The provision in one view
Section 156 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 punishes a public servant who, having the custody of any State prisoner or prisoner of war, voluntarily allows that prisoner to escape from any place in which the prisoner is confined. The punishment is imprisonment for life, or imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to ten years, and the offender is also liable to fine S1; S3.
Its predecessor is section 128 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 S2. A token-level comparison of the operative text returned 1.0000 -- a perfect match. The marginal note is identical too. Not a single word changed.
Four findings:
- This is the Chapter's first offence requiring a special capacity. Sections 147 to 155 can be committed by anyone; this one can be committed only by a public servant who has custody of such a prisoner.
- Neither "State prisoner" nor "prisoner of war" is defined anywhere in the Sanhita, and the expression "State prisoner" appears in only three sections of the entire Act.
- The First Schedule misdescribes the punishment in two ways at once, not one.
- A search for case law on "section 156" is actively misleading, because that number belongs to one of the most heavily cited provisions in Indian criminal procedure -- a different statute entirely.
The exact words
"Whoever, being a public servant and having the custody of any State prisoner or prisoner of war, voluntarily allows such prisoner to escape from any place in which such prisoner is confined, shall be punished with imprisonment for life, or imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to ten years, and shall also be liable to fine." S1; S3
The elements
The section has four requirements, and all must be met S1.
1. The accused must be a public servant. This is the first provision in Chapter VII to require an official capacity. "Public servant" is defined in the Sanhita's definitions chapter; this article has not examined that definition, and whether every category within it could have custody of such a prisoner was not considered.
2. The accused must have the custody of the prisoner. Custody is the link between the office and the offence. A public servant without custody is outside the section on its terms.
3. The prisoner must be a State prisoner or a prisoner of war. Neither expression is defined -- see below.
4. The allowing must be voluntary. This is what separates section 156 from section 157, which deals with a public servant who negligently suffers such a prisoner to escape S3. The two sections are a deliberate pair, and the penalties differ sharply: life or ten years here, against simple imprisonment for three years under section 157 S4. Section 157 is not analysed in this article.
What the section does not require. There is no requirement that the escape succeed in any larger sense, nor any requirement of motive, payment or sympathy with the prisoner. "Voluntarily" is the only mental element stated, and no authority construing it in this context was located.
"State prisoner" and "prisoner of war" are undefined
Both expressions carry the entire weight of the section's subject matter, and neither is defined in the Sanhita S1; S3.
This was checked rather than assumed. The Sanhita's definitions were read as a bounded window of some 25,900 characters running from the start of the definitions section to the beginning of the next Chapter. Neither "State prisoner" nor "prisoner of war" appears in it S3.
A further check went wider. Across the whole of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 the expression "State prisoner" appears exactly four times, and all four are inside Chapter VII -- in sections 156, 157 and 158, and once more in the Explanation to section 158 S3. It appears nowhere else in the Act.
So the term is used only in this three-section cluster and is left to take its meaning from outside the Sanhita. What source supplies that meaning was not researched, and no judicial definition of either expression was located.
A wording point. The operative text says "any State prisoner or prisoner of war", while the marginal note says "prisoner of State or war" S1. The two forms are inverted. Nothing appears to turn on it -- the marginal note is a compressed label -- and the same inversion existed in the Penal Code S2.
Note also that the Explanation about parole belongs to section 158, not to this section. Section 158 provides that a State prisoner or prisoner of war permitted to be at large on parole within certain limits in India is said to escape from lawful custody if he goes beyond those limits S3. Section 156 has no Explanation of its own, and whether that parole provision bears on the meaning of "escape" in section 156 was not researched.
The comparison with section 128 of the Penal Code
The Penal Code provision read:
"Whoever, being a public servant and having the custody of any State prisoner or prisoner of war, voluntarily allows such prisoner to escape from any place in which such prisoner is confined, shall be punished with imprisonment for life, or imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to ten years, and shall also be liable to fine." S2
A token-level comparison of the operative text, with the window bounded at the end of the operative sentence before any comparison was run, returned 1.0000. There are no differences at all.
The marginal notes are also identical: "Public servant voluntarily allowing prisoner of State or war to escape" in both S1; S2. In particular the marginal-note change recorded at sections 147, 149, 151, 153 and 154 -- the dropping of "the" before "Government" -- does not arise here, because this marginal note contains no reference to the Government. As at section 155, the section is not counted in that tally, which remains at five of seven.
The penalty history
One footnote marker appears inside the section 128 block, numbered 2, and it records that "transportation for life" was replaced by "imprisonment for life" by Act 26 of 1955, section 117 and the Schedule, with effect from 1 January 1956 S2.
