A note on what this article is. This is a research-and-verification write-up of a single section of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023. Every statutory quotation was tested against a primary source before it was written down, and artefacts of my own source data are disclosed, including one in the project's own inventory. It separates (A) what the statute says, (B) what retrieved courts have said, and (C) clearly-labelled editorial observation. It is not legal advice.
1. The section, in full
BNS Section 86 is titled "Cruelty defined." It reads S1S2:
"For the purposes of section 85, 'cruelty' means—
(a) any wilful conduct which is of such a nature as is likely to drive the woman to commit suicide or to cause grave injury or danger to life, limb or health (whether mental or physical) of the woman; or
(b) harassment of the woman where such harassment is with a view to coercing her or any person related to her to meet any unlawful demand for any property or valuable security or is on account of failure by her or any person related to her to meet such demand."
Section 86 creates no offence and prescribes no punishment. A control confirms it contains none of the words "punish", "imprison" or "fine" S1. It is purely a definition, and it is a definition for one section only: Section 85.
It has two lettered clauses and no sub-sections S1. Commencement: 1 July 2024, by notification S.O. 850(E) dated 23 February 2024 S4.
2. Where this text comes from: the Explanation to IPC 498A
Section 86 is IPC Section 498A's Explanation, lifted out and made a section.
In the Penal Code there was no "Section 86 equivalent". There was a single section, 498A, consisting of an operative sentence followed by S3:
"Explanation.—For the purposes of this section, 'cruelty' means— (a) … of the woman; (b) harassment of the woman …"
The Sanhita's Section 85 took the operative sentence; Section 86 took the Explanation. Classification: split_or_reorganised. The companion article on Section 85 covers the operative offence, the abolition of the Penal Code's Chapter XXA, and the 1983 provenance of the whole of this material.
A title that did not exist. The words "Cruelty defined" appear NOWHERE in the Penal Code S3. The Explanation had no heading of its own. They do appear in the Gazette text of the Sanhita S2. The definition has been promoted from an unlabelled Explanation to a titled, separately numbered section.
3. The two real textual changes
A word-level comparison of the Penal Code's Explanation against Section 86 produced three reported differences. One of them is not a change at all. It is a defect in my own source data, disclosed in section 6. The other two are real.
3.1 "this section" became "section 85"
| Penal Code | Sanhita |
|---|---|
| "For the purposes of this section, 'cruelty' means—" | "For the purposes of section 85, 'cruelty' means—" |
This is bookkeeping. Once the definition stands as a section of its own, "this section" would point at the definition rather than at the offence, so the cross-reference had to be re-pointed. It follows necessarily from the split.
(C) But one consequence is worth stating precisely, as a matter of text. The definition is expressed to operate "for the purposes of section 85": a single named section. Under the Penal Code it operated "for the purposes of this section", which was also a single section. So on the words the reach is the same in each case: one offence. This article does NOT analyse whether the definition can or cannot be used in construing any other provision of the Sanhita. No authority on the point was located.
3.2 The word "or" was ADDED between clauses (a) and (b)
This is the real textual addition, and it was verified several ways because a single inserted word is exactly the kind of finding that a careless comparison would get wrong.
| Text at the junction of the clauses | |
|---|---|
| IPC 498A, Explanation | "… of the woman**;** (b) harassment of the woman …" |
| BNS s. 86 | "… of the woman**; or** (b) harassment of the woman …" |
The verification:
- Positive test on the Gazette text of the Sanhita: the string "(whether mental or physical) of the woman; or" is present S2.
- Negative control on the Penal Code: the string "of the woman; or" is ABSENT, while "of the woman; (b)" is present S3. The control could have failed and did not. This is not an artefact of how one text was extracted.
- Independent corroboration from a judgment. The Bombay High Court at Nagpur set Section 86 out in full in Kanyalal Guruprasad Gupta, and its quotation contains the "or" S6. That is a source entirely independent of my Gazette extract.
So on the Penal Code's words the two limbs of the definition were separated by a semicolon alone; in the Sanhita the disjunction is express.
