no summary of it. The looser search query that hit the ten-result display limit is recorded as not surveyed S6. Any State amendments to IPC Section 301. Whether any classification attaches to Section 102 under the BNSS First Schedule. The Schedule has never been examined by this project, though since Section 102 creates no offence we would not expect it to appear there S7. The interaction between Section 102 and Section 101's Exceptions, which we flag as a live question and do not answer, because answering it properly requires the Section 301 authority.

How this article was prepared

This article was prepared by comparing the official text of BNS Section 102 with the official text of IPC Section 301 word by word, verifying the Sanhita text against the Gazette fragment by fragment, testing the section for any punishment clause five separate ways, and reading the single retrieved judgment in full.

Two of this project's standing rules did the real work here. A Gazette-side test returning False is not evidence of a discrepancy, which is why the marginal-note interleaving was diagnosed and explained rather than reported as a conflict between official sources. A proposition recorded as counsel's submission is never reported as the law, which is why the Section 102 argument in the bail order appears as a submission, with the Court's actual reasons and order given alongside it.

Where a body of authority exists but has not been surveyed, the article says so plainly rather than offering a thin summary that would read like a survey.

Documented material, judicial material and our own analysis are kept separate and labelled. Where we do not know something, the article says so instead of filling the gap.

This article was prepared with AI assistance. No lawyer has reviewed this article and no human legal review is claimed. Its status is "ready for human review": ready to be checked by a person, not already checked.

This article does not reproduce or alter any existing content on this website.

Law checked as of the date recorded in this article's metadata. Statutes and case law change, and this article is not legal advice. Whether this section applies in any given case, which description of homicide results, and what sentence may follow under Section 103 or Section 105, are matters only a court can determine on the evidence before it, and no outcome in any case is guaranteed. Verify the current position and take advice from a qualified advocate before acting.

