Overview and Statutory Text of BNS Section 210
What does BNS Section 210 criminalise, and how does it apply to documents and electronic records?
Section 210 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) penalises any person who, being legally bound to produce or deliver up any document or electronic record to any public servant, as such, intentionally omits so to produce or deliver up the same S1 (Section 210). Replacing Section 175 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC) S3 (Section 175; S6), Section 210 updates the marginal heading to explicitly include "or electronic record", organises the punishment branches into clauses (a) and (b), and raises the maximum monetary fines tenfold:
- Clause (a) (Omission to Produce to a General Public Servant): Simple imprisonment up to one month, or fine up to Rs. 5,000 (increased from Rs. 500), or both S1 (Section 210(a); S3, Section 175).
- Clause (b) (Omission to Produce or Deliver Up to a "Court"): Where the document or electronic record is to be produced or delivered up to a Court, simple imprisonment up to six months, or fine up to Rs. 10,000 (increased from Rs. 1,000), or both S1 (Section 210(b); S3, Section 175).
Verbatim Statutory Text and Illustration (BNS Section 210): "Whoever, being legally bound to produce or deliver up any document or electronic record to any public servant, as such, intentionally omits so to produce or deliver up the same,— (a) shall be punished with simple imprisonment for a term which may extend to one month, or with fine which may extend to five thousand rupees, or with both; (b) and where the document or electronic record is to be produced or delivered up to a Court, with simple imprisonment for a term which may extend to six months, or with fine which may extend to ten thousand rupees, or with both.
Illustration. A, being legally bound to produce a document before a District Court, intentionally omits to produce the same. A has committed the offence defined in this section." S1 (Section 210)
Essential Ingredients and Constitutional / Evidentiary Qualifications
To establish an offence under BNS Section 210, four cumulative conditions must be satisfied, subject to vital constitutional and evidentiary exceptions:
- Subject Matter: "Document" or "Electronic Record":
- Under BNS Section 2(8), "document" means any matter expressed or described upon any substance by means of letters, figures or marks, or by more than one of those means, intended to be used, or which may be used, as evidence of that matter, and expressly includes an electronic and digital record S1 (Section 2(8)).
- Under BNSS Section 94(1) (replacing CrPC Section 91(1)), a Court or an officer in charge of a police station may issue a summons or written order requiring the production of any "document, electronic communication, including communication devices, which is likely to contain digital evidence or other thing" S4 (Section 94(1)). Note carefully: BNS Section 210 applies only to a document or electronic record; it does not apply to a purely physical non-documentary chattel (such as a weapon, stolen jewellery, or vehicle) unless it bears or contains a document or electronic record S1 (Section 2(8), 210).
- "Being Legally Bound to Produce or Deliver Up... to Any Public Servant, As Such":
- The legal obligation ("legally bound", BNS Section 2(15)) normally arises either from a validly served subpoena duces tecum / summons / written order (such as under BNSS Section 94, Order XVI Rule 6 CPC, Order XI Rule 14 CPC, Income Tax Act Section 131, or GST Act Section 70) or from a direct statutory duty to deliver up official registers or licences S1 (Sections 2(15), 210; S4, Section 94).
- Crucial Constitutional Exception: Protection of an "Accused Person" Under Article 20(3) (State of Gujarat v. Shyamlal Mohanlal Choksi, AIR 1965 SC 1251): In its landmark five-Judge Constitution Bench ruling in State of Gujarat v. Shyamlal Mohanlal Choksi (1965), the Supreme Court held that to avoid conflict with Article 20(3) of the Constitution ("No person accused of any offence shall be compelled to be a witness against himself"), Section 94 of the CrPC 1898 (later Section 91 of the CrPC 1973 and now Section 94 of the BNSS, 2023) does not empower a Court or police officer to issue a summons or written order to an accused person requiring them to produce an incriminating document or electronic record in their possession S5. Because such a summons cannot lawfully be issued to an accused to compel self-incriminating documentary production, an accused who declines to produce an incriminating document against themselves is not "legally bound" to produce it and cannot be convicted under BNS Section 210 (formerly IPC Section 175) S1 (Section 210; S5).
