The provision in one view
Section 153 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 punishes a person who wages war against the Government of any foreign State at peace with the Government of India, who attempts to wage such war, or who abets the waging of such war. The punishment is imprisonment for life, to which fine may be added, or imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to seven years, to which fine may be added, or with fine S1; S3.
Its predecessor is section 125 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 S2. A token-level comparison of the operative text returned a similarity of 0.9489 with a single reported difference -- and unlike most sections in this Chapter, that difference is substantive. The Sanhita replaced "any Asiatic Power in alliance or at peace with" by "any foreign State at peace with".
Three further findings are set out below:
- The First Schedule misdescribes the punishment, converting a discretionary fine into a mandatory one, twice. This is a different kind of Schedule defect from any found earlier in this collection.
- The penalty runs down to a fine alone, which is remarkable for an offence of waging war.
- There is Supreme Court authority on the predecessor, and it shows what the section requires -- and that the Sanhita's broadening would not have changed the outcome of the case in which it was applied.
The exact words
"Whoever wages war against the Government of any foreign State at peace with the Government of India or attempts to wage such war, or abets the waging of such war, shall be punished with imprisonment for life, to which fine may be added, or with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to seven years, to which fine may be added, or with fine." S1; S3
The comparison with section 125 of the Penal Code: a real broadening
The Penal Code provision read:
"Whoever wages war against the Government of any Asiatic Power in alliance or at peace with the Government of India or attempts to wage such war, or abets the waging of such war..." S2
The Sanhita reads:
"Whoever wages war against the Government of any foreign State at peace with the Government of India or attempts to wage such war, or abets the waging of such war..." S1
Everything else -- the three verbs, the three-tier penalty, the structure of the sentence -- is identical. The single replacement does two things at once.
"Asiatic Power" became "foreign State"
This is a genuine expansion of the section's protective scope. Section 125 protected only the Governments of Asiatic Powers. A person who waged war from Indian territory against a European, African or American State was outside it. Section 153 protects the Government of any foreign State, without geographic limitation S1; S2.
That is the first substantive widening found in this Chapter since section 148, and unlike section 148's insertion of "and beyond" -- which appeared tautologous -- this one plainly changes what the section covers.
The restriction it removes was an artefact of the Penal Code's origins. A statute drafted for British India in 1860 was concerned with India's immediate neighbourhood, and the "Asiatic Power" formula reflected that. The Sanhita's drafter removed the limitation rather than updating the list of protected States, which is the same approach taken at section 151, where the surviving two offices were left as they stood rather than modernised.
"In alliance or" was dropped
The Penal Code covered a Power "in alliance or at peace with" the Government of India. Section 153 covers a foreign State "at peace with" it. The words "in alliance or" are gone S1; S2.
On its face this looks like tidying rather than narrowing. The old formula was a union of two categories, and a State in alliance with India would also be at peace with India, so the narrower alternative added nothing to the wider one. On that reading the section's reach is unchanged by the deletion.
That is offered as a reading of the text, not as a certainty. It assumes that alliance always implies peace, and no authority on the point was located. A reader should note that the deletion is there, and that its effect has not been judicially considered.
The marginal note drops "the", for the fourth time
The Penal Code's marginal note read "Waging war against any Asiatic Power in alliance with the Government of India"; the Sanhita's reads "Waging war against Government of any foreign State at peace with Government of India" S1; S2. The definite article is dropped before "Government" in both places where the marginal note uses it, while the operative text retains "the" in both places, as the Gazette confirms S1; S3.
That is the fourth instance of this marginal-note change in this Chapter, after sections 147, 149 and 151, against two sections where it did not occur. It remains frequent but not uniform, and no Chapter-wide rule is asserted.
The penalty history
Two footnote markers appear inside the section 125 block, numbered 1 and 14 S2:
| Marker | Records |
|---|---|
| 1 | "Queen" replaced by "Government of India" (Adaptation of Laws Order, 1950) |
| 14 | "transportation for life or any shorter term" replaced by "imprisonment for life" (Act 26 of 1955, s. 117 and the Schedule, with effect from 1 January 1956) |
So the offence was originally punishable with transportation for life or any shorter term. Two points of contrast with the rest of the Chapter are worth recording. First, that formula differs from sections 121 and 122, whose footnotes record plain "transportation". Second, and more significantly, no forfeiture-of-property footnote appears in the section 125 block. Sections 121 and 122 both carried forfeiture of all the offender's property until 1921; section 125 shows no trace of it, as section 123 did not either.
The penalty history of this Chapter is therefore not uniform, and the suggestion recorded earlier in this collection that the 1921 and 1955 amendments swept the whole Chapter is not borne out. The 1955 substitution reached sections 121, 122 and 125; the 1921 forfeiture repeal appears only at sections 121 and 122.
