Overview: Proportional Restructuring of IPC Section 152 into BNS Section 195
Under Section 152 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC), a person who actually used physical violence to obstruct a magistrate or police officer suppressing a riot and a person who merely uttered a threat or made an unsuccessful attempt to obstruct faced the exact same three-year felony exposure and cognizable arrest power S3, s. 152.
Section 195 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) introduces one of the most thoughtful structural refinements in Chapter XI by splitting IPC Section 152 into two distinct sub-sections S1, s. 195(1)-(2); S4:
- Sub-section (1) (
Actual Assault, Obstruction, or Criminal Force): Retains the 3-year imprisonment ceiling, introduces a statutory minimum fine floor of ₹25,000 where a fine is imposed, and remains Cognizable and triable by a Magistrate of the First Class S1, s. 195(1); S4. - Sub-section (2) (
Threatening to Assault or Attempting to Obstruct / Use Criminal Force): Separates inchoate threats and attempts into a lesser offence punishable with up to 1 year imprisonment, or fine (no minimum floor), or both, and reclassifies it under the BNSS First Schedule as Non-cognizable and triable by Any Magistrate S1, s. 195(2); S4.
Sub-Section Breakdown and Exact Ingredients
1. Common Functional Context Across Both Sub-sections
Both Section 195(1) and Section 195(2) BNS apply only when the victim is:
- A public servant as defined in Section 2(28) BNS (such as an Executive Magistrate, police officer, or armed forces officer acting under Sections 148–150 BNSS) S1, s. 2(28), s. 195; and
- Acting "in the discharge of his duty as such public servant" specifically in endeavouring to disperse an unlawful assembly, or to suppress a riot or affray S1, s. 195(1)-(2); S4.
If the public servant is discharging routine duties unrelated to dispersing an unlawful assembly or suppressing a riot or affray (for example, serving a civil summons or checking vehicle documents), obstructing or assaulting them falls under Section 221 BNS (obstructing public servant) or Section 132 BNS (assault/criminal force to deter public servant from duty), not Section 195 BNS S1, s. 132, s. 195, s. 221.
2. Sub-section (1): Actual Assault, Obstruction, or Use of Criminal Force
Section 195(1) BNS provides:
"Whoever assaults or obstructs any public servant, or uses criminal force on any public servant in the discharge of his duty as such public servant in endeavouring to disperse an unlawful assembly, or to suppress a riot or affray, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to three years, or with fine which shall not be less than twenty-five thousand rupees, or with both." S1, s. 195(1); S4
- Conduct Covered: Completed assault (defined in Section 130 BNS as making a gesture or preparation intending or knowing it to be likely to cause apprehension of criminal force), completed obstruction (physically blocking a police van, barricading a lane to stop riot-control personnel), or actual use of criminal force (Section 129 BNS: pushing, grappling with, or striking the officer) S1, s. 129, s. 130, s. 195(1).
- Sentencing Rule (
"fine which shall not be less than twenty-five thousand rupees"): The punishment conjunction is "or ... or with both" S1, s. 195(1). Thus, a court may impose imprisonment alone (up to 3 years), or fine alone, or both; however, whenever the court chooses to impose a fine (either alone or with imprisonment), the fine cannot be less than ₹25,000 S1, s. 195(1); S4.
3. Sub-section (2): Threatening to Assault or Attempting to Obstruct / Use Criminal Force
Section 195(2) BNS provides:
"Whoever threatens to assault or attempts to obstruct any public servant or threatens or attempts to use criminal force to any public servant in the discharge of his duty as such public servant in endeavouring to disperse an unlawful assembly, or to suppress a riot or affray, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to one year, or with fine, or with both." S1, s. 195(2); S4
- Conduct Covered: Verbal or written threats to assault or use criminal force against the officer, or an unsuccessful attempt to obstruct or use criminal force that falls short of actual obstruction or contact S1, s. 195(2).
IPC-to-BNS Comparison Table
| Feature | IPC Section 152 (1860) | BNS Section 195(1) & 195(2) (2023) | Legal Significance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Structure | Single composite section covering both actual assault/obstruction/force and threats/attempts S3, s. 152 | Split into Section 195(1) (actual assault/obstruction/force) and Section 195(2) (threats/attempts) S1, s. 195(1)-(2); S4 | Separates completed physical interference from threats/attempts S1; S3; S4. |
| Punishment for Actual Assault / Obstruction / Force | Up to 3 years, or fine (no minimum), or both S3, s. 152 | Up to 3 years, or fine not less than ₹25,000, or both (s. 195(1)) S1, s. 195(1); S4 | Introduces mandatory ₹25,000 floor whenever fine is imposed under s. 195(1) S1; S4. |
| Punishment for Threats or Attempts | Up to 3 years, or fine, or both S3, s. 152 | Up to 1 year, or fine, or both (s. 195(2)) S1, s. 195(2); S4 | Reduces maximum imprisonment by two-thirds (from 3 years to 1 year) for threats/attempts S1; S3; S4. |
| Procedural Classification for Threats or Attempts | Cognizable, Bailable, Magistrate of First Class S3 | Non-cognizable, Bailable, Any Magistrate (s. 195(2)) S4 | Prevents warrantless police arrest for mere verbal threats or unconsummated attempts during crowd control S4. |
Punishment and Procedural Classification under BNSS
| Offence Branch | Punishment | Cognizability | Bailability | Triable Court |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Actual assault, obstruction, or criminal force (Section 195(1) BNS) | Imprisonment of either description up to 3 years, or fine not less than ₹25,000, or both S1, s. 195(1) | Cognizable S4 | Bailable S4 | Magistrate of the First Class S4 |
Threatening to assault or attempting to obstruct / use criminal force (Section 195(2) BNS) | Imprisonment of either description up to 1 year, or fine, or both S1, s. 195(2) | Non-cognizable S4 | Bailable S4 | Any Magistrate S4 |
Practical Examples and Counterexamples
Example 1: Physically Grappling with a Sub-Inspector Dispersing a Riot (Section 195(1) BNS)
Assumed Facts: Sub-Inspector R arrives with a police picket to suppress an active street riot between two factions. As R steps between the rioters to arrest a stone-pelter, A grabs R's uniform collar and shoves him backward so the stone-pelter can escape.
Legal Analysis: A has used actual criminal force and obstructed a public servant in the discharge of his duty while suppressing a riot. A is liable under Section 195(1) BNS (Cognizable; up to 3 years imprisonment, or fine of at least ₹25,000, or both) S1, s. 195(1); S4.
Example 2: Shouting a Verbal Threat from a Balcony Without Physical Obstruction (Section 195(2) BNS)
Assumed Facts: While an Executive Magistrate is commanding an unlawful assembly on a street below to disperse, B leans out of a first-floor window and shouts at the Magistrate, "If you don't leave this lane in five minutes, I will come down and beat you!", but B never comes downstairs or physically blocks the dispersal operation.
Legal Analysis: B has threatened to assault / use criminal force against a public servant endeavouring to disperse an unlawful assembly, without committing actual physical obstruction or criminal force. Under the BNS, B is chargeable only under Section 195(2) BNS (Non-cognizable; maximum 1 year imprisonment, or fine, or both), not the heavier Section 195(1) S1, s. 195(1)-(2); S4.