What Section 5 does
Section 5 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 ("BNS") is one sentence long:
"The appropriate Government may, without the consent of the offender, commute any punishment under this Sanhita to any other punishment in accordance with section 474 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023."
It is followed by an Explanation defining "appropriate Government". S1S2
Three things are built into that sentence, and each matters:
- The power is executive, not judicial. It belongs to the "appropriate Government", not to the sentencing court. A court that has passed sentence cannot commute it under this section.
- The convict's consent is irrelevant. The words "without the consent of the offender" mean a prisoner cannot refuse a commutation: a point with real history, since a person sentenced to death cannot insist on execution rather than life imprisonment.
- The limits are not in the BNS. Section 5 confers the power but exports the substantive limits to section 474 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 ("BNSS"). Reading Section 5 alone tells you nothing about what a sentence may be commuted to.
That third point is the single most important thing about this section, and it is where the real change from the IPC lies.
The mapping: three IPC sections collapsed into one
| BNS s. 5 | IPC source | Change |
|---|---|---|
| Operative sentence (power to commute any punishment, in accordance with BNSS s. 474) | ss. 54 and 55 | Consolidated, and the substantive limits removed to the BNSS |
| Explanation, cls. (a) and (b) ("appropriate Government") | s. 55A | Verbatim |
The IPC kept the power and its limits together, in two separate sections:
- IPC s. 54: "Commutation of sentence of death": where a sentence of death had been passed, the appropriate Government could commute the punishment "for any other punishment provided by this Code".
- IPC s. 55: "Commutation of sentence of imprisonment for life": where a sentence of imprisonment for life had been passed, the appropriate Government could commute it "for imprisonment of either description for a term not exceeding fourteen years".
- IPC s. 55A: defined "appropriate Government" for ss. 54 and 55. S4
BNS s. 5 merges all three. The Explanation reproduces IPC s. 55A word for word, so the question of who exercises the power is unchanged:
- Central Government where the sentence is one of death, or is for an offence against a law relating to a matter within the Union's executive power; and
- State Government where the sentence (whether of death or not) is for an offence against a law relating to a matter within the State's executive power. The State "within which the offender is sentenced". S1S4
The two changes of substance in the BNS text itself
First, the fourteen-year cap has gone from the penal code. IPC s. 55 limited commutation of a life sentence to a term "not exceeding fourteen years". BNS s. 5 contains no such figure and no cap at all. S1S4
Second, the section now speaks of "any punishment", not just death and life imprisonment. IPC ss. 54 and 55 addressed only those two sentences. BNS s. 5 is drafted generally. But the apparent breadth is controlled, because the power must be exercised "in accordance with section 474" of the BNSS, and that section works through a closed list.
Where the limits actually live: BNSS s. 474
Because BNS s. 5 incorporates it by reference, BNSS s. 474 is not optional reading. It provides that the appropriate Government may, without the consent of the person sentenced, commute: S5
| BNSS s. 474 | Sentence | May be commuted to |
|---|---|---|
| (a) | death | imprisonment for life |
| (b) | imprisonment for life | imprisonment for a term not less than seven years |
| (c) | imprisonment for seven years or more | imprisonment for a term not less than three years |
| (d) | imprisonment for less than seven years | fine |
| (e) | rigorous imprisonment | simple imprisonment for any term to which that person might have been sentenced |
Note the structure. Clauses (b) and (c) set floors, not ceilings. They do not say how short a commuted term may not be exceeded; they say how short it may not fall below.
How this differs from the pre-2024 procedural position
The predecessor was s. 433 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 ("CrPC"), which is worth setting out because the differences are substantial and run in both directions. S6
| CrPC s. 433 | BNSS s. 474 | Effect of the change |
|---|---|---|
| (a) death → "any other punishment provided by the Indian Penal Code" | (a) death → imprisonment for life only | Narrowed. A death sentence can no longer be commuted directly to a fixed term or to a fine |
| (b) life → imprisonment for a term not exceeding fourteen years, or fine | (b) life → imprisonment for a term not less than seven years | Reversed in function: a ceiling becomes a floor. The option of commuting a life sentence to a fine is removed |
| (c) rigorous imprisonment → simple imprisonment for any term to which sentenced, or fine | (e) rigorous → simple imprisonment for any term to which sentenced | The fine option is removed |
| (d) simple imprisonment → fine | — | No direct counterpart |
| — | (c) imprisonment of seven years or more → not less than three years | New |
| — | (d) imprisonment of less than seven years → fine | New, and wider than CrPC (d), which applied only to simple imprisonment |
Editorial analysis. Read together, the change is not simply "stricter" or "more lenient". The death-sentence limb is clearly narrower: commutation of death now has one destination, imprisonment for life. The life-sentence limb is harder to characterise: the removal of the fourteen-year ceiling in favour of a seven-year floor means a commuted life sentence can in principle now be longer than fourteen years, which is stricter, while the floor itself is lower than the old ceiling. And the new clauses (c) and (d) extend the commutation structure to ordinary fixed-term sentences, which the CrPC addressed only patchily. Anyone describing this as a uniform tightening or a uniform relaxation is not describing the text.
