IPC2BNSConverter

BNS Section 94 · Deep dive

BNS Section 94: A One-Letter Change - and the Courts Had Been Spelling It That Way for Ninety Years

BNS Section 94 punishes whoever, by secretly burying or otherwise disposing of the DEAD BODY of a child - whether the child died before, after or during birth - intentionally conceals or endeavours to conceal the birth. The maximum is TWO YEARS, the lowest in this sub-heading, with fine as an alternative and no minimum. The titles of IPC Section 318 and BNS Section 94 are identical, and the operative texts differ in EXACTLY ONE WORD: the India Code text of the IPC spells it 'endeavors', the American way, while the Sanhita spells it 'endeavours'. A reinsertion test confirmed nothing else changed - 339 characters against 339, strings equal. What makes that one letter interesting is that every one of the five judgments retrieved for this article already quoted the section with the British spelling, some of them ninety years ago. The case law itself is substantial: the body must be DEAD when disposed of, and the concealment must be from 'all and sundry', not merely from some people.

By the Nyaya Yantra Editorial TeamLaw checked as of 10 October 2026 26 min read

Prepared with AI-assisted research from the official sources listed at the end of this article.

At a glance

Provision
BNS Section 94 — Concealment of birth by secret disposal of dead body
Earlier law (IPC)
Section 318 — Concealment of birth by secret disposal of dead body · substantively unchanged
Side-by-side converterIPC 318 → BNS 94

What Section 94 says

Section 94 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 is titled "Concealment of birth by secret disposal of dead body." It reads in full S1:

Whoever, by secretly burying or otherwise disposing of the dead body of a child whether such child die before or after or during its birth, intentionally conceals or endeavours to conceal the birth of such child, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to two years, or with fine, or with both.

That is the entire section: a single sentence. No sub-sections, no clauses, no proviso, no Explanation, no Illustration, no Exception S1.

The elements are tightly drawn:

  1. the dead body of a child. The child may have died "before or after or during its birth";
  2. secretly burying or otherwise disposing of that body;
  3. and by that act, intentionally concealing or endeavouring to conceal the birth.

The maximum is two years: the lowest maximum of any section under this sub-heading. The fine is an alternative, not an addition. There is no minimum. "Imprisonment of either description" takes its meaning from Section 4(c) S1.

Section 94 uses the word "child" with no age qualification attached, so the Sanhita's general definition governs: Section 2(3) defines "child" as "any person below the age of eighteen years" S1. Contrast its two neighbours. Section 93 says "child under the age of twelve years", Section 97 says "child under the age of ten years".

It came into force on 1 July 2024 by Ministry of Home Affairs notification S.O. 850(E) dated 23 February 2024, which commenced the whole Sanhita on that date except sub-section (2) of Section 106 S4.

(A) What the documented record shows about the change

The change is one letter

Section 94 corresponds to Section 318 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860.

The titles are identical. The operative texts differ in exactly one word, and that word differs by one letter: the India Code text of IPC Section 318 reads "endeavors", the Sanhita reads "endeavours" S3.

We did not take that on trust. The word-level comparison reported one difference; we then ran a reinsertion test: rebuild the whole Sanhita sentence with the IPC's spelling substituted back in, and assert string equality against the IPC text. The result: 339 characters against 339, strings equal S3. Had anything else differed (a comma, a number, a word order) that test would have failed.

So: the punishment is unchanged, the ingredients are unchanged, the structure is unchanged, the title is unchanged. One letter.

The IPC text is internally inconsistent about this word

Here is where it gets more interesting than a spelling note deserves to be.

The form "endeavors" appears exactly once in the entire India Code text of the IPC: at Section 318: and "endeavours" appears nowhere in it S3.

Yet the same text spells the word the British way elsewhere. At Section 152, it reads "in endeavouring to disperse an unlawful assembly, or to suppress a riot or affray" S3.

So that text is inconsistent with itself: British at Section 152, American at Section 318.

