Overview and Statutory Function in Substantive Criminal Law
Section 268 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) criminalises the personation of, or unlawful service as, an assessor in any legal proceeding S1, Section 268. Situated in Chapter XIV (Of False Evidence and Offences Against Public Justice), Section 268 replaces Section 229 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC) while pruning obsolete colonial references to "juror", "juryman", and "jury" S1, Section 268; S3, Section 229; S5, p. 27; S6.
Historically, under the 1861 and 1898 Codes of Criminal Procedure, Sessions trials in India were conducted either by jury or with the aid of assessors. Following the abolition of the assessor system in regular criminal trials (1955) and the abolition of jury trials in the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, the 2023 Sanhita systematically purged references to "juryman" both from the definition of "public servant" in Section 2(28) BNS S5, p. 3 and from Section 268 BNS S5, p. 27. At the same time, Parliament retained assessors in both Section 2(28)(d) BNS ("every assessor or member of a panchayat assisting a Court or public servant") and Section 268 BNS because specialized central and state statutes, such as formal marine casualty investigations and admiralty/shipping courts under the Merchant Shipping Act, 1958 (Sections 361, 366), boiler/mines accident inquiries, and specialized statutory tribunals: continue to provide for the empanelling of technical or lay assessors to assist the Court or presiding authority S1, Sections 2(28)(d), 268.
Verbatim Text and Textual Comparison with IPC 229
In the enacted Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (Act No. 45 of 2023), Section 268 reads as follows S1, Section 268:
"Whoever, by personation or otherwise, shall intentionally cause, or knowingly suffer himself to be returned, empanelled or sworn as an assessor in any case in which he knows that he is not entitled by law to be so returned, empanelled or sworn, or knowing himself to have been so returned, empanelled or sworn contrary to law, shall voluntarily serve on such assessor, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to two years, or with fine, or with both." S1, Section 268
(Editorial Note on Statutory Drafting: In the final clause of Section 268 BNS, when the drafters deleted the words "on such jury or as" from the IPC 229 phrase "shall voluntarily serve on such jury or as such assessor", the preposition "on" was inadvertently retained before "such assessor", resulting in the enacted Gazette phrase "shall voluntarily serve on such assessor" S1, Section 268; S6. In legal interpretation, this is read harmoniously with the preceding clauses as voluntarily serving as such assessor S1, Section 268).
Exact Offence Ingredients and Two Distinct Limbs of Liability
Section 268 BNS establishes two alternative limbs of criminal liability S1, Section 268:
Limb 1: Causing or Suffering Oneself to Be Returned, Empanelled, or Sworn as an Assessor
- Actus Reus ("By Personation or Otherwise..."): The accused must either cause himself or suffer (allow) himself to be returned (included on the official return/list), empanelled (selected onto the panel for the case), or sworn (administered the oath/affirmation) as an assessor in any case S1, Section 268. Notably, the phrase "by personation or otherwise" means the offence is not confined to impersonating another person! Even if the accused uses his own true name, if he is legally disqualified or unentitled to be empanelled as an assessor in that case (for example, by procuring his inclusion through a false qualification certificate or bribery) and intentionally causes or knowingly allows himself to be empanelled, Limb 1 is satisfied S1, Section 268.
- Mens Rea ("Intentionally Cause, or Knowingly Suffer... in Any Case in Which He Knows That He Is Not Entitled by Law"): The accused must act intentionally (in causing) or knowingly (in suffering), and must have actual knowledge that he is not entitled by law to be so returned, empanelled, or sworn S1, Section 268.
Limb 2: Voluntarily Serving as an Assessor Knowing Selection Was Contrary to Law
- Prior Unlawful Return, Empanelling, or Swearing: The accused has been returned, empanelled, or sworn as an assessor contrary to law (even if initially due to a clerical mistake by court staff without the accused's prior instigation) S1, Section 268.
- Knowledge + Voluntary Service: Discovering or knowing himself to have been so returned, empanelled, or sworn contrary to law, the accused voluntarily serves (as defined in Section 2(33) BNS) as such assessor instead of disclosing the legal disqualification to the Court S1, Sections 2(33), 268.
IPC-to-BNS Correspondence, Punishment Matrix, and BNSS Classification
| Parameter | IPC Section 229 (1860) | BNS Section 268 (2023) | Legal Significance of Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Section Heading | Personation of a juror or assessor S3; S6 | Personation of assessor. (Note: BNSS First Schedule entry uses Personation of an assessor) S1; S4; S5, p. 27 | Removes obsolete reference to "a juror" S5, p. 27. |
| Body Text | Refers to "juryman or assessor" and "on such jury or as such assessor" S3; S6 | Refers solely to "assessor" S1; S5, p. 27 | Aligns with Section 2(28) BNS, which also omitted "juryman" while retaining "assessor" in Section 2(28)(d) BNS S1; S5, p. 3, 27. |
| Substantive Punishment | Imprisonment of either description up to 2 years, or fine, or both S3; S6 | Imprisonment of either description up to 2 years, or with fine, or with both S1, Section 268 | Unchanged; default-of-fine imprisonment capped at 6 months under Section 8(3) BNS S1. |
| BNSS First Schedule Classification | Non-cognizable, Bailable, Magistrate of the First Class S4 | Non-cognizable | Bailable | Triable by Magistrate of the First Class S4, First Schedule, Entry 268 | Unchanged S4. |
Practical Examples and Counterexamples
- Editorial Hypothetical 1 (Personation of Summoned Assessor Under Limb 1 of Section 268 BNS): In a formal judicial investigation into a shipping collision under the Merchant Shipping Act, 1958, the Court summons Captain
A(an accredited nautical assessor on the official list) to sit as an assessor. CaptainAis unwell, and his retired friendB(who is not on the accredited list of assessors) appears in Court pretending to be CaptainA, takes the oath, and sits on the bench.Bhas intentionally caused himself to be empanelled and sworn as an assessor in a case in which he knows he is not entitled by law, and is guilty under Section 268 BNS S1, Section 268. - Editorial Hypothetical 2 (Voluntary Service Under Limb 2 Without Personation): Due to a namesake error in the tribunal registry, summons intended for
Dr. Rajesh Sharma (Senior Mining Engineer)to sit as a statutory assessor in a mine-safety inquiry is delivered toRajesh Sharma, a junior clerk who lacks the statutory engineering qualification required by law to be an assessor. Realising the mistake upon reading the statutory notice,Rajesh Sharmanevertheless stays silent, gets empanelled, and voluntarily serves as an assessor to collect the sitting allowance. Even though he did not impersonate another identity initially, he knew he was empanelled contrary to law and voluntarily served, attracting liability under Limb 2 of Section 268 BNS S1, Section 268.