Crucial Numbering Alert and Place in Chapter XVI
For practising advocates, police officers, and citizens transitioning from the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC), Section 302 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) requires immediate disambiguation:
- Under the repealed IPC, Section 302 IPC was the iconic provision prescribing the punishment for Murder (which is now housed in Section 103 BNS) S1; S7.
- Under the enacted BNS, Section 302 BNS is the final section of Chapter XVI (Of Offences Relating to Religion, Sections 298–302) and corresponds to Section 298 IPC (Uttering words, etc., with deliberate intent to wound the religious feelings of any person) S1; S4.
Within Chapter XVI BNS, Section 302 occupies the interpersonal, face-to-face tier of religious-offence regulation S1; S4. Whereas Section 299 BNS (formerly Section 295A IPC) addresses public or class-directed speech, writing, or electronic representations made with the deliberate and malicious intention of outraging the religious feelings of any class of citizens of India, Section 302 BNS addresses targeted oral words, sounds, gestures, or display of objects made directly in the hearing or in the sight of a specific individual with the deliberate intention of wounding that person's religious feelings S1; S4.
Operative Statutory Breakdown and Essential Ingredients
To secure a conviction under Section 302 BNS, the prosecution must establish two cumulative ingredients S1:
1. The Strict Mental Element: "With the Deliberate Intention of Wounding the Religious Feelings of Any Person"
- Deliberate Intention vs. Mere Knowledge or Carelessness: The statute uses the emphatic qualifier "deliberate intention" S1. Mere knowledge that a remark might offend a listener, or a heated, unpremeditated remark made during a sudden quarrel, or a bona fide theological debate, academic critique, or artistic expression does not satisfy Section 302 BNS S1; S6.
- "Deliberate" Connotes Premeditation and Design: The offender must consciously design and direct the utterance, sound, gesture, or object-placement for the primary purpose of wounding the target individual's religious feelings S1.
- "Religious Feelings": The feelings targeted must be religious in nature, not merely personal pride, caste superiority, political allegiance, or social embarrassment (contrast Section 301 BNS, which covers "wounding the feelings of any person" generally in the funerary context, and Section 352 BNS, which covers intentional insult to provoke breach of the peace) S1; S4.
2. The Sensory Actus Reus: Direct Aural or Visual Proximity to the Target Person
The offender must perform at least one of four physical acts in immediate sensory proximity to the target individual ("that person") S1:
- Utters any word in the hearing of that person; or
- Makes any sound in the hearing of that person; or
- Makes any gesture in the sight of that person; or
- Places any object in the sight of that person S1.
Critical Limit on Electronic and Indirect Communications: Because Section 302 BNS retains the exact physical-proximity phrasing of 1860: "in the hearing of that person" and "in the sight of that person", without adding "or through electronic means" (which Parliament explicitly added to Section 299 BNS), a general social media post or published article read asynchronously by the public does not ordinarily fit the sensory-proximity requirement of Section 302 BNS unless it is proved that the accused directly transmitted the audio/visual content into the immediate hearing or sight of a specific target individual with deliberate intent to wound that individual's religious feelings S1; S4. Conversely, public electronic posts aimed at a religious community are governed by Section 299 BNS (or Section 196 BNS, formerly Section 153A IPC) S1; S4.