What we cannot tell you, and will not guess

Whether the printed Code of 1860 really carried an Americanism at Section 318, or whether this is an artefact of how that text was transcribed, is not settled by anything we retrieved. We have not examined a physical copy of the 1860 Code or any earlier official printing S3.

We flag that gap rather than close it with a plausible story.

But the courts have been spelling it the British way for ninety years

This is the part worth knowing. Every one of the five judgments retrieved for this article quotes the section with "endeavours" or "endeavouring", and not one of them says "endeavors." That includes the Calcutta High Court in 1935, the Rajasthan High Court in 1973, the Gauhati High Court in 1980, the Kerala High Court in 2019 and the Bombay High Court in 2025 S5S6S7S8S9.

So the Sanhita's spelling matches how the courts had been reading and quoting this section for ninety years. Whether the drafters corrected the statute or simply caught up with the judiciary, the two are now aligned.

Chapter and sub-heading: the move, and one small structural point

As with the whole group, Section 94 changed chapters. IPC Section 318 sat in Chapter XVI, "OF OFFENCES AFFECTING THE HUMAN BODY". BNS Section 94 sits in Chapter V, "OF OFFENCES AGAINST WOMAN AND CHILD", under the sub-heading "Of offences against child" S2S3.

There is also a structural detail that the bare mapping hides. In the IPC, Section 318 was the last section under its sub-heading: the sub-heading "Of Hurt" begins immediately after it, before Section 319 S3. The IPC therefore treated exposure (317) and concealment (318) as a closed pair, and then moved straight on to hurt.

In the Sanhita, Section 94 is not last. Section 95 follows it inside the same sub-heading, then Sections 96 to 99 S2. The old two-section pair has been opened up and extended.

Amendment provenance

The India Code slice for IPC Section 318 carries no amendment footnote markers at all S3. On the text examined, these words stood as enacted in 1860. The standing caveat applies: absence of markers in a text is evidence about that text, not a certificate from the legislature.

Number collisions and cross-references

The BNSS makes no reference to Section 94 of the Sanhita; we tested with a whole-number search so the digits could not match inside a longer number such as 194 S10.

The number itself is treacherous across the three new codes. BNSS Section 94 concerns a Court or an officer in charge of a police station requiring production of a document or thing. Section 94 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 concerns the terms of a contract, grant or other disposition of property S10. Neither has anything to do with children.

Section 94 appears in neither list in Section 2(24) S1.

(B) Judicial and practical context

Because the operative words are unchanged in substance, the case law on Section 318 bears directly on Section 94. Five decisions spanning 1935 to 2025 were retrieved and read in full.

The body must be dead, and dead when disposed of

Mst. Radha v. The State of Rajasthan, Rajasthan High Court (Jaipur), 1 October 1973, equivalent citation 1973 (6) WLN 709, V.P. Tyagi J. S6

The appellant had been convicted by the Sessions Judge, Ajmer on 21 January 1970 under Section 302: life imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 500: and under Section 318, one year's rigorous imprisonment. She gave birth on 26 April 1968; the body of a newborn male child was found the next day in the vicinity of her house.

On the construction of Section 318 the Court was direct:

The necessary ingredient of this offence is that the culprit must secretly bury or dispose of the dead body of a child.

And, if he disposes of a living child, the act does not fall within the section. The Court put this beyond doubt by reference to Halsbury's Laws of England, Volume 10, page 733:

A person does not commit the offence of endeavouring to conceal the birth of a child, if such person puts it while it is still alive in a place of concealment, even though it may subsequently die.

Because the prosecution had not proved that the child was already dead when it was left in the Gali, the Section 318 case was not established. The appellant was acquitted of both charges and the sentences set aside.

A note on this source. The copy of this judgment served by the public repository is heavily corrupted: it contains "bean filed", "imprisonntnt", "challaged", "cirumstances", "Scetion" and "four cornets". A text in that condition cannot support any claim about how the judgment spelt or punctuated anything, and we make none. We rely on it only for its substantive holdings, which are legible and internally consistent S6.

