Overview and Direct Answer
Section 182 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) is a regulatory penal provision targeting the creation, use, or delivery of documents resembling currency-notes or bank-notes so nearly as to be calculated to deceive, even where there is no full-scale counterfeiting intent under Section 178 BNS (such as advertising handbills, film props, wedding tokens, or promotional vouchers printed to look like genuine RBI banknotes) S1, s. 182; S10. Replacing Section 489E of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC) and relocating it from IPC Chapter XVIII into BNS Chapter X, Section 182 BNS retains the three-subsection structure of IPC Section 489E while tripling the maximum fines:
- Under Section 182(1) BNS, making, causing to be made, using for any purpose, or delivering such a resembling document is punishable with a fine up to ₹300 (increased from ₹100 under IPC Section 489E(1)) S1, s. 182(1); S4, s. 489E(1);
- Under Section 182(2) BNS, a person whose name appears on such a document who refuses, without lawful excuse, to disclose to a police officer the name and address of the printer/maker is punishable with a fine up to ₹600 (increased from ₹200 under IPC Section 489E(2)) S1, s. 182(2); S4, s. 489E(2); and
- Under Section 182(3) BNS, the appearance of a person's name on the offending document (or any connected distributed document) raises a rebuttable statutory presumption (
"until the contrary is proved") that the person caused the document to be made S1, s. 182(3).
Statutory Text and Three-Subsection Architecture
Section 182 BNS reads:
"(1) Whoever makes, or causes to be made, or uses for any purpose whatsoever, or delivers to any person, any document purporting to be, or in any way resembling, or so nearly resembling as to be calculated to deceive, any currency-note or bank-note shall be punished with fine which may extend to three hundred rupees. (2) If any person, whose name appears on a document the making of which is an offence under sub-section (1), refuses, without lawful excuse, to disclose to a police-officer on being so required the name and address of the person by whom it was printed or otherwise made, he shall be punished with fine which may extend to six hundred rupees. (3) Where the name of any person appears on any document in respect of which any person is charged with an offence under sub-section (1) or on any other document used or distributed in connection with that document it may, until the contrary is proved, be presumed that the person caused the document to be made." S1, s. 182
Let us examine each sub-section in detail:
- Sub-section (1): Making, Using, or Delivering Documents Resembling Currency-Notes or Bank-Notes:
- Why Does Section 182(1) Exist Alongside Section 178 (Counterfeiting)?:
- Under Section 178 BNS (read with Section 2(4) BNS),
"counterfeiting"requires that the offender personally intend by means of the resemblance to practise deception or know that deception will likely be practised as counterfeit money S1, s. 2(4); S1, s. 178. - Frequently, however, merchants, advertisers, political campaigners, or stage/film crews print promotional coupons, handbills, or prop notes that look strikingly like ₹500 or ₹2000 currency notes on one or both sides, not because the advertiser intends to pass them off as money, but to catch the eye of passers-by. Once in circulation, such realistic imitation notes are easily used by unscrupulous persons in dimly lit markets or with illiterate/elderly citizens to commit fraud!
- Section 182(1) BNS therefore prohibits making, causing to be made, using
"for any purpose whatsoever", or delivering any"document"(which under Section 2(8) BNS includes electronic and digital records as well as printed matter) purporting to be, or resembling,"or so nearly resembling as to be calculated to deceive", any currency-note or bank-note S1, s. 2(8); S1, s. 182(1). The test"calculated to deceive"is an objective test of visual similarity (whether an ordinary unwary person could be deceived by its appearance), even if the advertiser's subjective purpose was merely publicity S1, s. 182(1).
- Under Section 178 BNS (read with Section 2(4) BNS),
- Why Does Section 182(1) Exist Alongside Section 178 (Counterfeiting)?:
- Sub-section (2): Refusal by Named Person to Disclose Printer/Maker to Police Officer:
- When an advertising handbill or coupon resembling a currency note is found in circulation, it typically bears the name of the shop, brand, or business owner being advertised, rather than the printing press.
- Sub-section (2) empowers a police officer to require any person whose name appears on a document offending Sub-section (1) to disclose the name and address of the person by whom it was printed or otherwise made S1, s. 182(2).
