A note on what this article is. This is a research-and-verification write-up of a single section of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023. Every statutory quotation was tested against a primary source before it was written down, and artefacts of my own extraction are disclosed. It separates (A) what the statute says, (B) what retrieved courts have said, and (C) clearly-labelled editorial observation. It is not legal advice.
1. The section, in full
BNS Section 85 is titled "Husband or relative of husband of a woman subjecting her to cruelty." It reads S1:
"Whoever, being the husband or the relative of the husband of a woman, subjects such woman to cruelty shall be punished with imprisonment for a term which may extend to three years and shall also be liable to fine."
That is the whole section: no sub-sections, no clauses, no proviso, and no Explanation S1. The absence of an Explanation is the point of this section, and section 2 explains why.
Note what Section 85 does NOT contain: a definition of "cruelty". That now sits in Section 86, a separate numbered section with its own title.
Commencement: 1 July 2024, by notification S.O. 850(E) dated 23 February 2024 S4.
2. The comparison with the Penal Code
Section 85 corresponds to IPC Section 498A, whose title was identical S3.
The operative sentence is word for word identical. A word-level comparison of IPC 498A's operative sentence against Section 85 produced ZERO differences: 213 characters against 213 S3.
What changed is structural. IPC 498A consisted of an operative sentence plus an Explanation defining "cruelty" in clauses (a) and (b). The Sanhita split that single section in two:
| Penal Code | Sanhita |
|---|---|
| s. 498A, operative sentence | s. 85 (identical) |
| s. 498A, Explanation | s. 86, a separate section titled "Cruelty defined." |
Classification: split_or_reorganised. The companion article on Section 86 analyses the definition itself, where two real textual changes were found.
A new title that did not exist before. The words "Cruelty defined" appear nowhere in the Penal Code S3. The Explanation had no heading of its own. They do appear in the Gazette text of the Sanhita S2. The definition has been promoted from an unlabelled Explanation to a titled section.
3. An entire Penal Code chapter was abolished
This is the finding a reader is least likely to know, and it was verified on both texts.
In the Penal Code, Section 498A had a chapter to itself. It was the sole section of Chapter XXA, headed "OF CRUELTY BY HUSBAND OR RELATIVES OF HUSBAND" S3.
In the Sanhita there is no such chapter and no such sub-heading. The words "Of cruelty" and "OF CRUELTY" appear NOWHERE in the Gazette text S2.
Instead, Sections 85 and 86 sit inside Chapter V, "Of offences against woman and child", under the sub-heading "Of offences relating to marriage". Chapter V carries exactly five sub-headings, located by index on the Gazette text S2:
- Of sexual offences
- Of criminal force and assault against woman
- Of offences relating to marriage ← Sections 85 and 86 are here
- Of causing miscarriage, etc.
- Of offences against child
Sections 85 and 86 fall between the third sub-heading and the fourth, verified by index bounds rather than by heading proximity S2.
(C) Editorial observation, clearly labelled. The cruelty offence has gone from occupying its own chapter to being one entry among several under a marriage sub-heading. This article does not say what, if anything, follows from that. No decision was retrieved that turns on the relocation, and headings and chapter titles are notoriously double-edged as aids to construction. It is recorded because it is true and because it is the kind of fact that a reader comparing the two codes would want to know.
This is the third "unchanged section, changed surroundings" finding in this collection. At Section 80 not a word changed but the section moved chapters; at Section 83 not a word changed but the clause interpreting its only pronoun did; here the operative words are untouched while the chapter housing them was abolished and its definition hived off into a section of its own.
4. Provenance: the whole of this offence is 1983 law, not Sanhita reform
Since Section 74 this collection has repeatedly found that an apparent Sanhita reform is much older law. At Sections 81 to 84 that run broke: all four appeared to carry wording of 1860. At Section 85 the run resumes, and decisively.
In the Penal Code, a footnote marker opens immediately before the Chapter XXA heading, and the matching closing bracket falls at the very end of Section 498A S3. The bracket pair therefore encloses the chapter heading and the whole of the section, Explanation included.
The footnote for that marker reads S3:
"Ins. by Act 46 of 1983, s. 2 (w.e.f. 25-12-1983)."
The checks I ran before attributing it, because the rule adopted at Section 82 is that a footnote must not be attributed until its attachment is confirmed:
- the bracket pair's span was located by index on both ends, confirming it covers heading-through-section-end;
- the string "Act 46 of 1983" occurs exactly once in the file examined;
- Section 498A carries no further inline footnote marker of its own.
So the cruelty offence entered the Penal Code on 25 December 1983, with its own chapter, by Act 46 of 1983, section 2. Everything in BNS Section 85: the actor formula, the three-year maximum, the mandatory fine: is that 1983 text, reproduced without alteration.