As elsewhere, this rests on the footnote apparatus published with the Penal Code; the 1860 Gazette has not been retrieved.
A penalty that runs down to a fine alone
The punishment clause has three tiers S1:
- imprisonment for life, to which fine may be added;
- imprisonment of either description up to seven years, to which fine may be added;
- fine alone.
The third tier is striking. A person who wages war against a friendly foreign State may, on the face of the section, be punished with a fine and nothing else. No minimum sentence is prescribed, and the court's discretion runs the whole way down.
Two points of contrast sharpen this:
- Section 147, which punishes waging war against the Government of India, carries death as its maximum and contains no fine-only option S6.
- Section 152 makes a fine a mandatory addition to imprisonment, with no fine-only alternative S7.
So within one Chapter the Sanhita contains a capital offence, an offence with a mandatory fine, and an offence punishable by fine alone. The gradient reflects the object attacked: war against India's own Government at the top, war against a friendly foreign State considerably lower.
Note also that the fine in the first two tiers is discretionary -- "to which fine may be added" -- not mandatory. That matters for the next part.
The First Schedule misdescribes the punishment
The First Schedule to the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 classifies the offence as follows S4:
| Column | Entry |
|---|---|
| Offence | Waging war against Government of any foreign State at peace with the Government of India |
| Punishment | Imprisonment for life and fine, or imprisonment for 7 years and fine, or fine |
| Cognizable or non-cognizable | Cognizable |
| Bailable or non-bailable | Non-bailable |
| By what court triable | Court of Session |
Compare the section itself, which reads "imprisonment for life, to which fine may be added, or ... seven years, to which fine may be added, or with fine" S1.
The Schedule says "and fine" where the section says the fine "may be added". It does so twice. On the Schedule's wording a fine is a compulsory component of either custodial sentence; on the section's wording it is discretionary in both.
This is a new kind of Schedule defect in this collection. The defects recorded earlier were of three types: the punishment column flattening a ceiling, as at sections 137(2), 141 and 145; the forum column assigning an offence to a court that cannot impose its maximum, as at sections 137(2), 139(1) and 140(3); and the offence column diverging in wording from the Sanhita's marginal note, as at sections 147 to 151. This is none of those. It is a misdescription of the penalty's structure, converting a discretionary element into a mandatory one.
Nothing turns on it as a matter of law. The First Schedule classifies offences for procedural purposes; it does not create or define the punishment, which is fixed by section 153. A court sentencing under section 153 would apply the section, and the fine would remain discretionary. But the Schedule is widely used as a quick reference, and on this entry it is wrong about what the section provides.
The forum, and a seventh wording divergence
The forum entry is correct. A maximum of imprisonment for life is far beyond the powers of any Magistrate under section 23 of that Sanhita, and the offence is assigned to the Court of Session S4. This is the nineteenth forum entry in this collection found to be correct, against three found defective.
The Schedule's description also restores "the" before the second "Government of India", which the Sanhita's marginal note omits, though it leaves the first omission as it stands S1; S4. That is a seventh wording divergence in this Chapter, on a count that now stands at six of seven -- the run having broken at section 152.
Compounding
Section 153 appears in neither table of compoundable offences in section 359 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 S4. The offence is not compoundable. Probes for "153", "foreign" and "war" were all negative in both tables, so no substring required adjudication.
The case law: a Supreme Court decision, and what it actually turned on
Section 125 produced a Supreme Court decision in Union of India v. Yasmeen Mohammad Zahid, decided on 2 August 2019 S5. It is the most substantial authority located for any section of this Chapter after section 147, and it repays careful reading because the obvious inference from it is the wrong one.
What happened
Fifteen accused were named in a charge-sheet in an investigation conducted by the National Investigation Agency. All but one were absconding, and the second accused alone was tried, on charges under section 120B of the Penal Code, section 125 of the Penal Code, and sections 38, 39 and 40 of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 S5.
The Special Court for the trial of National Investigation Agency cases at Ernakulam convicted her on all five counts, imposing rigorous imprisonment of three years under section 120B and seven years on each of the other four, with a fine of Rs. 25,000 S5.
The High Court of Kerala set aside the conviction under section 125 and under sections 39 and 40 of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, upheld the convictions under section 120B and section 38 of that Act, and reduced the sentences from three and seven years to one and three years S5.
Both sides appealed. The Supreme Court dismissed the Union's appeal against the acquittal under section 125 S5.
