Overview and Direct Answer
Section 175 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) criminalises the making or publishing of a false statement of fact relating to the personal character or conduct of any candidate with the intent to affect the result of an election, where the maker/publisher knows or believes the statement to be false or does not believe it to be true S1, s. 175. Replacing Section 171G of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC) verbatim, Section 175 BNS is punishable with fine only (no substantive imprisonment), and is classified under the First Schedule to the BNSS, 2023 as Non-cognizable, Bailable, and Triable by a Magistrate of the first class S1, s. 175; S3, s. 171G; S4, s. 175. As the Supreme Court established in the landmark decision Inder Lal vs. Lal Singh, AIR 1962 SC 1156 S8, this offence targets false factual attacks on "the man beneath the politician" (personal moral integrity and private conduct), and does not criminalise sharp criticism or opinions regarding a candidate's public policies, legislative voting record, or political performance S1, s. 175; S8.
Statutory Text and Five Cumulative Ingredients
Section 175 BNS states:
"Whoever with intent to affect the result of an election makes or publishes any statement purporting to be a statement of fact which is false and which he either knows or believes to be false or does not believe to be true, in relation to the personal character or conduct of any candidate shall be punished with fine." S1, s. 175
Every single one of the following five cumulative elements must be proved by the prosecution beyond reasonable doubt:
- Target Must Be a Nominated
"Candidate":- By virtue of Section 169(a) BNS,
"candidate"means a person"who has been nominated as a candidate at any election"S1, s. 169(a); S1, s. 175. False statements directed solely at a political party in the abstract, or at a campaigner/star campaigner who has not been nominated as a candidate, or made before the target has been nominated as a candidate, do not satisfy Section 175 BNS (though they may attract general defamation under Section 356 BNS) S1, s. 169(a); S1, s. 175.
- By virtue of Section 169(a) BNS,
- Actus Reus: Making or Publishing a Statement Purporting to Be a Statement of Fact:
- The accused must
"make or publish"(whether orally at a rally, in print pamphlets/newspapers, or via social media/electronic broadcasts) a statement"purporting to be a statement of fact"S1, s. 175. - Fact vs. Opinion / Rhetorical Hyperbole: Calling a candidate "incompetent", "anti-people", or "the worst legislator in the district" is an expression of opinion or value judgment, not a
"statement of fact"S1, s. 175; S8. By contrast, alleging that the candidate "embezzled ₹50 lakh from the village cooperative bank last year" or "was convicted of smuggling narcotics" is a verifiable statement of fact S1, s. 175; S8.
- The accused must
- Subject Matter:
"In Relation to the Personal Character or Conduct of Any Candidate":- This is the most frequently litigated ingredient in Indian election law. In Inder Lal vs. Lal Singh, AIR 1962 SC 1156 S8, Justice P.B. Gajendragadkar speaking for the Supreme Court drew the classic distinction between personal character/conduct and public/political character/conduct:
- Statements attacking a candidate's personal character or conduct strike at "the man beneath the politician": his private moral character, honesty, veracity, or personal integrity (for example, accusing him of taking bribes, committing a crime involving moral turpitude, or falsifying accounts) S8.
- Statements criticising a candidate's political or public policies, even if exaggerated or factually inaccurate (for example, falsely claiming that the candidate's party voted in favour of a controversial tax bill in the Assembly): relate to his public/political role rather than his personal character or conduct, because voters in a democracy can test and debate public policy claims in the political arena S8.
- This is the most frequently litigated ingredient in Indian election law. In Inder Lal vs. Lal Singh, AIR 1962 SC 1156 S8, Justice P.B. Gajendragadkar speaking for the Supreme Court drew the classic distinction between personal character/conduct and public/political character/conduct:
- Objective Falsity + Subjective Mens Rea Regarding Falsity:
- First, the statement must in fact be false (
"which is false") S1, s. 175. - Second, at the time of making or publishing it, the accused must either:
- (a) Know it to be false;
- (b) Believe it to be false; or
- (c) Not believe it to be true (which covers reckless fabrication made without any honest belief in its truth) S1, s. 175.
- First, the statement must in fact be false (
- Specific Ulterior Intent:
"With Intent to Affect the Result of an Election":- The statement must be made or published with the specific intention of influencing voters and affecting the outcome of the election S1, s. 175.