(C) Editorial observation, clearly labelled, and deliberately short. It is tempting to say this "makes no difference because the limbs were obviously alternatives anyway", and equally tempting to say it "settles" something. This article says neither. What the added "or" does (whether it confirms a disjunction that was already implicit, or does any work at all) is LEFT OPEN. No decision addressing the addition was retrieved; the one Court that quoted the section with the "or" in it did not remark on it. This is the principal item for human review on this section.
A control worth recording. No "or" was added at the end of clause (b): the Gazette runs straight from "meet such demand." into the next section S2. The addition is at one junction only, which is the only junction there is.
4. What the definition does NOT change, and a correction to a common claim
The words "(whether mental or physical)" are NOT new. They were in IPC Section 498A's Explanation, and a control placed that phrase inside the bracket of the 1983 insertion S3. The whole of this definition (both limbs, the suicide and grave-injury limb, the harassment-for-unlawful-demand limb, and the mental-or-physical parenthesis) is Act 46 of 1983 material, reproduced with the two changes identified above and nothing else.
That matters because the live site's existing dataset says otherwise, and the point is dealt with in section 8.
5. The structure of the definition, on the words
This itemisation is the author's reading, not a judicial formulation, and the terms in it are not construed here:
Clause (a) requires wilful conduct of such a nature as is likely:
- to drive the woman to commit suicide; or
- to cause grave injury or danger to life, limb or health, whether mental or physical, of the woman.
Clause (b) requires harassment of the woman which is either:
- with a view to coercing her, or any person related to her, to meet any unlawful demand for any property or valuable security; or
- on account of failure by her, or any person related to her, to meet such demand.
Points not analysed in this article: what "wilful" requires; what degree of likelihood "is likely to" imports; what makes an injury "grave"; what "harassment" means; what makes a demand "unlawful"; and who is "any person related to her". None of these is construed here. They are the substance of a very large body of Penal Code case law on Section 498A which, as section 7 records, was not surveyed.
6. A defect in this project's own source data, disclosed
The project's section inventory records Section 86's text with two stray full stops that the Gazette does not have: after "means—" and after the added "or" S1S2:
- inventory:
"cruelty" means—.· Gazette:"cruelty" means— - inventory:
… of the woman; or.· Gazette:… of the woman; or
Both were tested directly against the Gazette text and both stray stops are absent from it S2.
This matters for two reasons. First, those stray stops appeared in my word-level comparison as reported differences, and had they not been checked, this article would have reported a "change" in the Sanhita's punctuation that does not exist. Second, it is the second data-quality defect found in that inventory in this collection: the first being a truncated entry at Section 72. The quotation in section 1 above is the Gazette reading, not the inventory reading.
7. What the courts have said
The field was NOT surveyed. The principal query for the companion Section 85 returned ten results, the display limit, so there is more case law than was seen. Penal Code case law on Section 498A's Explanation was not surveyed at all, and it is large.
Four distinct decisions were examined for the pair of sections; two further documents proved to be duplicates of judgments already counted and were not counted twice (see the Section 85 article for that artefact class). On Section 86 specifically:
7.1 Kanyalal Guruprasad Gupta and Others v. The State of Maharashtra: Bombay High Court, Nagpur Bench, 14 August 2026
APL Nos. 32 and 40 of 2026, M. W. Chandwani J., 2026:BHC-NAG:10870 S6.
The Court set Section 86 out in full, and its quotation differs from the official text by one token only: the length of a dash S6. Its quotation contains the added "or", corroborating section 3.2 above.
The Court then summarised the section in its own words, describing cruelty as "any willful conduct of such a nature that will lead the women to commit suicide or harm herself (mentally or physically) or such harassment inflicted upon the women seeking to meet unlawful demand for property" S6. (C) That summary is narrower in places than the section's words. The section says "is likely to drive", not "will lead, and speaks of "grave injury or danger to life, limb or health", not "harm herself". It is reproduced as the Court's summary and this article draws no conclusion from the difference.
Applying the clauses, the Court found no material showing wilful conduct likely to drive the complainant to suicide or cause grave injury "as define in Clause (a) of Section 86", and no allegation of harassment for an unlawful demand within clause (b) S6.
