Overview and Statutory Function in Substantive Criminal Law
Section 274 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) criminalises the adulteration of any article of food or drink, so as to make such article noxious as food or drink, intending to sell such article as food or drink, or knowing it to be likely that the same will be sold as food or drink S1, Section 274. Situated in Chapter XV (Of Offences Affecting the Public Health, Safety, Convenience, Decency and Morals), Section 274 replaces Section 272 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC) S3, Section 272; S5, p. 28.
While Section 274 BNS retains the exact offence ingredients of IPC Section 272 and increases the statutory fine ceiling fivefold from Rs. 1,000 to Rs. 5,000 S1, Section 274; S3, Section 272; S5, p. 28, every practitioner must evaluate Section 274 BNS in light of the Supreme Court's landmark ruling in Ram Nath v. The State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors. (2024 INSC 138, decided 21 February 2024) S6, paras 18–23:
- In Ram Nath, the Supreme Court held that Section 89 read with Section 59 of the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006 (FSSA) gives the FSSA an overriding effect over general penal provisions on unsafe/noxious food (specifically IPC Sections 272 and 273, even as amended by states to carry life imprisonment), and that simultaneous prosecution under IPC Sections 272/273 is barred whenever the conduct is covered by Section 59 of the FSSA S6, paras 19–22.
- Because Section 1(6) BNS expressly provides that "Nothing in this Sanhita shall affect the provisions of any special law or local law" S1, Section 1(6), the special-law regime of the FSSA, 2006 and the Ram Nath ratio are critical when determining whether a police FIR or charge-sheet under Section 274 BNS is legally maintainable S1, Sections 1(6), 274; S6, paras 18–23.
Verbatim Statutory Text
Section 274 BNS reads as follows S1, Section 274:
"Whoever adulterates any article of food or drink, so as to make such article noxious as food or drink, intending to sell such article as food or drink, or knowing it to be likely that the same will be sold as food or drink, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to six months, or with fine which may extend to five thousand rupees, or with both." S1, Section 274.
Exact Offence Ingredients and Mental Element
To establish an offence under Section 274 BNS, the prosecution must prove three cumulative elements S1, Section 274:
- Act of Adulteration ("adulterates any article of food or drink"): The accused must mix, dilute, abstract from, or add an extraneous substance to an article of food or drink intended for human consumption S1, Section 274.
- Resulting Noxiousness ("so as to make such article noxious as food or drink"):
- This is the decisive threshold of Section 274 BNS: the adulteration must render the article "noxious" as food or drink: meaning injurious to health, unwholesome, poisonous, or deleterious to the human body S1, Section 274.
- Commercial Adulteration Without Noxiousness is NOT Covered by Section 274 BNS: Mixing clean potable water into pure milk, or mixing cheaper edible vegetable oil into pure ghee, reduces the commercial quality and nutritional value of the food (which may constitute cheating under Section 318 BNS or sub-standard food under Section 51 of the FSSA, 2006), but because clean water or edible oil does not make the milk or ghee noxious to health, it does not constitute an offence under Section 274 BNS S1, Section 274; S6.
- Commercial Mens Rea ("intending to sell such article as food or drink, or knowing it to be likely that the same will be sold as food or drink"):
- Section 274 BNS punishes the preparatory/manufacturing stage of noxious adulteration prior to actual sale S1, Section 274. Actual sale is not required under Section 274 BNS (actual sale or exposure for sale is covered by Section 275 BNS), provided the adulterator intended to sell the noxious article as food or drink or knew it was likely to be sold as such S1, Sections 274, 275.
- If a person adulterates food with poison to kill a specific enemy at a private dinner (with no intention or likelihood of sale), the act falls under homicide/attempt to murder or hurt by poison (Section 123 BNS, formerly Section 328 IPC), not Section 274 BNS S1, Sections 123, 274.
