A note on this article. As with Sections 63 to 72, this article keeps to a clinical legal register, contains no invented factual scenarios, and does not recount the facts of the cases it cites.
A source check, applied because of what happened at Section 72. That section's machine-readable text in this project's inventory turned out to be truncated. Section 73's copy was therefore checked before use: it is 479 characters, ends at a sentence boundary, and contains the Explanation, and it matches the Gazette. No truncation. S1S2
What the section says
Section 73 carries the marginal-note title Printing or publishing any matter relating to Court proceedings without permission. It is one sentence and one Explanation: S1S2
73. Whoever prints or publishes any matter in relation to any proceeding before a Court with respect to an offence referred to in section 72 without the previous permission of such Court shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to two years and shall also be liable to fine.
Explanation.—The printing or publication of the judgment of any High Court or the Supreme Court does not amount to an offence within the meaning of this section.
Section 73 is not in the Section 2(24)(a) or 2(24)(b) lists, so "offence" bears the Sanhita's narrow default meaning. Checked with the project's probe. S1
Where it came from: a sub-section promoted to a section
Section 73 is IPC Section 228A(3), standing alone. The Penal Code provision read: S4
"(3) Whoever prints or publishes any matter in relation to any proceeding before a court with respect to an offence referred to in sub-section (1) without the previous permission of such court shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to two years and shall also be liable to fine.
Explanation.—The printing or publication of the judgment of any High Court or the Supreme Court does not amount to an offence within the meaning of this section."
Two changes, both consequences of the split. The cross-reference moved from "sub-section (1)" to "section 72": necessary, since the material it points at is now in a different section. And "court" became "Court" in both places, a capitalisation change. Everything else (the opening words, the two-year maximum, the conjunctive fine and the Explanation) is carried over word for word. S1S2S4
Classification for this collection: split_or_reorganised, with substantively_unchanged wording.
One small point about quick mapping tables. The secondary compilation consulted for this collection maps IPC Section 228A to Section 72 and has no entry for Section 73 at all: checked. That is not a criticism: such a table pairs one Penal Code section with one Sanhita section, and a split has no natural place in it. But it means a reader working from a table of that kind will not see that Section 228A(3) became a separate section, and may look for the court-proceedings offence inside Section 72, where it no longer is. The compilation is a secondary source and is not relied on as authority here. S8
The amendment history is that of the parent provision, set out in the Section 72 article: IPC Section 228A was inserted by Act 43 of 1983, section 2, and its list of offences was substituted by Act 13 of 2013, section 4 and expanded by Act 22 of 2018, section 3. Sub-section (3) itself carries no separate amendment marker on the India Code text examined. S4
The Explanation survived, but on the words its reach is now narrower
This is the point worth slowing down for, and it was the open question left at the end of the Section 72 article.
In the Penal Code, the Explanation sat at the end of Section 228A and said "within the meaning of this section". "This section" was Section 228A as a whole, which contained both the victim-identity prohibition in sub-section (1) and the court-proceedings prohibition in sub-section (3). S4
In the Sanhita, the same words now sit at the end of Section 73. "This section" is therefore Section 73, and Section 73 is only the court-proceedings offence. Section 72, which carries the victim-identity prohibition, has no equivalent Explanation, as the Section 72 article records. S1S2
So on the face of the words, the exemption for printing or publishing a High Court or Supreme Court judgment now attaches to Section 73 and not to Section 72.
Two readings are available, and this article chooses neither.
- One: the split narrowed the exemption. Under the Penal Code the words covered the whole of Section 228A; they now cover only Section 73, so publishing a judgment is exempt from the permission requirement but not necessarily from the identity prohibition.
- The other: the Explanation was always directed at sub-section (3): it sat immediately after it, and publication of a judgment is naturally a matter "in relation to a proceeding before a Court", so the split merely made explicit what was already its scope.
No decision resolving this was located, and this article offers no view. (The identification of the question, and both readings, are the author's analysis of the two texts.)
And a reader should know what is missing from this collection on the point. As the Section 72 article records, the case law on IPC Section 228A: including Nipun Saxena v. Union of India, which appeared twice in the search results: was deliberately not retrieved. It may well address precisely this question. Nothing in this article should be taken as the law on whether a judgment may be published where it would identify a victim. Anyone facing that question must take advice.
Where the section sits
Section 73 remains under the sub-heading "Of sexual offences" within the chapter "OF OFFENCES AGAINST WOMAN AND CHILD". The next sub-heading, "Of criminal force and assault against woman", begins at Section 74. So Sections 63 to 73 form one group, and Section 73 is its last member. S2
(This corrects a note made in this collection's working records after Section 71, which had placed the end of that group at Section 71. The sub-heading in fact runs to Section 73. The correction is recorded rather than quietly made.)