That is the plain form of the phrase. Section 125 of the Penal Code had the longer formula "transportation for life or any shorter term" S2, so even within this Chapter the pre-1956 drafting was not uniform.
The amendment grid for this Chapter's predecessors, as far as examined, now reads:
| Penal Code section | 1921 forfeiture repeal | 1955 transportation substitution |
|---|---|---|
| 121 | yes | yes |
| 122 | yes | yes |
| 123 | no | no |
| 125 | no | yes, from "transportation for life or any shorter term" |
| 126 | no | no |
| 127 | no | no |
| 128 | no | yes, from "transportation for life" |
The Chapter's penalty history is not uniform, which is consistent with what was found at sections 153, 154 and 155.
As elsewhere, this rests on the footnote apparatus published with the Penal Code; the 1860 Gazette has not been retrieved.
The punishment, and what "liable to fine" attaches to
The section provides for imprisonment for life, or imprisonment of either description up to ten years, and shall also be liable to fine S1.
Read naturally, the words "and shall also be liable to fine" follow the whole of the preceding penalty clause, so a fine is available in addition to either sentence -- the life sentence or the term of years. And it is a liability, not a requirement: the offender is "liable to" a fine, not sentenced to one as of course.
That reading matters, because the First Schedule says something different.
Classification under the First Schedule
The First Schedule to the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 classifies the offence as follows S4:
| Column | Entry |
|---|---|
| Offence | Public servant voluntarily allowing prisoner of state or war in his custody to escape |
| Punishment | Imprisonment for life, or imprisonment for 10 years and fine |
| Cognizable or non-cognizable | Cognizable |
| Bailable or non-bailable | Non-bailable |
| By what court triable | Court of Session |
Two defects in one punishment column
First, "liable to" has become "and". The section says the offender "shall also be liable to fine"; the Schedule says "and fine" S1; S4. On the Schedule's wording a fine is a compulsory component; on the section's wording it is a liability. This is the fourth instance of that defect in this collection, after sections 153, 154 and 155.
Second, and separately, the fine appears attached to the wrong limb. The Schedule reads "Imprisonment for life, or imprisonment for 10 years and fine". On its most natural reading that offers a choice between (a) imprisonment for life, and (b) imprisonment for ten years with a fine -- as though no fine were available with a life sentence. The section places "and shall also be liable to fine" after both limbs, so a fine is available with either S1; S4.
This is a new kind of misdescription in this collection. The earlier punishment-column defects flattened a ceiling, or converted a liability into a requirement. This one appears to misplace which sentence the fine can accompany.
It is reported with its ambiguity acknowledged. The Schedule's phrase could also be read as "(life, or imprisonment for 10 years) and fine", in which case the only defect is the first one. Either way the entry does not reproduce the section's structure, and no authority on the point was located.
As at sections 153 to 155, nothing turns on this as a matter of law. The First Schedule classifies offences for procedural purposes and does not define the punishment, which is fixed by section 156. That statement reflects the respective functions of the two provisions; no authority on the conflict was located.
The forum is correct, and here it is a true fit
The maximum is imprisonment for life. Under section 23 of that Sanhita no Magistrate of any class may pass a sentence of imprisonment for life: a Chief Judicial Magistrate is barred from death, life, and terms exceeding seven years S4. So the Court of Session is not merely adequate here but required.
That distinguishes this entry from sections 154 and 155, where the seven-year maximum fell within a Chief Judicial Magistrate's powers and the assignment to the Court of Session was more senior than strictly necessary. Here the assignment is an exact fit, and it is the twenty-second forum entry in this collection found to be sound, against three found defective.
A tenth wording divergence
The Schedule's description of the offence differs from the Sanhita's marginal note in two ways: it writes "prisoner of state" in lower case where the section writes "prisoner of State", and it adds the words "in his custody", which the marginal note does not contain S1; S4.
The addition is not inaccurate -- custody is an element of the offence, as the operative text makes clear -- but it is not what the marginal note says. That is a tenth divergence in this Chapter, on a count that now stands at eight of ten, the two matches being sections 152 and 155.
Compounding
Section 156 appears in neither table of compoundable offences in section 359 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 S4. The offence is not compoundable. Probes for "156", "escape" and "custody" were all negative in both tables, so no substring required adjudication.
The duty to report does not extend to this section
Section 33(1)(iv) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 imposes a duty to inform the nearest Magistrate or police officer of offences under "sections 147 to 154 (both inclusive) and section 158" S4. Section 156 is outside that list, the clause stopping at section 154 and resuming at section 158.
