The provision in one view
Section 157 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 punishes a public servant who, having the custody of any State prisoner or prisoner of war, negligently suffers that prisoner to escape from any place of confinement in which the prisoner is confined. The punishment is simple imprisonment for a term which may extend to three years, and the offender is also liable to fine S1; S5.
Its predecessor is section 129 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 S2. A token-level comparison returned 1.0000 -- a perfect match, operative text and marginal note alike. Not a single word changed.
Four findings, and the third is the most consequential:
- This section is the negligence counterpart of section 156, and the gap between them is very wide: imprisonment for life or ten years there, simple imprisonment for three years here.
- It is the only offence in this Chapter punishable with simple imprisonment. Every other section uses "imprisonment of either description".
- The assigned forum cannot impose the full fine the section permits. The fine under this section is legally unlimited; a Magistrate of the first class may not impose more than fifty thousand rupees. This is a new kind of forum limitation in this collection -- one that bites on the fine rather than on the imprisonment.
- It is the first bailable offence in Chapter VII, and the first not assigned to a Court of Session.
The exact words
"Whoever, being a public servant and having the custody of any State prisoner or prisoner of war, negligently suffers such prisoner to escape from any place of confinement in which such prisoner is confined, shall be punished with simple imprisonment for a term which may extend to three years, and shall also be liable to fine." S1; S5
The elements, and the pair with section 156
The requirements track section 156 exactly except for the mental element S1; S6:
| Section 156 | Section 157 | |
|---|---|---|
| Accused | public servant | public servant |
| Custody | required | required |
| Prisoner | State prisoner or prisoner of war | same |
| Conduct | voluntarily allows the escape | negligently suffers the escape |
| Imprisonment | life, or either description up to 10 years | simple, up to 3 years |
| Fine | liable to | liable to |
The only difference in the conduct element is "voluntarily allows" against "negligently suffers", and on that single distinction the maximum falls from imprisonment for life to three years' simple imprisonment S1; S6.
"Negligently" is not defined in the Sanhita, and no authority construing it in this context was located. What standard of care a custodian owes, and what falls short of it, are therefore not addressed by the section itself.
"State prisoner" and "prisoner of war" are also undefined. This collection's work on section 156 verified that: the Sanhita's definitions chapter contains neither expression, and across the whole Act "State prisoner" appears exactly four times, all within sections 156, 157 and 158 and the Explanation to section 158 S5. No judicial definition of either was located.
The marginal note depends on section 156
The marginal note reads "Public servant negligently suffering such prisoner to escape" S1. The word "such" back-refers to section 156, and the marginal note cannot be understood on its own -- read in isolation it does not say which prisoners it concerns.
The operative text does not have that problem: it spells out "any State prisoner or prisoner of war" in full S1. So the dependency is confined to the label.
The Penal Code's marginal note had the identical structure, back-referring to section 128 in the same way S2, so this is inherited drafting rather than anything the Sanhita introduced.
Note also that the Explanation about parole belongs to section 158, not to this section S5. Section 157 has no Explanation of its own, and whether that parole provision bears on the meaning of "escape" here was not researched.
Simple imprisonment: the only instance in the Chapter
The section provides for simple imprisonment, not "imprisonment of either description" S1.
That matters because the Sanhita distinguishes rigorous from simple imprisonment, and where a section says "either description" the court chooses. Here the court has no choice: the imprisonment must be simple.
Every other section in Chapter VII examined in this collection -- sections 147 to 156 -- uses "imprisonment of either description" or specifies imprisonment for life S5; S6. Section 157 is the sole exception.
The First Schedule records this correctly, describing the punishment as "Simple imprisonment for 3 years and fine" S4. That part of the entry is accurate.
Why the Chapter's only negligence offence is also its only simple-imprisonment offence is not explained by the text, and no Law Commission or committee material was located or searched on the point. The association is noted, not accounted for.