The fourteen years did not disappear: it changed job
This is the point most likely to mislead a reader who notices that IPC s. 55's cap is gone.
The figure of fourteen years survives, but it has moved from being a limit on commutation to being a minimum period of actual imprisonment before release. BNSS s. 475 provides that notwithstanding s. 473, where a sentence of imprisonment for life is imposed for an offence for which death is one of the punishments provided by law, or where a death sentence has been commuted under s. 474 into imprisonment for life, "such person shall not be released from prison unless he had served at least fourteen years of imprisonment." S5
That mirrors the former CrPC s. 433A, which was in the same terms by reference to CrPC s. 432. S6 So the structural position is preserved: the fourteen-year figure is a floor on release in the gravest cases, not a cap on how a life sentence may be converted.
Commutation is not pardon, remission, suspension or parole
Section 5 is narrow, and conflating it with neighbouring concepts is the commonest error here.
- Commutation substitutes a different and lesser kind or degree of punishment for the one imposed. That is what s. 5 and BNSS s. 474 do.
- Remission reduces the quantum of a sentence without changing its character: dealt with elsewhere in the BNSS, and expressly referred to in s. 475 ("Notwithstanding anything contained in section 473").
- Pardon and the constitutional clemency powers are different again, and are not affected by s. 5. The Constitution separately confers power on the President under Article 72 and on the Governor of a State under Article 161 to grant pardons and to suspend, remit or commute sentences. S7 Those are constitutional powers and operate independently of the statutory power in BNS s. 5 read with BNSS s. 474; nothing in the BNS could curtail them.
Two allocation rules that qualify who may act, and one real tightening
BNSS s. 476 gives the Central Government a concurrent power, in the case of sentences of death, to exercise the powers conferred on the State Government by ss. 473 and 474. That reproduces CrPC s. 434. S5S6
BNSS s. 477 restricts the State Government's power, and here the BNSS is stricter than the CrPC in two distinct ways. Where the sentence is for an offence (a) investigated by any agency empowered to investigate an offence under any Central Act other than the BNSS, (b) involving misappropriation or destruction of or damage to property belonging to the Central Government, or (c) committed by a person in the service of the Central Government acting or purporting to act in the discharge of official duty, the State Government's power "shall not be exercised … except after concurrence with the Central Government". S5
Compare CrPC s. 435, whose marginal note read "State Government to act after consultation with Central Government in certain cases", and whose clause (a) named "the Delhi Special Police Establishment constituted under the Delhi Special Police Establishment Act, 1946 … or any other agency empowered to make investigation" into such an offence. S6
So two changes, both on the face of the text:
- "Consultation" has become "concurrence." Consultation requires the Central Government to be asked; concurrence requires it to agree. On the ordinary meaning of those words the State Government's power in these classes of case is now conditional on Central agreement rather than merely on Central input.
- The agency limb is generalised. The BNSS drops the express reference to the Delhi Special Police Establishment and covers any agency empowered to investigate under any Central Act other than the BNSS itself.
No judicial decision on BNSS s. 477 was located, so the practical effect of the move from consultation to concurrence is stated here as a textual reading, not as settled law.
Worked examples
Hypothetical illustrations constructed for this article, not decided cases.