- Statutory Evidentiary Privileges Under the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA):
Even for a non-accused witness, a person is not "legally bound" to produce a document protected by an absolute statutory privilege, such as:
- BSA Section 128 (formerly Section 122 Evidence Act: communications during marriage);
- BSA Section 129 (formerly Section 123 Evidence Act: unpublished official records relating to affairs of State);
- BSA Section 136(1) (formerly Section 130 Evidence Act: title-deeds of a witness who is not a party to the suit, or documents which might tend to criminate him, unless he has agreed in writing to produce them); or
- BSA Section 137 (formerly Section 131 Evidence Act: documents or electronic records in his possession which another person would be entitled to refuse to produce if they were in their possession, such as client documents held by an advocate). At the same time, under BSA Section 165(1) (formerly Section 162 Evidence Act), a witness summoned to produce a document in Court must bring it to Court notwithstanding any objection to its production or admissibility, and the Court decides on the validity of any such objection (except regarding affairs of State) S1 (Section 210).
- Possession, Custody, or Power over the Document or Electronic Record:
- "Lex non cogit ad impossibilia". The law does not compel the impossible. A person cannot be convicted of "intentionally omitting to produce" a document or electronic record unless the prosecution proves (or it is admitted) that the document/electronic record actually existed and was in the possession, custody, or control of the summoned person at the relevant time S1 (Section 210).
- "Intentionally Omits So to Produce or Deliver Up" (Mens Rea):
- The omission must be intentional S1 (Section 210). Accidental loss, inadvertent destruction prior to service of the summons, or a bona fide inability to locate an archived file after diligent search negates the intentional mental element required by Section 210 S1 (Section 210). (Note: If a person intentionally destroys, obliterates, or secretes a document or electronic record to prevent its production as evidence before a Court or public servant, they commit the far graver offence of destruction of document or electronic record to prevent its production as evidence under BNS Section 241 [formerly IPC Section 204], punishable up to 3 years S1 (Section 210).)
Statutory Illustration Explained
The single statutory illustration appended to Section 210 states:
"A, being legally bound to produce a document before a District Court, intentionally omits to produce the same. A has committed the offence defined in this section." S1 (Section 210 Illustration)
Because a District Court is a "Court" under BNS Section 2(5), A's intentional omission falls squarely under Clause (b) of Section 210, carrying simple imprisonment up to 6 months, or a fine up to Rs. 10,000, or both S1 (Sections 2(5), 210(b)). Notice that BNS Section 210 also modernises the colonial phrase "a Zila Court" used in the original 1860 IPC Section 175 Illustration to "a District Court" S1 (Section 210 Illustration; S3, Section 175 Illustration).
Comparison with IPC Section 175
| Feature / Element | BNS Section 210 (2023) | IPC Section 175 (1860) | Legal Significance of Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Marginal Heading | "Omission to produce document or electronic record to public servant by person legally bound to produce it" S1 (Section 210) | "Omission to produce document to public servant by person legally bound to produce it" S3 (Section 175) | Heading modernisation: Aligns the section heading with the body text (which already included electronic records since the IT Act, 2000) S1 (Section 210; S3, Section 175). |
| Paragraph Structure | Clauses (a) and (b) S1 (Section 210) | Unlettered two-paragraph structure S3 (Section 175) | Structural modernisation matching BNSS First Schedule entries 210(a) and 210(b) S4 (First Schedule). |
| Judicial Forum Term & Illustration | "to a Court" in (b) and "a District Court" in Illustration S1 (Section 210) | "to a Court of Justice" and "a Zila Court" S3 (Section 175) | Terminological modernisation S1 (Section 210; S3, Section 175). |
| Clause (a) Fine Ceiling | Up to Rs. 5,000 S1 (Section 210(a)) | Up to Rs. 500 S3 (Section 175) | Substantive enhancement: Tenfold increase in maximum fine S1 (Section 210(a)). |
| Clause (b) Fine Ceiling | Up to Rs. 10,000 S1 (Section 210(b)) | Up to Rs. 1,000 S3 (Section 175) | Substantive enhancement: Tenfold increase in maximum fine S1 (Section 210(b)). |
| Imprisonment Terms | Simple imprisonment up to 1 month ((a)) or 6 months ((b)) S1 (Section 210) | Simple imprisonment up to 1 month or 6 months S3 (Section 175) | Substantively unchanged S1 (Section 210; S3, Section 175). |
Complete Punishment and Dual Procedural Track Matrix (BNSS Section 384 Summary Contempt vs. BNSS Section 215 Regular Complaint)
