Overview: Affirmative Duties of Landowners, Beneficiaries, and Estate Agents
Historically, agrarian and urban land disputes in India frequently saw absentee landlords or estate managers instigating or quietly tolerating riots on their estates while remaining physically absent from the scene to avoid direct liability under Sections 189–191 BNS S1, s. 189-193; S3, s. 154-156.
Section 193 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) consolidates Sections 154, 155, and 156 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC) into three sub-sections S1, s. 193; S3, s. 154-156. All three sub-sections penalise breaches of affirmative statutory duties to give notice and use lawful means to prevent/suppress unlawful assemblies and riots, and all three are punishable with fine only (no substantive imprisonment) S1, s. 193(1)-(3).
Sub-Section-by-Sub-Section Analysis
1. Sub-section (1): Liability of Owner or Occupier of Land on Which Unlawful Assembly or Riot Takes Place (Formerly IPC Section 154)
Whenever any unlawful assembly or riot takes place, the owner or occupier of the land upon which such unlawful assembly is held, or such riot is committed, and any person having or claiming an interest in such land, shall be punishable with fine which may extend to one thousand rupees, if he or his agent or manager, knowing that such offence is being or has been committed, or having reason to believe that it is likely to be committed:
- does not give the earliest notice thereof in his or their power to the principal officer at the nearest police station; and
- does not, in the case of his or their having reason to believe that it was about to be committed, use all lawful means in his or their power to prevent it, and, in the event of its taking place, use all lawful means in his or their power to disperse or suppress the riot or unlawful assembly S1, s. 193(1); S3, s. 154.
Notable Strict Vicarious Feature of Sub-section (1): Notice the words "if he or his agent or manager, knowing..." S1, s. 193(1). Under Section 193(1) BNS, an absentee landowner can be fined up to ₹1,000 for the omission and knowledge of their resident agent or manager, even if the landowner personally had no knowledge of the gathering: one of the rare instances of vicarious statutory liability for an agent's omission in Indian criminal law, justified by the fact that the penalty is capped at a ₹1,000 fine with no imprisonment S1, s. 193(1); S3, s. 154.
2. Sub-section (2): Liability of Person for Whose Benefit a Riot Is Committed (Formerly IPC Section 155)
Whenever a riot is committed for the benefit or on behalf of any person who is the owner or occupier of any land respecting which such riot takes place or who claims any interest in such land, or in the subject of any dispute which gave rise to the riot, or who has accepted or derived any benefit therefrom, such person shall be punishable with fine, if he or his agent or manager, having reason to believe that such riot was likely to be committed or that the unlawful assembly by which such riot was committed was likely to be held, shall not respectively use all lawful means in his or their power to prevent such assembly or riot from taking place, and for suppressing and dispersing the same S1, s. 193(2); S3, s. 155.
Key Differences Between Sub-section (1) and Sub-section (2):
- Locus vs. Benefit: Sub-section (1) applies to the owner/occupier of the land on which the unlawful assembly or riot physically takes place (even if the riot is not for their benefit), whereas Sub-section (2) applies when an actual riot is committed for the benefit or on behalf of a person claiming an interest in the disputed land or subject matter (even if the riot physically spills onto a public road or a neighbour's plot) S1, s. 193(1)-(2).
- Fine Quantum: Sub-section (1) caps the fine at ₹1,000, whereas Sub-section (2) prescribes an unlimited fine (subject to Section 8(2) BNS that where no sum is expressed, the fine is unlimited, provided it shall not be excessive) S1, s. 8(2), s. 193(1)-(2).
3. Sub-section (3): Personal Liability of the Agent or Manager (Formerly IPC Section 156)
Whenever a riot is committed for the benefit or on behalf of any person who is the owner or occupier of any land respecting which such riot takes place, or who claims any interest in such land, or in the subject of any dispute which gave rise to the riot, or who has accepted or derived any benefit therefrom, the agent or manager of such person shall be punishable with fine, if such agent or manager, having reason to believe that such riot was likely to be committed, or that the unlawful assembly by which such riot was committed was likely to be held, shall not use all lawful means in his power to prevent such riot or assembly from taking place and for suppressing and dispersing the same S1, s. 193(3); S3, s. 156.
Whereas Sub-section (2) holds the principal/owner liable for the omission of the principal or agent, Sub-section (3) holds the agent or manager personally liable for the agent's own knowledge and omission S1, s. 193(2)-(3).
IPC-to-BNS Comparison Table
| BNS Sub-section | Former IPC Section | Target Accused & Trigger | Punishment | BNSS Procedural Classification |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Section 193(1) | IPC Section 154 | Owner/occupier of land on which unlawful assembly or riot takes place (for own or agent's omission) S1; S3 | Fine up to ₹1,000 S1, s. 193(1) | Non-cognizable, Bailable, Any Magistrate S4 |
| Section 193(2) | IPC Section 155 | Owner/occupier/claimant for whose benefit a riot is committed (for own or agent's omission) S1; S3 | Fine (unlimited, not excessive under s. 8(2) BNS) S1, s. 193(2) | Non-cognizable, Bailable, Any Magistrate S4 |
| Section 193(3) | IPC Section 156 | Agent or manager of person for whose benefit a riot is committed (for agent's own omission) S1; S3 | Fine (unlimited, not excessive under s. 8(2) BNS) S1, s. 193(3) | Non-cognizable, Bailable, Any Magistrate S4 |
Practical Examples and Counterexamples
Example 1: Estate Manager Knowingly Allowing Retainers to Riot Over Disputed Crop (Sub-sections (2) and (3))
Assumed Facts: O owns a 50-acre orchard in Bihar but lives in Delhi. O's resident estate manager M learns on Monday evening that 10 retainers employed on the estate have gathered lathis intending to attack rival sharecroppers the next morning to harvest disputed mangoes for O's benefit. Instead of forbidding the retainers or informing the local police station, M stays silent, and the retainers commit a riot the next morning and deposit the harvested mangoes in O's godown.
Legal Analysis: A riot has been committed for O's benefit respecting land in which O claims an interest, and M (having reason to believe the riot was likely) failed to use lawful means to prevent or suppress it. Under Section 193(2) BNS, O is liable to a fine for M's omission, and under Section 193(3) BNS, M is personally liable to a fine S1, s. 193(2)-(3).
Example 2: Sudden Unforeseeable Mob Spillover Coupled with Immediate 112 Police Call (No Offence)
Assumed Facts: A sudden political procession on a public highway turns violent, and 20 rioters unexpectedly jump over the wall into X's factory compound. The moment X's security supervisor sees the rioters enter, he locks the inner factory doors and dials the police emergency helpline 112 to report the intrusion.
Legal Analysis: Neither X nor his supervisor had prior reason to believe the assembly would take place on the land, and the moment it occurred they gave the earliest notice in their power to the police and took lawful steps without endangering their lives. No offence is committed under Section 193(1) BNS S1, s. 193(1).