1. Death sentence. A is sentenced to death. Under BNS s. 5 with BNSS s. 474(a), the appropriate Government (the Central Government, since the sentence is one of death) may commute it to imprisonment for life, and to nothing else. Under the IPC and CrPC it could have been commuted to "any other punishment provided by the Indian Penal Code", which was wider. S1S4S5S6
2. Death commuted, then release sought. A's sentence having been commuted to imprisonment for life under s. 474(a), A applies for release after ten years. BNSS s. 475 bars release before A has served at least fourteen years. S5
3. Life sentence for an offence not carrying death. B is sentenced to imprisonment for life for an offence for which death is not a punishment. Commutation under s. 474(b) must be to a term of not less than seven years. Section 475's fourteen-year bar is by its terms confined to offences for which death is one of the punishments provided by law, and to death sentences commuted under s. 474: so it does not apply to B on these facts. S5
4. A ten-year sentence. C is sentenced to ten years' imprisonment. Clause (c) applies, as the sentence is of seven years or more, and commutation must be to a term of not less than three years. Under CrPC s. 433 there was no equivalent clause for a fixed term of this length. S5S6
5. A three-year rigorous sentence. D is sentenced to three years' rigorous imprisonment. Two clauses are capable of applying: clause (d), as the sentence is of less than seven years, allowing commutation to a fine; and clause (e), allowing commutation of rigorous imprisonment to simple imprisonment for any term to which D might have been sentenced. S5
6. Refusal is not open to the convict. E, sentenced to death and commuted to imprisonment for life, objects. The words "without the consent of the offender" in s. 5 mean E's objection is irrelevant to the validity of the commutation. S1
Common mistakes
- Reading s. 5 on its own. It states the power; the permissible conversions are in BNSS s. 474, which s. 5 expressly incorporates. S1S5
- Saying the BNS abolished the fourteen-year limit on commuting a life sentence. The cap in IPC s. 55 is indeed gone, but fourteen years reappears in BNSS s. 475 as a minimum period of actual imprisonment before release in the gravest cases. Its function changed; it did not vanish. S1S4S5
- Treating clauses (b) and (c) of BNSS s. 474 as maxima. They are minima: "not less than seven years", "not less than three years". S5
- Assuming a death sentence can be commuted to a fixed term. Under BNSS s. 474(a) the only destination is imprisonment for life. That is narrower than CrPC s. 433(a). S5S6
- Thinking a court can commute under s. 5. The power is the appropriate Government's. S1
- Using commutation and remission interchangeably. Commutation changes the kind of punishment; remission reduces its quantum, and BNSS s. 475 opens with a non-obstante reference to the remission provision in s. 473. S5
- Assuming s. 5 limits the President or a Governor. The clemency powers under Articles 72 and 161 of the Constitution are separate and unaffected. S7
- Assuming the State Government always decides. The Explanation allocates the power by subject matter and makes death sentences Central; BNSS s. 476 gives the Central Government a concurrent power in death cases, and s. 477 now requires Central concurrence, not merely consultation, as under CrPC s. 435: in three defined classes of case. S1S5S6
On the "need for change"
- Documented section-specific legislative rationale: none was located for Section 5 while preparing this article, and none is asserted.
- What the texts establish: the BNS consolidated IPC ss. 54, 55 and 55A into one section, carried the "appropriate Government" definition across verbatim, and relocated the substantive limits on commutation from the penal code to BNSS s. 474. In doing so the fourteen-year ceiling in IPC s. 55 was dropped, and BNSS s. 474 replaced the CrPC s. 433 structure with a five-clause scale built on minimum terms. S1S4S5S6
- Editorial assessment: the drafting choice is coherent: commutation is an executive act performed after sentence, so its machinery arguably belongs in the procedural code rather than the penal one. The practical consequence for a reader is that BNS s. 5 is now unusable in isolation. For anyone advising on a commutation application, the operative provisions are BNSS ss. 473 to 477, with BNS s. 5 supplying only the power and the identity of the appropriate Government.
Verified judicial interpretation
No judgment on BNS s. 5 or BNSS s. 474 was located while preparing this article; both have been in force only since 1 July 2024. S3
There is a substantial body of IPC-era and CrPC-era authority on commutation, remission and the fourteen-year rule under CrPC s. 433A. That authority is not summarised here, for a reason that should be stated plainly rather than glossed: the operative conversions have changed. A decision construing CrPC s. 433(b)'s ceiling of fourteen years cannot be carried across to BNSS s. 474(b)'s floor of seven years, because the provisions do different things. By contrast, authority on the nature of the power. That it is executive, that it does not require the convict's consent, and that it is distinct from the constitutional clemency powers: rests on wording that the BNS and BNSS reproduce, and is correspondingly more likely to survive. Readers relying on pre-2024 commutation authority should check the specific clause being construed before assuming it applies.
Related provisions in this collection
- BNS s. 4: the list of punishments that a commuted sentence must fall within.
- BNS s. 6: fractions of terms of punishment; the twenty-year equivalence for imprisonment for life, which is a computation rule and not a commutation rule.
- BNS s. 7: power of the court to direct that imprisonment be wholly or partly rigorous or simple, which should not be confused with the Government's power under s. 5 to commute rigorous to simple imprisonment.
- BNSS ss. 473 to 477: remission, commutation, the fourteen-year bar on release, the Central Government's concurrent power in death cases, and the requirement of Central concurrence before a State Government may remit or commute in the three classes of case listed in s. 477(1).
Sources and disclaimer
BNS text is from the Gazette of India publication of Act 45 of 2023 S1, cross-checked against the
India Code entry for the section S2. IPC text is from the India Code version of Act 45 of 1860
S4. BNSS text is from the Gazette publication of Act 46 of 2023 S5, and the title of BNSS
s. 474 was additionally confirmed from India Code. CrPC text is from the India Code version of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 S6. Constitutional provisions are identified from the official
text of the Constitution S7. Pinpoints and access dates are in the sources array.
This article is for education and general information. It is AI-assisted and has not been reviewed, verified or approved by a lawyer. It is not legal advice and must not be relied on for any actual case. Commutation is a discretionary executive decision; nothing here suggests that any application will or should succeed. Verify the current position and take advice from a qualified advocate before acting.