Limits, stated plainly. The short title of Act 46 of 1983 has NOT been verified, and no amending Act has ever been retrieved in this project. What the 1983 Act's own history was, and whether Section 498A was amended after 1983, were not traced beyond the absence of further markers.
5. Punishment, and what the section does not say
Imprisonment for a term which may extend to three years, and a fine which the section makes mandatory: "shall also be liable to fine" S1.
- There is no minimum. "Not be less than", "minimum" and "rigorous" are all absent S1.
- Section 85 does not use the phrase "imprisonment of either description". It says simply "imprisonment for a term". That differs from Sections 82, 83 and 84, each of which uses "either description" S1. What follows from that difference is not analysed here.
- Section 86 carries no punishment at all: it contains none of "punish", "imprison" or "fine" S1. It is purely definitional.
Meaning of "offence" here. Neither Section 85 nor Section 86 appears in either list in BNS s. 2(24) S1, so the narrow default applies.
6. Procedure: Section 85 is OUTSIDE the complaint bar that governs its neighbours
The companion articles on Sections 81 to 84 record BNSS Section 219(1), which bars a Court from taking cognizance of offences under BNS Sections 81 to 84 (both inclusive) except on a complaint by an aggrieved person.
Section 85 is outside that bar, and this was verified rather than assumed: the string "sections 81 to 85" appears NOWHERE in the BNSS S5. The range stops at 84.
Further verified points S5:
- The BNSS does not name BNS Section 85 or Section 86 anywhere, tested in four formulations.
- No row for this offence was found in the portion of the BNSS s. 359(1) compounding Table examined. The phrase "Husband or relative of husband" is absent from that region. That is stated as a limit on what was examined, NOT as a finding that the offence is non-compoundable.
Whether this offence is cognizable or bailable is NOT stated in this article. That depends on the First Schedule to the BNSS, which was not examined. The website's own existing dataset asserts that the offence is cognizable S10; this article does not adopt that proposition, because it was not verified here.
A number-collision warning. A provision numbered 85 exists in the BNSS: concerning attachment of property of a person absconding, following the proclamation provision in BNSS s. 84, and referring to a receiver and to the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908: and in the BSA, concerning a presumption about certain electronic agreements. Provisions numbered 86 exist in both as well S1S5. Check the subject matter before relying on an abbreviated reference.
7. What the courts have said
The field was NOT surveyed, and that must be said first. The repository displays at most ten results, and the principal query for this section returned ten: meaning there is more case law than was seen. Section 85 is the successor to one of the most litigated provisions in Indian criminal law, and nothing below should be read as a survey.
Four distinct decisions were examined. Two further documents were found to be duplicates and were not counted twice: see section 9.
7.1 Kanyalal Guruprasad Gupta and Others v. The State of Maharashtra: Bombay High Court, Nagpur Bench, 14 August 2026
Criminal Application (APL) Nos. 32 of 2026 and 40 of 2026, M. W. Chandwani J., 2026:BHC-NAG:10870 S6.
The Court set out Sections 85 and 86, and its quotation of Section 85 is word for word the official text: verified by word-level comparison, 213 characters against 213, zero differences. Its quotation of Section 86 differs by one token only: the length of a dash S6.
Independent corroboration of a textual finding. The Court's quotation of Section 86 contains the word "or" at the end of clause (a) S6, which is one of the two real changes identified in the companion article on Section 86, now confirmed from a source independent of the Gazette extract.
The construction of "relative of the husband". The Court held S6:
"for bringing a person within the ambit of Section 85 of the BNS, he must be the husband or relative of the husband."
Applying that, it held that an applicant who was "not a relative of co-accused … out of marriage, blood or by adoption and … belongs to a different family" could not be termed a relative of the husband, and that allegations that she had a relationship with the husband and went about with him would not fall within the section S6.
Three renderings reproduced as found, with no conclusion drawn S6:
- At one point the order says "Section 85 of the IPC" where the context is plainly the Sanhita. This is the seventh citation discrepancy recorded in this collection. It is reproduced as found.
- The order paraphrases the section as "whoever being in the role of the husband or relative of the husband": words not in the section.
- The order refers to "Clause (a) or (b) of explanation to Section 86 of the BNS", but Section 86 has no Explanation; (a) and (b) are the section's own clauses. (C) Editorially, that reads like the Penal Code's structure persisting in judicial language after the split; nothing is inferred from it.
The order also uses "couture of Section 85" and "Sofaras", reproduced as found.
