What the section says
Section 13 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 reads: S1
13. Whoever, having been convicted by a Court in India, of an offence punishable under Chapter X or Chapter XVII of this Sanhita with imprisonment of either description for a term of three years or upwards, shall be guilty of any offence punishable under either of those Chapters with like imprisonment for the like term, shall be subject for every such subsequent offence to imprisonment for life, or to imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to ten years.
The official marginal-note title is "Enhanced punishment for certain offences after previous conviction.", cross-checked against the India Code entry for the section. S2
This is the Sanhita's general recidivism provision, and it is the last section of Chapter II (Of Punishments): Chapter III (General Exceptions) begins at s. 14. S1 It is also the first section in this part of the Sanhita where the text, read against its Penal Code predecessor, produces a substantive change in scope rather than a renumbering.
The four conditions
Section 13 is a single sentence with four cumulative requirements. All must be satisfied.
- A previous conviction by a Court in India. Not a charge, not an arrest, not a pending appeal left undecided: a conviction, and one recorded by a Court in India.
- The previous conviction must be for an offence punishable under Chapter X or Chapter XVII of the Sanhita. Only those two chapters qualify. A previous conviction under any other chapter (murder, hurt, kidnapping, criminal intimidation, forgery) does not open s. 13 at all.
- The previous offence must have been punishable with imprisonment of either description for a term of three years or upwards. The test is the punishment the statute provides, not the sentence the court actually passed. A person sentenced to six months for an offence carrying a three-year maximum satisfies this condition.
- The subsequent offence must be punishable "under either of those Chapters with like imprisonment for the like term", that is, it too must be a Chapter X or Chapter XVII offence punishable with imprisonment of either description for three years or upwards.
Only when all four are met does the consequence follow: the offender "shall be subject for every such subsequent offence to imprisonment for life, or to imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to ten years."
What the enhancement actually does, and what it does not do
The words "shall be subject… to" mean liable to. Section 13 enlarges the court's maximum sentencing power; it does not direct any particular sentence and it does not create a minimum.
So where s. 13 applies:
- the ceiling for the subsequent offence rises to ten years, or imprisonment for life, displacing whatever lower maximum that offence ordinarily carries;
- but the court remains free to pass a sentence within the ordinary range, or below it, because nothing in s. 13 compels an enhanced sentence;
- and s. 13 creates no separate offence. It is a sentencing provision. There is no such thing as "an offence under s. 13"; a person is convicted of theft, or of counterfeiting, and s. 13 governs the punishment available for it.
This last point matters in practice because the procedural rules treat the previous conviction as a sentencing fact to be charged and proved, not as an ingredient of the substantive offence, which is why it is kept out of the trial until guilt has been determined. That machinery is described below.
The two chapters, and a renumbering trap
Everything in s. 13 turns on which chapters it names, so the chapter headings were read directly from the Gazette text of both codes. S1S4
| Indian Penal Code, 1860 | Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 | |
|---|---|---|
| First qualifying chapter | Chapter XII: "Of Offences relating to Coin and Government Stamps" | Chapter X: "Of Offences relating to Coin, Currency-Notes, Bank-Notes, and Government Stamps" (ss. 178–188) |
| Second qualifying chapter | Chapter XVII: "Of Offences against Property" | Chapter XVII: "Of Offences against Property" (begins at s. 303) |
Two consequences follow, and they pull in different directions.
First, a trap for anyone carrying the old numbering across. The coinage chapter moved from XII to X. But the BNS also has a Chapter XII: "Of Offences by or relating to Public Servants". So a reader who remembers s. 75 as covering "Chapter XII or Chapter XVII" and applies that to the Sanhita will land on public-servant offences, which s. 13 does not cover at all. The number survived; it now denotes something entirely different.
Second, and more significantly, the first chapter is substantively wider. Its heading now names currency-notes and bank-notes, and that is not cosmetic.
The real change: currency-note offences now qualify
Under the Penal Code, the offences of counterfeiting and dealing in forged currency-notes and bank-notes: ss. 489A to 489E: sat under the sub-heading "Of currency-notes and bank-notes" inside Chapter XVIII ("Of Offences relating to Documents and to Property Marks"). They were not in Chapter XII. S4
The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita moved them. Counterfeiting of coin, Government stamps, currency-notes and bank-notes is now dealt with together in Chapter X, s. 178 being the opening provision and carrying imprisonment for life, or imprisonment of either description up to ten years, and fine. The Sanhita's Chapter XVIII ("Of Offences relating to Documents and to Property Marks") was searched in full: the words "currency" and "bank-note" appear in it zero times. The relocation is complete. S1S4
The consequence for s. 13 is direct and checkable:
A previous conviction for counterfeiting currency-notes was not a qualifying previous conviction under IPC s. 75, because that offence lay in Chapter XVIII. Under BNS s. 13 the identical offence is a qualifying previous conviction, because it now lies in Chapter X.