A rendering reproduced as found. The order refers to "Clause (a) or (b) of explanation to Section 86 of the BNS" S6 — but Section 86 has no Explanation; (a) and (b) are the section's own clauses. (C) Editorially that reads like the Penal Code's structure persisting in judicial language after the split. Nothing is inferred from it.
Outcome: both applications allowed; the FIR under BNS ss. 85, 351(2), 351(3) and 3(5), the charge-sheet and the case QUASHED qua the applicants under BNSS s. 528 S6.
Authorities cited but NOT retrieved: U. Suvetha [2009 (6) SCC 757]; Punam Sureshrao Aundhakar [Cri. APL 677/2023]; Abdul Salim Ahmad Abdul Jabbar [Cri. APL 1054/2022].
7.2 Mrs. Manisha Kishor Barapatre v. State of Maharashtra — Bombay High Court, Nagpur Bench, 10 August 2026
APL No. 223 of 2026, 2026:BHC-NAG:10542 S7. The Court recorded that it was "pertinent to analyze Sections 85 and 86 of the BNS so as to reach to a proper conclusion", and set them out S7. Outcome: partly allowed — dismissed as not pressed for one applicant, with an express direction that the Trial Court not be influenced by the observations made, and allowed for two others, the FIR under ss. 85 and 3(5) being quashed and set aside qua them S7. Cites Ghanshyam Soni [2025 INSC 803] — not retrieved.
7.3 Shyam Narayan Lal v. The State of Jharkhand — Jharkhand High Court, 2 December 2025
Cr. M. P. No. 2348 of 2025, Anil Kumar Choudhary J., 2025:JHHC:36681 S9.
This is the one retrieved matter where Section 86 is engaged at sub-clause level. Counsel submitted that nothing was done with intention to cause or inflict grave injury or to abet suicide, "hence, the same will not amount to cruelty under Section 86(a) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita" S9.
(C) That is a fact about how the split is being used in argument — the definition now has a section number, so a limb of it can be cited as "86(a)". Under the Penal Code the same argument would have been put as a limb of an Explanation. Nothing further is inferred.
Outcome: the Court held the offence under Section 85 was not made out even taking the allegations as true in their entirety, and QUASHED the proceeding qua the petitioners; petition allowed S9.
7.4 Satyadev Tiwari v. State of Chhattisgarh — Chhattisgarh High Court, Division Bench, 13 August 2026
CRMP No. 1810 of 2026, Ramesh Sinha CJ and Ravindra Kumar Agrawal J., 2026:CGHC:35948-DB S8. Decided on the absence of "sufficient and specific material constituting the ingredients of the offence punishable under Section 85", particularly as to individual role; proceedings quashed S8. It does not construe Section 86's clauses.
7.5 On the fact that all four quashed
All four retrieved decisions quashed proceedings, one partly. NO inference about outcomes is drawn, for two reasons set out in full in the Section 85 article: the field hit the display limit, and the sample is self-selected in a direction — successful High Court quashing orders are far more likely to be reported and indexed than dismissals or post-trial convictions.
8. The live site's existing dataset
The dataset has no separate entry for Section 86. Its entry for IPC 498A maps to BNS 85 and correctly notes that the definition of cruelty is "carried into the accompanying Section 86" S10.
But that entry records the key difference as "Added provisions for mental cruelty", and its existing long-form content states that "The new code expressly recognises mental cruelty alongside physical cruelty."
That is wrong, and Section 86 is where it is demonstrably wrong. The words "(whether mental or physical)" sit in clause (a) of Section 86 and sat in IPC 498A's Explanation, inside the 1983 insertion bracket S3. The Sanhita added nothing about mental cruelty. The two things it did add or alter in this definition are the re-pointed cross-reference and the word "or" — neither touches mental cruelty.
Update, 10 November 2026: the mapping table has since been corrected against the bare Acts. The IPC 498A entry now reads: punishment "Same - Up to 3 years with fine"; key difference "Same offence and punishment. The definition of cruelty, which already covered mental harm, is now a separate section, BNS 86". The long-form text that quoted the same claim was corrected at the same time.