The comparison with section 129 of the Penal Code
The Penal Code provision read:
"Whoever, being a public servant and having the custody of any State prisoner or prisoner of war, negligently suffers such prisoner to escape from any place of confinement in which such prisoner is confined, shall be punished with simple imprisonment for a term which may extend to three years, and shall also be liable to fine." S2
A token-level comparison of the operative text, with the window bounded at the end of the operative sentence before any comparison was run, returned 1.0000. There are no differences at all, and the marginal notes are identical too S1; S2.
This is the second consecutive perfect match in this Chapter, after section 156.
As at sections 155 and 156, the marginal-note change recorded at sections 147, 149, 151, 153 and 154 -- the dropping of "the" before "Government" -- does not arise here, because this marginal note contains no reference to the Government. The section is not counted in that tally, which remains at five of seven.
Section 129 was never amended
No footnote marker appears anywhere inside the section 129 block S2.
That makes section 129 the second provision in this cluster with a blank amendment history, after section 127. It carried no reference to the Queen requiring adaptation, no transportation to be converted into imprisonment in 1956, and no general forfeiture to be removed in 1921 -- the 1955 substitution could not reach it, because its punishment was already simple imprisonment for a term of years.
The amendment grid for this Chapter's predecessors, as far as examined, now reads:
| Penal Code section | 1921 forfeiture repeal | 1955 transportation substitution |
|---|---|---|
| 121 | yes | yes |
| 122 | yes | yes |
| 123 | no | no |
| 125 | no | yes, from "transportation for life or any shorter term" |
| 126 | no | no |
| 127 | no | no |
| 128 | no | yes, from "transportation for life" |
| 129 | no | no |
The Chapter's penalty history is not uniform. As elsewhere, this rests on the footnote apparatus published with the Penal Code; the 1860 Gazette has not been retrieved, and the absence of a marker is evidence of no recorded amendment rather than proof that none occurred.
The fine is unlimited, and that creates a forum problem
The section says the offender "shall also be liable to fine" without naming any sum S1.
Section 8(1) of the Sanhita supplies the consequence:
"Where no sum is expressed to which a fine may extend, the amount of fine to which the offender is liable is unlimited, but shall not be excessive." S3
So the fine available under section 157 is legally unlimited, subject only to not being excessive. That provision is carried forward unchanged from section 63 of the Penal Code S2; S3.
The Magistrate of the first class is capped at fifty thousand rupees
The First Schedule assigns this offence to a Magistrate of the first class S4. Section 23 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 sets out what each class of Magistrate may impose:
"(2) The Court of a Magistrate of the first class may pass a sentence of imprisonment for a term not exceeding three years, or of fine not exceeding fifty thousand rupees, or of both, or of community service." S4
The imprisonment fits exactly. Three years does not exceed three years, so the three-year maximum is within the court's power.
The fine does not. The section permits an unlimited fine; the court may impose no more than fifty thousand rupees. On a case calling for a larger fine, the assigned forum could not impose the penalty the section allows.
This is a new kind of forum limitation, and it narrows
The forum defects recorded earlier in this collection -- at sections 137(2), 139(1) and 140(3) -- all concerned imprisonment: an offence assigned to a court that could not impose the custodial maximum. This one concerns the fine, and it is the first of its kind found.
But it narrows on the same reasoning applied to section 139(1). "Magistrate of the first class" includes a Chief Judicial Magistrate, and section 23(1) gives a Chief Judicial Magistrate
"any sentence authorised by law except a sentence of death or of imprisonment for life or of imprisonment for a term exceeding seven years" S4
-- which contains no cap on fine at all. So a Chief Judicial Magistrate could impose the full fine, and the limitation bites only where the case is tried by an ordinary first-class Magistrate.
The practical significance is therefore modest, and this article does not suggest otherwise. What can be said is that the Schedule's forum entry does not guarantee a court able to impose the full penalty, which is a real if narrow mismatch. Twenty-two forum entries in this collection have been found sound; this is the fourth found to carry a limitation, and the only one of this kind.