Concealment must be from "all and sundry", not from some people

Sailabala Dasi v. Emperor, Calcutta High Court, 4 April 1935, AIR 1935 Cal 489; 158 Ind. Cas. 7, Lort-Williams J. S5

The appellant was convicted of concealment of birth under Section 318 and sentenced to nine months' rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 300, with three months' rigorous imprisonment in default. Two co-accused were acquitted.

The facts defeated the charge. On 4 July 1934, Ushabala, the daughter of the appellant, gave birth to male twins in the Calcutta Medical School and Hospital. The Court held:

But a much more important point is that Section 318, Penal Code, punishes a person for secretly burying or otherwise disposing of the dead body of a child, and so intentionally concealing or endeavouring to conceal the birth of such child. In this case, there was no concealment of the birth. The birth took place in the Calcutta Medical School and Hospital and was attended by nurses and others in the Hospital who were well aware that Ushabala had given birth to twins.

The Court then stated the test:

Section 318 is designed to punish such a person for intentionally concealing the birth of the child from all and sundry; though ... she will not escape the consequences of her act if she merely discloses the fact of the birth to some confidant.

And on the facts: "It is clear from the evidence that this birth was not concealed from the world at large."

The Court also recorded two propositions from outside Indian case law. From Mayne's Criminal Law of India, 4th edition, page 545: "a woman is not bound to announce that she is going to have a child, and if the child lives she is quite at liberty to keep its existence secret." And from Reg. v. Mary Ann William, 11 Cox CC 684, where Montague Smith J. decided that to convict a woman of attempting to conceal the birth of her child, "the dead body must be found and identified as that of the child of which she is alleged to have been delivered."

The conviction and sentence were set aside and the accused acquitted.

No body, no offence: twenty-three years later

Thaganabai Bhagwan Ghode v. The State of Maharashtra, High Court of Bombay, 17 December 2025 S9

The appellant had been convicted under Section 318 on 17 June 2002 by the IIIrd Additional Sessions Judge, Jalna in Sessions Case No. 134 of 1996, and sentenced to one year's rigorous imprisonment. Her appeal was decided on 17 December 2025: twenty-three years after the conviction, and thirty years after the report that started it.

The Court's reasoning was simple and fatal to the conviction. The body of the child "had never been found or seized by the prosecution", and there was "no evidence of burying secretly or disposing of dead body of the child."

The Court also noticed an inconsistency in the trial. The Sessions Court had acquitted two co-accused precisely because the prosecution had failed to discover a body, and then convicted the appellant "on the basis of same evidence."

Stating the requirement: "For the purpose of attracting offence under Section 318 of the Indian Penal Code, the prosecution is required to prove that the accused has concealed the birth or secrete disposing of dead body."

The appeal was allowed and the conviction and sentence set aside.

The charge does sometimes stick

Cheluvi v. State of Kerala, High Court of Kerala, 4 April 2019, Crl. Appeal No. 1254 of 2014 S8

This is the only one of the five retrieved decisions in which the Section 318 conviction survived.

The appellant had been convicted by the Sessions Court, Kalpetta under Sections 302, 201 and 318: life imprisonment with a fine for the murder, two years with a fine for causing disappearance of evidence, and one year for Section 318, all concurrent.

On appeal she was acquitted of Sections 302 and 201 on the benefit of doubt: "Motive for the offence is not proved. We don't find conclusive evidence to elicit intention on the part of the appellant to commit murder of the child."

But Section 318 was confirmed. The act "was done by her in secrecy and it came to light only after she was admitted in Taluk Head-Quarters hospital, Sultan Bathery and examined by PW3." The Court noted that "The maximum sentence for an offence u/s 318 of I.P.C. is 2 years or with fine or with both" and sentenced her to one year. The appeal was partly allowed.