- If that person refuses
"without lawful excuse"(for example, genuine ignorance where a rival or third party printed the person's name without their knowledge would be a lawful excuse), they commit a separate offence under Section 182(2) BNS punishable with a fine up to ₹600 S1, s. 182(2).
- Sub-section (3): Permissive Rebuttable Statutory Presumption (
"may, until the contrary is proved, be presumed"):- To prevent businesses from disowning currency-resembling promotional handbills bearing their name, Sub-section (3) provides that where the name of any person appears on the offending document (or on any other document used or distributed in connection with it), the Court
"may, until the contrary is proved, be presumed that the person caused the document to be made"S1, s. 182(3). - Notice the exact evidentiary standard under the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA) (Section 2(1)(h)
"may presume"): it is a permissive, rebuttable presumption of fact and law, which the named person can rebut on a preponderance of probabilities by showing that the handbills were printed without their authority or knowledge S1, s. 182(3).
- To prevent businesses from disowning currency-resembling promotional handbills bearing their name, Sub-section (3) provides that where the name of any person appears on the offending document (or on any other document used or distributed in connection with it), the Court
Comparison with IPC Section 489E
| Statutory Unit | IPC, 1860 (Section 489E) | BNS, 2023 (Section 182) | Legal & Sentencing Comparison |
|---|---|---|---|
| Placement | Chapter XVIII (Of Offences Relating to Documents and to Property Marks) S4, s. 489E | Chapter X (Of Offences Relating to Coin, Currency-Notes, Bank-Notes, and Government Stamps) S1, s. 182 | Relocated to sit alongside currency-note offences (Sections 178–181) S6. |
| Sub-section (1) Fine | Fine up to one hundred rupees (₹100) S4, s. 489E(1) | Fine up to three hundred rupees (₹300) S1, s. 182(1) | Three-fold increase in maximum fine S1, s. 182(1); S6; S10. |
| Sub-section (2) Fine | Fine up to two hundred rupees (₹200) S4, s. 489E(2) | Fine up to six hundred rupees (₹600) S1, s. 182(2) | Three-fold increase in maximum fine S1, s. 182(2); S6; S10. |
| Sub-section (3) Presumption | Rebuttable presumption that named person caused document to be made S4, s. 489E(3) | Identical verbatim S1, s. 182(3) | Unchanged S1, s. 182(3). |
Punishment Matrix, Default of Fine, and Procedural Classification
- Primary Punishments:
- Section 182(1) BNS: Fine up to ₹300 (no substantive imprisonment) S1, s. 182(1).
- Section 182(2) BNS: Fine up to ₹600 (no substantive imprisonment) S1, s. 182(2).
- Imprisonment in Default of Payment of Fine: Under Section 8(5)(a) BNS, because both sub-sections are punishable with fine only and the fine does not exceed ₹5,000, any imprisonment in default of payment must be simple imprisonment for a term not exceeding two months S1, s. 8(5)(a); S1, s. 182.
- BNSS First Schedule Classification:
Practical Examples and Counterexamples
- Editorial Hypothetical 1 (Jewellery Shop Printing Promotional Coupons Identical in Size and Colour to ₹500 Notes: Guilty under Section 182(1) & (2) BNS):
- Assumed Facts: J, the proprietor of "Shree Jewellers", orders 5,000 promotional discount flyers printed in the exact size, green-grey colour, Mahatma Gandhi portrait layout, and denomination font of a ₹500 RBI note, with "Shree Jewellers — ₹500 Off" printed in small letters where "Reserve Bank of India" normally appears. When a police officer investigating complaints that the flyers are being slipped into cash bundles asks J who printed them, J refuses to reveal the printer's name and address.
- Analysis: Even if J lacked the mens rea to counterfeit money under Section 178 BNS, the flyers
"so nearly resembl[e] as to be calculated to deceive"a currency-note, and under Section 182(3) BNS J's shop name on the flyer raises the presumption that J caused it to be made S1, s. 182(1), (3). J is liable under Section 182(1) BNS (fine up to ₹300), and his refusal without lawful excuse to disclose the printer's name and address to the police officer constitutes a separate offence under Section 182(2) BNS (fine up to ₹600) S1, s. 182(1)–(2).