Overview and Statutory Function in Substantive Criminal Law
Section 257 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) penalises corrupt or malicious abuse of adjudicatory or reporting authority by a public servant at any stage of a judicial proceeding S1, Section 257; S7. Replacing Section 219 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC) without alteration S3, Section 219; S5, p. 26; S7, Section 257 sits at the intersection of judicial accountability and judicial immunity in Chapter XIV (Of False Evidence and Offences Against Public Justice).
Under Section 15 BNS (formerly Section 77 IPC), nothing is an offence which is done by a Judge when acting judicially in the exercise of any power which is, or which in good faith he believes to be, given to him by law S1, Section 15. However, Section 2(11) BNS defines "good faith" negatively: nothing is said to be done or believed in good faith which is done or believed without due care and attention S1, Section 2(11). When a Judge, Magistrate, coroner, court commissioner, or other public servant participating in a judicial proceeding steps outside the shield of good faith and corruptly or maliciously makes or pronounces a report, order, verdict, or decision which he knows to be contrary to law, Section 15 BNS ceases to protect him, and Section 257 BNS visits the act with imprisonment of either description up to seven years, or fine, or both S1, Sections 15, 257; S7.
Verbatim Text and Statutory Definitions
Section 257 BNS is enacted as a single, self-contained paragraph S1, Section 257; S7:
"Whoever, being a public servant, corruptly or maliciously makes or pronounces in any stage of a judicial proceeding, any report, order, verdict, or decision which he knows to be contrary to law, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to seven years, or with fine, or with both." S1, Section 257; S7
Key Statutory Terms
- "Public servant" (Section 2(28) BNS): Includes not only Judges and Magistrates (Section 2(28)(b) and Section 2(16) BNS), but also court officers, liquidators, receivers, or commissioners whose duty is to investigate or report on any matter of law or fact (Section 2(28)(c)), assessors or panchayat members assisting a Court (Section 2(28)(d)), and arbitrators to whom a cause has been referred by a Court or competent public authority (Section 2(28)(e)) S1, Sections 2(16), 2(28). Notice that the statutory phrase "makes or pronounces... any report, order, verdict, or decision" deliberately pairs "report" (made by a court officer, commissioner, or inquiring official in a judicial proceeding) with "order, verdict, or decision" (pronounced by a Judge, Magistrate, tribunal member, or assessor) S1, Section 257; S7.
- "In any stage of a judicial proceeding": Under Section 2(1)(m) of the BNSS, 2023 (imported into the BNS via Section 2(39) BNS), "judicial proceeding" includes any proceeding in the course of which evidence is or may be legally taken on oath S1, Section 2(39); S4. Furthermore, as illustrated in the Explanations to Section 229 BNS (formerly Section 193 IPC), an investigation directed by law preliminary to a proceeding before a Court, or an inquiry conducted by an officer deputed by a Court (such as a local commissioner), is a stage of a judicial proceeding S1, Section 229. In addition, numerous central and state enactments (such as land revenue, land reforms, and panchayat statutes) expressly deem statutory inquiries before revenue or administrative tribunals to be "judicial proceedings" within the meaning of Section 257 BNS (formerly Section 219 IPC) S7.
Exact Offence Ingredients and High Mens Rea Threshold
To prevent disappointed litigants from weaponising criminal prosecutions against honest judicial or quasi-judicial officers over erroneous orders, Section 257 BNS imposes an exceptionally stringent, dual mens rea standard S1, Section 257; S6:
- Status as a Public Servant Acting in a Stage of a Judicial Proceeding: The accused must be a public servant (Section 2(28) BNS) and must act "in any stage of a judicial proceeding" S1, Section 257; S6. Purely executive or police investigation reports that are not made in a stage of a judicial proceeding fall under Section 256 BNS (framing an incorrect record) rather than Section 257 BNS S1, Sections 256, 257.
