Overview and Dual Function in Chapter X
Section 186 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) (which replaces Section 263A of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC)) serves two distinct and vital functions within Chapter X S1, s. 186; S3, s. 263A:
- Regulatory Offence Against Fictitious Postage Stamps and Facsimiles (
Sub-sections (1)–(3)): Even where a person lacks the mens rea to defraud the treasury required for the 7-to-10-year felony of counterfeiting revenue stamps under Sections 178–181 BNS, printing, importing, selling, possessing without lawful excuse, or using unauthorized facsimiles or bogus designs purporting to denote postage creates severe confusion in domestic and international mail sorting. Sub-sections (1) to (3) impose a summary regulatory prohibition backed by a fine up to ₹200 and mandatory forfeiture S1, s. 186(1)-(3); S5. - Global Interpretive Extension for Postage Stamps (
Sub-section (4)): Under Section 2(12) BNS, the word "Government" normally means only the Central Government or a State Government of India S1, s. 2(12). However, because the Universal Postal Union (UPU) Convention obligates member states to suppress the counterfeiting and fraudulent reuse of foreign postage stamps as well as domestic ones, Section 186(4) BNS expands the meaning of "Government" across Sections 178 to 181 (both inclusive), Sections 183 to 185 (both inclusive), and Section 186 whenever the stamp is used for postage to include any person or persons authorised by law to administer executive government in any part of India or in any foreign country S1, s. 186(4); S5.
Complete Sub-Section Breakdown
Sub-section (1): Three Prohibited Conduct Clauses and Fine
Whoever
- Clause
(a)(Making, Uttering, Dealing, or Selling): makes, knowingly utters, deals in or sells any fictitious stamp, or knowingly uses for any postal purpose any fictitious stamp; or - Clause
(b)(Possession Without Lawful Excuse): has in his possession, without lawful excuse, any fictitious stamp; or - Clause
(c)(Dies, Plates, Instruments, or Materials): makes or, without lawful excuse, has in his possession any die, plate, instrument or materials for making any fictitious stamp, shall be punished with fine which may extend to two hundred rupees S1, s. 186(1); S5.
Sub-section (2): Seizure and Mandatory Forfeiture
Any such stamp, die, plate, instrument or materials in the possession of any person for making any fictitious stamp may be seized and, if seized, shall be forfeited S1, s. 186(2); S5. Notice the contrast between "may be seized" (enabling power) and "shall be forfeited" (mandatory confiscation once seized) S1, s. 186(2).
Sub-section (3): Statutory Definition of "Fictitious Stamp"
In this section, "fictitious stamp" means:
- any stamp falsely purporting to be issued by Government for the purpose of denoting a rate of postage; or
- any facsimile or imitation or representation, whether on paper or otherwise, of any stamp issued by Government for that purpose S1, s. 186(3); S5.
Sub-section (4): Extended Definition of "Government" for Postage Stamps
In this section and also in sections 178 to 181 (both inclusive), and sections 183 to 185 (both inclusive), the word "Government", when used in connection with, or in reference to, any stamp issued for the purpose of denoting a rate of postage, shall, notwithstanding anything contained in clause (12) of section 2, be deemed to include the person or persons authorised by law to administer executive government in any part of India, and also in any foreign country S1, s. 186(4); S5.
Important Textual Verification Note (First Bill vs. Enacted Act 45 of 2023): Some unofficial online reproductions (such as Devgan.in's Chapter 10 page) inadvertently carried over the unamended numbering from the August 2023 First Bill (
sections 176 to 179,181 to 183, andclause (11) of section 2) S4. In the enacted Gazette text of Act 45 of 2023 and official eCourts IndiaCode records, Section 186(4) correctly referencessections 178 to 181 (both inclusive), and sections 183 to 185 (both inclusive)andclause (12) of section 2S1, s. 186(4); S5.
Key Legal Distinctions: "Lawful Excuse" and Philatelic Catalogues
Because Section 186(3) defines a "fictitious stamp" to include "any facsimile or imitation or representation, whether on paper or otherwise, of any stamp issued by Government for that purpose", printing full-scale illustrations of postage stamps in philatelic books, stamp albums, or educational journals prima facie produces a "representation" on paper S1, s. 186(3). However:
- Clauses (1)(b) and (1)(c) explicitly incorporate the defence of "without lawful excuse" S1, s. 186(1)(b)-(c).