Why the section 125 charge failed
The reasoning the Supreme Court left undisturbed was that there was evidence that the accused had attended classes of Jihad propagating the ideology of a terrorist organisation, but
"there was nothing to indicate that she had taken any steps to wage a war or had attempted or abetted waging of such war against any Asiatic Power in alliance with or at peace with Government of India and as such there was no material to sustain the charge under Section 125 IPC." S5
So ideological alignment, however serious, is not enough. The section requires steps towards waging war -- or an attempt, or abetment -- directed at the Government of a particular foreign State.
The point most likely to be got wrong
It would be natural to suppose that the prosecution failed because the organisation concerned was not the Government of an "Asiatic Power", and therefore that section 153's broader "any foreign State" would have produced a conviction. That does not follow from the judgment.
The acquittal did not rest on the target failing to qualify. It rested on the absence of any steps towards waging war at all. On that reasoning the replacement of "Asiatic Power" by "foreign State" would not have saved the charge: the missing element was conduct, not the identity of the State.
The broadening at section 153 is therefore real, but this decision is not evidence that it will make prosecutions easier. No authority on section 153 itself was located, and the practical effect of the change is undetermined.
Two further points from the same decision
The Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act did the work that section 125 did not. The conviction that survived was under section 120B of the Penal Code and section 38 of that Act S5. Where section 125 required war-waging steps, section 38 required association with a terrorist organisation with intention to further its activities.
The sentence was restored. The High Court had reduced the sentences on the ground of sympathy. The Supreme Court held that "there was no room for invoking sympathetic considerations", that the trial court's sentence "was absolutely correct and adequate", and allowed the Union's appeal on that point, restoring the original sentences S5. The Court also corrected the High Court's observation that section 39 becomes superfluous where a person is punishable under section 38, holding that "the scope of these two Sections and their fields of operation are different" S5.
No Sanhita-era authority
A targeted search for authority on section 153 returned four results, every one of which was the text of a statute rather than a judgment S1. No decision under section 153 was located. The section rests on its text, on the Supreme Court's construction of its predecessor, and on nothing else.
Commencement and application
Section 153 came into force on 1 July 2024, by Ministry of Home Affairs notification S.O. 850(E) dated 23 February 2024 S8.
Conduct before that date falls under section 125 of the Penal Code; conduct on or after it falls under section 153 S1; S2. Here the distinction has substance, because the two provisions differ: conduct directed against the Government of a non-Asiatic foreign State, before 1 July 2024, was not within section 125 at all.
Practical points for readers
- The protected States are now all foreign States, not only Asiatic Powers S1; S2.
- The State must be at peace with India. Waging war against a State that is not at peace with India is outside this section S1.
- Steps towards waging war are required. On Supreme Court authority, attending classes propagating a violent ideology did not sustain a charge under the predecessor S5.
- An attempt and abetment are both inside the section, at the same penalty as the completed offence S1.
- The punishment runs from imprisonment for life down to a fine alone S1.
- The fine is discretionary, not mandatory, despite what the First Schedule says S1; S4.
- Do not rely on the First Schedule's punishment column for this section. It states "and fine" twice where the section makes the fine optional S1; S4.
- Cognizable, non-bailable, Court of Session, not compoundable S4.
- There is no decided authority on section 153 itself S1.
Limitations of this article
- No authority on section 153 was located. A targeted search returned four results, all of them statute texts rather than judgments.
- The effect of the "Asiatic Power" to "foreign State" change is undetermined. It plainly widens the section's scope on the text, but no decision applying the widened provision was located, and the Supreme Court decision on the predecessor did not turn on the point.
- The reading that dropping "in alliance or" does not narrow the section is an argument from the text, resting on the assumption that a State in alliance with India is necessarily at peace with it. No authority on the point was located.
- What constitutes being "at peace with" the Government of India was not researched, and no judicial or statutory definition was located. Nor was it examined whether that question is justiciable or determined by the executive.
- "Foreign State" is not defined in the section, and whether it extends to an entity claiming statehood but not recognised by India was not researched. The Supreme Court decision discussed did not decide it.
- The 1860 Gazette has not been retrieved. The penalty history is an inference from the footnote apparatus published with the Penal Code.
- No Law Commission or legislative-committee material was located or searched for this section, so no documented rationale for removing the "Asiatic Power" limitation is offered. That is the obvious place such a rationale would be found.
- The relationship between section 153 and the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 is described only as it appeared in the decision discussed. How a prosecutor would choose between them was not researched.
- Bail law was not examined beyond recording the Schedule's classification.
- Sections 154 to 158 were not analysed, although the First Schedule entry for section 154 was read incidentally.