Comparison with IPC Section 171G, Section 123(4) RP Act, and BNS Section 356 (Defamation)
| Dimension | BNS Section 175 (IPC Section 171G) | Section 123(4), Representation of the People Act, 1951 | BNS Section 356 (Defamation, formerly IPC 499/500) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Protected Person | Nominated "candidate" at any legislative, municipal, or public authority election S1, s. 169(a); S1, s. 175 | Candidate at a Parliamentary or State Legislative election S8 | Any person (including non-candidates and political parties) S1, s. 356 |
| Subject Matter | False statement of fact regarding personal character or conduct S1, s. 175 | False statement of fact regarding personal character or conduct, or in relation to the candidature or withdrawal of any candidate S8 | Any imputation concerning any person intending to harm, or knowing/having reason to believe it will harm, reputation (subject to 10 Exceptions) S1, s. 356 |
| Falsity Burden | Prosecution must prove the statement is false and accused knew/believed it false or did not believe it true S1, s. 175 | Election petitioner must prove falsity and lack of belief in truth S8 | Harm to reputation is sufficient unless accused proves Truth + Public Good under First Exception S1, s. 356 |
| Punishment | Fine only S1, s. 175 | Corrupt practice voiding election (Section 100 RP Act) and causing disqualification | Simple imprisonment up to 2 years, or fine, or both, or community service S1, s. 356(2) |
(Notice the subtle textual difference between Section 175 BNS and Section 123(4) of the RP Act, 1951: Section 123(4) RP Act also covers false statements of fact "in relation to the candidature, or withdrawal, of any candidate", whereas Section 175 BNS (like IPC Section 171G) is strictly confined to statements "in relation to the personal character or conduct of any candidate"! Thus, falsely publishing on polling morning that a rival candidate has withdrawn from the race is a corrupt practice under Section 123(4) RP Act, 1951, but does not fall within Section 175 BNS unless it also impugns the candidate's personal character or conduct) S1, s. 175; S8.
Punishment Matrix and Default-of-Fine Rules
- Primary Punishment: Fine only (
"shall be punished with fine") S1, s. 175. Under Section 8(1) BNS, because no monetary ceiling is specified in Section 175 BNS, the amount of fine is unlimited,"but shall not be excessive"S1, s. 8(1); S1, s. 175. - Imprisonment in Default of Payment of Fine: Because Section 175 BNS is punishable with fine only, Section 8(5) BNS governs any default sentence: the imprisonment in default of payment of fine must be simple imprisonment, and its term shall not exceed two months (when fine ≤ ₹5,000), four months (when fine ≤ ₹10,000), or one year (when fine > ₹10,000) S1, s. 8(5); S1, s. 175.
Procedural Classification under the BNSS, 2023
Under the First Schedule to the BNSS, 2023 S4, s. 175:
- Cognizability: Non-cognizable S4, s. 175.
- Bailability: Bailable S4, s. 175.
- Trial Court: Triable by Magistrate of the first class S4, s. 175.
Practical Examples and Counterexamples
- Editorial Hypothetical 1 (Fabricated Pamphlet Alleging Embezzlement of Orphanage Funds: Guilty under Section 175 BNS):
- Assumed Facts: On the eve of polling for a Legislative Assembly seat, D prints and circulates via WhatsApp and handbills a statement alleging as a fact that nominated candidate C stole ₹25 lakh from a local charitable orphanage trust. D has fabricated the allegation without any basis, knowing it to be false, to swing undecided voters against C.
- Analysis: The statement purports to be a statement of fact, is false, was published by D knowing it to be false, attacks C's personal character and conduct ("the man beneath the politician"), and was published with intent to affect the election result S1, s. 175; S8. D is guilty under Section 175 BNS S1, s. 175.
- Editorial Hypothetical 2 (Counterexample, Inaccurate Claim About Candidate's Legislative Attendance or Policy Stance, Not Guilty under Section 175 BNS):
- Assumed Facts: During an election debate, speaker S asserts that incumbent candidate C never asked a single question in the Assembly regarding local irrigation canals and supported privatising state bus routes. In fact, C had asked two questions on irrigation three years earlier.
- Analysis: Even if S's statement was factually inaccurate, it relates strictly to C's public and political performance as a legislator, not to C's private moral integrity or personal character or conduct S1, s. 175; S8. Applying Inder Lal vs. Lal Singh, AIR 1962 SC 1156 S8, S is not guilty under Section 175 BNS S1, s. 175; S8.