Numbering collision. BNSS Section 73 concerns a direction for security on a warrant of arrest and BSA Section 73 concerns proof of a digital signature, so an abbreviated reference to "section 73" is ambiguous. S5S6
Case law: the vires of the section have been challenged, and the challenge failed
A search for "Section 73 of BNS" returned no results: the literal "No matching results", zero result entries. A search for "section 73 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita" returned one entry. S9 That one entry is directly on point.
Rohit Mehta v. Punjab and Haryana High Court and Others
High Court of Punjab and Haryana, CWP-PIL-160-2024, 20 September 2024, Sheel Nagu CJ and Anil Kshetarpal J., neutral citation 2024:PHHC:124565-DB. A public interest writ petition, and the vires of Section 73 were among the challenges. The petition recorded, at its paragraph 2.4: S7
"Vires of Section 73 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, is assailed, which penalises publishing of any matter in relation to any proceeding before before the Court with respect to an offence referred to in Section 72 without prior permission of Court, even after personal details of victim being hidden."
(The doubled "before before" is as found in the retrieved text and is not corrected: see the source note.)
The petition also challenged the online availability of judicial records and search options on the Court's website, and Section 22 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 and Section 33 of the Special Marriage Act, 1954 so far as they prohibit publication of judgments in matrimonial disputes. S7
The outcome. The Court recorded that "no case of interference is made out" and that the "Petition stands dismissed without costs". S7
The reasoning is summarised here and deliberately NOT quoted. The retrieved text of this judgment contains extensive word-duplication artefacts (words and fragments repeated, apparently from overlapping text layers in the source document) so no passage of the reasoning is reproduced, because quoting it would either carry the duplications or require silent tidying, and this collection does neither. In summary, and in this article's own words: the Court proceeded on the basis that the right to information, resting on Article 19(1)(a), is subject to reasonable restrictions including those relating to decency or morality; that disclosure of a victim's identity engages those grounds because it prevents the victim from living with dignity; that victims in crimes relating to women and juveniles are a specially vulnerable class entitled to protection against harm to body, mind or reputation; and that such protections stand on a higher footing than the petitioner's asserted right to information. S7
Three cautions, stated plainly.
First, this article does not say the Court gave separate reasons upholding Section 73. The reasoning examined addresses the right to information against victim anonymity in general, and names Section 33 of the Special Marriage Act, Section 22 of the Hindu Marriage Act and the High Court's administrative instructions. Whether and how it dealt specifically with Section 73's vires was not worked through for this article. What is stated is the fact that the challenge was among those raised and that the petition was dismissed.
Second, nothing is said about the decision's weight. It is a Division Bench decision, which is more than can be said of most of the decisions used elsewhere in this collection, but no view is expressed on whether it is correct, whether it has been followed, or what it binds. No appellate consideration of it was located.
Third, the other statutes are not analysed. The Hindu Marriage Act, the Special Marriage Act, the Court's administrative instructions and Article 19(1)(a) are named only because the judgment names them, and none is construed here.
What the searches establish, and what they do not
The search on the Explanation's distinctive wording returned 10 entries, but that phrase appears in several Penal Code provisions: the results include the statute pages for IPC Sections 505 and 228A, and matters as old as 1891. None of those was retrieved, and nothing in this article rests on them. S9
No decision construing Section 73's ingredients was located: what "any matter in relation to any proceeding" covers, what "previous permission" requires, and how permission is to be sought are all unanalysed here. No negative finding about the wider case law is asserted.
Common misconceptions
| Misconception | Why it is wrong |
|---|---|
| "Section 73 is a new offence." | It is IPC Section 228A(3) standing alone. The only changes are the cross-reference, from "sub-section (1)" to "section 72", and "court" to "Court". S1S4 |
| "Publishing a High Court or Supreme Court judgment is always safe." | The Explanation exempts it from "an offence within the meaning of this section", and "this section" is now Section 73. Whether the exemption also reaches Section 72 is a question this article does not answer, and no decision on it was located. Take advice. S1S2 |
| "Section 72 has the same Explanation." | It does not. As the Section 72 article records, Section 72's only Explanation defines "recognised welfare institution or organisation". S2 |
| "The permission requirement applies to any criminal proceeding." | It applies to a proceeding "with respect to an offence referred to in section 72", that is, the eight offences in Section 72's list. S1 |
| "A fine is optional." | The words are conjunctive: "and shall also be liable to fine". S1 |
| "Nobody has challenged this provision." | Its vires were assailed in Rohit Mehta v. Punjab and Haryana High Court (Punjab & Haryana HC, Division Bench, 20 September 2024), and the petition was dismissed. S7 |
| "That judgment settles the section's validity." | This article does not say so. It does not state that the Court gave separate reasons on Section 73, and expresses no view on the decision's weight or correctness. S7 |
| "Section 73 is in a different part of the chapter from the sexual offences." | It is the last section under the sub-heading "Of sexual offences"; the next sub-heading begins at Section 74. S2 |
| "'Section 73' unambiguously means the BNS." | BNSS s. 73 (security on a warrant of arrest) and BSA s. 73 (proof of a digital signature) both exist. S5S6 |
Temporal application
The Sanhita came into force on 1 July 2024, appointed by Ministry of Home Affairs notification S.O. 850(E) dated 23 February 2024, published in the Gazette of India, Extraordinary, Part II: Section 3: Sub-section (ii), No. 811, 24 February 2024 (CG-DL-E-24022024-252353), for all provisions except sub-section (2) of Section 106. Section 73 was not excepted and commenced on 1 July 2024. S3
On the prohibition itself nothing of substance changed: the conduct, the two-year maximum and the fine are the same as under IPC Section 228A(3), and the cross-reference now points at the same body of offences that sub-section (1) used to carry. The one open question is the reach of the Explanation, discussed above, and it is not resolved here, for conduct before or after the commencement date. (That assessment is the author's; no decision on it was located.)
