Crucial Numbering Alert and Function of Section 312 BNS
First, note the numbering shift from the repealed Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC):
- Under the IPC, Section 312 IPC dealt with Causing miscarriage (which is now Section 88 BNS) S1.
- Under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (
BNS), Section 312 BNS replaces Section 398 IPC (Attempt to commit robbery or dacoity when armed with deadly weapon) S1; S4.
"312. If, at the time of attempting to commit robbery or dacoity, the offender is armed with any deadly weapon, the imprisonment with which such offender shall be punished shall not be less than seven years." S1
How Section 312 BNS Interacts with Section 309(5) BNS (Attempt to Commit Robbery) and Section 310(2) BNS (Dacoity)
Like Section 311 BNS, Section 312 BNS does not create an independent substantive offence; it regulates the minimum sentence for an underlying charge of attempting to commit robbery (Section 309(5) BNS) or attempting to commit dacoity (Section 310(1) & (2) BNS) S1; S6; S7:
- In a Case of Attempted Robbery (
1 to 4 Offenders):- Under Section 309(5) BNS (formerly Section 393 IPC), the maximum punishment for attempting to commit robbery is rigorous imprisonment up to 7 years and mandatory fine S1.
- When the offender is armed with a deadly weapon at the time of the attempt, Section 312 BNS sets the minimum floor at 7 years S1. Because the maximum under Section 309(5) is 7 years and the minimum under Section 312 is 7 years, an offender convicted of attempted robbery while armed with a deadly weapon under Section 309(5) read with Section 312 BNS (where no hurt was caused under Section 309(6)) receives an exact sentence of 7 years rigorous imprisonment and fine, and the trial forum moves from the Magistrate of the First Class (
S. 309(5)) to the Court of Session (S. 312) S1; S3!
- In a Case of Attempted Dacoity (
5 or More Offenders):- Under Section 310(1) and 310(2) BNS, an attempt to commit robbery by 5 or more persons is punishable with imprisonment for life or rigorous imprisonment up to 10 years, and fine S1.
- When read with Section 312 BNS, any offender who was armed with a deadly weapon during that attempted dacoity must receive at least 7 years rigorous imprisonment (up to 10 years, or imprisonment for life) and fine S1; S6.
Why Section 312 Uses "Is Armed With Any Deadly Weapon" While Section 311 Uses "Uses Any Deadly Weapon"
In Phool Kumar v. Delhi Administration (AIR 1975 SC 905), the Supreme Court explained the legislative logic behind the contrasting verbs in Section 397 IPC (Section 311 BNS: "uses any deadly weapon") and Section 398 IPC (Section 312 BNS: "is armed with any deadly weapon") S6:
- During a completed robbery or dacoity (
Section 311), the offender has carried the crime through to completion; if they merely kept a weapon hidden in their pocket and never displayed or employed it to overawe the victim, Section 311 does not apply S6. - By contrast, during an attempt to commit robbery or dacoity (
Section 312), the crime was frustrated or interrupted before completion: often before the offender had the opportunity to draw or use the weapon they brought for the hold-up S6! Therefore, Parliament deliberately used the broader phrase "is armed with any deadly weapon" in Section 312 BNS: if the offender is carrying a deadly weapon on his person (equipped/furnished with it, even inside a holster or coat pocket) at the time of attempting to commit robbery or dacoity, Section 312 BNS is immediately attracted without needing to prove that the weapon was drawn or brandished S1; S6.
Individual Liability Only ("Such Offender")
Just like Section 311 BNS, Section 312 BNS uses the singular words "the offender" and "such offender" S1. Consequently:
- If
A(carrying a pistol in his waistband) andB(unarmed) jointly attempt to rob a jewellery shop and are overpowered before taking anything, onlyAis subject to the 7-year mandatory minimum under Section 309(5) read with Section 312 BNS S1; S6; S7. - Unarmed co-accused
Bcannot be saddled with the 7-year minimum floor of Section 312 BNS via Section 3(5) BNS (common intention);Bis sentenced under Section 309(5) read with Section 3(5) BNS (up to 7 years RI and fine, without a mandatory minimum) S1; S6; S7.
Punishment, Sentencing, and BNSS Procedural Classification
| Statutory Provision | Offence Description | Imprisonment Term & Type | Fine & Default Rules | Cognizability | Bailability | Triable By | Compoundability (S. 359 BNSS) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Section 312 BNS (read with S. 309(5) or S. 310(2) BNS) | Attempt to commit robbery or dacoity when armed with deadly weapon | Not less than 7 years Rigorous Imprisonment (up to 7 years under S. 309(5), or up to 10 years RI / Life under S. 309(6) or S. 310(2)) S1 | Mandatory fine under parent provision (S. 309(5)/(6) or S. 310(2) BNS) S1 | Cognizable S3 | Non-bailable S3 | Court of Session S3 | Non-compoundable S5 |
Practical Examples and Counterexamples
-
Example 1: Foiled Highway Hold-Up Where Armed Accused Is Tackled Before Drawing Gun (Section 312 Attracted): Assumed Facts:
Ajumps in front ofZ's motorcycle on a dark road, grabs the handlebar, and shouts "Hand over your cash bag or I will kill you!" BeforeAcan reach into his jacket, a police patrol jeep arrives and arrestsA. A search ofA's jacket reveals a loaded country-made pistol (katta). Legal Analysis:Aattempted to commit robbery (Section 309(5) BNS) and, at the time of attempting to commit robbery, was armed with a deadly weapon. Even thoughAnever drew the pistol from his jacket,Ais liable under Section 309(5) read with Section 312 BNS (mandatory minimum 7 years rigorous imprisonment and fine, triable by the Court of Session) S1; S3; S6. -
Counterexample: Carrying a Wooden Toy Pistol During Attempted Robbery (Section 309(5), Not Section 312): Assumed Facts:
Bpoints a plastic toy replica of a pistol at a cashier and demands money, but the cashier locks the shutter andBflees without getting anything. Legal Analysis: While the realistic replica was used to attempt to put the cashier in fear of instant death/hurt (soBis guilty of attempt to commit robbery under Section 309(5) BNS), a plastic toy pistol is objectively incapable of causing death and is not a "deadly weapon". Therefore, the 7-year mandatory minimum of Section 312 BNS is not attracted S1.