The threshold condition is comfortably met: s. 178 carries life or up to ten years, far above "three years or upwards". So the pool of qualifying convictions has been widened, and widened without a single word being added to the recidivism provision itself. The change was effected entirely by reorganising the chapters the provision points to.
This is an inference from the chapter structure of the two codes, each of which was read directly; it is not a proposition taken from any judgment, and no decision on the point was located. It is set out here because it is the kind of change that a section-by-section comparison of s. 75 against s. 13: which shows the operative words as nearly identical: would entirely miss.
Comparison with IPC Section 75
| IPC s. 75 | BNS s. 13 | |
|---|---|---|
| Marginal title | "Enhanced punishment for certain offences under Chapter XII or Chapter XVII after previous conviction" | "Enhanced punishment for certain offences after previous conviction" |
| Structure | "Whoever, having been convicted,— (a) by a Court in India, of an offence…" followed by an omitted clause shown as asterisks | Single continuous sentence; no clause lettering |
| Qualifying chapters | Chapter XII (coin and Government stamps) or Chapter XVII (property) | Chapter X (coin, currency-notes, bank-notes and Government stamps) or Chapter XVII (property) |
| Currency-note offences qualify? | No. They were in Chapter XVIII | Yes. They are now in Chapter X |
| Threshold | three years or upwards | three years or upwards (unchanged) |
| Enhanced maximum | imprisonment for life, or either description up to ten years | identical |
| Mandatory? | No: "shall be subject… to" | No: identical |
So the operative words are carried over almost exactly. The changes are: the title was shortened, the vestigial clause lettering was removed, and, by reorganisation elsewhere in the code, the first qualifying chapter became wider.
The drafting remnant the BNS cleaned up
The odd "(a)" in IPC s. 75, with no "(b)" following it, was not a printing error. The amendment footnotes to the official text record the section's history: S4
- the whole of s. 75 was substituted by Act 3 of 1910, s. 2;
- the words "British India" were successively substituted by the Adaptation of Laws Order 1948, the Adaptation of Laws Order 1950 and Act 3 of 1951, s. 3 and the Schedule (w.e.f. 1 April 1951), to read "India";
- the word "or" at the end of clause (a) was omitted by Act 3 of 1951, s. 3 and the Schedule (w.e.f. 1 April 1951);
- clause (b) was omitted by the same provision (w.e.f. 1 April 1951);
- "imprisonment for life" was substituted for "transportation for life" by Act 26 of 1955, s. 117 and the Schedule (w.e.f. 1 January 1956).
When clause (b) went in 1951, the lettering of clause (a) was left standing. The Penal Code therefore carried an orphaned "(a)" for seventy-three years. Section 13 removes it and runs the provision as one sentence. That is a tidying of form, not a change of substance, but it is worth knowing that the missing clause (b) was deliberately omitted in 1951 and is not something the BNS dropped.
A note on sources: the amendment history above is taken from the footnotes to the official Penal Code text. The amending Acts and Adaptation Orders themselves were not separately accessed.
Special and local laws do not count
Section 13 says "an offence punishable under Chapter X or Chapter XVII of this Sanhita". A previous conviction under a special or local law (a narcotics statute, an arms statute, a State enactment) therefore does not qualify, however serious, and however closely it may resemble a property offence.
This is reinforced by the definition of "offence" in s. 2(24). That clause lists the chapters and sections in which "offence" is extended to things punishable under special or local law. The list in s. 2(24)(a) runs: Chapter III and sub-sections (2) to (5) of s. 8, ss. 9, 49, 50, 52, 54 to 61, 119, 120, 123, sub-sections (7) and (8) of s. 127, 222, 230, 231, 240, 248, 250, 251, 259 to 263, sub-sections (6) and (7) of s. 308, and sub-section (2) of s. 330. Section 13 is not in it. Nor is it in the narrower list in s. 2(24)(b). The list was read in full and checked for the number rather than recalled. S1
So two independent features of the text (the words "of this Sanhita" in s. 13, and the absence of s. 13 from s. 2(24)) point the same way. The position under the Penal Code was the same: IPC s. 75 spoke of offences "under… this Code".
Section 13 is not the only recidivism rule in the Sanhita
Section 13 is the general provision, confined to two chapters. The BNS also contains a number of section-specific repeat-offence rules, which were located by searching the whole text: S1
- s. 71: punishment for repeat offenders previously convicted under ss. 64, 65 or 66;
- ss. 77 and 78: enhanced punishment on a second or subsequent conviction;
- s. 290 and s. 295: enhanced punishment in the event of a second or subsequent conviction;
- s. 303(2): theft.