That long-form content is existing website content. It has NOT been altered, reproduced or incorporated by this article — this is a separate piece of work, and the discrepancy is recorded here only so that a human reviewer can see it. This is the sixteenth distinct outcome recorded for that dataset in this collection, and the second flatly incorrect one in succession.
9. Procedure, and what is not stated
Section 86 creates no offence, so questions of cognizability, bailability and compounding do not arise for it directly; they arise for Section 85, and the Section 85 article records that none of the three is stated, the BNSS First Schedule not having been examined.
Two verified points S5:
- The BNSS does not name BNS Section 85 or Section 86 anywhere, tested in four formulations.
- BNSS s. 219(1)'s complaint bar stops at BNS Section 84 — a control confirmed "sections 81 to 85" appears nowhere in the BNSS.
Number-collision warning. Provisions numbered 86 exist in both the BNSS (concerning a written request from a police officer) and the BSA (a presumption about secure electronic records) S1S5. Check the subject matter before relying on an abbreviated reference to "section 86".
Meaning of "offence". Section 86 appears in neither list in BNS s. 2(24) S1.
10. Verification record
- Inventory sanity: 515 characters, ends at a full stop — but see section 6: the inventory text carries two stray full stops absent from the Gazette. The quotation in section 1 follows the Gazette.
- Candidate lines printed before extraction: IPC 498A's title appears at line 876 (table of contents) and line 7549 (body); scoped to the body.
- Lone footnote digits and "Ins./Subs." footnote lines excised before comparison; slice length printed and asserted.
- Word-level diff: three reported differences, resolved as two real changes and one inventory artefact.
- The added "or" verified three ways: positive test on the Gazette; negative control on the Penal Code that could have failed and did not; independent corroboration from a judgment's quotation.
- A control confirmed no "or" was added at the end of clause (b).
- A raw-text Gazette test for "(whether mental or physical)" returned False; this was NOT a discrepancy but line-splitting in the raw extract — the normalised test passes S2.
- Chapter and sub-heading structure established by locating all five Chapter V sub-headings by index and checking containment by bounds.
- Judgment quotations compared word-level against the official text; duplicate-document check run; duplication scans run on all four judgments.
- The dataset entry was read only after the statutory comparison was complete.
11. Open questions and what was not done
- What the added "or" does is LEFT OPEN — the principal item for human review on this section. No decision addressing the addition was retrieved, and the one Court that quoted the section with the "or" in it did not remark on it.
- Whether the definition can be used in construing any provision other than Section 85 is NOT analysed. On the words it operates "for the purposes of section 85".
- None of the definition's terms is construed here — "wilful", "is likely to", "grave injury", "harassment", "unlawful demand", "any person related to her".
- Penal Code case law on Section 498A's Explanation was NOT surveyed, and it is large. This is the most significant gap on this section.
- The field of Sanhita case law was NOT surveyed — the principal query hit the display limit.
- No inference is drawn from the fact that all four retrieved decisions quashed proceedings.
- The short title of Act 46 of 1983 is NOT verified, and no amending Act has ever been retrieved in this project.
- State amendments were not examined.
- The inventory data defect at Section 86 has been logged for a project-level audit, alongside the truncation found at Section 72.
12. How this article was prepared
Prepared with AI assistance. Statutory text was verified against the Gazette texts of the Sanhita and the BNSS and against the India Code repository; a defect in the project's own inventory was found by that comparison and is disclosed above. Judgments were obtained from a judgment-text repository, each checked at page level, and duplicates identified by full-text comparison. Research notes and the verification record are kept separate from this article.
No lawyer has reviewed this article and no human legal review is claimed. Its status is "ready for human review" — ready to be checked by a person, not already checked.
This article does not reproduce or alter any existing content on this website.
Law checked as of the date recorded in this article's metadata. Statutes and case law change, and this article is not legal advice. What the added "or" does, whether particular conduct falls within clause (a) or clause (b), and what follows in any given case, are matters only a court can determine on the evidence before it, and no outcome in any case is guaranteed. Verify the current position and take advice from a qualified advocate before acting.