IPC-to-BNS Correspondence and State-Amendment Context
| Parameter | IPC Section 272 (1860) | BNS Section 274 (2023) | Legal Significance of Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Section Number | Section 272 S3 | Section 274 S1; S5, p. 28 | Renumbered in Chapter XV S5, p. 28. |
| Offence Ingredients | Adulterating food or drink so as to make it noxious, intending or knowing it likely to be sold as food or drink S3 | Identical S1, Section 274 | Complete continuity of central statutory ingredients S1; S3. |
| Maximum Fine | Up to Rs. 1,000 S3, Section 272 | Enhanced to Rs. 5,000 ("fine which may extend to five thousand rupees") S1, Section 274; S5, p. 28 | Fivefold enhancement of the statutory fine ceiling; maximum imprisonment remains 6 months of either description S1; S5, p. 28. |
| Prior State Amendments (UP, WB, Odisha) | State amendments in Uttar Pradesh (1975), West Bengal (1973), and Odisha (1999) had made IPC 272 cognizable, non-bailable, and punishable with imprisonment for life S6, para 2 | The central BNS text retains up to 6 months / Rs. 5,000 fine; moreover, Ram Nath (2024 INSC 138) held that the FSSA, 2006 overrode those IPC provisions S1; S6, paras 19–22 | Practitioners in UP, WB, and Odisha must verify both whether any post-2023 state amendment to BNS 274 has received Presidential assent under Article 254(2) and the overriding bar of the FSSA, 2006 recognized in Ram Nath S6. |
Punishment Matrix and BNSS Procedural Classification
Under the First Schedule to the BNSS, 2023, Section 274 BNS is classified as Non-Cognizable, Bailable, and triable by Any Magistrate S1, Section 274; S4, First Schedule, Entry 274:
| Section | Offence Description | Imprisonment Term & Type | Fine & Conjunction | Cognizability | Bailability | Triable By |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BNS 274 | Adulterating food or drink to make it noxious, intending or knowing it likely to be sold as food or drink S1, Section 274 | Up to 6 months (Imprisonment of either description: rigorous or simple) S1, Section 274 | Fine up to Rs. 5,000, or imprisonment, or both S1, Section 274 | Non-Cognizable S4, First Schedule, Entry 274 | Bailable S4, First Schedule, Entry 274 | Any Magistrate S4, First Schedule, Entry 274 |
Judicial Authorities: Special-Law Pre-emption by the FSSA, 2006
- Ram Nath v. The State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors., 2024 INSC 138; (2024) 3 SCC 502 (Decided 21 February 2024, Supreme Court of India: Abhay S. Oka and Sanjay Karol, JJ.) S6:
- Legal Issue: Whether the provisions of the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006 (FSSA) override Sections 272 and 273 of the IPC (including state amendments in Uttar Pradesh that prescribed life imprisonment under IPC 272/273), and whether police can register FIRs and prosecute accused persons under IPC Sections 272/273 for manufacturing or selling unsafe/adulterated food S6, paras 1–4.
- Holding and Ratio:
- The Supreme Court compared Section 59 of the FSSA, 2006 (which punishes any person who manufactures for sale, stores, sells, distributes, or imports any article of "unsafe food": defined in Section 3(1)(zz) FSSA as food whose nature, substance, or quality is so affected as to render it injurious to health, including by addition of any article or substance) with Sections 272 and 273 IPC (now Sections 274 and 275 BNS), which punish adulterating or selling "noxious" food or drink S6, paras 12–18.
- Because "noxious" food or drink under IPC 272/273 is synonymous with "unsafe food" injurious to health under Section 3(1)(zz) read with Section 59 of the FSSA, and because Section 89 of the FSSA gives the FSSA overriding effect over "any other food related law", the Court held that Section 59 of the FSSA overrides the provisions of Sections 272 and 273 of the IPC, and therefore "there will not be any question of simultaneous prosecution under both the statutes" S6, paras 19–22.
- Application to BNS Section 274: Although the BNS was enacted in December 2023 after the FSSA, 2006, Section 1(6) BNS explicitly saves all special laws ("Nothing in this Sanhita shall affect the provisions of any special law or local law"), and the FSSA contains an exhaustive statutory code for sampling, laboratory analysis by a Food Analyst, time-bound launching of prosecution by a designated Food Safety Officer, and graded penalties under Section 59 FSSA (up to life imprisonment where unsafe food results in death) S1, Section 1(6); S6, paras 14–22. Defence counsel facing a standalone police prosecution under Section 274 BNS for commercial food adulteration can invoke Ram Nath and Section 1(6) BNS to challenge police bypass of the mandatory FSSA procedure, while noting whether the prosecution contends that the BNS (as a 2023 central statute) alters the chronological pre-emption analysis of Section 89 FSSA S1, Sections 1(6), 274; S6, paras 18–23.
Practical Legal Distinctions, Hypotheticals, and Counterexamples
- Hypothetical 1: Noxious Adulteration vs. Non-Noxious Dilution:
- Case A (Noxious Adulteration: Section 274 BNS / Section 59 FSSA): M, a wholesale spice grinder, mixes toxic lead chromate into turmeric powder to give it a bright yellow colour, intending to sell it to retail grocers. Lead chromate is poisonous and injurious to human health ("noxious as food"). M's conduct satisfies the ingredients of Section 274 BNS (and Section 59 of the FSSA, 2006) S1, Section 274; S6, para 18.
- Case B (Non-Noxious Dilution, Not Section 274 BNS): N, a dairy vendor, adds 20% boiled, clean potable drinking water to buffalo milk before selling it. While N is liable for selling sub-standard food under the FSSA, 2006 (and potentially cheating under Section 318 BNS if sold as unadulterated full-cream milk), N is not guilty under Section 274 BNS because clean potable water does not render the milk "noxious" (injurious to health) S1, Section 274.