A decision that records something troubling

Miss Lulano Lotha v. The State of Nagaland, Gauhati High Court, 9 September 1980, 1981 CriLJ 522, K.N. Saikia J. (D. Pathak, Actg. C.J. agreeing) S7

The appellant, described in the judgment as "a Naga tribal girl", appealed from jail against conviction under Sections 302 and 318, with concurrent sentences of life imprisonment and two years' simple imprisonment. She had pleaded guilty and prayed for mercy; the trial court nevertheless proceeded to record evidence.

Two observations of the Court are worth setting out. On the plea:

The plea of guilty with prayer for mercy taken by this teen-aged forlorn tribal girl after charge may have been the result of plea bargaining by someone, which cannot be encouraged for it conceals the truth, creating false hopes and fears.

And on the investigation:

The letters written by the I. O. to the doctors were of solicitous nature, so much so, that medical findings themselves may have been tinged.

Nobody had deposed to seeing her pregnant during the possible gestation period, and the connection with the placenta found in the nalla was not established. "Charge under Section 318, I.P.C. must, therefore, fail." She was acquitted of both charges and ordered to be "set at liberty forthwith."

Judgments that mis-quote the section

Three of the five reproduce the section inexactly, and we controlled each against the IPC text:

  • Cheluvi (2019) and Thaganabai (2025) both render it "the death body of a child". The official text says "the dead body". The phrase "death body" appears nowhere in the IPC text examined S3S8S9.
  • Lulano Lotha (1980) renders it "where such child dies before or after or during its birth". The official text says "whether such child die". "where such child dies" appears nowhere in the IPC text examined S3S7.

None of these affected any outcome. All are reasons to quote statutes from the statute.

(C) Editorial analysis: clearly labelled as ours

Everything in this part is our own reading. No source is offered for it beyond the statutory and judicial texts already cited.

A spelling change is a legitimate thing for a re-enactment to do, and this one costs nothing. Nobody's liability turns on a "u". But it is worth noticing why this kind of change is safe here and would not be safe everywhere: the word "endeavours" has no technical content in this section that the spelling could disturb. Where a re-enactment alters a word that does carry technical content, the calculation is entirely different. The value of recording a change this small is that it establishes, by exhaustion, that nothing else changed.

The case law suggests this section is harder to prove than it looks. Four of the five retrieved decisions ended in acquittal or a set-aside on Section 318, and the reasons cluster: the prosecution could not show the child was already dead (Radha), could not produce a body at all (Thaganabai), or was met with a birth that plainly was not concealed (Sailabala Dasi). The section asks for proof about a body that, by the nature of the offence, the accused has tried to make disappear. That is a structural difficulty, not a drafting flaw, and the Sanhita has not altered it.

The pattern of the charge is worth flagging to anyone reading the section cold. In four of the five, Section 318 rode alongside a murder charge under Section 302; the murder charge failed on the evidence; and the court then assessed Section 318 separately, and in three of those four it failed too. On this small sample the provision reads less like a free-standing offence than like a fallback to a homicide allegation. We offer that as our reading of five decisions, not as a statistic about Indian practice.

The age point is a genuine, if quiet, change. Section 318 said "child" and the IPC never defined the word. Section 94 says "child" and the Sanhita does define it: a person below eighteen. In the ordinary run of these cases the point will be academic, because the bodies are those of newborns. But the definition closes an open edge that had been open since 1860, and it closes it uniformly and without reference to the sex of the child, which the IPC's only definition of a comparable term (Section 363A(b), "minor": male under sixteen, female under eighteen) did not manage.

Two years remains a very low maximum, and the Sanhita did not revisit it. The Sanhita raised the maximum in Section 99 from ten years to fourteen and added a seven-year minimum there. Here it left two years untouched. We have found no documented reason for the difference in treatment, and we do not supply one. We note only that Section 94 is now the least severely punished offence in its sub-heading, as it was in its old one.