Outcome: both applications were allowed and FIR No. 10/2026 under BNS ss. 85, 351(2), 351(3) and 3(5), with the consequent charge-sheet and case, were QUASHED qua the applicants, under BNSS s. 528 S6.
Authorities cited but NOT retrieved: U. Suvetha v. State by Inspector of Police [2009 (6) SCC 757]; Punam Sureshrao Aundhakar v. State of Maharashtra [Cri. APL No. 677/2023, decided 19.10.2023]; Abdul Salim Ahmad Abdul Jabbar v. State of Maharashtra [Cri. APL No. 1054/2022]. No proposition in this article rests on any of them.
7.2 Mrs. Manisha Kishor Barapatre v. State of Maharashtra: Bombay High Court, Nagpur Bench, 10 August 2026
Criminal Application (APL) No. 223 of 2026, M. W. Chandwani J., 2026:BHC-NAG:10542 S7.
The Court recorded that it was "pertinent to analyze Sections 85 and 86 of the BNS so as to reach to a proper conclusion", and set them out S7. Counsel submitted that the complaint did not depict harassment on account of a demand of dowry and that vague and general allegations had been made S7.
Outcome: the application was PARTLY allowed. It was dismissed as not pressed for one applicant, with an express direction that the Trial Court should not be influenced by the observations made, and allowed for the other two, FIR No. 664/2025 under BNS ss. 85 and 3(5) and the consequent charge-sheet and case being quashed and set aside qua them S7.
Cites Ghanshyam Soni v. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi) [2025 INSC 803]: not retrieved.
7.3 Satyadev Tiwari v. State of Chhattisgarh: Chhattisgarh High Court, 13 August 2026
CRMP No. 1810 of 2026, Division Bench of Ramesh Sinha CJ and Ravindra Kumar Agrawal J., 2026:CGHC:35948-DB S8.
The petitioners were the father-in-law, mother-in-law, husband and brother-in-law; Crime No. 370/2025 was registered under BNS ss. 85 and 3(5) S8. The Court held that the FIR and charge-sheet "do not disclose sufficient and specific material constituting the ingredients of the offence punishable under Section 85", particularly as to the individual role of three of the petitioners, and noted that mediation, though unsuccessful, showed efforts to resolve the matrimonial dispute S8.
Outcome: petition allowed under BNSS s. 528; proceedings QUASHED qua the petitioners S8.
7.4 Shyam Narayan Lal v. The State of Jharkhand: Jharkhand High Court, 2 December 2025
Cr. M. P. No. 2348 of 2025, Anil Kumar Choudhary J., 2025:JHHC:36681 S9.
Quashing was sought of Chutia P.S. Case No. 114 of 2025 under BNS s. 85. Counsel submitted there was no allegation of a dowry demand or coercion, and framed the argument at sub-clause level. That the matter "will not amount to cruelty under Section 86(a) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita" S9. That is a sub-clause-level framing of the new definition section, and is recorded as a fact about how the split is being used in argument.
Outcome: the Court held that even taking the allegations as true in their entirety the offence under Section 85 was not made out, that continuation would be an abuse of the process of law, and QUASHED and set aside the entire proceeding qua the petitioners; the petition was allowed S9.
7.5 A pattern in these four, and why it must NOT be generalised
All four were quashed, one partly.
(C) That is a fact about these four decisions and it is expressly NOT offered as a pattern in the law. Two reasons, both of which matter:
- The field was not surveyed: the principal query hit the ten-result display limit.
- The sample is selected, and selected in a direction. Successful quashing applications in High Courts are the kind of order that is reported and indexed; dismissals and convictions after trial are far less likely to surface in a repository search of this kind. Drawing any inference about outcomes from four self-selected orders would be wrong, and this article does not do it.
Penal Code case law on Section 498A was NOT surveyed either. That body of law is very large and is entirely outside what this article examined, which matters greatly here, because Section 85's operative words are identical to Section 498A's.
8. Search position
| Query | Entries | Status |
|---|---|---|
| "section 85 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita" cruelty husband | 10 | LIMIT: FIELD NOT SURVEYED |
| "section 86 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita" cruelty defined | 7 | exhausted for this query |
| "85 and 86 of the BNS" cruelty 498A | 3 | exhausted for this query |
Official court portals were not used. Judgment texts come from a repository, not from an official reporter.
9. A new artefact class: the same judgment served under two identifiers
Two of the documents retrieved were not independent authorities, and treating them as such would have overstated the material twice over:
- Two documents carried the Kanyalal judgment text. A word-level comparison showed the only difference to be the party name in the heading. They are the judgment in the two connected applications, APL 32/2026 and APL 40/2026, uploaded under separate records S6.
- Two documents carried the Shyam Narayan Lal judgment and the two texts were BYTE-IDENTICAL S9.