Structural Comparison: Section 302 BNS vs. Section 299 BNS
| Feature | Section 302 BNS (formerly IPC 298) | Section 299 BNS (formerly IPC 295A) |
|---|---|---|
| Target Victim | Any individual person ("the religious feelings of any person") S1 | Any class of citizens of India ("the religious feelings of any class of citizens of India") S1; S4 |
| Mental Standard | Deliberate intention to wound religious feelings S1 | Deliberate and malicious intention to outrage religious feelings S1; S4 |
| Modes of Commission | Spoken words or sounds in the hearing of that person; gestures or placing objects in the sight of that person S1 | Spoken or written words, signs, visible representations, through electronic means, or otherwise S1; S4 |
| Maximum Punishment | Imprisonment of either description up to 1 year, or fine, or both S1 | Imprisonment of either description up to 3 years, or fine, or both S1; S4 |
| BNSS Cognizability & Bail | Non-cognizable and Bailable S3 | Cognizable and Non-bailable S4 |
| Prior Government Sanction | Not required under Section 217 BNSS | Mandatory prior sanction of Central or State Government under Section 217(1) BNSS (formerly Section 196(1) CrPC) |
| Compoundability (S. 359 BNSS) | Compoundable without court permission under Section 359(1) BNSS by the person whose religious feelings were intended to be wounded S5 | Non-compoundable S5 |
Punishment, Sentencing, and BNSS Procedural Classification
| Statutory Provision | Offence Description | Imprisonment Term & Type | Fine & Default Rules | Cognizability | Bailability | Triable By | Compoundability (S. 359 BNSS) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Section 302 BNS | Uttering words, making sounds/gestures, or placing objects in sight/hearing with deliberate intent to wound religious feelings | Up to 1 year (Simple or Rigorous: either description under S. 7 BNS); no mandatory minimum S1 | Optional ("or with fine, or with both"); unlimited but not excessive under S. 8(1) BNS; default imprisonment up to 3 months (1/4th of max term) under S. 8(3) BNS if imprisonment + fine imposed S1 | Non-cognizable S3 | Bailable S3 | Any Magistrate S3 | Compoundable without permission of the Court under S. 359(1) BNSS by the person whose religious feelings are intended to be wounded S5 |
Procedural Safeguards in Practice:
- Because Section 302 BNS is Non-cognizable S3, a police officer cannot register a First Information Report (
FIR) or investigate a standalone allegation under Section 302 BNS without an order of a Magistrate having power to try the case under Section 174(2) BNSS (formerly Section 155(2) CrPC). - Furthermore, under Section 359(1) BNSS, the aggrieved individual has an absolute statutory right to compound the offence without requiring leave of the trial court (unless the case has been committed for trial or an appeal is pending under Section 359(5) BNSS), and such composition operates as an immediate acquittal under Section 359(8) BNSS S5.
Judicial Authorities and Interpretive Principles
- Threshold of "Deliberate Intention" and Quashing of Frivolous Complaints: Mahendra Singh Dhoni v. Yerraguntla Shyamsundar, (2017) 7 SCC 760 (
2017 INSC 368) S6:- Facts & Holding: A private complaint was filed alleging that a magazine cover depicting the cricketer as Lord Vishnu holding commercial products wounded religious feelings under Sections 295A and 298 IPC. The Supreme Court quashed the criminal proceedings, holding that the complaint disclosed neither the deliberate and malicious intention required for Section 295A IPC nor the deliberate intention and sensory-proximity requirements of Section 298 IPC, and warned Magistrates against mechanically summoning accused persons in religion-related complaints S6.
- Carry-Over to Section 302 BNS: Because Section 302 BNS preserves Section 298 IPC verbatim, the Supreme Court's ruling applies with full force: careless, commercial, or insensitive expression lacking premeditated, deliberate intent to wound a specific listener's or viewer's religious feelings cannot be prosecuted under Section 302 BNS S1; S6.
Practical Examples and Counterexamples
-
Example 1: Deliberately Placing an Offensive Object in the Sight of a Worshipper (Section 302 Attracted): Assumed Facts: Knowing that
Zis performing morning prayers on his veranda and holds a particular religious scripture sacred,Astands directly in front ofZ's veranda, makes sureZis looking at him, and deliberately spits upon and tears pages of a replica of that scripture while shouting derisive slurs atZ's faith inZ's hearing. Legal Analysis:Ahas bothuttered words in the hearing ofZand made gestures/placed an object in the sight ofZwith the premeditated, deliberate intention of woundingZ's religious feelings. Section 302 BNS is attracted S1. -
Counterexample 1: Casual Remark or Theological Disagreement (Section 302 Not Attracted): Assumed Facts: During a university seminar on comparative religion,
Bargues that a particular historical miracle described inZ's faith is metaphorical rather than literal.Z, who is sitting in the audience, feels deeply hurt. Legal Analysis:B's statement is an academic expression of opinion lacking a deliberate intention to woundZ's religious feelings. Section 302 BNS is not attracted S1; S6. -
Counterexample 2: Sudden Quarrel Over Parking (Section 302 Not Attracted): Assumed Facts: During a heated road-rage dispute over vehicle parking,
Closes his temper and hurls a generic profanity that includes a religious reference atD. Legal Analysis: An outburst in the heat of a sudden secular quarrel lacks the premeditated "deliberate intention" to wound religious feelings required by Section 302 BNS (though it may be examined under Section 352 BNS if intended to provoke a breach of the peace) S1; S6.