The Lulano Lotha observations deserve to survive the re-enactment. What that Court said about an apparent plea bargain concealing the truth, and about investigative letters that may have tinged medical findings, has nothing to do with the words of Section 318 and everything to do with how such cases reach court. Those risks are not addressed by renumbering a section, and nothing in the Sanhita changes them.

What we checked, and what we could not

Checked and verified. The full text and title of Section 94 against this project's verified inventory and, fragment by fragment, against the Gazette S1S2. The word-level comparison with IPC Section 318, confirmed by a reinsertion test with printed lengths and asserted string equality S3. The occurrence counts for "endeavors" and "endeavours" across the whole IPC text, and the inconsistency with Section 152 S3. The absence of amendment markers S3. Chapter and sub-heading placement in both codes, including that Section 318 closed its sub-heading and Section 94 does not S2S3. Commencement S4. Five judgments, read in full S5S6S7S8S9. The absence of any BNSS cross-reference, by whole-number test S10.

Method note. The Gazette interleaves marginal side-notes into the running text. For this section it literally reads "intentionally conceals or endeavours secret disposal to conceal the birth of such child", which is why a single-string test on "endeavours to conceal" fails even though the text is correct. Every failed test was re-run in halves and resolved; none disclosed a discrepancy S2.

Not checked. Whether the offence is cognizable or bailable: set by the First Schedule to the BNSS, which this project has not examined S10. Whether the printed 1860 Code spelt the word "endeavors" or "endeavours"; we examined the India Code text only, and no earlier official printing S3. Halsbury's Laws of England, Mayne's Criminal Law of India and Reg. v. Mary Ann William, 11 Cox CC 684: all three are cited here only as the Indian courts reproduced them; none was retrieved S5S6. Any State amendments to IPC Section 318. Whether any court has yet construed Section 94 itself; our searches returned results at the repository's ten-item display limit, which means the field was not exhausted and further decisions may exist.

How this article was prepared

This article was prepared by comparing the official text of BNS Section 94 with the official text of IPC Section 318 word by word, confirming the single reported difference by a reinsertion test that asserts string equality, verifying the Sanhita text against the Gazette fragment by fragment, and reading in full every judgment relied on.

Where a source is in poor condition, we say so and limit what we draw from it, which is why no claim about spelling or punctuation is made from the 1973 judgment. Where a judgment's reproduction of the statute differs from the statute, we say so and give the statutory reading. Where a treatise or an English case is cited, we attribute it to the Indian court that cited it, because we did not retrieve it ourselves.

Documented material, judicial material and our own analysis are kept separate and labelled. Where we do not know something, including whether the 1860 Code itself spelt the word with a "u", the article says so instead of filling the gap.

This article was prepared with AI assistance. No lawyer has reviewed this article and no human legal review is claimed. Its status is "ready for human review": ready to be checked by a person, not already checked.

This article does not reproduce or alter any existing content on this website.

Law checked as of the date recorded in this article's metadata. Statutes and case law change, and this article is not legal advice. Whether the ingredients of this section are made out in any given case, whether any statutory exception or defence applies, and what sentence may follow, are matters only a court can determine on the evidence before it, and no outcome in any case is guaranteed. Verify the current position and take advice from a qualified advocate before acting.