Section 303(2) deserves separate mention, because it is new and it sits inside one of the very chapters s. 13 names. Theft is punishable with imprisonment of either description up to three years, or fine, or both, and the Sanhita adds that "in case of second or subsequent conviction of any person under this section, he shall be punished with rigorous imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than one year but which may extend to five years and with fine". IPC s. 379, by contrast, contained no repeat-offender clause at all; it stopped at "or with both". S1S4
That creates an overlap the Penal Code did not have. On a second theft conviction:
- s. 303(2) supplies a specific rule: rigorous imprisonment, a mandatory minimum of one year, a maximum of five years, and a mandatory fine;
- s. 13 supplies a general rule: liability to up to ten years or life, with no minimum.
The two do not say the same thing, and they are not obviously reconcilable by simply taking the higher figure, because s. 303(2) is in some respects stricter (it compels a minimum and a fine, which s. 13 does not) and in others laxer (its ceiling is five years, against s. 13's ten years or life). The orthodox approach would be that the specific provision governs over the general, but s. 13 is expressed as applying to "any offence punishable under either of those Chapters", and theft is such an offence.
This is editorial analysis. No judgment resolving the interaction was located, and the point appears to be untested: both provisions having been in force only since 1 July 2024. S3 It is flagged here because it is a live question for anyone sentencing a repeat thief under the Sanhita, not because any view on it can be asserted.
How a previous conviction is charged and proved
Section 13 supplies no procedure. The machinery is in the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, and it carries over from the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 with the section numbers changed: S5S6
| Function | BNSS | CrPC predecessor |
|---|---|---|
| Previous conviction to be stated in the charge | s. 234(7) | s. 211(7) |
| Previous conviction procedure: trial before a Court of Session | s. 259 | s. 236 |
| Same: trial of warrant-cases by Magistrates | s. 267(3) | s. 248(3) |
| How a previous conviction or acquittal is proved | s. 334 | s. 298 |
BNSS s. 234(7) provides that where the accused is liable by reason of a previous conviction to enhanced punishment or to punishment of a different kind, and it is intended to prove that conviction for the purpose of affecting the punishment, "the fact, date and place of the previous conviction shall be stated in the charge; and if such statement has been omitted, the Court may add it at any time before sentence is passed". S5 So the omission is curable, but it must be cured before sentence.
The safeguard that makes this workable is in BNSS ss. 259 and 267(3). Where the accused does not admit the previous conviction, the court may take evidence on it and record a finding, but only after convicting him of the substantive offence. The proviso is explicit: S5
Provided that no such charge shall be read out by the Judge nor shall the accused be asked to plead thereto nor shall the previous conviction be referred to by the prosecution or in any evidence adduced by it, unless and until the accused has been convicted…
The reason is obvious once stated: a tribunal told at the outset that the accused is a convicted thief would find it hard to try the fresh theft fairly. The previous conviction is therefore sealed off from the trial of guilt and opened only at the sentencing stage.
BNSS s. 334 then sets out how it is proved: by a certified extract of the sentence or order from the officer having custody of the court records, or, in the case of a conviction, by a certificate signed by the officer in charge of the jail where the punishment was undergone, or by production of the warrant of commitment: in addition to any other mode provided by law. S5
Worked examples
1. Theft, then theft. A is convicted of theft (s. 303, Chapter XVII, punishable up to three years) and later commits theft again. Both conditions as to chapter and threshold are met, so s. 13 is engaged on its terms. But s. 303(2)'s own repeat-offender limb also applies. Which governs is the unresolved question described above.
2. Counterfeiting currency-notes, then robbery. B is convicted under s. 178 (Chapter X, life or up to ten years) and later commits robbery (Chapter XVII, punishable with ten years or more). Section 13 applies. Under the Penal Code it would not have, because counterfeiting currency-notes was a Chapter XVIII offence. This is the practical effect of the relocation.
3. Murder, then theft. C is convicted of murder and later commits theft. Section 13 does not apply: murder is an offence against the human body, in Chapter VI, not Chapter X or Chapter XVII. The gravity of the earlier conviction is irrelevant; only the chapter and the three-year threshold matter. The court may of course treat antecedents as an aggravating circumstance in the ordinary way, but without the enlarged ceiling s. 13 would have given.
4. Criminal breach of trust, then criminal trespass. D is convicted of criminal breach of trust (Chapter XVII) and later commits criminal trespass. The first condition is met, but the second offence must itself be punishable with imprisonment of either description for three years or upwards. If the particular trespass offence charged carries less, s. 13 is not engaged. The threshold applies to both offences, which is easy to overlook.