This analysis rests on the three provisions quoted -- section 157, section 8(1) of the Sanhita and section 23 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita. No authority on the point was located, and whether a court faced with such a case would commit it elsewhere, or simply impose the capped fine, was not researched.
Classification under the First Schedule
The First Schedule classifies the offence as follows S4:
| Column | Entry |
|---|---|
| Offence | Public servant negligently suffering prisoner of State or war in his custody to escape |
| Punishment | Simple imprisonment for 3 years and fine |
| Cognizable or non-cognizable | Cognizable |
| Bailable or non-bailable | Bailable |
| By what court triable | Magistrate of the first class |
The first bailable offence in the Chapter
Every section from 147 to 156 is non-bailable and triable by a Court of Session S4. Section 157 is the first to break both patterns: it is bailable, and it is tried by a Magistrate.
That is consistent with its position as the Chapter's only negligence offence and its lowest maximum. It is recorded as a structural observation, not as a view on whether the classification is appropriate.
The punishment column, for the fifth time
The section says the offender "shall also be liable to fine"; the Schedule says "and fine" S1; S4. On the Schedule's wording a fine is compulsory; on the section's wording it is a liability.
This is the fifth instance of that defect in this collection, after sections 153, 154, 155 and 156.
The "simple imprisonment for 3 years" part of the entry is correct, and unlike at section 156 there is no second limb for a fine to be misattached to.
As elsewhere, nothing turns on the wording as a matter of law: the First Schedule classifies offences for procedural purposes and does not define the punishment, which is fixed by section 157. That statement reflects the respective functions of the two provisions; no authority on the conflict was located.
An eleventh wording divergence, of a different sort
The Schedule's description reads "negligently suffering prisoner of State or war in his custody to escape", where the Sanhita's marginal note reads "negligently suffering such prisoner to escape" S1; S4.
The Schedule has expanded the back-reference, spelling out what "such prisoner" means. That is helpful rather than inaccurate -- it makes the entry intelligible standing alone, which a Schedule entry needs to be -- but it is not what the marginal note says, and it adds "in his custody" as the entries for section 156 did.
That is an eleventh divergence in this Chapter, on a count that now stands at nine of eleven, the two matches being sections 152 and 155.
Compounding
Section 157 appears in neither table of compoundable offences in section 359 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023. The offence is not compoundable S4.
A probe for "157" was negative in both tables, as were probes for "escape". A probe for "negligen" produced hits in the second table, and these were checked against their own entries: they belong to "Causing hurt by doing an act so rashly and negligently as to endanger human life or the personal safety of others", listed against section 125(a), and the corresponding grievous-hurt offence under section 125(b) -- both compoundable by the person to whom hurt is caused S4. Neither has anything to do with section 157.
The duty to report does not extend to this section
Section 33(1)(iv) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 imposes a duty to inform the nearest Magistrate or police officer of offences under "sections 147 to 154 (both inclusive) and section 158" S4. Section 157 is outside that list.
As recorded at sections 154, 155 and 156, that gap is inherited: section 39(1)(i) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 imposed the duty for sections 121 to 126 of the Penal Code together with one further section, so it equally stopped at the predecessor of section 154 and left section 129 outside it.
The same oddity noted at section 156 applies here: the duty covers section 158, which punishes aiding such a prisoner's escape, but not sections 156 and 157, which punish the custodians whose conduct permits it S4; S5. Why the line falls there was not researched, and the same line existed under the old law.
One caution. The text of section 39 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 was not retrieved from an official source for this collection; its scope is taken from a judgment that states it.
The case law: none, and the anticipated trap did not appear
This collection's work on section 156 found that a search for "section 156" returns results about section 156(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 -- the magistrate's power to order an investigation -- and not about the offence at all. The same hazard was anticipated here, since section 157 of that Code deals with the procedure for investigation.