Frequently asked questions

+What does BNS Section 94 provide?
It punishes WHOEVER, by SECRETLY BURYING OR OTHERWISE DISPOSING OF THE DEAD BODY of a child - whether the child died before, after or during its birth - INTENTIONALLY CONCEALS OR ENDEAVOURS TO CONCEAL the birth of that child. Punishment: imprisonment of either description up to TWO YEARS, OR fine, OR both. No minimum. S1
+Which IPC section does it replace?
Section 318 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860. The titles are IDENTICAL and the operative texts differ in EXACTLY ONE WORD. S1S3
+What is that one word?
A spelling. The India Code text of IPC Section 318 reads 'endeavors' - the American spelling - while BNS Section 94 reads 'endeavours'. Nothing else changed. We confirmed that by a reinsertion test: substituting the American spelling back into the Sanhita text produced a string EQUAL to the IPC text, 339 characters against 339. S3
+Is that really the only difference? It sounds too small to be true.
It is, and we did not take it on trust. The word-level comparison reported one difference; the reinsertion test then rebuilt the whole Sanhita sentence with the IPC's spelling and asserted STRING EQUALITY against the IPC text. Equal, with both lengths printed. If anything else had differed - a comma, a word order, a number - that test would have failed. S3
+Was 'endeavors' a mistake in the IPC?
We cannot tell you, and we are not going to guess. What we CAN report is this. The form 'endeavors' appears EXACTLY ONCE in the whole India Code text of the IPC - at Section 318 - and 'endeavours' appears nowhere in it. Yet the same text spells the word the British way at Section 152, 'endeavouring to disperse an unlawful assembly'. So that text is internally inconsistent. Whether the printed 1860 Code really carried an Americanism at Section 318, or whether this is an artefact of transcription, is something the sources we retrieved do not settle. S3
+Here is the interesting part. How did the courts spell it?
The British way - and they always seem to have. Every one of the FIVE judgments retrieved for this article quotes the section with 'endeavours' or 'endeavouring', including the Calcutta High Court in 1935. Not one of them says 'endeavors'. So the Sanhita's spelling matches how the courts had been reading and quoting the section for ninety years. S5S6S7S8S9
+So did the Sanhita correct the statute, or just catch up with the courts?
That is exactly the question we cannot answer from the retrieved sources, and we say so rather than pick the more satisfying story. Either the drafters corrected a genuine Americanism in the 1860 text, or the 1860 text always said 'endeavours' and the India Code transcription is the odd one out. Both are consistent with everything we found. S3S5
+What else changed, apart from the spelling?
The section changed chapters, as the whole group did. IPC Section 318 sat in Chapter XVI, 'OF OFFENCES AFFECTING THE HUMAN BODY'. BNS Section 94 sits in Chapter V, 'OF OFFENCES AGAINST WOMAN AND CHILD', under the sub-heading 'Of offences against child'. S2S3
+Is there a structural change worth noticing?
Yes, a small one. In the IPC, Section 318 was the LAST section under its sub-heading - the sub-heading 'Of Hurt' began immediately after it. In the Sanhita, Section 94 is NOT last: Section 95 follows it inside the same sub-heading, and then Sections 96 to 99. So the old pairing of exposure (317) plus concealment (318) has been opened up and extended with further child-related offences. S2S3
+Has Section 318 ever been amended?
Not on the text examined. The India Code slice for IPC Section 318 carries NO amendment footnote markers at all, so far as that text shows these words stood as enacted in 1860. S3
+What is the single most important ingredient of this offence?
That the body disposed of must be a DEAD body. The Rajasthan High Court put it directly in Mst. Radha v. State of Rajasthan: 'The necessary ingredient of this offence is that the culprit must secretly bury or dispose of the dead body of a child' - and if he disposes of a LIVING child, the act does not fall within the section. S6
+What if the child was alive when hidden and died afterwards?
On the authority retrieved, that is not this offence. Citing Halsbury's Laws of England, Volume 10, page 733, the Rajasthan High Court held: 'A person does not commit the offence of endeavouring to conceal the birth of a child, if such person puts it while it is still alive in a place of concealment, even though it may subsequently die'. S6
+What happened in Mst. Radha's case?
She had been convicted by the Sessions Judge, Ajmer in January 1970 under Section 302 (life imprisonment and a Rs. 500 fine) and Section 318 (one year's rigorous imprisonment). On appeal she was ACQUITTED of both. On Section 318 the reason was precise: the prosecution had not proved that the child was already dead when it was left in the Gali. S6
+How much concealment is needed? Is hiding it from the family enough?
No - it must be concealment from everyone. In Sailabala Dasi v. Emperor (Calcutta High Court, 1935), the Court held that 'Section 318 is designed to punish such a person for intentionally concealing the birth of the child from ALL AND SUNDRY', adding that a person 'will not escape the consequences of her act if she merely discloses the fact of the birth to some confidant'. On the facts, 'It is clear from the evidence that this birth was not concealed from the world at large'. S5
+Why was there no concealment in Sailabala Dasi?
Because the birth happened in a hospital. Twins were born on 4 July 1934 in the Calcutta Medical School and Hospital, attended by nurses and others who knew of it. A birth known to hospital staff is not a concealed birth. The conviction - nine months' rigorous imprisonment and a Rs. 300 fine - was SET ASIDE and the accused acquitted. S5