Frequently asked questions

+What does BNS Section 102 provide?
Where a person, by doing something he intends or knows to be likely to cause death, commits culpable homicide by killing SOMEONE ELSE - a person whose death he neither intended nor knew himself likely to cause - the culpable homicide 'is of the description of which it would have been if he had caused the death of the person whose death he intended or knew himself to be likely to cause'. S1
+What is that in plain terms?
A aims at Z and kills Y. Section 102 says A's liability is determined by what he MEANT to do, not by whose body received the blow. The homicide is of the description it would have been had he killed Z. S1
+Is this the 'transferred malice' provision?
Yes - that is how practitioners refer to it, though the phrase appears NOWHERE in the statute itself. S1S8
+Does Section 102 create an offence or carry a punishment?
NO to both, and this is the point most easily got wrong. We tested the section FIVE separate ways: 'shall be punished', 'punished', 'imprisonment', 'fine' and 'punishable' are ALL absent from it. S1
+Then what does it do?
It is an ATTRIBUTION rule. It answers one question - which description of homicide is this? - and then hands over. If the answer is murder, the sentence comes from Section 103. If it is culpable homicide not amounting to murder, the sentence comes from Section 105. S1
+Which IPC section does it replace?
Section 301 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860. The titles are IDENTICAL: 'Culpable homicide by causing death of person other than person whose death was intended'. S3
+What changed?
NOTHING. The word-level comparison returns ZERO DIFFERENCES - word for word and punctuation for punctuation, the provision is reproduced exactly. It is the cleanest result in this group: Section 100 had one added full stop, Section 101 had twenty-one layout differences, and Section 102 has none at all. S3
+Has IPC Section 301 ever been amended?
Not on the text examined. The India Code slice carries NO amendment footnote markers, so on that text these words stood as enacted in 1860 and were carried across untouched - 164 years without a comma moving. S3
+Why does zero differences matter? Isn't it just an absence of a finding?
It is a finding, and a useful one. It establishes that the ENTIRE body of transferred-malice authority on Section 301 transfers to Section 102 without any adjustment whatever. No new word to argue about, no relabelled clause to map across. A practitioner can cite Section 301 authority under Section 102 and the only thing that has changed is the number on the front. S3
+You mention your own Gazette test returning False. What happened?
The longer fragments came back False, which on a careless reading would look like a conflict between the Gazette and the India Code text. It was not. The Gazette prints this section with its MARGINAL NOTE interleaved word by word through the running text - so the flat string reads 'likely to cause HOMICIDE BY death' and 'whose death he CAUSING DEATH OF PERSON OTHER neither intends'. Those bold words are the section's own title dropping in from the narrow side column. Resolved in halves, every fragment is confirmed present and there is NO discrepancy. S2
+Has any court construed Section 102 of the Sanhita?
No decision construing it was retrieved. We ran four queries: the exact phrase was EXHAUSTED and returned a single document, and three further queries - including abbreviated forms - produced GENUINE NILS with the repository's no-results marker and zero entries. S6
+Why run the abbreviated queries too?
Because a nil on a long phrase is not evidence that no decision exists - only that nobody used that exact wording. Running the shorter forms is how you tell the difference. S6
+Did any of your searches fail to settle the question?
Yes, and we say so. A looser query hit the repository's ten-result display limit, which means the field was truncated rather than exhausted. That query is recorded as NOT SURVEYED, not as a nil. S6
+What was the one document you found?
M. Selva Kumar v. The State of Karnataka, High Court of Karnataka at Dharwad, CRL.P No. 101377 of 2026, order of 20 July 2026, Anant Ramanath Hegde J. It is a BAIL ORDER, and the reference to Section 102 is in COUNSEL'S SUBMISSION, not in the Court's reasoning. S5
+What was the submission?
The order records: 'It is also urged that... at the most, the petitioner could have been accused of offence PUNISHABLE UNDER SECTION 102 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, which would carry MAXIMUM PUNISHMENT OF 10 YEARS of imprisonment and thus, would urge that the petitioner be released on bail.' S5
+Was that submission correct?
No - and this is why the point about Section 102 carrying no punishment matters. Section 102 is not an offence 'punishable' with anything; it has no penalty clause at all. The ten-year figure matches SECTION 105, which for culpable homicide not amounting to murder provides a term of not less than five years extending to ten years, with fine, on the intention limb. We read Section 105's own text to confirm that rather than assuming it. S1S5
+Did the Court accept the argument?
No. The order records that 'the accused allegedly assaulted his wife on her neck with an axe three to four times. Prima facie, the manner of assault indicates an intention to cause her death.' Noting two eye-witnesses, both stated to be relatives of the accused, and the recovery of the alleged weapon, the Court held that 'no grounds are made out for grant of bail' and DISMISSED the petition. S5
+Does that order decide anything about Section 102?
No, and we are careful to say so. It is a submission that misread the section, in an order that rejected the application - and the Court expressly recorded that its observations 'are not expression on the merits of the case before the Trail Court'. S5
+What do you take from that episode?
This is our own assessment, offered as editorial analysis. Nothing about Section 102 is harder than Section 301 was - the words are identical. What changed is the NUMBERING, and with it the mental map. In the IPC, Section 301 sat between 300 and 302, so its non-punitive character was visible from its neighbours; in the Sanhita it sits between 101 and 103, structurally identical - and yet an argument was advanced treating it as an offence carrying ten years. We read that as a transitional hazard of renumbering, not a defect in the drafting. The useful habit is simple: before attributing a punishment to a section, check whether the section contains one. S1S5
+What about the case law on IPC Section 301?
It has NOT been surveyed by this project, and this article offers no summary of it. Transferred malice has been litigated in India for well over a century, and that authority applies to Section 102 unchanged - because the words are unchanged. S6
+Is Section 102 cognizable or bailable?
No classification attaches to it, because it creates no offence and no punishment. And in any event this project has NOT examined the First Schedule to the BNSS. S7
+When did Section 102 come into force?
1 July 2024, by MHA notification S.O. 850(E) dated 23 February 2024, which commenced the whole Sanhita except sub-section (2) of Section 106. S4
+Does the BNSS refer to Section 102 of the BNS?
No - a whole-number search found no reference, so the digits could not match inside a longer number. S7
+What does this website's own mapping table say, and is it right?
It maps IPC 301 to BNS 102 with the topic 'Transferred Malice', punishment 'Same' and key difference 'No major change' - and on our verification it is CORRECT. Given zero differences, 'No major change' is accurate and if anything understates it, and the 'Transferred Malice' label is genuinely useful because that phrase is nowhere in the statute. We have criticised that dataset elsewhere in this collection, including a flatly wrong punishment entry at Section 99, so accuracy deserves reporting as readily as error. S8

Sources

  1. S1The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (Act No. 45 of 2023) - official text of section 102, and of ss. 100, 101, 103 and 105, as held in this project's verified section inventory drawn from India Code (accessed 10 October 2026)
  2. S2The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 - Gazette of India text published by the Ministry of Home Affairs (PDF) (accessed 10 October 2026)
  3. S3The Indian Penal Code, 1860 (Act No. 45 of 1860) - official text at India Code, used for the section 301 comparison (accessed 10 October 2026)
  4. S4Ministry of Home Affairs notification S.O. 850(E) dated 23 February 2024 bringing the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 into force (accessed 10 October 2026)
  5. S5M. Selva Kumar v. The State of Karnataka, High Court of Karnataka at Dharwad, CRL.P No. 101377 of 2026, order of 20 July 2026, Anant Ramanath Hegde J. - full text as served by Indian Kanoon (accessed 10 October 2026)
  6. S6Indian Kanoon public judgment repository - searches run for any decision construing section 102 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (accessed 10 October 2026)
  7. S7The Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (Act No. 46 of 2023) - Gazette text published by the Ministry of Home Affairs (PDF) (accessed 10 October 2026)
  8. S8ipc2bns.in IPC-to-BNS mapping dataset (this website's own existing comparison table) - treated as secondary commentary, never relied on as authority (accessed 10 October 2026)

Related deep dives

← All BNS section deep dives