- Authorized philatelic publications that print stamp illustrations in compliance with postal guidelines (for example, black-and-white or defaced/diagonal-line illustrations or authorized catalogue reproductions not capable of deceiving postal sorters) possess a lawful excuse S1, s. 186(1).
IPC-to-BNS Comparison Table
| Feature | IPC Section 263A (inserted 1895) | BNS Section 186 (2023) | Legal Significance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Section Number | Section 263A (Chapter XII) S3 | Section 186 (Chapter X) S1 | Renumbered into standard sequential numbering S1; S3. |
| Colonial Wording in Sub-section (4) | Included "and also in any part of Her Majesty's dominions or in any foreign country" S3, s. 263A(4) | Deletes "and also in any part of Her Majesty's dominions", retaining "in any part of India, and also in any foreign country" S1, s. 186(4); S5 | Decolonises statutory text; former British dominions outside India are now covered simply as "any foreign country" S1; S3. |
| Internal Statutory Cross-References | Referenced Sections 255 to 263 and Section 17 IPC S3, s. 263A(4) | References Sections 178 to 181, Sections 183 to 185, and Section 2(12) BNS S1, s. 186(4); S5 | Updates cross-references to match BNS numbering (excluding Section 182 BNS, which deals only with currency-notes/bank-notes) S1, s. 182, s. 186(4). |
| Punishment & Forfeiture | Fine up to Rs. 200 + seizure and mandatory forfeiture S3, s. 263A(1)-(2) | Fine up to Rs. 200 + seizure and mandatory forfeiture S1, s. 186(1)-(2) | Substantively unchanged S1; S3. |
Punishment and Procedural Classification under BNSS
| Offence Branch | Punishment | Cognizability | Bailability | Triable Court |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Making, uttering, selling, using, or possessing fictitious stamps or dies (Section 186(1) BNS) | Fine up to ₹200 + mandatory forfeiture of seized stamps/dies under Section 186(2) S1, s. 186(1)-(2) | Cognizable S4; S5 | Bailable S4; S5 | Any Magistrate S4; S5 |
Practical Examples and Counterexamples
Example 1: Printing Novelty Un-defaced Postage Stamp Stickers (Offence Committed)
Assumed Facts: P, a stationery printer, prints perforated adhesive stickers bearing exact colour facsimiles of current ₹5 India Post and US Postal Service stamps as decorative "vintage mail stickers" and sells them in packets at a gift shop. Some buyers stick them onto actual postcards and drop them into postboxes.
Legal Analysis: The stickers are exact paper representations of domestic and foreign postage stamps within Section 186(3) and (4) BNS S1, s. 186(3)-(4). By making and selling them, P is liable under Section 186(1)(a) BNS to a fine up to ₹200, and the printing plates and sticker sheets are subject to seizure and mandatory forfeiture under Section 186(2) BNS S1, s. 186(1)-(2). (If P intended them to be passed off to defraud the postal revenue, P would face much heavier felony charges under Section 178 BNS read with Section 186(4) BNS) S1, s. 178, s. 186(4).
Example 2: Counterfeiting Foreign Revenue Stamps vs. Foreign Postage Stamps (Crucial Distinction)
Assumed Facts: Scenario A: Q counterfeits United Kingdom postage stamps in Mumbai to sell to international mailers. Scenario B: R calls Section 186(4) in aid regarding a foreign municipal tax stamp that is not used for postage.
Legal Analysis: Under Section 186(4) BNS, "Government" includes foreign executive governments only when used "in connection with, or in reference to, any stamp issued for the purpose of denoting a rate of postage" S1, s. 186(4). Thus, in Scenario A, Q can be prosecuted under Sections 178–181 BNS read with Section 186(4) BNS S1, s. 178, s. 186(4). In Scenario B, Section 186(4) does not extend "Government" to non-postal foreign revenue stamps (though general forgery provisions under Chapter XVIII BNS may apply) S1, s. 186(4).