+Is a woman obliged to announce a pregnancy or a birth?
On the authority retrieved, no. Citing Mayne's Criminal Law of India, 4th edition, page 545, the Calcutta High Court recorded that 'a woman is not bound to announce that she is going to have a child, and if the child lives she is quite at liberty to keep its existence secret'. The offence is about concealing the birth of a DEAD child by secretly disposing of the body - not about privacy. S5
+Must the body actually be found?
The retrieved cases point strongly that way. The Calcutta High Court referred to Reg. v. Mary Ann William, 11 Cox CC 684, where Montague Smith J. decided that to convict a woman of attempting to conceal the birth of her child 'the dead body must be found and identified as that of the child of which she is alleged to have been delivered'. In the 2025 Bombay case the absence of any recovered body was decisive. S5S9
+What happened in the 2025 Bombay case?
In Thaganabai Bhagwan Ghode v. State of Maharashtra the appellant had been convicted under Section 318 in JUNE 2002 and sentenced to one year. Her appeal was decided in DECEMBER 2025 - twenty-three years later. The High Court recorded that the body of the child 'had never been found or seized by the prosecution' and that there was 'no evidence of burying secretly or disposing of dead body of the child'. The appeal was allowed and the conviction set aside. S9
+The Bombay Court noticed something odd about the trial. What was it?
That the Sessions Court had acquitted two co-accused precisely because no body was discovered, but convicted the appellant 'on the basis of same evidence'. The High Court recorded that inconsistency in setting the conviction aside. S9
+Do Section 318 convictions ever survive?
Yes - one of the five retrieved decisions upheld it. In Cheluvi v. State of Kerala (2019) the appellant was acquitted of Sections 302 and 201 on benefit of doubt, but the Section 318 conviction was CONFIRMED because the act 'was done by her in secrecy and it came to light only after she was admitted in Taluk Head-Quarters hospital'. She was sentenced to one year. S8
+Is there a pattern across these cases?
A striking one. In four of the five, the Section 318 charge was brought ALONGSIDE a murder charge under Section 302; the murder charge failed on the evidence; and the court then assessed Section 318 separately. In three of those four it also failed. This looks like a provision that most often appears as a fallback to a homicide allegation - though we offer that as our reading of five decisions, not as a statistic about Indian practice. S5S6S7S8S9
+Was anything troubling recorded in these cases?
Yes, in the 1980 Gauhati case. Miss Lulano Lotha, described as a Naga tribal girl, appealed from jail against conviction under Sections 302 and 318. She had pleaded guilty and prayed for mercy. The Court observed that the plea 'may have been the result of plea bargaining by someone, which cannot be encouraged for it conceals the truth, creating false hopes and fears', and that the investigating officer's letters to the doctors 'were of solicitous nature, so much so, that medical findings themselves may have been tinged'. She was acquitted of both charges and ordered set at liberty forthwith. S7
+Do the judgments quote the section accurately?
Several do not, and the departures are worth knowing if you are quoting from a judgment rather than from the statute. Cheluvi (2019) and Thaganabai (2025) BOTH render it 'the DEATH body of a child'; the official text says 'the dead body'. Lulano Lotha (1980) renders it 'WHERE such child DIES'; the official text says 'whether such child die'. We controlled each of these against the IPC text: 'death body', 'where such child dies' and 'such child dates' appear NOWHERE in it. S3S7S8S9
+Why do you not draw conclusions from the spelling in the 1973 judgment?
Because the copy of that judgment served by the repository is heavily corrupted - it contains 'bean filed', 'imprisonntnt', 'challaged', 'cirumstances', 'Scetion' and 'four cornets'. A text in that condition cannot support any claim about how the judgment spelt or punctuated anything. We rely on it only for its substantive holdings, which are legible and internally consistent. S6
+Does 'child' here have an age limit?
Section 94 uses 'child' with no further qualification, so the Sanhita's own definition applies: Section 2(3) defines 'child' as 'any person below the age of eighteen years'. Contrast Section 93, which says 'child under the age of twelve years', and Section 97, which says 'child under the age of ten years'. S1
+Is the offence under Section 94 cognizable or bailable?
This article does NOT say, because we have not examined the source that decides it - the First Schedule to the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023. Check that Schedule or take advice. S10
+When did Section 94 come into force?
1 July 2024, by MHA notification S.O. 850(E) dated 23 February 2024, which commenced the whole Sanhita on that date except sub-section (2) of Section 106. S4
+Does the BNSS mention Section 94 of the BNS?
No. A whole-number search found no reference. And watch the number: BNSS Section 94 is about a Court or officer in charge of a police station requiring production of a document or thing, and Section 94 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 is about the terms of a contract, grant or other disposition of property. S10
+What does this website's own mapping table say?
It maps IPC 318 to BNS 94, with the punishment 'Same - Up to 2 years' and the key difference 'No major change'. That is CORRECT. It does not mention the spelling change or the chapter move, which is a fair simplification for a table of that kind. S11