That gap is inherited rather than introduced. Section 39(1)(i) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 imposed the duty for sections 121 to 126 of the Penal Code together with one further section, and so equally stopped at the predecessor of section 154, leaving section 128 outside it S7. The line falls in the same place. No view is offered on whether it is well drawn.
There is an oddity worth noting without resolving it: the duty to report covers section 158, which punishes aiding a State prisoner's escape, but not sections 156 and 157, which punish public servants whose conduct permits the same escape S3; S4. Why the line falls there was not researched, and the same line existed under the old law.
One caution. The text of section 39 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 was not retrieved from an official source for this article; its scope is taken from a judgment that states it S7.
The case law: a search that misleads, and why
A search for authority on "section 156" returns results that have nothing to do with this offence, and the reason is worth stating plainly.
A targeted search returned nine results for section 156 of the Sanhita. One was the text of the section. The others were judgments on social media regulation, trafficking, narcotics and a politician's challenge to an investigation S5.
The explanation is a section-number collision. "Section 156" in Indian criminal practice almost always means section 156 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 -- in particular section 156(3), the magistrate's power to order a police investigation, which is among the most frequently litigated provisions in the entire Code.
This was verified rather than assumed. One of the nine results, a Karnataka High Court judgment of 17 December 2024, was retrieved and examined. Every reference to "section 156" in it is to section 156(3) or 156(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, in the context of a magistrate referring a private complaint for investigation. The judgment mentions a prisoner once and escape twice, both incidentally, and has no connection to the offence in section 156 of the Sanhita S5.
So the nine results are noise. An article that reported them as case law on this section would have been entirely wrong.
The same problem affects the predecessor. A search on section 128 of the Penal Code returned 101 results, headed by major constitutional decisions and a municipal statute -- matches on common words in the query rather than on the section S2. None was a prosecution under section 128.
No authority construing section 128 or section 156 was located. The sections rest on their text.
Commencement and application
Section 156 came into force on 1 July 2024, by Ministry of Home Affairs notification S.O. 850(E) dated 23 February 2024 S6.
Conduct before that date falls under section 128 of the Penal Code; conduct on or after it falls under section 156 S1; S2. Since the two provisions are textually identical, the transition raises no question of altered scope.
Practical points for readers
- Only a public servant with custody of the prisoner can commit this offence S1.
- The allowing must be voluntary. Negligence is dealt with separately, and far more leniently, by section 157 S1; S3.
- "State prisoner" and "prisoner of war" are undefined in the Sanhita, and "State prisoner" appears in only three sections of the whole Act S1; S3.
- The maximum is imprisonment for life, with up to ten years as the alternative S1.
- A fine is a liability, not a requirement, and is available with either sentence -- despite the Schedule's wording S1; S4.
- Do not rely on the Schedule's punishment column for this section. It renders "liable to" as "and", and appears to attach the fine only to the ten-year limb S1; S4.
- Cognizable, non-bailable, Court of Session, not compoundable S4.
- Failing to report this offence is not itself an offence under section 33 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, although failing to report an offence under section 158 is S3; S4.
- Searching for "section 156" case law will mislead you. The results concern section 156(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 S5.
- There is no decided authority on this section or its predecessor S2; S5.
Limitations of this article
- No authority construing section 156 or section 128 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 was located. Nine results were returned on the section and 101 on the predecessor; one was retrieved and verified to be about a different statute, and the remainder were not examined individually.
- "State prisoner" and "prisoner of war" are undefined in the Sanhita and no judicial definition of either was located. What source supplies their meaning, and whether any other enactment defines them, were not researched.
- The definition of "public servant" was not examined, nor whether every category within it could have custody of such a prisoner.
- "Voluntarily" was not researched in this context and no authority construing it was located.
- Whether the parole Explanation in section 158 bears on the meaning of "escape" in section 156 was not researched. That Explanation is attached to section 158, not to this section.
- The reading that a fine is available with a life sentence under this section is a reading of the section's words, supported by their order. No authority on the point was located.
- The First Schedule's apparent misplacement of the fine is reported with its ambiguity acknowledged. The entry admits of a second reading on which only the "liable to" defect arises. No authority was located on what a court should do where the Schedule and the section conflict.
- Section 157 was not analysed, and the comparison drawn with it goes no further than its penalty and its negligence standard as they appear in the Sanhita and the First Schedule.
- Section 158 was not analysed beyond noting its subject matter, its Explanation and its inclusion in the duty to report.
- Why the duty to report covers section 158 but not sections 156 and 157 was not researched.
- The text of section 39 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 was not retrieved from an official source for this article.
