1. Executive Summary and Role as the Apex Forgery Offence
Section 338 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) (which directly replaces Section 467 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC)) is the most severely punished substantive forgery provision in Chapter XVIII S1, s. 338; S4. It targets the forgery of instruments that create, transfer, extinguish, or acknowledge proprietary, testamentary, or financial rights: specifically valuable securities, wills, authorities to adopt a son, authorities to make/transfer valuable securities or receive money/property, and acquittances or receipts for payment of money or delivery of movable property or valuable securities S1, s. 338.
Because the fabrication of such instruments strikes at the security of property titles, succession, banking, and commercial credit, Section 338 prescribes imprisonment for life, or imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to ten years, and shall also be liable to fine S1, s. 338. Moreover, Section 338 serves as the statutory anchor for three subsequent provisions in Chapter XVIII:
- Section 339 (Second Limb): Knowing possession of a forged Section 338 document with intent to use it as genuine S1, s. 339;
- Section 341(1): Making or possessing a counterfeit seal, plate, or instrument with intent to commit forgery punishable under Section 338 S1, s. 341(1); and
- Section 342(1): Counterfeiting a device or mark used for authenticating documents described in Section 338 S1, s. 342(1).
2. Exhaustive Breakdown of the Eight Protected Document Classes
To establish an offence under Section 338, the prosecution must prove (a) that the accused forged a document (satisfying Section 335 and Section 336(1)), and (b) that the forged document purports to be one of the following eight classes of instruments S1, ss. 335, 336(1), 338:
- A "Valuable Security" (defined in BNS Section 2(31)):
- Under Section 2(31), "valuable security" means a document which is, or purports to be, a document whereby any legal right is created, extended, transferred, restricted, extinguished, or released, or whereby any person acknowledges that he lies under legal liability, or has not a certain legal right S1, s. 2(31).
- Common Examples: Registered or unregistered sale deeds, gift deeds, mortgage deeds, lease deeds, promissory notes, bills of exchange, cheques, bank fixed deposit receipts, share certificates, insurance policies, and deeds of release/relinquishment S1, s. 2(31); S5. Note that because both Section 2(31) and Section 338 use the words "or purports to be", an unstamped or unregistered instrument that purports to transfer title or create a legal right still qualifies as a document purporting to be a valuable security under Section 338 even if it would be inadmissible in civil evidence for want of registration or stamping [Editorial Analysis based on S1, ss. 2(31), 338].
- A "Will" (defined in BNS Section 2(34)): Any testamentary document (including a codicil) disposing of property upon death S1, ss. 2(34), 338; S6.
- An Authority to Adopt a Son: Retained verbatim from IPC Section 467 (historically reflecting the formal numati patra or written authority executed by a husband empowering his widow to adopt) S1, s. 338.
- An Authority to Make or Transfer Any Valuable Security: For example, a Special or General Power of Attorney authorising an agent to execute a sale deed, mortgage, or share transfer on behalf of the principal S1, s. 338.
- An Authority to Receive Principal, Interest, or Dividends on Any Valuable Security: Mandates, dividend warrants, or letters of authority to collect bond/debenture proceeds S1, s. 338.
- An Authority to Receive or Deliver Any Money, Movable Property, or Valuable Security: Payment orders, delivery orders on a warehouseman/banker, or withdrawal authorisations S1, ss. 2(21), 338.
- An Acquittance or Receipt Acknowledging the Payment of Money: Rent receipts, loan discharge receipts, payment vouchers, or settlement acknowledgements S1, s. 338.
- An Acquittance or Receipt for the Delivery of Any Movable Property or Valuable Security: Goods delivery receipts or escrow acknowledgement receipts S1, s. 338.
3. IPC-to-BNS Correspondence Table
| Attribute | IPC Section 467 (1860) | BNS Section 338 (2023) | Legal Effect of Transition |
|---|---|---|---|
| Section Heading | Forgery of valuable security, will, etc. | Forgery of valuable security, will, etc. | Verbatim retention S1; S4. |
| Operative Text | Covers valuable security, will, authority to adopt a son, authority to make/transfer valuable security or receive principal/interest/dividends or money/movable property/valuable security, or acquittance/receipt | Verbatim retention of IPC Section 467 | Zero substantive change; all IPC Section 467 precedents apply directly S1; S4. |
| Punishment | Imprisonment for life, or imprisonment of either description up to 10 years, and fine | Imprisonment for life, or imprisonment of either description up to 10 years, and fine | Identical punishment ceiling and mandatory fine S1; S4. |
4. Punishment Matrix and the Magistrate Sentencing-Power Paradox
- Statutory Punishment: Imprisonment for life, or imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to ten years, and shall also be liable to fine S1, s. 338.
- Crucial Trial Practice Point: Trial Forum vs. Sentencing Competence:
- Under the First Schedule to the BNSS, 2023 (Gazette p. 186), an offence under Section 338 is shown as triable by a Magistrate of the first class (JMFC) S3, First Schedule; S4.