Unlike Sections 206–208, BNS Section 210 is subject to a dual procedural architecture under the BNSS, 2023 when the offence is committed in the view or presence of a Court S4 (First Schedule, Sections 215, 384, 385):
| Clause / Procedural Track | Triggering Fact Pattern | Imprisonment Term & Nature | Fine Limit & Conjunction | Cognizability & Bailability | Forum / Trial Court (BNSS First Schedule & Chapter XXVIII) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Section 210(a): Non-Court Public Servant | Intentional omission to produce/deliver up document or electronic record to a public servant (non-Court) S1 (Section 210(a)) | Simple imprisonment up to 1 month S1 (Section 210(a)) | Up to Rs. 5,000, or imprisonment, or both S1 (Section 210(a)) | Non-cognizable, Bailable S4 (First Schedule) | Any Magistrate, upon a written complaint under BNSS s. 215(1)(a)(i) S4 (First Schedule, Section 215) |
| Section 210(b): Regular Trial Track (BNSS s. 385 & s. 215) | Intentional omission to produce/deliver up document or electronic record to a Court, where the Court forwards a complaint for regular trial S1 (Section 210(b); S4, Section 385) | Simple imprisonment up to 6 months S1 (Section 210(b)) | Up to Rs. 10,000, or imprisonment, or both S1 (Section 210(b)) | Non-cognizable, Bailable S4 (First Schedule) | Magistrate having jurisdiction, on a written complaint under BNSS s. 215(1)(a)(i) / s. 385 S4 (Sections 215, 385) |
| Section 210(b): Summary In-Presence Contempt Track (BNSS s. 384(1)) | When an offence under Section 210 is committed in the view or presence of any Civil, Criminal, or Revenue Court and tried summarily on the same day S4 (Section 384(1)) | Detained in custody until the rising of the Court; in default of fine, simple imprisonment up to 1 month S4 (Section 384(1)) | Fine not exceeding Rs. 1,000 (increased from Rs. 200 in CrPC s. 345) S4 (Section 384(1)) | Summary contempt proceeding (appealable under BNSS s. 415) S4 (Section 384) | The Civil, Criminal, or Revenue Court itself before rising on the same day S4 (First Schedule, Section 384(1)) |
Concrete Hypothetical Examples and Counterexamples
- Example 1: Bank Branch Manager Intentionally Refusing to Produce Electronic KYC & Transaction Logs to Court (Clause (b) Offence Made Out):
Assumed Facts: A Judicial Magistrate First Class issues a summons under BNSS Section 94(1) to
M, a Bank Branch Manager (a non-accused witness), directingMto produce certified electronic RTGS logs and KYC records of an account holder before the Court on 20 November.Mreceives the summons, has immediate access to the electronic records on the bank server, and appears in Court, but intentionally refuses to produce the electronic records to shield the account holder, a personal friend. Legal Analysis:Mis legally bound under BNSS Section 94(1) to produce the electronic record to the Court and has intentionally omitted to do so S1 (Section 210(b); S4, Section 94(1)). The Magistrate may either deal withMsummarily on the same day under BNSS Section 384(1) (fine up to Rs. 1,000) or, considering the gravity of the defiance, record the facts and forward a complaint under BNSS Section 385 / Section 215(1)(a)(i) to another Magistrate for a full trial under BNS Section 210(b) (up to 6 months simple imprisonment or Rs. 10,000 fine or both) S1 (Section 210(b); S4, Sections 215, 384, 385). - Counterexample 1: Police Summons to an Accused to Produce an Incriminating Diary (Shyamlal Mohanlal Choksi Rule):
Assumed Facts: An Investigating Officer serves a written order under BNSS Section 94(1) on
X, who is already arraigned as the sole accused in an FIR for criminal breach of trust, commandingXto produce his personal handwritten ledger containing incriminating entries.Xrefuses to produce the ledger. Legal Analysis: Following the Constitution Bench ruling in State of Gujarat v. Shyamlal Mohanlal Choksi (AIR 1965 SC 1251) S5 and Article 20(3) of the Constitution, an accused person cannot be compelled by a summons under BNSS Section 94 to produce self-incriminating documents in their possession. BecauseXis not "legally bound" to comply with an unconstitutional compulsion,Xcommits no offence under BNS Section 210 S1 (Section 210; S5). (The police must instead resort to lawful search and seizure powers under BNSS Section 96 or Section 185.) - Counterexample 2: Summons to Produce a Document Not in Witness's Possession or Control:
Assumed Facts:
Y, a former company secretary who resigned three years ago and handed over all statutory registers to the Board of Directors, is served with a summons to produce the company's original minutes book.Yfiles an affidavit stating that he no longer has possession, custody, or access to the minutes book. Legal Analysis: Because the document is neither inY's possession nor underY's control,Y's inability to produce it is not an "intentional omission" by a person legally bound to produce it under BNS Section 210 S1 (Section 210).