Overview and Statutory Text of BNS Section 215
When is refusing to sign a statement a criminal offence under BNS Section 215, and why can the police NEVER invoke it for a police interrogation statement? Section 215 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) penalises any person who refuses to sign any statement made by him, when required to sign that statement by a public servant legally competent to require that he shall sign that statement S1 (Section 215). Replacing Section 180 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC) S3; S6 (IPC Section 180), BNS Section 215 retains the identical statutory wording and maximum simple imprisonment of three months, while increasing the maximum fine sixfold from Rs. 500 to Rs. 3,000, or both S1; S3.
In criminal practice, IPC Section 180 / BNS Section 215 is one of the most frequently misapplied provisions by investigating police officers. Police officers routinely add Section 180 IPC (now BNS Section 215) to chargesheets when an accused or witness refuses to sign a disclosure statement or interrogation statement at the police station. As the Supreme Court of India authoritatively held in Supriya Jain v. State of Haryana (2023) S5 ((2023) 7 SCC 711, paras 22–24), such a charge is patently illegal: Section 181(1) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS) (formerly Section 162(1) CrPC) expressly prohibits any statement made by any person to a police officer in the course of a Chapter XIII investigation from being signed by the person making it S4; S5 (BNSS Section 181(1); Supriya Jain, paras 22–24). Because a police officer is forbidden by statute from taking a signature on an investigation statement, the police officer is not "legally competent to require" that signature, and refusing to sign a police statement can never constitute an offence under BNS Section 215 S1; S4; S5.
Verbatim Statutory Text (BNS Section 215): "Whoever refuses to sign any statement made by him, when required to sign that statement by a public servant legally competent to require that he shall sign that statement, shall be punished with simple imprisonment for a term which may extend to three months, or with fine which may extend to three thousand rupees, or with both." S1 (Section 215)
Essential Ingredients: When IS a Public Servant "Legally Competent" to Require a Signature?
To establish an offence under BNS Section 215, three cumulative elements must be proved S1 (Section 215):
- A Statement Actually Made by the Accused: The document presented for signature must be a record of a statement made by him S1 (Section 215). If a public servant fabricates a statement the person never made, or refuses to record what the person actually stated, the person cannot be convicted for refusing to sign a statement not made by them.
- Requisition by a Public Servant "Legally Competent to Require That He Shall Sign That Statement":
- The public servant must possess express statutory authority to require the maker of the statement to sign it S1; S5 (BNS Section 215; Supriya Jain, paras 22–24).
- Comparison of Proceedings Where Signature CAN vs. CANNOT Be Legally Required:
| Proceeding / Statement Type | Governing Statutory Provision | Is the Public Servant Legally Competent to Require Signature? | Does Refusal to Sign Attract BNS Section 215? |
|---|---|---|---|
| First Information Report (FIR) given orally and reduced to writing by police | BNSS Section 173(1) (ex-CrPC Section 154(1)) | Yes ("and shall be signed by the person giving it") S4 | Technically yes if the informant demands registration of their oral FIR and then refuses to sign, though rare in practice S1; S4. |
| Witness or Accused Statement to Police During Investigation | BNSS Section 180 & Section 181(1) (ex-CrPC Sections 161 & 162(1)) | NO: Expressly Prohibited ("No statement made by any person to a police officer in the course of an investigation under this Chapter, shall, if reduced to writing, be signed by the person making it") S4; S5 | NO (Supriya Jain v. State of Haryana, (2023) 7 SCC 711) S5. |
| Inquest Report on Unnatural/Sudden Death | BNSS Section 194(2) (ex-CrPC Section 174(2)) | Only the police officer and respectable inhabitants joining the inquest investigation sign the report (witnesses examined are not required by Section 194(2) to sign separate statements) S4 | No for ordinary witnesses questioned during inquest S1; S4. |
| Judicial Confession Recorded by Magistrate Under BNSS Section 183 | BNSS Section 183(4) (ex-CrPC Section 164(4)) | Section 183(4) states it shall be signed by the person making the confession, but because a confession must be completely voluntary under BNSS s. 183(2), an accused who changes their mind and refuses to sign is exercising their right not to confess S4 | No: refusal to sign a confession merely shows the confession is involuntary; the accused cannot be punished for declining to complete a confession S1; S4. |
| Examination of Accused by Magistrate or Sessions Court (BNSS s. 351 / s. 316) | BNSS Section 316(4) (ex-CrPC Section 281(5)) | Section 316(4) states that the record of examination of the accused shall be shown or read to him and "shall be signed by the accused" and by the Magistrate or presiding Judge S4 | Historically debated; however, where a statute expressly requires a witness deposition (e.g., Order XVIII Rule 5 CPC or civil/revenue court rules) or statutory statement (Customs/GST/Income Tax) to be signed by the deponent, refusal attracts Section 215 S1; S4. |
| Civil Court Witness Deposition / Statutory Inquiry Statement (CPC Order XVIII Rule 5, Income Tax s. 131, Customs s. 108) | Relevant Civil Court Rules / Special Statute | Yes, where the governing statute or procedural rule requires the deponent to read and sign their recorded deposition S1 | Yes, refusal to sign after the deposition is accurately read over triggers BNS Section 215 S1. |
- Intentional Refusal to Sign:
- The refusal must be deliberate after being lawfully required to sign S1 (Section 215). If a witness points out a material transcription error in the recorded deposition and asks that the correction (or a memorandum of their objection under BNSS Section 313(2) / Order XVIII Rule 5 CPC) be noted before signing, requesting correction of an inaccurate record is not an unlawful refusal under Section 215.