It did not materialise. A targeted search for section 157 of the Sanhita returned three results, every one of which was the text of a statute S1. There was no collision to diagnose.
The predecessor is a different matter. A search on section 129 of the Penal Code returned 56 results, headed by major constitutional decisions and a municipal statute -- matches on common words in the query rather than on the section S2. None was a prosecution under section 129.
The judgments already held for this Chapter were searched first. Neither contains any reference to section 129, and the bare appearances of the numbers 129 and 157 in one of them are not section references S2.
So no authority construing section 129 or section 157 was located. The sections rest on their text.
Commencement and application
Section 157 came into force on 1 July 2024, by Ministry of Home Affairs notification S.O. 850(E) dated 23 February 2024 S7.
Conduct before that date falls under section 129 of the Penal Code; conduct on or after it falls under section 157 S1; S2. Since the two provisions are textually identical, the transition raises no question of altered scope.
Practical points for readers
- Only a public servant with custody of the prisoner can commit this offence S1.
- The standard is negligence, not intention. Voluntarily allowing the escape is the far graver offence under section 156 S1; S6.
- The imprisonment must be simple, and is capped at three years. This is the only section in the Chapter so punishable S1.
- The fine is unlimited by the section, because no sum is expressed and section 8(1) of the Sanhita makes such a fine unlimited though not excessive S1; S3.
- But a Magistrate of the first class cannot impose more than fifty thousand rupees S4.
- The fine is a liability, not a requirement, despite the Schedule's "and fine" S1; S4.
- This is the first bailable offence in Chapter VII, and the first tried by a Magistrate rather than a Court of Session S4.
- Not compoundable S4.
- Failing to report this offence is not itself an offence under section 33 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 S4.
- "Negligently", "State prisoner" and "prisoner of war" are all undefined and no judicial definition of any of them was located S1; S5.
- There is no decided authority on this section or its predecessor S1; S2.
Limitations of this article
- No authority construing section 157 or section 129 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 was located. Three results were returned on the section, all statute texts, and 56 on the predecessor, none of them a prosecution. Not all were examined individually.
- "Negligently" is not defined in the Sanhita and no authority construing it in this context was located. What standard of care a custodian owes was not researched.
- "State prisoner" and "prisoner of war" are undefined and no judicial definition of either was located. What source supplies their meaning was not researched.
- The Sanhita's definition of "public servant" was not examined.
- The forum analysis rests on the three provisions quoted -- section 157, section 8(1) of the Sanhita and section 23 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita. No authority on the mismatch was located, and whether a court would commit such a case elsewhere or simply impose the capped fine was not researched.
- Whether the parole Explanation in section 158 bears on the meaning of "escape" in section 157 was not researched. That Explanation is attached to section 158.
- Why the Chapter's only negligence offence is also its only simple-imprisonment offence is not accounted for. No Law Commission or committee material was located or searched.
- The First Schedule's rendering of "liable to" as "and" is reported as a defect in the Schedule. No authority was located on what a court should do where the Schedule and the section conflict.
- Section 156 was analysed separately and is used here only for the comparison the pair invites.
- Section 158 was not analysed beyond noting its subject matter, its Explanation and its inclusion in the duty to report.
- The text of section 39 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 was not retrieved from an official source for this collection.
- The Gazette of 1860 has not been retrieved. The penalty history rests on the footnote apparatus published with the Penal Code.
- Bail law was not examined beyond recording the Schedule's classification of the offence as bailable.
- Community service, which section 23(2) also permits a first-class Magistrate to order, was not examined in relation to this offence.
- Prison and custody legislation was not examined.
Frequently asked questions
1. What does section 157 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita punish? A public servant who, having custody of a State prisoner or prisoner of war, negligently suffers that prisoner to escape from a place of confinement S1.