- The Schedule's misdescription of the fine is reported as a defect in the Schedule. No authority was located on what a court should do where the Schedule and the section conflict, and the article's statement that the section prevails is a reading of their respective functions.
- Nineteen search results for the predecessor were returned and not all examined. One decision was read in full; the others were noted as National Investigation Agency and terrorism matters and not pursued.
Frequently asked questions
1. What does section 153 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita punish? Waging war against the Government of any foreign State at peace with the Government of India, attempting to wage such war, or abetting it S1.
2. What is the punishment? Imprisonment for life, to which fine may be added; or imprisonment of either description up to seven years, to which fine may be added; or fine alone S1.
3. Can this offence really be punished by a fine alone? On the face of the section, yes. The third tier of the punishment clause is a fine with no imprisonment, and no minimum sentence is prescribed S1.
4. Which section of the Indian Penal Code did this replace? Section 125 S2.
5. Did the wording change? Yes, and substantively. A comparison returned 0.9489 with one difference: "any Asiatic Power in alliance or at peace with" became "any foreign State at peace with" S1; S2.
6. What does that change do? Two things. It removes the geographic restriction, so the Governments of all foreign States are now protected and not only Asiatic Powers. And it drops the words "in alliance or" S1; S2.
7. Does dropping "in alliance or" narrow the section? Probably not, because a State in alliance with India would also be at peace with India, so the wider alternative already covered the narrower one. That is a reading of the text; no authority on it was located S1; S2.
8. Is this the first real change in this Chapter? It is the first substantive widening since section 148, and unlike section 148's "and beyond", which appears tautologous, this one plainly changes what the section covers S1; S2.
9. Does the section protect a State that is not at peace with India? No. The State must be at peace with the Government of India S1.
10. What does "at peace with" mean? The section does not say, and no definition or authority was located. It was not researched here S1.
11. Is ideological support for a violent organisation enough? No. The Supreme Court upheld an acquittal under the predecessor where there was evidence the accused had attended classes propagating a violent ideology but nothing to show she had taken any steps to wage war S5.
12. Would the broadening to "any foreign State" have changed that result? Not on the Court's reasoning. The acquittal rested on the absence of any war-waging steps, not on the target failing to be an Asiatic Power S5.
13. What happened in that case overall? The trial court convicted on five counts. The High Court set aside the convictions under section 125 and under sections 39 and 40 of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act and reduced the sentences. The Supreme Court dismissed the appeals against the acquittals, but restored the original sentences on the counts that stood S5.
14. Why did the Supreme Court restore the sentences? Because the only ground on which the High Court had reduced them was sympathy, and the Court held there was no room for sympathetic considerations and that the trial court's sentence was correct and adequate S5.
15. Is there any decided authority on section 153 itself? No. A targeted search returned four results, all of them statute texts S1.
16. Does the First Schedule describe the punishment correctly? No. It states "Imprisonment for life and fine, or imprisonment for 7 years and fine, or fine", whereas the section says the fine "may be added" in each of the custodial tiers. The Schedule converts a discretionary fine into a mandatory one S1; S4.
17. Which prevails? The section. The First Schedule classifies offences for procedural purposes and does not define the punishment. No authority on the conflict was located, and that statement reflects the respective functions of the two provisions S1; S4.
18. Is the offence cognizable and bailable? Cognizable and non-bailable, according to the First Schedule S4.
19. Which court tries it? The Court of Session, which is correct given a maximum of imprisonment for life S4.
20. Can it be compounded? No. Section 153 appears in neither table of compoundable offences in section 359 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 S4.
21. What was the original punishment under the Penal Code? Transportation for life or any shorter term, replaced by imprisonment for life by Act 26 of 1955 with effect from 1 January 1956 S2.
22. Did this section ever carry forfeiture of property, as sections 121 and 122 did? No forfeiture footnote appears in the section 125 block, so on the material examined it did not. The Chapter's penalty history is not uniform S2.
23. How does the punishment compare with waging war against India itself? Section 147, which punishes waging war against the Government of India, carries death as its maximum and has no fine-only option. Section 153 is capped at imprisonment for life and can be met by a fine S1; S6.
24. When did section 153 come into force? 1 July 2024, by Ministry of Home Affairs notification S.O. 850(E) dated 23 February 2024 S8.
This article states the law as published in the sources cited and is for general information only. It is not legal advice. Section 153 widens its predecessor by protecting the Government of any foreign State rather than only an Asiatic Power, its punishment runs from imprisonment for life down to a fine alone, the First Schedule misdescribes that punishment as including a mandatory fine, and no court has yet construed the section as enacted. Anyone affected by, or advising on, a matter under this section should obtain qualified legal advice. Verify the current text, and take advice on your own facts, before acting.