- However, under Section 23(2) of the BNSS, a Judicial Magistrate of the first class cannot pass a sentence of imprisonment exceeding 3 years, and under Section 23(1) of the BNSS, a Chief Judicial Magistrate (CJM) cannot pass a sentence of imprisonment exceeding 7 years S3, s. 23(1)–(2).
- Consequently, while a JMFC is competent to try a Section 338 case, if the JMFC is of opinion that the accused is guilty and ought to receive a punishment more severe than 3 years (up to 7 years), the JMFC must submit the proceedings to the Chief Judicial Magistrate under Section 364 of the BNSS (formerly CrPC Section 325); and if the Magistrate considers that the gravity of the forgery warrants a sentence exceeding 7 years (up to 10 years or imprisonment for life), the case must be committed to the Court of Session under Section 362 of the BNSS (formerly CrPC Section 323) S3, ss. 22, 23, First Schedule; Editorial Analysis.
5. Procedural Classification Split in the BNSS First Schedule
Just like the old CrPC First Schedule entry for IPC Section 467, the First Schedule to the BNSS, 2023 (Gazette p. 186) divides BNS Section 338 into two distinct procedural rows based on the nature of the valuable security S3, First Schedule; S4:
| BNSS First Schedule Entry for Section 338 | Punishment Summary | Cognizable or Not | Bailable or Not | Triable By | Compoundable (BNSS s. 359) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Row 1 (General): Forgery of a valuable security, will, or authority to make or transfer any valuable security, or to receive any money, etc. | Imprisonment for life, or imprisonment for 10 years and fine | Non-cognizable | Non-bailable | Magistrate of the first class | Non-compoundable S3; S4 |
| Row 2 (Central Govt Promissory Note): When the valuable security is a promissory note of the Central Government | Imprisonment for life, or imprisonment for 10 years and fine | Cognizable | Non-bailable | Magistrate of the first class | Non-compoundable S3; S4 |
- Why Do Police Register Cognizable FIRs for Forged Sale Deeds or Wills Under Row 1?: Even though Row 1 of Section 338 is Non-cognizable when standing alone, in practice almost every FIR alleging a forged will or forged sale deed also invokes Section 336(3) (forgery for the purpose of cheating, Cognizable) and/or Section 340(2) (using a forged document as genuine, Cognizable) S3, First Schedule; S4. Under Section 174(4) of the BNSS (formerly CrPC Section 155(4)), where a case relates to two or more offences of which at least one is cognizable, the entire case is deemed to be a cognizable case, empowering the police to investigate Section 338 without a Magistrate's order S3, First Schedule; Editorial Analysis.
6. Landmark Judicial Authorities
- Forged Will Produced in Probate Proceedings: Iqbal Singh Marwah & Anr. v. Meenakshi Marwah & Anr., (2005) 4 SCC 370 S6:
- In Iqbal Singh Marwah, the appellants produced an allegedly forged will in probate proceedings before the District Judge, and the widow and son of the deceased filed a private criminal complaint alleging offences including IPC Section 467 (now BNS Section 338). The Five-Judge Constitution Bench held that because the will was allegedly forged before it was filed in the probate court, the bar of Section 195(1)(b)(ii) CrPC (now BNSS Section 215(1)(b)(ii)) did not apply, and the private criminal complaint under Section 467 IPC was maintainable S6.
- Sale Deed Executed Without Title in One's Own Name: Mohammed Ibrahim & Ors. v. State of Bihar & Anr., (2009) 8 SCC 751 S5:
- Even though a sale deed is undeniably a "valuable security", the Supreme Court held that a person cannot be prosecuted under IPC Section 467 (now BNS Section 338) merely because he executed a sale deed in his own genuine name conveying land to which he had no legal title; without impersonation, antedating, post-execution alteration, or deception of an incapacitated signer under Section 335, the sale deed is not a "false document" S1, ss. 335, 338; S5.
7. Hypothetical Examples and Counterexamples
- Example 1: Forging Testator's Thumb Impression on a Will [Editorial Hypothetical]: After the death of T, his nephew N prepares a backdated document purporting to be T's last will bequeathing T's house to N, and presses the thumb of an accomplice onto the signature block claiming it is T's thumb impression. Because a will is expressly covered by Section 338 and N made a false document in the name of a deceased person (Section 335 Explanation 2) to support a claim or title (Section 336(1)), N is liable under Section 338 S1, ss. 2(34), 335 Exp. 2, 336(1), 338.
- Example 2: Altering Figures on a Loan Discharge Receipt [Editorial Hypothetical]: Debtor D pays creditor C Rs. 5,000 toward a loan and obtains a signed receipt for "Rs. 5,000". Subsequently, D dishonestly alters the receipt to read "Rs. 50,000 in full and final settlement". Because an acquittance or receipt acknowledging the payment of money is expressly listed in Section 338 and D materially altered it after execution (Section 335(B)), D is liable under Section 338 S1, ss. 335(B), 338.
- Counterexample: Forging a Certified Copy vs. Original Sale Deed [Editorial Hypothetical]: If A forges a certified copy of a court order or a birth certificate (which does not itself create or transfer a legal right or acknowledge payment of money), the offence falls under Section 337 (7 years), not Section 338 (life or 10 years) S1, ss. 337, 338.