Sources

  1. S1The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (Act No. 45 of 2023) - official text of section 94, with sections 2(3), 2(24) and 4, as held in this project's verified section inventory drawn from India Code (accessed 10 October 2026)
  2. S2The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 - Gazette of India text published by the Ministry of Home Affairs (PDF) (accessed 10 October 2026)
  3. S3The Indian Penal Code, 1860 (Act No. 45 of 1860) - official text at India Code, used for the section 318 comparison (accessed 10 October 2026)
  4. S4Ministry of Home Affairs notification S.O. 850(E) dated 23 February 2024 bringing the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 into force (accessed 10 October 2026)
  5. S5Sailabala Dasi v. Emperor, Calcutta High Court, 4 April 1935, equivalent citations AIR 1935 Cal 489; 158 Ind. Cas. 7 - full text as served by Indian Kanoon (accessed 10 October 2026)
  6. S6Mst. Radha v. The State of Rajasthan, Rajasthan High Court (Jaipur), 1 October 1973, equivalent citation 1973 (6) WLN 709 - full text as served by Indian Kanoon (accessed 10 October 2026)
  7. S7Miss Lulano Lotha v. The State of Nagaland, Gauhati High Court, 9 September 1980, equivalent citation 1981 CriLJ 522 - full text as served by Indian Kanoon (accessed 10 October 2026)
  8. S8Cheluvi v. State of Kerala, High Court of Kerala, 4 April 2019, Crl. Appeal No. 1254 of 2014 - full text as served by Indian Kanoon (accessed 10 October 2026)
  9. S9Thaganabai Bhagwan Ghode v. The State of Maharashtra, High Court of Bombay, 17 December 2025 - full text as served by Indian Kanoon (accessed 10 October 2026)
  10. S10The Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (Act No. 46 of 2023) - Gazette text published by the Ministry of Home Affairs (PDF) (accessed 10 October 2026)
  11. S11ipc2bns.in IPC-to-BNS mapping dataset (this website's own existing comparison table) - treated as secondary commentary and checked against the primary sources, never relied on as authority (accessed 10 October 2026)

Related deep dives

← All BNS section deep dives