Neither pair was counted twice. This is a new artefact class for this project, and the check that caught it, comparing full bodies when two results have suspiciously similar lengths, is now part of the method.
10. The live site's existing dataset: correct in part, and wrong on the headline
The dataset entry for IPC 498A maps it to BNS 85, records the punishment as "Same - Up to 3 years with fine", and states that the definition of cruelty is "carried into the accompanying Section 86". All of that is correct S10.
But the same entry says the key difference is "Added provisions for mental cruelty", and its existing long-form content states that "The new code expressly recognises mental cruelty alongside physical cruelty."
That is wrong, and it is wrong on a verifiable point. The words "(whether mental or physical)" were in IPC Section 498A's Explanation, and a control placed that phrase inside the 1983 insertion bracket S3. The Sanhita added nothing about mental cruelty. Section 85's operative text is identical to Section 498A's, and Section 86 differs from the Explanation in exactly two respects, neither of which touches mental cruelty: the cross-reference and the inserted "or".
Update, 10 November 2026: the mapping table has since been corrected against the bare Acts. The IPC 498A entry now reads: punishment "Same - Up to 3 years with fine"; key difference "Same offence and punishment. The definition of cruelty, which already covered mental harm, is now a separate section, BNS 86". The long-form text that quoted the same claim was corrected at the same time.
The entry also asserts that the offence is cognizable; this article does not adopt that, for the reason given in section 6.
That long-form content is existing website content. It has NOT been altered, reproduced or incorporated by this article. This article is a separate piece of work, and the discrepancy is recorded here only so that a human reviewer can see it. This is the sixteenth distinct outcome recorded for that dataset in this collection, and the second flatly incorrect one in succession (the other being the IPC 498 entry discussed in the Section 84 article).
11. Verification record
- Inventory sanity: 213 characters, ends at a full stop; defect scan clean S1.
- Candidate lines printed before extraction (the rule adopted at Section 84): IPC 498A's title appears at line 876 (table of contents) and line 7549 (body). Scoped to the body line.
- Lone footnote digits and "Ins./Subs." footnote lines excised before comparison; slice length printed and asserted.
- Word-level diff of operative sentences: zero differences. Title comparison: identical.
- Footnote attachment confirmed by locating BOTH ends of the bracket pair, before any attribution: the rule from Section 82, here producing a positive result rather than a negative one.
- Gazette verification fragment by fragment. A raw-text test for "(whether mental or physical)" returned False; this was NOT a discrepancy but line-splitting in the raw extract: the normalised test passes S2.
- Chapter and sub-heading structure established by locating all five Chapter V sub-headings by index and checking containment by bounds, not proximity S2.
- Judgment quotations compared word-level against the official text; duplicate-document check run on suspiciously similar results; duplication scans run on all four judgments.
- The dataset entry was read only after the statutory comparison was complete.
12. Open questions and what was not done
- "Cruelty" is defined in Section 86 and that definition is NOT construed here: see the companion article, which also leaves its central questions open.
- "Relative of the husband" has been construed in ONE retrieved decision only, on its own facts, in a field that was not surveyed.
- Penal Code case law on Section 498A was NOT surveyed. This is the most significant gap on this section.
- What follows from the abolition of Chapter XXA and the relocation of the offence is LEFT OPEN.
- What follows from Section 85 saying "imprisonment for a term" rather than "imprisonment of either description" is NOT analysed.
- Whether this offence is cognizable or bailable is NOT stated. The BNSS First Schedule was not examined; nor is non-compoundability asserted.
- The short title of Act 46 of 1983 is NOT verified, and no amending Act has ever been retrieved in this project; Section 498A's post-1983 history was not traced.
- State amendments were not examined.
- No conclusion is drawn from the fact that all four retrieved decisions quashed proceedings. The sample is small, self-selected and drawn from an unsurveyed field.
13. How this article was prepared
Prepared with AI assistance. Statutory text was verified against the Gazette texts of the Sanhita and the BNSS and against the India Code repository; judgments were obtained from a judgment-text repository, each checked at page level, and duplicates identified by full-text comparison. Research notes and the verification record are kept separate from this article.
No lawyer has reviewed this article and no human legal review is claimed. Its status is "ready for human review": ready to be checked by a person, not already checked.
This article does not reproduce or alter any existing content on this website.
Law checked as of the date recorded in this article's metadata. Statutes and case law change, and this article is not legal advice. Whether the ingredients of Section 85 are made out in any given case, who is a relative of the husband on particular facts, and what sentence may follow, are matters only a court can determine on the evidence before it, and no outcome in any case is guaranteed. Verify the current position and take advice from a qualified advocate before acting.