- Making or Pronouncing a Report, Order, Verdict, or Decision: The public servant must actually make or pronounce a report, order, verdict, or decision S1, Section 257.
- Actual Knowledge of Illegality ("Which He Knows to Be Contrary to Law"): An honest error of law, misinterpretation of a statute, or mistaken appreciation of evidence, however grave or reversible on appeal, never constitutes an offence under Section 257 BNS S1, Sections 15, 257. The prosecution must prove that the public servant positively knew at the time of making or pronouncing the report, order, verdict, or decision that it was contrary to law S1, Section 257.
- Corrupt or Malicious Motive ("Corruptly or Maliciously"): Even knowing departure from strict procedure is insufficient unless done "corruptly" (induced by bribery, pecuniary gain, or unlawful favouritism) or "maliciously" (driven by personal ill-will, spite, grudge, or ulterior hostility) S1, Section 257.
Procedural Safeguards: Judicial Officers Protection and Section 218 BNSS
Advocates must read Section 257 BNS alongside two mandatory statutory shields:
- Section 218 BNSS (formerly Section 197 CrPC): No court can take cognizance of an offence under Section 257 BNS alleged to have been committed by a Judge, Magistrate, or public servant not removable from office save by or with the sanction of the Government, while acting or purporting to act in the discharge of official duty, without the previous sanction of the Central or State Government S4, Section 218 BNSS; S6.
- Judges (Protection) Act, 1985: Under Section 3(1) of the Judges (Protection) Act, 1985, no court shall entertain or continue any civil or criminal proceeding against any person who is or was a Judge for any act, thing, or word committed, done, or spoken by him when, or in the course of, acting or purporting to act in the discharge of his official or judicial duty or function, subject only to the power of the Central or State Government or the Supreme Court / High Court or other statutory authority under Section 3(2) to institute criminal or disciplinary proceedings.
IPC-to-BNS Correspondence, Punishment Matrix, and BNSS Classification
| Parameter | IPC Section 219 (1860) | BNS Section 257 (2023) | Legal Significance of Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Section Number & Text | Section 219 IPC S3 | Section 257 BNS S1; S7 | Renumbered verbatim with zero substantive or structural modifications S1; S3; S5, p. 26; S7. |
| Substantive Punishment | Imprisonment of either description up to 7 years, or fine, or both S3 | Imprisonment of either description up to 7 years, or with fine, or with both S1, Section 257; S7 | Unchanged; default-of-fine imprisonment capped at 1 year and 9 months (1/4th of 7 years) under Section 8(3) BNS S1. |
| BNSS First Schedule Classification | Non-cognizable, Bailable, Magistrate of the First Class S4 | Non-cognizable | Bailable | Triable by Magistrate of the First Class S4, First Schedule, Entry 257; S7 | Retains Non-cognizable and Bailable status despite a 7-year maximum sentence, protecting adjudicators from warrantless police arrest S4; S7. |
Practical Examples and Counterexamples
- Editorial Hypothetical 1 (Corruptly Making a False Report in a Judicial Proceeding):
C, an official Court Commissioner appointed by a Civil Judge to inspect disputed land on oath and submit a report in a pending suit (a stage of a judicial proceeding), accepts Rs. 2,00,000 from the defendant and submits a report stating that no construction exists on the plot, knowing the report to be false and contrary to the Court's mandate. After requisite sanction/complaint,Cis liable under Section 257 BNS S1, Sections 2(28)(c), 257. - Editorial Hypothetical 2 (Counterexample: Erroneous Bail Order Passed in Good Faith):
M, a Judicial Magistrate, grants bail to an accused under a misreading of a recent statutory amendment, without any corrupt motive or personal malice. Although the Sessions Court sets aside the bail order as contrary to law,Mis completely protected by Section 15 BNS and commits no offence under Section 257 BNS becauseMneither acted corruptly or maliciously nor knew that the order was contrary to law S1, Sections 15, 257.