Comparison with IPC Section 180
| Feature / Element | BNS Section 215 (2023) | IPC Section 180 (1860) | Legal Significance of Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Offence Ingredients | Identical verbatim wording S1 | Identical verbatim wording S3 | Substantively unchanged S1; S3. |
| Imprisonment Term & Nature | Simple imprisonment up to 3 months S1 | Simple imprisonment up to 3 months S3 | Substantively unchanged S1; S3. |
| Maximum Fine Ceiling | Up to Rs. 3,000 S1 | Up to Rs. 500 S3 | Substantive enhancement: Sixfold increase in maximum fine S1; S3. |
Complete Punishment and Dual Procedural Classification Matrix
Like Sections 210, 213, and 214, BNS Section 215 is included in BNSS Section 384(1) for summary in-presence contempt disposal when committed before a Civil, Criminal, or Revenue Court S4 (BNSS Sections 215, 384, 385, First Schedule):
| Procedural Track | Triggering Fact Pattern | Imprisonment Term & Nature | Fine Limit & Conjunction | Cognizability & Bailability | Forum / Trial Court (BNSS First Schedule & Chapter XXVIII) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Regular Trial Track (BNSS s. 215(1)(a)(i) & s. 385) | Refusing to sign a statement made by the person when required by a legally competent public servant (or where a Court forwards a complaint under BNSS s. 385) S1; S4 | Simple imprisonment up to 3 months S1 | Up to Rs. 3,000, or imprisonment, or both S1 | Non-cognizable, Bailable S4 | Any Magistrate (upon a written complaint under BNSS s. 215(1)(a)(i)) S4 |
| Summary In-Presence Contempt Track (BNSS s. 384(1)) | Refusing to sign statement in the view or presence of any Civil, Criminal, or Revenue Court and dealt with summarily on the same day S4 | Detained in custody until the rising of the Court; in default of fine, simple imprisonment up to 1 month S4 | Fine not exceeding Rs. 1,000 S4 | Summary contempt proceeding (appealable under BNSS s. 415) S4 | The Civil, Criminal, or Revenue Court itself before rising on the same day S4 |
Concrete Hypothetical Examples and Counterexamples
- Example 1: Witness in a Civil Trial Refusing to Sign Accurately Recorded Deposition (Offence Made Out):
Assumed Facts: In an appealable civil suit before a Civil Judge, witness
Wgives oral testimony which is taken down in writing in narrative form and read over toWin open Court in accordance with Order XVIII Rule 5 of the Code of Civil Procedure and applicable High Court Civil Rules requiring the witness to sign the deposition.Wadmits the record is accurate but refuses to sign the deposition sheet because he regrets having made an admission during cross-examination. Legal Analysis: The Civil Judge is a public servant legally competent to requireWto sign the deposition made by him, andWhas intentionally refused to sign S1 (Section 215). The Civil Court may either fineWup to Rs. 1,000 summarily before rising on the same day under BNSS Section 384(1) or forward a complaint under BNSS Section 385 / Section 215(1)(a)(i) to a Judicial Magistrate for trial under BNS Section 215 S1; S4. - Counterexample: Police Adding BNS Section 215 Because Accused Refused to Sign a Police Disclosure Statement (Supriya Jain Rule):
Assumed Facts: During police investigation of a cheating FIR, the Investigating Officer writes down an alleged disclosure statement of accused
Aand demands thatAsign it.Arefuses to sign. The Investigating Officer adds BNS Section 215 to the final report (chargesheet) filed before the Magistrate. Legal Analysis: As held by the Supreme Court in Supriya Jain v. State of Haryana (2023) S5 (paras 22–24), the charge under BNS Section 215 is doubly illegal:- Substantively, under BNSS Section 181(1) (ex-CrPC Section 162(1)), a police officer is expressly prohibited from taking the signature of any person on a statement made during investigation; hence the police officer is not "legally competent to require"
Ato sign S4; S5. - Procedurally, under BNSS Section 215(1)(a)(i), a Magistrate is barred from taking cognizance of BNS Section 215 on a police report (chargesheet) S4 (BNSS Section 215(1)(a)(i)).
- Substantively, under BNSS Section 181(1) (ex-CrPC Section 162(1)), a police officer is expressly prohibited from taking the signature of any person on a statement made during investigation; hence the police officer is not "legally competent to require"