What this article does not cover
The statutory analysis rests on the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 as published on India Code and verified against the Gazette; on the Indian Penal Code, 1860 as published on India Code, including its footnote apparatus; on the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 and the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 for the numbering collision only; and on the commencement notification. S1S2S3S4S5S6 The inventory copy was length-checked before use; the two texts were compared word for word; the Explanation's reference to "this section" was compared in its two settings; and Section 2(24) membership was checked with the project's probe.
THE REACH OF THE EXPLANATION IS NOT RESOLVED. Both readings are set out and neither is adopted. No decision on it was located, and the case law on IPC Section 228A: which may well address it: was deliberately not retrieved, as the Section 72 article records. This is the principal gap on this section.
The ingredients of Section 73 are NOT construed: "any matter in relation to any proceeding", "previous permission", and the procedure for obtaining permission are not analysed, and no decision on them was located.
Section 72 is referred to only for the cross-reference and for the absence of a comparable Explanation; its own content is not restated here. Sections 63 to 71 are referred to only as the body of offences Section 72's list carries. Sections 74 onwards are not analysed.
The reasoning in Rohit Mehta is summarised, not quoted, because the retrieved text carries extensive duplication artefacts. This article does not state that the Court gave separate reasons on Section 73's vires, does not state the decision's weight, and expresses no view on whether it is correct. The Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, the Special Marriage Act, 1954, the High Court's administrative instructions and Article 19(1)(a) are named only because the judgment names them, and none is construed. No appellate consideration of the decision was located. The judgment was read from a judgment-text repository rather than an official court portal, and the official report was not consulted.
The ten results on the Explanation's distinctive wording were NOT retrieved: that phrase appears in several Penal Code provisions, and the results include unrelated statute pages and matters from as early as 1891. Nothing rests on them. No negative finding about the wider case law is asserted.
Short titles of Acts 43 of 1983, 13 of 2013 and 22 of 2018 were not verified, and no amending Act was retrieved. State amendments were not examined. Procedural matters were not researched: cognizability, bailability, the trial court and limitation were not researched for Section 73.
Labelled as the author's analysis: the identification of the Explanation question and both readings of it; the observation that the cross-reference and capitalisation changes are consequences of the split; the placement of Section 73 as the last section under its sub-heading; and the temporal assessment. No decision stating any of these was located.
Source note. The quoted statutory text uses plain quotation marks where the official texts use typographic ones. In the Gazette, Section 73's marginal note runs down the right-hand column and its lines interleave with the sentence, so the section was verified fragment by fragment, all fragments passing. On the Penal Code side, sub-section (3) and its Explanation are printed after the footnotes to Section 228A, which are editorial apparatus and not statutory wording.
The retrieved text of Rohit Mehta contains extensive word-duplication artefacts, for example doubled words and part-words running through the reasoning, which appear to come from overlapping text layers in the source document. Only short passages verified to be free of duplication are quoted: the petition's paragraph 2.4 (quoted with its doubled "before before", disclosed), and the operative words "no case of interference is made out" and "Petition stands dismissed without costs". The reasoning is summarised in this article's own words and expressly not quoted. This collection does not silently tidy quotations, and does not quote text it cannot reproduce faithfully.
This article is for education and general information. It is AI-assisted and has not been reviewed, verified or approved by a lawyer. It is not legal advice and must not be relied on for any actual case. In particular, nothing here tells a reader whether a High Court or Supreme Court judgment may be published where doing so would identify a victim. The reach of the Explanation is unresolved on the material examined, and the leading case law on the predecessor provision was deliberately not retrieved. Anyone considering publishing any matter relating to proceedings in such a case, or any judgment in one, should take advice from a qualified advocate first. Whether an offence under this section has been committed is a matter only a court can determine on the evidence before it, and no outcome in any case is guaranteed. Verify the current position and take advice from a qualified advocate before acting.