- The Gazette of 1860 has not been retrieved. The penalty history rests on the footnote apparatus published with the Penal Code.
- No Law Commission or legislative-committee material was located or searched for this section.
- Bail law was not examined beyond recording the Schedule's classification.
- Prison and custody legislation was not examined, so how custody of such a prisoner arises in practice, and under what authority, are outside this article.
Frequently asked questions
1. What does section 156 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita punish? A public servant who, having custody of a State prisoner or prisoner of war, voluntarily allows that prisoner to escape from a place of confinement S1.
2. Who can commit this offence? Only a public servant who has custody of such a prisoner. This is the first section in Chapter VII to require an official capacity S1.
3. What is the punishment? Imprisonment for life, or imprisonment of either description up to ten years, and the offender is also liable to fine S1.
4. Is the fine compulsory? No. The section says the offender "shall also be liable to" a fine. The First Schedule says "and fine", which overstates it S1; S4.
5. Can a fine be imposed along with a life sentence? On the words of the section, yes -- the liability to a fine follows both limbs of the penalty clause. The Schedule's wording suggests otherwise, and no authority on the point was located S1; S4.
6. What does "voluntarily" mean here? The section does not say, and no authority construing it in this context was located. What it does is separate this offence from section 157, which deals with negligence S1.
7. What is the difference between sections 156 and 157? Section 156 punishes voluntarily allowing the escape; section 157 punishes negligently suffering it. The penalties differ sharply -- life or ten years here, simple imprisonment for three years there S1; S3; S4.
8. What is a "State prisoner"? The Sanhita does not define it. The expression appears only four times in the whole Act, all within sections 156, 157 and 158 and the Explanation to section 158. No judicial definition was located S1; S3.
9. What is a "prisoner of war"? Also undefined in the Sanhita, and no judicial definition was located S1; S3.
10. Which section of the Indian Penal Code did this replace? Section 128 S2.
11. Did the wording change? No. The comparison returned 1.0000 -- a perfect match. The marginal note is identical as well. Not a single word changed S1; S2.
12. Was section 128 ever amended? Once, so far as the footnotes record: "transportation for life" was replaced by "imprisonment for life" by Act 26 of 1955, with effect from 1 January 1956 S2.
13. Is that the same amendment as at other sections in this Chapter? The same Act reached sections 121, 122 and 125 as well, but section 125's original words were "transportation for life or any shorter term", a longer formula. Sections 123, 126 and 127 were not touched by it S2.
14. Does the First Schedule describe the offence correctly? Not quite. It lower-cases "state" and adds "in his custody", which the marginal note does not contain -- though custody is genuinely an element of the offence S1; S4.
15. Is the offence cognizable and bailable? Cognizable and non-bailable S4.
16. Which court tries it? The Court of Session, and here that is required rather than merely adequate: no Magistrate of any class may pass a sentence of imprisonment for life S4.
17. Can it be compounded? No. Section 156 appears in neither table of compoundable offences in section 359 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 S4.
18. Must I report this offence if I know about it? No. The duty under section 33 of that Sanhita covers sections 147 to 154 and section 158. Section 156 is outside it S4.
19. Is it odd that aiding an escape must be reported but a custodian's conduct need not? It is a line that falls in an unexpected place, and the same line existed under section 39 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. Why it falls there was not researched S4; S7.
20. Is there any case law on this section? None was located S2; S5.
21. But a search for "section 156" returns many judgments. What are they? They concern section 156 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, especially section 156(3), the magistrate's power to order a police investigation. That is one of the most litigated provisions in Indian criminal procedure and has nothing to do with this offence S5.
22. How do you know that? One of the nine results, a Karnataka High Court judgment of December 2024, was retrieved and read. Every reference to "section 156" in it is to section 156(3) or 156(1) of that Code S5.
23. Does the parole Explanation apply to this section? That Explanation is attached to section 158, not to section 156. Whether it bears on the meaning of "escape" here was not researched S3.
24. When did section 156 come into force? 1 July 2024, by Ministry of Home Affairs notification S.O. 850(E) dated 23 February 2024 S6.
This article states the law as published in the sources cited and is for general information only. It is not legal advice. Section 156 reproduces its predecessor word for word; its two central expressions, "State prisoner" and "prisoner of war", are undefined in the Sanhita and appear in only three of its sections; the First Schedule both overstates the fine and appears to attach it to the wrong limb of the sentence; and no court has construed the section or its predecessor so far as could be established. Anyone affected by, or advising on, a matter under this section should obtain qualified legal advice. Verify the current text, and take advice on your own facts, before acting.