2. What is the punishment? Simple imprisonment for up to three years, and the offender is also liable to fine S1.
3. How does this differ from section 156? Only in the conduct element. Section 156 covers voluntarily allowing the escape; section 157 covers negligently suffering it. Everything else is the same, but the maximum falls from imprisonment for life to three years' simple imprisonment S1; S6.
4. What counts as negligence here? The section does not say, and no authority construing it in this context was located S1.
5. Why "simple" imprisonment? The section specifies it, so the court has no choice between rigorous and simple. This is the only offence in Chapter VII so punishable; the others use "imprisonment of either description" S1; S5.
6. Is the fine limited? Not by the section, which names no sum. Section 8(1) of the Sanhita provides that where no sum is expressed the fine is unlimited, though it must not be excessive S1; S3.
7. So can a Magistrate of the first class impose an unlimited fine? No. Section 23(2) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 caps that court's fine at fifty thousand rupees S4.
8. Is that a problem? It is a mismatch: the Schedule assigns the offence to a court that cannot impose the full fine the section permits. It narrows considerably, because a Chief Judicial Magistrate is also a Magistrate of the first class and section 23(1) imposes no fine cap on that court S4.
9. Is the imprisonment maximum within the Magistrate's power? Yes, exactly. Three years does not exceed the three-year limit in section 23(2) S4.
10. Which section of the Indian Penal Code did this replace? Section 129 S2.
11. Did the wording change? No. The comparison returned 1.0000 -- a perfect match, marginal note included. Not a single word changed S1; S2.
12. Was section 129 ever amended? No footnote marker appears anywhere in the section 129 block, so on the material examined it stood unaltered from 1860. It is the second section in this cluster with a blank amendment history, after section 127 S2.
13. Why did the 1955 amendment not reach it? Because its punishment was already simple imprisonment for a term of years. That Act replaced "transportation", which this section never carried S2.
14. Is the offence bailable? Yes. It is the first bailable offence in Chapter VII; sections 147 to 156 are all non-bailable S4.
15. Which court tries it? A Magistrate of the first class -- the first section in this Chapter not assigned to a Court of Session S4.
16. Is it cognizable? Yes S4.
17. Can it be compounded? No. Section 157 appears in neither table of compoundable offences in section 359 of that Sanhita. Search hits for "negligently" in the second table belong to the hurt offences under section 125(a) and 125(b) S4.
18. Does the First Schedule describe the punishment correctly? The "simple imprisonment for 3 years" part is correct. But it says "and fine" where the section says the offender is "liable to" a fine S1; S4.
19. Does its description of the offence match the marginal note? No. The marginal note says "such prisoner", back-referring to section 156; the Schedule spells out "prisoner of State or war in his custody". That is helpful rather than wrong, but it is a divergence S1; S4.
20. Why does the marginal note say "such prisoner"? Because it depends on section 156, which identifies the prisoners concerned. The Penal Code's marginal note had the same structure. The operative text spells it out in full, so only the label is dependent S1; S2.
21. Must I report this offence if I know about it? No. The duty under section 33 of that Sanhita covers sections 147 to 154 and section 158. Section 157 is outside it S4.
22. Is there any case law on this section? None was located, on either section 157 or section 129 S1; S2.
23. Does searching for "section 157" return irrelevant results, as with section 156? That was expected, because section 157 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 deals with investigation procedure. It did not happen: the search returned three results, all statute texts S1.
24. When did section 157 come into force? 1 July 2024, by Ministry of Home Affairs notification S.O. 850(E) dated 23 February 2024 S7.
This article states the law as published in the sources cited and is for general information only. It is not legal advice. Section 157 reproduces its predecessor word for word; it is the only offence in its Chapter punishable with simple imprisonment and the first that is bailable; the fine it permits is unlimited while the court it is assigned to may impose no more than fifty thousand rupees; and no court has construed it or its predecessor so far as could be established. Anyone affected by, or advising on, a matter under this section should obtain qualified legal advice. Verify the current text, and take advice on your own facts, before acting.