5. A previous conviction under a special law. E is convicted under a narcotics statute and later commits theft. Section 13 does not apply, because the previous conviction was not under Chapter X or Chapter XVII "of this Sanhita".
6. A short sentence for a serious offence. F was convicted of an offence carrying a maximum of three years and was sentenced to two months' imprisonment, and later commits another qualifying offence. Section 13 applies: the test is the punishment the offence was punishable with, not the sentence imposed.
7. The charge omits the previous conviction. G is tried for theft; the charge says nothing about his earlier theft conviction. Under BNSS s. 234(7) the court may add the statement at any time before sentence is passed. Section 13 is not lost by the omission, provided it is cured in time.
Common mistakes
- Carrying the IPC chapter numbers across. Section 13 names Chapter X, not Chapter XII. The BNS has a Chapter XII, and it deals with offences by or relating to public servants, which s. 13 does not cover.
- Assuming the scope is unchanged because the words are. Currency-note and bank-note offences moved from IPC Chapter XVIII into BNS Chapter X, so they now count as qualifying convictions when they previously did not.
- Applying the three-year threshold only to the earlier offence. Both the previous and the subsequent offence must be punishable with imprisonment of either description for three years or upwards, that is what "with like imprisonment for the like term" requires.
- Reading the threshold as the sentence served. It is the punishment the offence is punishable with, not what the court awarded.
- Treating s. 13 as mandatory. "[S]hall be subject… to" means liable to. It raises the ceiling to ten years or life; it imposes no minimum and compels no enhanced sentence.
- Treating s. 13 as creating an offence. It is a sentencing provision. Nobody is convicted "under s. 13".
- Counting a previous conviction under a special or local law. Section 13 is confined to offences under the Sanhita, and s. 2(24) does not extend "offence" for the purposes of s. 13.
- Forgetting s. 303(2) and the other section-specific recidivism rules. For a repeat theft in particular there are two candidate regimes, and s. 303(2)'s is new.
- Referring to the previous conviction during the trial of guilt. BNSS ss. 259 and 267(3) expressly forbid reading out the charge, taking a plea to it, or referring to the conviction in evidence until the accused has been convicted of the substantive offence.
- Assuming the missing clause (b) in IPC s. 75 was dropped by the BNS. It was omitted by Act 3 of 1951. The BNS merely removed the orphaned "(a)" lettering that omission left behind.
Status of authority on BNS Section 13
No judgment on BNS s. 13 was located. The section has been in force only since 1 July 2024 under notification S.O. 850(E) dated 23 February 2024. S3 Nor was any decision located on the two questions this article identifies as open: the effect of the relocation of currency-note offences into Chapter X on the pool of qualifying previous convictions, and the interaction between s. 13 and s. 303(2) on a second theft conviction. Both are textual arguments drawn from reading the two codes side by side, and both are expressly labelled as such. They are set out so that a reader knows the questions exist, not as settled propositions.
Authority on IPC s. 75 was not surveyed for this article, and no case is cited for it. Where s. 13 reproduces s. 75's operative words, IPC-era authority on those words would be expected to remain useful; where the change lies in the chapters the provision points to, it will not assist.
Related sections
- BNS s. 4: Punishments: the kinds of punishment s. 13's enhanced ceiling draws on.
- BNS s. 7: Sentence may be wholly or partly rigorous or simple: relevant because the threshold is framed as "imprisonment of either description".
- BNS s. 12: Limit of solitary confinement: the preceding section, closing the set of provisions on how punishments are measured and executed.
- BNS s. 303: Theft: contains its own repeat-offender rule, which overlaps with s. 13.
- BNS s. 178: Counterfeiting coin, Government stamps, currency-notes or bank-notes: the offence whose relocation into Chapter X widens s. 13.
Law checked as of 2 October 2026. The statutory text was read from the Gazette of India publication of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 hosted by the Ministry of Home Affairs and cross-checked against India Code. The chapter headings and chapter boundaries of both the Sanhita and the Indian Penal Code were read directly from the published texts, as were IPC s. 75 with its amendment footnotes, IPC ss. 379 and 489A, BNS ss. 178, 303 and 2(24), and BNSS ss. 234(7), 259, 267(3) and 334 with their counterparts in the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. The amending Acts and Adaptation of Laws Orders referred to in the Penal Code footnotes were not separately accessed; the amendment history is stated as those footnotes record it. No case law was cited for this section, and none on BNS s. 13 was located.
This article is for education and general information. It is AI-assisted and has not been reviewed, verified or approved by a lawyer. It is not legal advice and must not be relied on for any actual case. The two open questions it identifies are untested textual arguments, not settled law. Verify the current position and take advice from a qualified advocate before acting.